Vista Rant

soulesschild

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Feb 18, 2007
Messages
6,176
So I work in an IT department and we mainly use macs, but have pcs users on XP pro. It's SUPER frustrating to see my co-workers rag all day on Vista and Vista x64 and basically shitting on anyone that gets Vista with a pre-installed laptop. My co-worker says, Vista sucks, and the i7 sucks because it makes you get 3/6/12 gb of ram when only XP pro supports 3GB max. So I ask why not go Vista x64 and he's like, the only x64 I'll ever go is XP Pro x64.

WTF is with all this hate on Vista. I use it on all my machines and I'm pretty much the only one that deals with Vista trouble shooting because everytime someone comes in with a Vista related problem, my co-workers just tell him to reformat.

Are all IT departments this retarded?
 
And when a person that blindly repeats Vista FUD like it's wisdom from their own brain get's a chance to actually try out Vista and learns it's got a lot to offer over Windows XP, they just shut up. They instead should go around and apologize to everyone for repeating gossip like it was fact and ask for forgiveness for misleading their friends and coworkers.
 
Not all IT departments, just the ones who do not take the time to learn about vista. Instead they just repeat what they hear from others. I have Vista Ult. and i love it :D
 
You're co-workers are getting it from watching those STUPID friggen mac commercials.
 
So I work in an IT department and we mainly use macs, but have pcs users on XP pro. It's SUPER frustrating to see my co-workers rag all day on Vista and Vista x64 and basically shitting on anyone that gets Vista with a pre-installed laptop. My co-worker says, Vista sucks, and the i7 sucks because it makes you get 3/6/12 gb of ram when only XP pro supports 3GB max. So I ask why not go Vista x64 and he's like, the only x64 I'll ever go is XP Pro x64.

WTF is with all this hate on Vista. I use it on all my machines and I'm pretty much the only one that deals with Vista trouble shooting because everytime someone comes in with a Vista related problem, my co-workers just tell him to reformat.

Are all IT departments this retarded?

Pull a Mojave Experiment on them.
 
They are just jumping on the band wagon. Everyone is bashing vista so others follow without testing or trying it themselves

Vista has it's issues (the one I hate the most is its inability to remember folder settings) but it is a stable OS that I have been using for a while now.

At work we are all on XP and even laptops and desktops that come with Vista, we just keep the key and then load them with XP just because it is an engineering firm and they have some programs that don't play well with Vista.

I like it and looking forward to 7.

mmmm i7 with Windows 7 and 12 gig ram.
 
Vist'as not perfect. it STILL has weird bugs and some modern games crashing. also i COMPLETELY HATE the way it handles audio. i know they made major chances to the audio system for stability or something, but i didnt have any problems with audio in XP.

even with these bugs, it's much much better than XP. the GFX-card rendered, GUI, excellent 64bit support (XP x64 was fantastic for the last 2+ years as well), DX10, Live Search is fantastic, the built-in Windows Update that doesnt require IE is great, the new start menu is marginally better than XP, and Ultimate's DreamScene is simply awesome.

most of the issues with Vista revolve around the different way it handles audio, how UAC interacts with some apps (just disable it), and some GUI crashes. UAC is very cool in theory, but i dont think it does much in the long wrong. the whole premise relies on people knowing why the UAC permission pops up and what caused it. when probably 99% of standard PC users click "OK" to everything anyway, UAC doesnt really do much.
 
UAC is very cool in theory, but i dont think it does much in the long wrong. the whole premise relies on people knowing why the UAC permission pops up and what caused it. when probably 99% of standard PC users click "OK" to everything anyway, UAC doesnt really do much.

This is why I've been laughing outright at UAC advocates for years now. Some respond "so add a password prompt, that'll make them slow down and think." Not true. It'll just annoy and alienate the end user even further. I've had a few people try Linux, and one of the most common complaints is having to 'sudo' and type in a password so much. No one -- not even myself or most others with an abnormally high level of understanding as to what's really going on -- wants to take the time there.
 
Vist'as not perfect. it STILL has weird bugs and some modern games crashing. also i COMPLETELY HATE the way it handles audio. i know they made major chances to the audio system for stability or something, but i didnt have any problems with audio in XP.

If you want good audio on Vista, god help me for posting this, get a Creative X-Fi card.

The latest drivers rock and work just as good as the X-Fi worked on XP. The whole sound issue is what turned me off back in the early days of Vista... I revisted Vista when I got my free Ultimate copies from Microsoft and was very very surprised at how well the sound worked with Creatives new drivers.
 
Vista sucks
Wrong
i7 sucks because it makes you get 3/6/12 gb of ram
Wrong
when only XP pro supports 3GB max.
Wrong
Are all IT departments this retarded?
No.

I don't think Vista has a spot in the mainstream workspace yet, and it won't for some time, but these people are obviously idiots and have no idea what they are talking about, so their opinion on Vista means nothing. I'll tell you though, built in 'run as admin' for limited accounts, and being able to allow certain hardware installation via policy, are 2 nice features I wish I had in XP pro. Some day :)
 
um.....

you can install les then 3G of ram in i7..lol it does do dual channel..

i think all of these people should be brought together and burned or.. something
 
I don't think you can call Vista new at this point. I'd say it's matured nicely.

Yes for audio, get an x-fi. The drivers sucked at first but now their just fine and dandy.

@the ram comment about i7. I think i7 runs best in tri channel am I correct? + the low voltage ddr3 dims only come in 3gigs i think...

Does anyone just love how when you reformat vista, shit just works or it finds the drivers for you? I remember how much I hated reformatting dells when users lost their driver Cd and I'd have to hunt on dell's website to find drivers.
 
Let them slam Vista and i7 all they want. I'll be running both and they can suffer with what the have. They deserve every minute with their old slow worn out junk. :eek:
 
WTF is with all this hate on Vista. I use it on all my machines and I'm pretty much the only one that deals with Vista trouble shooting because everytime someone comes in with a Vista related problem, my co-workers just tell him to reformat.
We got some laptops in recently and my boss and I started putting the (corporate supplied) Vista x64 images on them, and they worked really well. Then one day one of the other guys decided "Vista x64 doesn't support the company antivirus software" and re-did ALL of the laptops with Vista x86.

Note: The anti-virus software he was talking about was plainly visible running in the system tray on the x64 installs, since it came with the 64-bit version of the software.

I was already hopped up on caffeine, but when he told me he did that I almost exploded.
 
WTF is with all this hate on Vista. I use it on all my machines and I'm pretty much the only one that deals with Vista trouble shooting because everytime someone comes in with a Vista related problem, my co-workers just tell him to reformat.

Are all IT departments this retarded?

IT departments are often "that retarded" because the people filling responsible positions within them are so often adherents to what I like to call the "Piblic Service School of Learning'. People, in other words, who have learnt what they know by virtue of training which has them memorising step by step 'press this button next' instructions in oirder to be able to do stuff. And who pass that approach on to others.

For such people, any change to procedure poses a rather large problem. Change a routine or move a setting, and it all needs to learnt over again. Those people haven't learnt to think in terms of 'concept', so they are less well equipped for adapting to a changed environment.


Don't forget, though, that there are many corporations where the deployment of a newer OS version genuinely isn't a viable option, because of hardware and/or software compatibility issues present within the organisation.

But the scanario you are dexcribing isn't one of those. What you are describing is nothing other than people (whether they like to admit it or not) effectively saying "Go put XP on it because I don't know how to help you with Vista!"
 
Part of the problem is, if they are used to macs and have been using them for quite some time, they don't remember what it is like to form their own opinions. Mac zealots are used to, and actually prefer being told how everything will be, how it will work, and how they are supposed to use it, they are often afraid to try anything new, unless Steve Jobs blessed it first.

If an IT Department, here in Winter 2008, haven't been trying and testing Vista by now, they aren't doing their duties towards their client/customer base. It also speaks poorly to their quality of knowledge and service, if they bash a techology without even doing some basic research into it.
 
Vista not new, sorry. From someone my age I have seen this argument for over 40 years. Its new because its not understood, 5 years from now all will like vista and hate the new os.

What seems to work best is if stuff like this forum continues to help others the transitions seem to work.

Its just new people.

I remember a day when the internet did not exist for people, hard disk information from manufacturers like pulling teeth, GUI ha, I learned from a C:>.
 
"Go put XP on it because I don't know how to help you with Vista!"

That was one of my reasons for getting Vista. I don't need it, but I'm the family IT guy. People started getting machines preloaded so I needed to get fluent. I built my new machine around it as it is a great OS. I am a lucky one, though. I haven't had any real problems since Me :eek:. Pretty much everything has worked out of the box unless I was fucking with it :p
 
That was one of my reasons for getting Vista. I don't need it, but I'm the family IT guy. People started getting machines preloaded so I needed to get fluent. I built my new machine around it as it is a great OS. I am a lucky one, though. I haven't had any real problems since Me :eek:. Pretty much everything has worked out of the box unless I was fucking with it :p

I'm the family IT guy largely *because* I have a background in IT (government IT, going back to the days when IT meant *mainframes*); however, I learned Really Early that if you don't keep up with new advances (hardware/software/etc.) you get covered with butter and syrup (basically, you get pancaked). I have run nearly every version of Windows (back to Windows/286 on the old Zeniths) to Vista Ultimate (I've crossgraded three designed-around-XP machines to Vista x86, and crossgraded three Vista x86 PCs with 64-bit processors to Vista x64; all six are running withouth Vista-related issues).

Additional information on the three Vista x64 crossgrades: NONE has more than 2 GB of RAM (in fact, two have a mere 512 MB). All three have integrated graphics (two from VIA, one from Intel). The 2 GB machine (the HP Pavilion I am typing from) is also the only dual-core PC among the crossgraded (the others are single-core-but-LGA775 Celerons).
Among the Vista x86 PCs, they have 512 MB, 1 GB, and 2 GB, with Northwood-B/Northwood-B/Northwood-C processors, respectively. (All three are running Vista Ultimate x86.) The 2 GB Vista x86 PC was designed around XP, not Vista (it's the rig in my sig) and actually runs Vista better than it ran XP (however, the Pavilion I'm on eats its lunch, despite integrated graphics, a lower WEI score, and a 1 GHz clock deficit, not to mention that it's running Vista Ultimate x64).Crow Sammiches; Get your Hot Crow Sammiches!
 
Ok, honestly? While the reasons they gave are idiotic, there are very valid reasons why an IT dept may not want to move to vista yet. I mean aside from the hardware and software reasons.

We tend to operate on the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" mentality. Xp ain't broke, we're looking at security patches through, what, 2012? What possible business case could be given to cause such an upheaval. Not only of our resources ( IT ), but also of our users?

There isn't one. Especially not with a new OS coming out within the next two years. So again, from a management perspective, here are the choices;

1) Start migrating to Vista. This option entails relearning the GUI for both IT and end users, a royal pain in the ass. Not only that, but the new features of the OS mean nothing in every day use. Do the same thing in two years when the next OS comes out, because you just KNOW MS can't leave the fucking interface alone.

2) Wait for the next OS; this will be much closer to the cut off date of xp, and will entail all the fun of the Vista move, but will only be done ONCE.

It's really a no-brainer.
 
There's no validity for an IT department to tell someone to just go buy XP when Vista is just fine and dandy. We have the budget, our software that people use is supported by Vista. So why not? Why have people pay like 199 for a XP downgrade is beyond me. Especially with everyone up in arms about the economy.

They don't want to support it basically. They don't want to learn it. They bash Vista too because it doesn't work well in Parallels, but from what I hear, Parallels pretty much sucks ass right now compared to VirtualBox/
 
Back
Top