what do i do with all these hard drives?

Joined
Jul 4, 2005
Messages
601
currently i have 1x150 raptor, 1x320 wd, 2x640 aaks, 1x750 aaks, one of the 640's is a backup to the other. i'm at max capacity and wanted to add a couple more disks, but not sure of configuring it. now i have 3 internal, and 2 external, and am maxed out for onboard connectors (i have two optical drives), plus using a usb connector, unless i get a raid card or something, which is what i am wondering about.

there's a certain amount of stuff that i want backed up, but not everything, at least the way it's set up now, it's just too many disks, and am wondering about setting up a raid 5 array. the problem is that afaik that's not a really good backup situation, because you could get a virus, or some other problem and still lose everything. how do you avoid this problem, do you have to back up the whole array? in which case that would again be too many disks.

what's the best backup solution for having a raid 5 array, or do most ppl not use anything else?

do all the disks have to be identical, down to the model, or just the same size?

currently i have my os/apps drive separate from all storage, would i want to keep it that way for raid 5?

is midrange controller card, like promise fastrak4310 (only one i saw for vista), way better than using onboard raid solution? one of the main things for me is that it would allow me to still have 4xraid5 drives plus os drive, rather than 3 & os.

thanks for any help,
rlr
 
you need to consolidate your drives

Get some 1tb or 1.5tb and sell the rest.
 
Get a couple of 1Tb drives to replace what you have inside your case, and a cheap DIY NAS an stuff your largest existing drives in that...then calll it a day.
 
I also suggest that you keep it simple and just replace some of your drives with larger capacity ones.
 
Yep, do as mentioned above.
Keep the older hard drives for backups of important stuff.
 
I also suggest that you keep it simple and just replace some of your drives with larger capacity ones.

Is raid just problematic, or why wouldn't i want to use that? it seems like everywhere i look ppl are talking about various raid arrays. i thought i could get more redundancy out of fewer disks that way?
 
Is raid just problematic, or why wouldn't i want to use that? it seems like everywhere i look ppl are talking about various raid arrays. i thought i could get more redundancy out of fewer disks that way?

In your case, you just want to consolidate your stuff onto fewer disks (if I understand you correctly). RAID can accomplish this, but is overkill for just consolidating your storage - especially since you're going to end up buying a bunch of disks anyway (you need identical sized drives for RAID 5). With individual disks, you don't have to worry about the RAID controller or multiple disk failures - both of which will likely take out the entire array. You also don't have to worry about spending money on a RAID controller.

As yourself this: what do you want with RAID that can't be accomplished with individual drives?
 
In your case, you just want to consolidate your stuff onto fewer disks (if I understand you correctly). RAID can accomplish this, but is overkill for just consolidating your storage - especially since you're going to end up buying a bunch of disks anyway (you need identical sized drives for RAID 5). With individual disks, you don't have to worry about the RAID controller or multiple disk failures - both of which will likely take out the entire array. You also don't have to worry about spending money on a RAID controller.

As yourself this: what do you want with RAID that can't be accomplished with individual drives?

I guess that's the question. I was just going under the assumption that it was a better setup for larger storage systems, being that i would need less drives and still have fault tolerance, to a degree anyways. I guess there's some stuff i would backup beyond the array though anyway, so maybe it wouldn't make that much difference....

thx
 
Thanks, what is a 'cheap DIY NAS'?

Cheap DIY NAS:
AMD Sempron LE-1600 45W CPU - $27
Gigabyte GA-MA74GM-S2 AMD 740G mATX AMD Motherboard - $55
Kingston KVR800D2N6/2G 2GB DDR2 800 RAM - $21
Sigma ORCA ORCA-WB ATX Case - $40
Antec Earthwatts 430W PSU - $35
Microsoft Windows Home Server with Power Pack 1 - $100
---
Total: $278 plus tax and shipping

Just reuse your 320GB drive as the boot drive for this NAS and the 640s and 750s as the storage. When you need more storage, just add another hard drive to the storage pool. Do some research about Windows Home Server and see if it fits your needs.

Is raid just problematic, or why wouldn't i want to use that? it seems like everywhere i look ppl are talking about various raid arrays. i thought i could get more redundancy out of fewer disks that way?

In addition to SockMan's answer, onboard RAID 5 is relatively slow and will use the CPU to do all of the parity calculations. So you'll see a constant 10% or more depending on the size of the array CPU usage. Also note that a true hardware RAID card starts around $300. True hardware RAID cards have a CPU specifically dedicated to doing all of the parity calculations. As a result, you get significantly better performance over onboard RAID solutions. When buying a RAID card, you have to make sure whether or not you're getting a software RAID card, whose performance won't be that much better over onboard RAID, or a true hardware RAID card.
 
I was just going under the assumption that it was a better setup for larger storage systems

For servers that need to be running 24/7, then yes RAID is desirable and probably necessary. RAID is meant for ensuring downtime in case of a disk failure. With RAID you'll ideally be able to swap out a failed hard drive with a good one while the server is still running. However, uptime is probably not an issue for you (and I'm guessing you don't have hot-swap bays in your case anyway).

Just remember that RAID is not a backup. I'm not sure if you already knew that, but that seems to be the #1 misconception about RAID.
 
Back
Top