I'm of mixed feelings about this. As many of the above posters have mentioned: in light of the Gamers' Bill of Rights, you'd think that if one company could "get it right," that company would be Stardock.
That said, it's my [limited] understanding that blaming Stardock for the release state of Demigod is unreasonable: it wasn't developed by Stardock. If they get negative points for Demigod (which seems to have improved greatly by their hand), they should get kudos for Sins of a Solar Empire.
But I digress. Stardock released an unready product, and they're paying: they're paying in bad press and customer loyalty and dollars spent on their product. I think it's admirable that their CEO steps up and assumes responsibility - but that doesn't change their product. Giving a free expansion might: it adds value to what people have already purchased.
Also, I thought I understood that part of the reason for Elemental's rushed release (a few days/weeks earlier than planned?) was that due to Stardock's no DRM policy, when a distributor leaked an early version, Stardock needed to do something. Fact or myth?
At some level though, this all seems fairly...academic. Irrelevant, even. Because reasonably, when determining whether or not to purchase a particular game, how we feel about a company or head thereof does not change the product itself (though I suppose customers may wish to reward a company they see as having good business practices). I'll buy Elemental when it seems like a good buy, and I'll do the same for future Stardock games.
Tarrosion
Stardock gets some blame for Demigod when it launched. Or rather they took the blame when it had issues at launch. Personally I'd toss a lot of that blame on the pirates that downloaded it, but whatever. Either, Gas Powered Games made a ton of promises for Demigod and then just dropped the game in Stardock's lap and ignored it.
Yeah the game leaked early, but as Wardell said it doesn't matter the game wouldn't have been ready anyway. From what I've been hearing from people who own it I'd have to agree. I'm just glad I didn't buy the game. I had thought about it, but got caught up in other things. If I did own it I'd probably be joining others in calling for fixes and someone's head.