Western Digital Raptor questions.

Rozal0

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 3, 2006
Messages
408
I intend on purchasing a raptor, I've never owned one myself however I am curious on the amount of noise it has.

Are raptors worth their money? Is it something, when i buy it, I'm going to fall in love with?
 
A Raptor is not a quiet hard drive. You can minimize the seek noise if you have a steel case with suspended drive mounts. If you don't have a steel case with suspended drive mounts, it is going to be loud.

Water cooling is generally not the best solution for a quiet PC, although some watercooling setups certainly produce less noise than others.

If I were building a silent setup with your components, it would consist of an Antec SOLO case, Corsair 520HX power supply, Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme with a 120mm Scythe S-Flex SFF21E, a 120mm Scythe S-Flex SFF21E for the exhaust, Artic Cooling Accelero S1 + S-Flex SFF21E on your 8800GT, and a Western Digital 320GB WD3200AAKS-00B3A0 in the SOLO's suspended drive mount.

All three S-Flex fans would be connected to headers on your Abit IP35 Pro and set to run at 6v during idle temps and 9-12v during load temps. I believe 8v is the minimum you can set in the bios, but 6v can be set with Abit software (which you can then uninstall).

That will produce less noise than any watercooling setup and should provide sufficient cooling for a 3.2-3.6GHz overclock.
 
Interesting, how would the noise level compare with your suggestions but a water solution for the CPU and GPU. (Upgrading my case, fans, HD, and perhaps my PSU fan)
 
Interesting, how would the noise level compare with your suggestions but a water solution for the CPU and GPU. (Upgrading my case, fans, HD, and perhaps my PSU fan)
That depends on the watercooling solution you buy. Do your research. Do not assume that all setups are about the same (or even close) in terms of noise.

Water pumps make noise. Some make [much] more noise than others. Some water pumps are meant for internal case use; others are in an external box, out of the way. Regardless, you're going to need the same 120mm fan(s) on the radiator.

The setup I describe above would be basically inaudible at idle and quiet at load.
 
My Raptor 150 is as quite as my 320KS in my Antec Super Lanboy. The only time it is louder is when I am moving a lot of non-congruent data to another drive.
 
My Raptor 150 is as quite as my 320KS in my Antec Super Lanboy. The only time it is louder is when I am moving a lot of non-congruent data to another drive.
The 320KS is not quiet. It produces 70-80% more noise than the drives I mentioned above.
 
I'm no "Noise Nazi", but both of my Raptors have a "search rumble".

For me, the increase in performance more than offsets the noise/price factors.

Your questions have been asked many times, and the answer's still the same. You won't know if they're worth it, 'till you try one.
 
I don't know how many of you where around for the loud a$$ hard drives from the 80s (man do I miss how they sounded!) but my raptor 150, though louder than my WD5000KS, is not loud enough to be distracting. I use it for recording without problem, not that I have a properly setup tracking studio. I use watercooling, my system is VERY quiet, and I would say that the raptor is the loudest component. But to say it's twice as loud as an old 40GB deathstar I have in there isn't saying much - twice as loud is only a 3dB increase. I don't have a dB meter on me, but I would call my system 'whisper' quiet, with the drive noise not significant enough to matter. If I crank all the fans up, you can't hear any of the drives.
 
I don't know how many of you where around for the loud a$$ hard drives from the 80s (man do I miss how they sounded!) but my raptor 150, though louder than my WD5000KS, is not loud enough to be distracting.

I think perceived loudness will depend in part on the current noise level of your PC. If your PC is sufficiently quiet that you can't tell it is on, then a Raptor will seem very loud.

On the other hand, if you have several 1600+rpm fans in your case, you'll barely hear the Raptor except when its seeking.

But to say it's twice as loud as an old 40GB deathstar I have in there isn't saying much - twice as loud is only a 3dB increase. I don't have a dB meter on me, but I would call my system 'whisper' quiet, with the drive noise not significant enough to matter. If I crank all the fans up, you can't hear any of the drives.
Perceived volume doubling ("twice the noise") is usually described as a 10dB increase.

Anandtech Noise Measurements

15238.png


15240.png


The new Western Digital 320Gb platter drives (production began January 21) produces comparable idle noise and less seek noise than the Samsung.
 
Perceived volume doubling ("twice the noise") is usually described as a 10dB increase.

Actually I agree, especially considering all the background noise. However, +3dB is the actual measurement for twice the power, just to be clear. (i.e. 1 fan = 26dB : 2 fans = 29dB).
 
Unfortunately, if you want one of the fastest single SATA drives in the world, you're going to have to deal with a little noise. It's really not THAT bad. I've got a Lian Li PC65 case with a side window and the drive is mounted in the lower, forward part of the case right behind the front fans. The drive is quite noticable when it's reading and writing, but it really doesn't bother me. I like hearing my PC work. The only time I really hear it when I'm gaming is during initial loading of the map. Once playing, I can't hear it over the sound of the game. I've got both a Raptor and a new WD SE16 750AAKS. The SE16 is virtually silent and it's a pretty fast drive. I use the Raptor as my C: drive with the OS, programs/games on it. The SE16 is just a storage drive right now. My case use to be loaded with loud Panaflow fans and I replaced them with silent Nexus fans because I couldn't take it anymore (more significantly, neither could my wife). The Raptor is not nearly as annoying as the sound those things made!
 
I have 2 and find them no more noisy than regular HDs, except for the chatter when they are reading and writing. I actually like the r/w chatter, it's like an acoustic HD light and lets you know all is well.
 
Back
Top