What do YOU think I should do?

Joined
Dec 27, 2008
Messages
40
I currently have a 19" eMachines LCD, 22" ViewSonic LCD, and a 24" 1920x1080 Dell S2409w LCD... currently the 19 and 24 are hooked up due to their low height, they just match better than the 22.

I bought the 24 a week ago. I have several days to return it yet if I so choose.

I read some rumors that LCDs (monitors and TVs alike) are expected to drop in price in late Jan/early Feb. I don't have a problem returning my 24 and using my 22 as my main (19 as secondary) for a month as long as it's pretty much a guarantee I can get something better for my money. By then, I also may have a few more bucks saved up for a higher model monitor.

My concern is this. I plan to dual screen, as I have been. The 19 inch eMachines is surprisingly nice. For eMachines I was floored by how good it is. Not to say it'll beat a Dell UltraSharp, but nonetheless, I dig it.

Anyway, say panel prices drop and I can pick up a 24" 1920x1080/1200 IPS panel from a decent company for... say... 475... locally (just sayin). When dual screening with a 19" TN, would that be something that would drive the typical person crazy?

I game a decent amount, but nothing too heavy. I play Counterstrike Source along with Ultima Online. In Ultima Online, I have 4 accounts, and I often run 2 at a time (1 on each screen) so if the color imbalance (along with slower response time for games like CS:Source) is going to be enough to drive me insane, then I think I will save my money and stick with a TN panel in the future, or even keep my existing 24" Dell TN panel which, I gotta admit, I kinda like.

Dual screening is a must, though. I love it. But I'm also a fresh-outa-college student who's got bills out the wazoo, so it's not like I can go pick up a pair of 30" Gateway 3000's.

Another little side thought that kind of makes me more comfortable to stick to TN is the fact that there have been several companies that I've read about who've started with IPS or MVA and later replaced the panel with TN, therefore making me nervous if I were still in warranty if the thing would go out, I'd get a product that wasn't 100% what I ordered originally. Knowing this information, along with the fact if I can afford an MVA/IPS, it'll be a low end one, makes me want to just stick with TN from the sense of knowing that what I paid for on day 1 is what I'll get down the road if it needs to be replaced.

Anyway, hit me with your thoughts. Keeping the 19 is a must. The 22 will only serve as a spare monitor for when I work on other computers. Do I run 19/24? Keep the 24? Return it and run 19/22 for a month till "better" deals come out? Get a higher end TN? IPS? Other thoughts? I'm all ears.
 
Hmm, I didn't think the title would be a problem. Considering a few simple facts.

A: I'm in the displays section, so you know that I'm posting a thread regarding monitors.
B: I posted the title with obvious indication that I'm not sure what I should do, meaning I'm caught in a dilemma.

Considering those facts, it should be relatively easy to realize that my thread will be indeed about my indecisiveness regarding certain monitors (again, I'm in the display section) that I'm comparing.

But, just to make you happy, I fixed it. Now that I'm sure you're satisfied with the new title, perhaps you can give me an opinion of what you suggest?
 
Hmm, I didn't think the title would be a problem. Considering a few simple facts.

A: I'm in the displays section, so you know that I'm posting a thread regarding monitors.
B: I posted the title with obvious indication that I'm not sure what I should do, meaning I'm caught in a dilemma.

Considering those facts, it should be relatively easy to realize that my thread will be indeed about my indecisiveness regarding certain monitors (again, I'm in the display section) that I'm comparing.

But, just to make you happy, I fixed it. Now that I'm sure you're satisfied with the new title, perhaps you can give me an opinion of what you suggest?

I don't think you will find a 24 inch ips 1 or even 4 months from now. I would wait to see if you know you can repurchase that monitor again later if you know for a fact but to be honest those specs for 475 i hightly doubt. maybe va but not ips.
 
Hmm, maybe I'll stick with what I got and enjoy it till prices come down enough to justify something like that.

I game more than I do picture editing or anything. In fact, I rarely do that anymore, and if I do it's just to get rid of some red eye on pictures I took with my own digital camera.

I have another day to decide what I'm gonna do, so I'm curious to hear any more input. But logic points to keeping the TN panels.

But I'm curious. Has anybody ran a TN and IPS in dual screen? I have a feeling it'd urk me enough to either go with two TN or two IPS, and two IPS with my budget is worth laughing at. :D
 
I wouldn't buy anything right now given we're so close to CES and, presumably, the announcement of some new models...
 
How do you like the Dell 24"? It's hard finding people that have these and I'm looking at the 23" model right now.
 
Figured I'd post some pictures and whatnot while I'm at it.

Overall - Good monitor. Yes, it's a TN panel, but I consider it a very nice one. I personally love the style of the monitor. It reminds me more of Apple's style stands. The hinge on it is very secure and isn't really wobbly. I know some people have talked against this here, but I LOVE widescreen displays. I understand I'm not getting "all that" with 1920x1080, but I don't care. I really dig my setup and in the future I intend to buy widescreen monitors such as this one.

The colors on it aren't that bad either. In fact, I consider them to be pretty decent for a TN panel. I just came back from an Apple store where I got to oogle over their insanely overpriced hardware, and I looked first hand at the displays. I can see the color differences from the cinema display apple offers versus this Dell with the TN panel, but nonetheless, I wouldn't hesitate to buy it. It has a better color range than my ViewSonic 2235 did, but I still loved my 2235 and I still use it for when I work on computers for other people.

Anyway, I took several pictures at different angles to give people an idea what kind of range this monitor has, along with pictures with the camera being really low to the desk and high on the desk, so you can see the vertical viewing angles too.

Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


Computer%20Stuff


So, there you have it. Decent colors, good backlighting, good design, nice stand, decent price, pretty decent viewing angles side to side, and as typical of any TN panel, mediocre viewing angles top to bottom. But, the damn thing tilts. So when I need to, I make use of it, and it serves me fine. :)

But, as always, don't just take my word for it. You have the benefit of Dell products being in Staples now, so go check it out in person.

I was shocked when I saw it in person. It really was beautiful. Again, the only reason I considered returning it was in case I could get a sick deal with something else of a decent price range... but that's really not looking like it'll happen. So I think I'll stick with what I got. For the record, the other monitor is an eMachines 19" 1440x900 720p monitor.

I paid 279 for it. It was on sale. For that price, I consider this monitor worth it. It does great with games too, btw. I don't do any hardcore gaming but CS Source works (and looks) beautifully with it, especially when I switch the color mode to game mode. Makes a world of difference then!

For the sake of throwing this out there, in all of the pictures the Dell's brightness/contrast is 70/100 & 70/100. It really gets pretty bright above 80ish... like... headache bright.
 
Thanks for the extensive report :) One more question, have you hooked the Dell up over HDMI? I was wondering if you could set the RGB values running under that mode, and if not, what preset color settings it has.
 
Stick with what you have.

Companies are cautious and you aren't going to see any ball breaking good deals come along. Keep it and enjoy it. It obviously serves your purposes well, and it looks like you received a good unit in terms of backlight bleed and uniformity, so why take a chance on a new screen and new headaches a month or two down the line?

They may get cheaper, but you never know what is going to come out. The 16:9 TN models are already dirt cheap as it is.
 
Thanks for the extensive report :) One more question, have you hooked the Dell up over HDMI? I was wondering if you could set the RGB values running under that mode, and if not, what preset color settings it has.

I did not notice if I could set the RGB colors individually. I never really mess with that anyway, but I'll check it when I get home to see what all you can do.

It has 6 or 7 preset modes, 3 of which I use a lot. Game, Multimedia, and Standard. All 3 of those really stand out to me. I always ignored those on my last monitor but this time around it makes a decent change when I switch it over to another mode depending on what I'm doing.

FYI - Found this. Just figured I'd share.

http://forum.lowyat.net/topic/724890/+960



Is there anybody who has played with another TN panel that's available at a local store (staples, circuit city, best buy) that I could compare to? I just have this burning feeling that maybe there's something else out there that'd be better suited for me, but I'm not sure.
 
I paid 279 for it. It was on sale. For that price, I consider this monitor worth it. It does great with games too, btw. I don't do any hardcore gaming but CS Source works (and looks) beautifully with it, especially when I switch the color mode to game mode. Makes a world of difference then!
Definitely keep it, you got a great deal. It's $379 at Best Buy and $349 at Micro Center.
 
Definitely keep it, you got a great deal. It's $379 at Best Buy and $349 at Micro Center.

The only thing I question is the color gamut. How important is something like that? Granted, the HP w2408h is like 400 some dollars, and a TN panel I believe (same as I got), but I think the color gamut is 92% whereas my Dell is 72% or 75% or something...

Is it that big of a deal? Should I invest in something like that? Or should I just shut up already? :D
 
The color gamut thing is not a big deal. If you're happy with what you have, just be thankful...b/c some people in this forum never find something they're happy with.
 
The only thing I question is the color gamut. How important is something like that? Granted, the HP w2408h is like 400 some dollars, and a TN panel I believe (same as I got), but I think the color gamut is 92% whereas my Dell is 72% or 75% or something...

Is it that big of a deal? Should I invest in something like that? Or should I just shut up already? :D
Beats me, I am red-green color blind....
 
I'm kind of interested in the DELL E248WFP now... Granted, it's pretty much the same thing with 1920x1200 resolution and 92% color gamut, still packs a TN panel and all, but I've read some people saying they've seen it go on sale for real cheap... And it's often available at Staples and Best Buy and what not.

Do you think it's worth returning the s2409w for a chance to grab the DELL E248WFP at 340ish or below? I'd have no problem shelling that amount out for it, but currently it's like 460 at staples or something, which is laughable.

EDIT - Maybe that's a bad idea. I have a 17" version of that monitor here I use for testing computers. It's very bland. It's not bad, don't get me wrong, but... that's why I use this monitor to test computers with. I did some research and some people compared this to the s2409w I already have. Most people said the colors on the other model, despite being listed as 92% color gamut, are very comparable to the s2409w, to the point that some don't understand why one is 92 and the other is 72. In fact, most people swayed towards the s2409w, despite the fact some people preferred 16:10 ratios.

Bleh.
 
The wide color gamut isn't a great advantage unless you're doing pro photo/print work in AdobeRGB color spaces or other extended color spaces. In some cases the wide gamut can have the effect of making all sRGB content (web, most video, etc) look a bit out of wack.
 
Back
Top