Wardell apologizes

I'm of mixed feelings about this. As many of the above posters have mentioned: in light of the Gamers' Bill of Rights, you'd think that if one company could "get it right," that company would be Stardock.

That said, it's my [limited] understanding that blaming Stardock for the release state of Demigod is unreasonable: it wasn't developed by Stardock. If they get negative points for Demigod (which seems to have improved greatly by their hand), they should get kudos for Sins of a Solar Empire.

But I digress. Stardock released an unready product, and they're paying: they're paying in bad press and customer loyalty and dollars spent on their product. I think it's admirable that their CEO steps up and assumes responsibility - but that doesn't change their product. Giving a free expansion might: it adds value to what people have already purchased.

Also, I thought I understood that part of the reason for Elemental's rushed release (a few days/weeks earlier than planned?) was that due to Stardock's no DRM policy, when a distributor leaked an early version, Stardock needed to do something. Fact or myth?

At some level though, this all seems fairly...academic. Irrelevant, even. Because reasonably, when determining whether or not to purchase a particular game, how we feel about a company or head thereof does not change the product itself (though I suppose customers may wish to reward a company they see as having good business practices). I'll buy Elemental when it seems like a good buy, and I'll do the same for future Stardock games.

Tarrosion

Stardock gets some blame for Demigod when it launched. Or rather they took the blame when it had issues at launch. Personally I'd toss a lot of that blame on the pirates that downloaded it, but whatever. Either, Gas Powered Games made a ton of promises for Demigod and then just dropped the game in Stardock's lap and ignored it.

Yeah the game leaked early, but as Wardell said it doesn't matter the game wouldn't have been ready anyway. From what I've been hearing from people who own it I'd have to agree. I'm just glad I didn't buy the game. I had thought about it, but got caught up in other things. If I did own it I'd probably be joining others in calling for fixes and someone's head.
 
Now Brad announced that they have layed off a bunch of employee's because of this. Of course he's on vacation so he doesn't have to look them in the eye when they are told not to come back to work on Tuesday due to his mistakes as CEO. What a douche bag.
 
The difference between Stardock and people like EA or Ubisoft or Activision is that those three big companies have a history of simply dropping a product and not supporting it. Stardock doesn't. Hell every single patch for Demigod was done by Stardock. GPG ditched the game pretty much right after it was done. As of right now Stardock has yet to prove that they can't be trusted to fix a product. When/if they get to that point then I'll have a different tune. I'm not going to attack a company without good reason. I'm a game journalist that actually takes some damn pride in his work and actually believes in waiting to see if a company deserves a fair shot.


ahem.. battlefield 2142.. ahem... by far one of the better futuristic battfield games to be released only to see EA completely dumb it because its core fan base didnt like it..they never finished patching it.. i mean ffs they had a beta patch for almost a year before releasing a SECOND beta patch and then nothing.. never released a final patch and just let the game completely die..

EA has a long long history of screwing people.. releasing games and never fixing them completely.. Not to mention sweeping shit under the rug hoping the problem disapears.. THQ is the same way.. hell most of the big name gaming companies are..

Wardell at least admitted his fuck up.. he got way to involved in his own creation and failed to see the big picture.. shit happens.. now we just have to see if he follows through with his word and attempts to fix all the problems..


Stardock gets some blame for Demigod when it launched. Or rather they took the blame when it had issues at launch. Personally I'd toss a lot of that blame on the pirates that downloaded it, but whatever. Either, Gas Powered Games made a ton of promises for Demigod and then just dropped the game in Stardock's lap and ignored it.

Yeah the game leaked early, but as Wardell said it doesn't matter the game wouldn't have been ready anyway. From what I've been hearing from people who own it I'd have to agree. I'm just glad I didn't buy the game. I had thought about it, but got caught up in other things. If I did own it I'd probably be joining others in calling for fixes and someone's head.


the number 1 problem with demigod is that the game was build off a completely flawed supreme commander engine.. we all knew it was flawed.. THQ knew it was flawed and yet made absolutely no attempt to fix the problem.. instead they just released a few updates.. swept it under the rug and started hyping up supreme commander 2 which had a completely new engine but a shitty game..
 
Now Brad announced that they have layed off a bunch of employee's because of this. Of course he's on vacation so he doesn't have to look them in the eye when they are told not to come back to work on Tuesday due to his mistakes as CEO. What a douche bag.

:rolleyes: He said long before the game came out he was going on vacation as soon as it was finished. He also ended his vacation early because of this.

Besides how often is it that the CEO of a company personally tells people face to face when they are laid off? Usually that is someone else's job.

Brad is a better man than you.
 
Also, I thought I understood that part of the reason for Elemental's rushed release (a few days/weeks earlier than planned?) was that due to Stardock's no DRM policy, when a distributor leaked an early version, Stardock needed to do something. Fact or myth?

Myth. The street date was broken by a couple of days by some retailers, but the reason the game was shipped was because Wardell was too close to it--he was programming lots of it--and thought that his baby was ready for primetime. Basically he wouldn't listen to anyone who told him otherwise, and many beta testers did.

Stardock did have to decide whether to release now or next February, because that was the only time they could get shelf space in the B&M stores. But Wardell has said that if they had held the release until then it still would have been a failed launch because he ignored anyone who told him his labor of love had significant problems.
 
EA has a long long history of screwing people... hell most of the big name gaming companies are..

Wardell at least admitted his fuck up.. he got way to involved in his own creation and failed to see the big picture.. shit happens.. now we just have to see if he follows through with his word and attempts to fix all the problems..

Who cares if the guy apologized or not - his game was garbage, and he failed to listen to his own beta testers.

Screw the apology. If he's genuinely sincere about his mistakes then he should be prepared to give people their money back.

You make it out like out like EA is this evil empire, in which there are these cloaked figures sitting in a dark boardroom gleefully counting the profits and trying to figure out new ways of screwing gamers.

Companies like EA produce dozens and dozens of triple-a titles and employ thousands of people - the odds of there being problems rises exponentially. A company like Stardock produces one game, and they can't even get that right.

It amazes me that you crap all over a company that has provided amazing triple-a titles which millions of people love (have you ever met a Sims Fanatic in person, or somebody who has played Mass Effect ten times), and then defend some guy who creates a ridiculous gamers' bill of rights, violates it, doesn't listen to his own beta testers because his head is so far up his ass, apologizes for his mistake, and then does nothing about it. Do you actually believe, with people being laid off, and disastrous review scores piling up, that this game is going to receive the resources it needs to be fixed?

The sad fact is that EA, the company you've dismissed with a wave of your hand, would never have released a steaming, festering turd like Elemental, but guys like you and Derangel can't see that because you think it's cool to bash EA or Ubisoft or THQ or any of the big name companies that actually produce the truly great titles which most of us love to play.
 
Whatever, Wabe; you obviously have a personal vendetta against Stardock. You were bashing them before Elemental came out, you have bashed Impulse, which works great--better than Steam even, IMO--and now you're treating Brad Wardell as if he ran over your dog and laughed in your face. I have to wonder what they did to you to make you hate them so much.
 
Whatever, Wabe; you obviously have a personal vendetta against Stardock. You were bashing them before Elemental came out, you have bashed Impulse, which works great--better than Steam even, IMO--and now you're treating Brad Wardell as if he ran over your dog and laughed in your face. I have to wonder what they did to you to make you hate them so much.

Not true at all.

I'm being fair about it. Wardell is apologizing. But again, so what. If EA had done this, if THQ had done this, if Ubisoft had done this... if any company had done this, then people would be laughing at them.

Words mean nothing.

Also, I feel the need to respond when EA gets bashed (look at the post above), or when THQ gets bashed - really, for no good reason. When somebody praises Stardock, even in light of this fiasco, and then in the very same post chooses to bash EA, then something is wrong. I'm just not following that line of reasoning - Stardock breaks their own set of conduct rules by releasing a game that's got major design issues, and that's terribly buggy, and what do we do: we take the opportunity to bash EA.

Huh?
 
Not true at all.

I'm being fair about it. Wardell is apologizing. But again, so what. If EA had done this, if THQ had done this, if Ubisoft had done this... if any company had done this, then people would be laughing at them.

Words mean nothing.

Also, I feel the need to respond when EA gets bashed (look at the post above), or when THQ gets bashed - really, for no good reason. When somebody praises Stardock, even in light of this fiasco, and then in the very same post chooses to bash EA, then something is wrong. I'm just not following that line of reasoning - Stardock breaks their own set of conduct rules by releasing a game that's got major design issues, and that's terribly buggy, and what do we do: we take the opportunity to bash EA.

Huh?

Wabe shut up and actually listen to what people are saying. We're not "taking the oppertunity to bash EA". YOU brought them up .YOU brought up the comparison. YOU wondered why there was a difference. It was all YOU. And no one is giving them a complete pass. Its called waiting to see what happens. Stardock has yet to screw anyone over. They have a history of fixing problems. As for the bill of rights, who says they aren't willing to give refunds? Has anyone asked and been turned down? Did you buy the game? If not why the hell are you getting so worked up?

You bring up large companies who do have a history of leaving gamers high and dry and yet YOU are giving them a pass. So why do YOU give a pass to multi-million dollar companies with a bad history and shit on a small company that has a good one?
 
Wabe shut up and actually listen to what people are saying. We're not "taking the oppertunity to bash EA". YOU brought them up .YOU brought up the comparison. YOU wondered why there was a difference. It was all YOU.

No, Derangel.

sirmonkey1985 wrote this in the post above: "EA has a long long history of screwing people.. releasing games and never fixing them completely.. Not to mention sweeping shit under the rug hoping the problem disapears.. THQ is the same way.. hell most of the big name gaming companies are..."

That's what I was referring to, and that's why I quoted it.

This logic makes no sense to me. Stardock screws up, and this guy takes the opportunity to bash EA, THQ, and 'most of the big name gaming companies'.

That's just plain silly - actually, there's a name for this type of fallacy, and it's called the Red Herring argument. He's deflecting attention from Stardock towards EA, which has nothing to do with the Elemental fiasco.
 
So why do YOU give a pass to multi-million dollar companies with a bad history and shit on a small company that has a good one?

Because most of the triple-A titles I've played from the giants have been relatively bug free, and certainly weren't shit.

Recently, Mass Effect 2, Dragon Age, Assassin's Creed 2, Bioshock 2, Just Cause 2, were all beautifully programmed titles... and quite frankly, Derangel, these games were far more ambitious than anything created by Stardock.

AC 2 in particular, for the amount of stuff that was happening in that game, was amazingly well programmed and bug free - but people couldn't see past the DRM, and just had to bash away at Ubisoft.

Meanwhile, Stardock provides a game that's got huge problems, and certain people start jumping to this Wardell guy's defense - why? Because he apologized. LOL!
 
No, Derangel.

sirmonkey1985 wrote this in the post above: "EA has a long long history of screwing people.. releasing games and never fixing them completely.. Not to mention sweeping shit under the rug hoping the problem disapears.. THQ is the same way.. hell most of the big name gaming companies are..."

That's what I was referring to, and that's why I quoted it.

This logic makes no sense to me. Stardock screws up, and this guy takes the opportunity to bash EA, THQ, and 'most of the big name gaming companies'.

That's just plain silly - actually, there's a name for this type of fallacy, and it's called the Red Herring argument. He's deflecting attention from Stardock towards EA, which has nothing to do with the Elemental fiasco.

Because YOU brought up EA and THQ originally. He was responding to my post which was in response to YOU. Its part of the original discussion.

Because most of the triple-A titles I've played from the giants have been relatively bug free, and certainly weren't shit.

Recently, Mass Effect 2, Dragon Age, Assassin's Creed 2, Bioshock 2, Just Cause 2, were all beautifully programmed titles... and quite frankly, Derangel, these games were far more ambitious than anything created by Stardock.

AC 2 in particular, for the amount of stuff that was happening in that game, was amazingly well programmed and bug free - but people couldn't see past the DRM, and just had to bash away at Ubisoft.

Meanwhile, Stardock provides a game that's got huge problems, and certain people start jumping to this Wardell guy's defense - why? Because he apologized. LOL!

Bioshock 2 was utter shit on the PC. Beyond that your examples are fine, but what about Just Cause 1? Mercs 2? Dozens of other piss poorly released ports that were never supported? The question isn't whether or not those companies can release good titles its whether or not they care enough to support the poorly released ones. If Elemental was released in working state we wouldn't be having this conversation. Its not, so the point comes down to post-release support. So far (key words) Stardock has not proven themselves to be unreliable in that area. That is exactly why people are willing to wait while if someone like the big publishers released a game in that state any promises to fix it would be taken with skepticism. Stardock could have left Demigod in terrible shape and passed the buck off on GPG, instead they fixed it themselves long after Chris Taylor and his team stopped caring. Something like that is exactly the kind of example that people look to. Wardell apologizing, taking the blame, and explaining why he fucked up is just part of it. If he had ignored the problem or given a typical bull shit apology people would be having a different reaction entirely.
 
I think that the most bothersome thing about Wardell is that what he's doing here is really just PR.

Some people here are buying it, others aren't.

The thing is though that this tactic of apologizing (and yeah I do believe it's a tactic) will only work once. It reminds me of that scene from Traffic in which the former drug czar tells a joke to Micheal Douglas.

The leader of the Soviet Union was on his way out, and handed two envelopes to his successor. When you run into a problem he said, open the first envelope, and when you run into a second problem, open the second.

Pretty soon the new guy ran into a problem, so he opened the first envelope, which said: Blame everything on me. So he did it. He blamed everything on his predecessor, and it worked like a charm.

It wasn't long before he ran into his second big problem, so he opened the second envelope.

The letter inside said, sit down and write two letters for two envelopes....
 
I think that the most bothersome thing about Wardell is that what he's doing here is really just PR.

Some people here are buying it, others aren't.

The thing is though that this tactic of apologizing (and yeah I do believe it's a tactic) will only work once. It reminds me of that scene from Traffic in which the former drug czar tells a joke to Micheal Douglas.

The leader of the Soviet Union was on his way out, and handed two envelopes to his successor. When you run into a problem he said, open the first envelope, and when you run into a second problem, open the second.

Pretty soon the new guy ran into a problem, so he opened the first envelope, which said: Blame everything on me. So he did it. He blamed everything on his predecessor, and it worked like a charm.

It wasn't long before he ran into his second big problem, so he opened the second envelope.

The letter inside said, sit down and write two letters for two envelopes....

Well yeah of course its PR. What else would it be? PR has such a negative stigma attached to it, but people don't seem to realize that a lot of things they praise are "just PR". Valve's free updates? Thats PR. Game patches? Another form of PR. Hell releasing good games can be considered PR.Good PR is essentially anything that builds trust or confidence in a product or company. Good PR builds customer relations that will keep bringing people back and making them more willing to spend money on the company.

If Stardock starts developing a history of releasing games in this kind of state there will be no amount of apologizing Wardell could do, it would drive people away. It would result in bad press and give the company a bad public image. In essence it would be bad PR. If (take careful note of that word) Stardock fixes Elemental then the whole issue will blow over assuming their next title releases in much better shape.
 
Well yeah of course its PR. What else would it be? PR has such a negative stigma attached to it, but people don't seem to realize that a lot of things they praise are "just PR".
Because it's "just PR" - nothing else. Things done for PR that also benefit the customer/consumer are also PR, but are not "just" PR, since they give us something else.

Valve's free updates? Thats PR. Game patches? Another form of PR. Hell releasing good games can be considered PR.Good PR is essentially anything that builds trust or confidence in a product or company. Good PR builds customer relations that will keep bringing people back and making them more willing to spend money on the company.
Different kind of PR. Not a canned speech/letter written by somebody else. We actually get something out of it.
 
Because it's "just PR" - nothing else. Things done for PR that also benefit the customer/consumer are also PR, but are not "just" PR, since they give us something else.


Different kind of PR. Not a canned speech/letter written by somebody else. We actually get something out of it.

Yeah but by that logic, Stardock offering free the "Book 2" upcoming expansion pack to everyone who has already bought a game is not merely PR, either.
 
:rolleyes: He said long before the game came out he was going on vacation as soon as it was finished. He also ended his vacation early because of this.

Besides how often is it that the CEO of a company personally tells people face to face when they are laid off? Usually that is someone else's job.

Brad is a better man than you.
Get off your knees bud. What has Wardell done for you to justify thinking releasing shitty, unfinished products, then coming back to lay off all of his workers is OK?
 
Get off your knees bud. What has Wardell done for you to justify thinking releasing shitty, unfinished products, then coming back to lay off all of his workers is OK?

Talk about not paying an ounce of attention to the situation. They laid off the SECOND game team they had recently created. This was due to Elemental's poor performance. Thats how it goes when companies lose money.
 
Talk about not paying an ounce of attention to the situation. They laid off the SECOND game team they had recently created. This was due to Elemental's poor performance. Thats how it goes when companies lose money.
I don't give a shit. The guy released a shitty product and you guys are defending him for some reason. No wonder they do this when guys like you and blade join the rest of the sheep and blindly buy his crap products. He doesn't have to release a good game.
 
I don't give a shit. The guy released a shitty product and you guys are defending him for some reason. No wonder they do this when guys like you and blade join the rest of the sheep and blindly buy his crap products. He doesn't have to release a good game.

Learn some mother fucking reading comprehension.
 
Back
Top