Wardell apologizes

WabeWalker

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
4,508
From the wire:

Speaking on the official Stardock forums, Brad Wardell, the CEO of Stardock has revealed that the problems associated with Elemental’s disastrous launch were nothing to do with the game being pushed out the door early. In fact, Wardell says that releasing a game early is “an easy thing for a company to ‘fix’… If the game had come out in February, it would still have been a disastrous launch because lack of time wasn’t the issue.” Wardell says he had his “head in the sand.”

The full post, below, makes for extraordinary reading.

(I’m up north on vacation typing on an extremely slow connection so bear with me)

I don’t think people yet fully realize the completeness of Stardock’s fail on Elementa’s launch.

I’m going to write more about this but not only did we think v1.05 was ready for everyone but we felt v1.0 was too. That’s the level of disconnect/poor judgment on our part we’re talking about.

If the game had come out in February, it would still have been a disastrous launch because lack of time wasn’t the issue. It was blindness, sheer blindness. We felt the game was finished. And I speak of v1.0, not v1.05. Blindness.

There will be massive consequences for Stardock’s game studio. I’ll be talking more about this when I get back. But the game wasn’t released early. The game was released poorly. Head in the sand syndrome imo. I’ve read the reviews as much as possible given my hideous internet access up here and I agree with them. We just didn’t see what they were talking about. We thought any complaints would be about polish points or something.

The point is, the issue here is far far worse than many of you think it is. I wish it was an issue of the game being released too early. That’s an easy thing for a company to “fix”. Elemental’s launch is the result of catastrophic poor judgment on my part.

EVERY competent software developer knows that the programmer must never be the one deciding whether the program is done. Yet, my love of Elemental broke my self discipline and I began coding on the game itself in vast amounts and lost any sense of objectivity on where the game’s state was. I normally only program the AI on our games so I can keep a level of distance from the game itself to determine whether it’s “Ready”. On Elemental, I was in love with the world and the game and lost my impartiality.

We’ll do better.
 
And this is why I have a ton of respect for Brad Wardell. He is willing to come out and say "Hey I fucked up" and not lay the blame elsewhere. Other execs could learn a thing or two.
 
I bought that game Demigod, it was great, but got repetitive real fast, but was worth a few days of fun imo. I haven't played it at all this year, but last year I played it a little.

I think Stardock's CEO is a great person, i think he needs to focus more on making better games than trying to be a good CEO/PR/Programmer.

I'm not saying one person can't be all 3, he should just focus on making sure BETTER games get released.

FWIW, I agree with Derangel, he has a lot of credibility because of how he accepts personal accountability when something goes wrong, but he should just fucking learn his lessons. Demigod wasn't without it's share of problems, it could have been a much better game than it was.
 
What is Stardock doing? Galactic Civilizations 2 was a fantastic game. Demigod was a disaster (and i never bought/played it due to waiting to see how the game released first) and Stardock acknowledged the problems, apologized, and said something similiar would not happen again. Now the very next game sounds like an even bigger disaster? And this was actually supposed to be their next "flagship" game, unlike Demigod. What is going on here?
 
GPG developed Demigod. Stardock only published and handled the online part of it, AFAIK.

Wasn't Gal Civ 2 just as buggy as Elemental when it was released?
 
And this is why I have a ton of respect for Brad Wardell. He is willing to come out and say "Hey I fucked up" and not lay the blame elsewhere. Other execs could learn a thing or two.

Uh... What?

So as long as a developer was willing to admit, after copies of the game had been sold, that the game was crap, then - what? - we, as gamers, are supposed to accept that? We're supposed to let them off the hook because they apologized? If developers started doing this I think it would start to piss me off even more.

I'm seriously not following your line of reasoning here.

This seems to me like a massive cop-out. If this guy is willing to refund people's money, then, yeah, okay, I'll have respect for him.

For me, this is yet another ploy to suck up to gamers, and to tell them what they want to hear, which is what this company seems to thrive on. I thought that this company's so called Gamers Bill of Rights was pretty much laughable - for the obvious reason that they had just violated their own rules.

This developer, in acting so humble, is trying to come across as a sympathetic character in order to win favor with gamers. It's kind of transparent, IMO.
 
Last edited:
I don't buy the graphics complaints. They are cartoony, but they get the job done for that genre.
 
looking forward to playing this game when it is actually polished. I hope they keep working on it, they still have a chance at my money.

also, developers should never have the final say in what ships and what gets held back for large projects. this is why things like qa and product manager exist.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
And this is why I have a ton of respect for Brad Wardell. He is willing to come out and say "Hey I fucked up" and not lay the blame elsewhere. Other execs could learn a thing or two.

Bullshit, the cart was so deep in the mud that there was no other recourse. The post is the work of some image consultant and not Brad's original work. Look back at any post he ever made, this guy is not the type to apologize and the only reason he did is to save the company not because he truly feels that he did anything wrong.

IMHO the only consequence that would be meaningful is for him to retire and leave Stardock to more capable hands.
 
Bullshit, the cart was so deep in the mud that there was no other recourse. The post is the work of some image consultant and not Brad's original work. Look back at any post he ever made, this guy is not the type to apologize and the only reason he did is to save the company not because he truly feels that he did anything wrong.

IMHO the only consequence that would be meaningful is for him to retire and leave Stardock to more capable hands.

Yes actually he is. Look at Demigod. He came right out and said "we fucked up". He didn't say "the pirates screwed us over" he straight up said the way the online stuff was designed in the game was fundamentally flawed. Wardell has spent the last couple years coming off as being opinionated, but fairly honest about his thoughts when speaking to the press.

Wardell easily could have just said "We're working on patches. Expect them soon. The game will be perfect once its patched. Sorry". That would be the a-typical response someone in his position gives to this situation. I have never seen, in the game industry, a CEO of a company take personal responsibility for a game being fucked. Wardell is the only one who gives the impression that he gives two fucks if the games his company puts out are good.

As for more capable hands? Uhh he founded Stardock and has turned it into a company which has been growing fairly steadily for 19 years. I'd say he is very capable at running it.
 
Last edited:
Uh... What?

So as long as a developer was willing to admit, after copies of the game had been sold, that the game was crap, then - what? - we, as gamers, are supposed to accept that? We're supposed to let them off the hook because they apologized? If developers started doing this I think it would start to piss me off even more.

I'm seriously not following your line of reasoning here.

This seems to me like a massive cop-out. If this guy is willing to refund people's money, then, yeah, okay, I'll have respect for him.

For me, this is yet another ploy to suck up to gamers, and to tell them what they want to hear, which is what this company seems to thrive on. I thought that this company's so called Gamers Bill of Rights was pretty much laughable - for the obvious reason that they had just violated their own rules.

This developer, in acting so humble, is trying to come across as a sympathetic character in order to win favor with gamers. It's kind of transparent, IMO.

Don't put words in my mouth. I simply said its nice to see a CEO stepping up to the plate and taking blame instead of passing the buck. Plain and simple.
 
Of course we dont want games released with issues, but it's better that the damn CEO owns up to the problems rather than sweep them under the rug, these are 2 different issues, the fact that we think it's good to own up to mistakes does not mean we automatically prefer to have mistakes in the first place.

Hopefully they'll fix it all as quickly as possible and learn from their mistakes for next time.
 
Of course we dont want games released with issues, but it's better that the damn CEO owns up to the problems rather than sweep them under the rug, these are 2 different issues, the fact that we think it's good to own up to mistakes does not mean we automatically prefer to have mistakes in the first place.

Hopefully they'll fix it all as quickly as possible and learn from their mistakes for next time.

Exactly. I heard about these issues with Elemental and have stayed far away from the game.
 
Ok, he owned up to releasing crap. My question is are they going to fix their crap?
 
Ok, he owned up to releasing crap. My question is are they going to fix their crap?

Thats the part we have to wait and see. I believe they've put out a few patches so far. So its a good start I guess. Stardock is one of the few companies I'd be willing to give a little faith to in regards to fixing a broken game. Though I could be completely wrong.
 
Wasn't Gal Civ 2 just as buggy as Elemental when it was released?

I don't think it was. If my memory is correct, only about 5% or people had serious problems with Gal Civ 2. There were lots of fixes and improvements, but it was mostly small stuff.
 
Wabe, are you in the video game industry or something? Or do you have a friend or relative in it?

I'm trying to make sense of where you are coming from. Something about Stardock really itches you the wrong way.
 
Wabe, are you in the video game industry or something? Or do you have a friend or relative in it?

I'm trying to make sense of where you are coming from. Something about Stardock really itches you the wrong way.

Wabe seems pretty reasonable in this thread. I would actually think more people should have an issue with Stardock proclaiming their Gamer Bill of Rights as the way to do business, and then releasing a steaming pile of shit as a retail product before trying to run clean up with an apology. Not to mention then trying to obfuscate things by saying the game was actually done, it just "released poorly".

Stardock pretends they operate at a higher standard, they need to act like it. People would have their torches and pitchforks out if EA released a game in this terrible of a state.
 
Last edited:
Brad posted this on the Elemental forums yesterday:

I think, for starters, the first expansion pack for Elemental - Book 2, will have to be given away for free to the people who already bought the game.

In my mind, that's a START. So, anyone who sticks with is going to get at least one free expansion pack out of it. And it won't be some piddly "look, it's a new campaign". Think Dark Avatar level expansion.

He's also had some pretty significant mea culpas on the Elemental board.
 
Apologies are worse than useless if you don't follow it up with some kind of doing something...He really needs to work on timing. Usually the best time to apologise is when you have some kind of "compensation" ammunition to distract people with.

huh I figured itd be because the game looks indie.

fixed. They are synonyms nowadays...
 
Last edited:
Money back?

And this is why I have a ton of respect for Brad Wardell. He is willing to come out and say "Hey I fucked up" and not lay the blame elsewhere. Other execs could learn a thing or two.
I"ll have a lot more respect if he follows his own bill of rights and refunds people.

Anyways, I call his bluff that they thought the game was done. How can a game that crashes so often and have so many bugs be looked at as 'ready'. Unless of course his testers didn't actually play the game or that he doesn't play it himself. He may of also been pressuring the team to release and someone he trusted told him it was ready. Of course this comes back to him not playing it to see with his own eyes.
And this is why I have a ton of respect for Brad Wardell. He is willing to come out and say "Hey I fucked up" and not lay the blame elsewhere. Other execs could learn a thing or two.
OK, that's great. So it's OK to admit your wrong but not do anything about it? If I were you, I would reserve judgment to wait until they actually do something about it. Words saying "I'm wrong" mean nothing if you don't actually change your behavior. Words are just that, words. Very easy to to speak.
 
Last edited:
He has said that he was doing significant coding himself. He thought the game was ready and was going to be great. He had most certainly seen it with his own eyes.
 
I'm surprised that anybody would defend this - as ocellaris suggested above, if EA had created the gamers bill of rights, people would have laughed at them.

But imagine if EA had released a game like this and then apologized for it, which is what Derangel says he wants to see developers do more of: I may be wrong about this but I have my doubts that very many gamers, if any, would applaud EA, and then show respect for them. (I have a hunch that gamers would likely have a field day at the forums.)

What if the company had been Ubisoft? Or how about Activision?

Would gamers show respect to any of these companies if they released an unfinished product and then apologized afterwards, especially in light of having created a gamers' bill of rights?
 
I'm surprised that anybody would defend this - as ocellaris suggested above, if EA had created the gamers bill of rights, people would have laughed at them.

But imagine if EA had released a game like this and then apologized for it, which is what Derangel says he wants to see developers do more of: I may be wrong about this but I have my doubts that very many gamers, if any, would applaud EA, and then show respect for them. (I have a hunch that gamers would likely have a field day at the forums.)

Exactly.

What if the company had been Ubisoft?

Can you imagine that in addition to all the DRM stuff? Forget it.


Or how about Activision?

They might have half a chance.


Would gamers show respect to any of these companies if they released an unfinished product and then apologized afterwards, especially in light of having created a gamers' bill of rights?

I would, you probably would, Derangel would, some others would but a lot of others probably wouldn't.

Personally I, too, would like to see more accountability and honesty in the gaming world like what Mr. Wardell has done. :)
 
I'm surprised that anybody would defend this - as ocellaris suggested above, if EA had created the gamers bill of rights, people would have laughed at them.

But imagine if EA had released a game like this and then apologized for it, which is what Derangel says he wants to see developers do more of: I may be wrong about this but I have my doubts that very many gamers, if any, would applaud EA, and then show respect for them. (I have a hunch that gamers would likely have a field day at the forums.)

What if the company had been Ubisoft? Or how about Activision?

Would gamers show respect to any of these companies if they released an unfinished product and then apologized afterwards, especially in light of having created a gamers' bill of rights?

The difference between Stardock and people like EA or Ubisoft or Activision is that those three big companies have a history of simply dropping a product and not supporting it. Stardock doesn't. Hell every single patch for Demigod was done by Stardock. GPG ditched the game pretty much right after it was done. As of right now Stardock has yet to prove that they can't be trusted to fix a product. When/if they get to that point then I'll have a different tune. I'm not going to attack a company without good reason. I'm a game journalist that actually takes some damn pride in his work and actually believes in waiting to see if a company deserves a fair shot.
 
The difference between Stardock and people like EA or Ubisoft or Activision is that those three big companies have a history of simply dropping a product and not supporting it. Stardock doesn't. Hell every single patch for Demigod was done by Stardock. GPG ditched the game pretty much right after it was done. As of right now Stardock has yet to prove that they can't be trusted to fix a product. When/if they get to that point then I'll have a different tune. I'm not going to attack a company without good reason. I'm a game journalist that actually takes some damn pride in his work and actually believes in waiting to see if a company deserves a fair shot.

This is true. For once (I swear it'll never happen again) I mostly agree with Wabe that this whole fiasco is being largely given a pass. But as you've said the big difference is that Stardock has always eventually fixed their issues. EA releases one or two patches if you're lucky then moves on to the next big thing. Hell, they are still selling Mercs 2 although the game has more bugs than a bed in NYC and online MP doesn't work at all.

I still don't buy Brad's excuse at all. There is no way this game was "ready to ship". I believe that Stardock will eventually get it right, but my money is staying in my pocket until then and I've lost a ton of respect for them overall.
 
I'm a game journalist that actually takes some damn pride in his work and actually believes in waiting to see if a company deserves a fair shot.

Who are you? Or at least: Who are you with? If you don't mind my asking. :)
 
Derangel, you don't have to announce in every second post you write that you're a 'game journalist' - it doesn't make your opinion of something anymore valid than anybody else's here, and it's also getting a little tiring.

I mention it when its valid. If you don't like it, too bad. I wasn't using it to say "Hey my opinion is better" it was mentioned to say "this is why I'm sitting a bit on the sidelines on the issue". Outside of a few times I talked about reviewing Mafia 2 I haven't mentioned it in a while anyway. So if you saw it its because you're posting in that thread.
 
Last edited:
This is true. For once (I swear it'll never happen again) I mostly agree with Wabe that this whole fiasco is being largely given a pass. But as you've said the big difference is that Stardock has always eventually fixed their issues. EA releases one or two patches if you're lucky then moves on to the next big thing. Hell, they are still selling Mercs 2 although the game has more bugs than a bed in NYC and online MP doesn't work at all.

I still don't buy Brad's excuse at all. There is no way this game was "ready to ship". I believe that Stardock will eventually get it right, but my money is staying in my pocket until then and I've lost a ton of respect for them overall.

My whole idea is just to wait and see what happenes. If Stardock drops the ball on it then they'll have earned a lot of ire and have lost a lot of trust among gamers. If they fix it likely everyone will forget that it ever happened. Until I see it going one way or the other I'm not going to be worked up. Now if I owned the game that'd be a different story.
 
So who are you a journalist for? Otherwise its not really valid and no one cares.

Not that anyone would care in the first place since its not even a known site. But since you asked an incredibly tiny site called Pixel Smashers.
 
Let's get back on the topic folks.

back on topic. I got Demigod as a birthday present after reading a lot about it here on the forum and on other sites. I was excited for it, it seemed great at first. Then you play it for a while, and what? It's just really repetitive. They tried to make it like DotA with a different graphics engine. The concept was fine, they just didn't have enough heroes, that's what made it suck so bad. Without variety, why would you play that type of game? It'll almost always be the same every time.

I think that's what Stardock has been guilty of with some of their past releases, not truly releasing a full game. It seems like they put enough in a game to ship it out, and then ship it. I realize that not all companies can do what Blizzard does or what Mr. Miyamoto of Nintendo does as far as their policy of "It's done when it's done." Miyamoto, if he doesn't like what he sees of a game, forces the programmers to start over from SCRATCH untill he sees enough progress and polish to satisfy him, only then will it be released.

I think that Stardock has some great ideas for games, they just need to spent more time polishing their games and making sure that when it's released, that the customers will be satsfied, that it's working and that all the bugs have been ironed out from enough beta (bug?) testing.

I would rather Wardell focus on that, and then he wouldn't see debacles like this happen. I like him and his company, I'd like to see them succeed, it would be good for us as PC Gamers if they succeed. But at the same time, if they don't put out a good product, I'm not buying it!

I also want to add that I think his lack of objectivity from being "so personally involved" (his words) in the programming and producing of it was not a good thing when he decided that it should be shipped. Games are better off when they shipped in a completed state.
 
I'm of mixed feelings about this. As many of the above posters have mentioned: in light of the Gamers' Bill of Rights, you'd think that if one company could "get it right," that company would be Stardock.

That said, it's my [limited] understanding that blaming Stardock for the release state of Demigod is unreasonable: it wasn't developed by Stardock. If they get negative points for Demigod (which seems to have improved greatly by their hand), they should get kudos for Sins of a Solar Empire.

But I digress. Stardock released an unready product, and they're paying: they're paying in bad press and customer loyalty and dollars spent on their product. I think it's admirable that their CEO steps up and assumes responsibility - but that doesn't change their product. Giving a free expansion might: it adds value to what people have already purchased.

Also, I thought I understood that part of the reason for Elemental's rushed release (a few days/weeks earlier than planned?) was that due to Stardock's no DRM policy, when a distributor leaked an early version, Stardock needed to do something. Fact or myth?

At some level though, this all seems fairly...academic. Irrelevant, even. Because reasonably, when determining whether or not to purchase a particular game, how we feel about a company or head thereof does not change the product itself (though I suppose customers may wish to reward a company they see as having good business practices). I'll buy Elemental when it seems like a good buy, and I'll do the same for future Stardock games.

Tarrosion
 
Back
Top