We Learn More From Success, Not Failure

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Here’s the science behind the reason we don't learn from our mistakes. It would seem we don’t learn crap from our failures, it is our successes that make an impact. I knew that whole “learn from our mistakes” thing was a load of bull.

Scientists there have shown that the brain responds to success at the level of individual brain cells, but the neurons show virtually no response to failures.
 
Might be something to that.

I can remember all of the women in my life who have said yes. Heck if I could be bothered to remember all of 'em that have said no...
 
well its only logical that one would be more likely to remember the good and not the bad.
I guess it kinda depends on what tho.
I sure as hell remember that its not a good idea to stick a fork in a light socket. And that was learned like 20 years ago >.>
 
The problem is that they are subtly redefining what they mean by "Leaning". Just reading the first statements made it clear that they are really talking about what I would call "conditioning", rather than "learning". The examples are "dogs and children" and they are more effectively "trained" by positive reinforcement. But Learning is really different!

I would personally define "Learning" as taking in new information, then analysing that information to see how it fits with prior information that I've asymilated. I do this by "testing" the information for accuracy. And it's in this context that one can "learn more" from some types of failure. Because failure can force you to reevaluate your view of "how things work", or how you are conducting your "tests". And with Sucess you are just prepared to move on to some other piece of information. Meaning that you don't have to think about things quite as much.

But that's just my 2¢ worth...
 
The problem is that they are subtly redefining what they mean by "Leaning". Just reading the first statements made it clear that they are really talking about what I would call "conditioning", rather than "learning". The examples are "dogs and children" and they are more effectively "trained" by positive reinforcement. But Learning is really different!

I would personally define "Learning" as taking in new information, then analysing that information to see how it fits with prior information that I've asymilated. I do this by "testing" the information for accuracy. And it's in this context that one can "learn more" from some types of failure. Because failure can force you to reevaluate your view of "how things work", or how you are conducting your "tests". And with Sucess you are just prepared to move on to some other piece of information. Meaning that you don't have to think about things quite as much.

But that's just my 2¢ worth...

[It took me awhile to get past the typos and I pictured you doing "air quotes" every "time" you "quoted" "something" :) ]

This is learning in that it is task-based. The subject is making a conscious decision to carry out a set of actions to get a desired outcome. It's not like they are drilling the animals to elicit an unconscious reaction to a stimulus (ring bell => drool).

When is the last time you really sat down and said to yourself: "What can I learn from this failure?" No one does that except in seminars. We get pissed off and sometimes try again until we get it right. And then promptly forget that we used to suck because that's a waste of time.

Why should my neurons expend energy storing and recalling the wrong way to do something? (E.g. If I know the rules to building well-formed XML, why should I worry about the infinite ways in which I can write badly-formed XML?) Even if failing killed me, focusing on the successful path should be protection enough.
 
Eh, when I make a mistake that results in failure, I normally do not make that same mistake.... Then again, I can see where we learn from out success. The first time is always the most fun :)
 
Funny, so THAT'S why I'm always late to work.

I seem to remember something about how real failure-provoking changes don't happen unless one's life is threatened. (I think wherever I heard it from was mostly referring to recreational drugs, though)
Epiphanies or paradigm shifts or something like that...
 
Eh, when I make a mistake that results in failure, I normally do not make that same mistake.... Then again, I can see where we learn from out success. The first time is always the most fun :)

That's the reasonable you speaking. Unfortunately, chemicals (e.g. dopamine that motivates to repeat success) are more powerful than only reason :D
 
The problem is that they are subtly redefining what they mean by "Leaning". Just reading the first statements made it clear that they are really talking about what I would call "conditioning", rather than "learning". The examples are "dogs and children" and they are more effectively "trained" by positive reinforcement. But Learning is really different!

I would personally define "Learning" as taking in new information, then analysing that information to see how it fits with prior information that I've asymilated. I do this by "testing" the information for accuracy. And it's in this context that one can "learn more" from some types of failure. Because failure can force you to reevaluate your view of "how things work", or how you are conducting your "tests". And with Sucess you are just prepared to move on to some other piece of information. Meaning that you don't have to think about things quite as much.

But that's just my 2¢ worth...

nice job bringing the psychology part into this :)
i wanted to reply to this thread but you have done better than i could have, i totally agree with you.

if we don't learn from our failures, then we will repeat those failures, and that is just stupid.
 
nice job bringing the psychology part into this :)
i wanted to reply to this thread but you have done better than i could have, i totally agree with you.

if we don't learn from our failures, then we will repeat those failures, and that is just stupid.

The only thing to learn from failure is how to fail. The learned behaviour should be to NOT do that thing. The way you learn to do something else is to practice something else: the successful procedure.

Surely neuroplasticity dictates that the brain would reinforce Good memories at the expense of Bad. It's just never been measured at the neuron level before.

This is just another in a long line of studies that go against commonly held myths about learning. Spacing and repetition vs. bootcamps; early vs. late feedback; providing answers before vs. after assignments. The study shows one thing, no one believes it. 300 studies show the same thing, everyone still builds 5-day instructor-led training.
 
We have repeated our failures Ripken.. Korea.. Vietnam.. Iraq.. *place held for next third world country to be "liberated" in ~15 years*
 
We are happier with our successes, that doesn't mean we learn from only them. When we're wrong, we learn, to try again, try something else, re-evaluate, this doesn't work with that because of.., and so on. When we're right, we're done, so we're happy, it works.

We don't remember all those little failures, they just get us to the success, except for epic failures of course. If we get success too soon, we don't remember how we got there since without experience, we don't understand the process.

This is assuming we are trying to figure something out with reason and logic, not random chance.

I know many times I've been so happy about learning something that I used what I''ve learned many times again. But it didn't work. Just because it works in one situation doesn't mean it works everywhere. Failing causes you figure out why.

The article does not consider hardship caused by mistakes either. That's completely unbalanced. Why change if there is no penalty? If the monkey picks a square, say, what makes him feel good about that? The scientists stacked the deck. They rewarded the monkey's themselves for choosing correctly. I think their research is too simplistic. Real analytical problems cannot be figured out by feeling happy when you get lucky. Just reason and logic. Happiness comes afterwards, or not. :)
 
The only thing to learn from failure is how to fail. The learned behaviour should be to NOT do that thing. The way you learn to do something else is to practice something else: the successful procedure..
what we learn is not to do that thing which caused us to fail and to instead choose something else. that something else may also fail, we then keep trying until something works.
 
As author Peter Drucker said: "A man can make the same mistake for 20 years and
call it experience."

The psychologists say "positive re-inforcement elicits more positive responses than does
negative re-inforcement."

Jenny Puelos (sp?) says"Failure is underestimated as a success tool. I've failed into every
good thing that has ever happened to me."

Even though I studied Psych. for a time, I'm still out on the results of Positive vs: negative
re-inforcement. Personality traits play a large part in how we view success and how we
view failure. There are so many variables that go into what we (as individuals) consider
"failure" that it's hard to generalize.

Just my $.02 worth
 
Back
Top