Visit Microcenter or Wait for Next Big Thing?

Syllabub

n00b
Joined
Jun 24, 2011
Messages
62
I am heading down to Atlanta on business Wednesday the 14th coming back on Friday the 16th. I don't get down that way very often so this is pretty much an opportunity I won't get again for a good long while. Having laid that ground work my question: Should I jump at this opportunity to stop by Microcenter to get a Core i3 2100 for $99 or a Core i5 2400 for $149 or is it best to wait and see how the whole Bulldozer/Zambezi thing shakes out? I know Ivy Bridge is also due sometime before year end but for what I do with a computer I just don't see that as a good use of my money. I could also look at getting a Phenom II X4 970 for $139..

My computer usage isn't anything psychotic: gaming at 1680x1050 (Company of Heroes, Dragon Age Origins, Galactic Civilizations, Warhammer 40K, Portal 2) typical internet stuff, and Adobe CS4 Web Suite playing around with Photoshop and Actionscript.

I had been running an old AMD Athlon 64 3000+ that I recently gave to my brother in law so I am mooching off of my wife's Intel Core 2 Duo e6750 based system. To be perfectly honest that machine still feels pretty responsive and does most of what we ask it to do.

I really wanted to wait for BD but AMD's timing and my timing are not aligning and the Sandy Bridge stuff is so darn compelling. I know the i5 2400 would be a bit more future proof but I am not sure if it is worth the additional fifty bucks over the i3 2100.

Any suggestions are appreciated.
 
The Core i5 2400 is totally worth the extra $50 and $10 over the Core i3 2100 and AMD Phneom II X4 970 for gaming. Hell, even the $100 Core i3 2100 outperforms that $140 AMD Phenom II X4 970 in games.

Ultimately, it's really down to you and you alone to make that hardware decision. You could go for the sure thing and go with the Intel CPUs whose performance is greater than most AMD CPUs. Or you could wait and hope that AMD's new CPUs will finally be able to compete well with the current generation of Intel CPUs and go with that. It really comes down to whether or not you believe AMD's Bulldozer will be a good buy.
 
The Core i5 2400 is totally worth the extra $50 and $10 over the Core i3 2100 and AMD Phneom II X4 970 for gaming. Hell, even the $100 Core i3 2100 outperforms that $140 AMD Phenom II X4 970 in games.

Ultimately, it's really down to you and you alone to make that hardware decision. You could go for the sure thing and go with the Intel CPUs whose performance is greater than most AMD CPUs. Or you could wait and hope that AMD's new CPUs will finally be able to compete well with the current generation of Intel CPUs and go with that. It really comes down to whether or not you believe AMD's Bulldozer will be a good buy.

Thanks for the reply Danny. That i5 2400 is really tugging at my wallet with the MC price of $149 beating anything else I can find online by a good bit. Someone might point out that an online purchase would save sales tax but Newegg collects state tax in Tennessee so that is not a big factor for me. As far as Bulldozer goes I am drawing the conclusion that it will approach the performance of Sandy Bridge for users that can push enough of the cores but for mainstream users it will have to be a price to performance decision.

When I ask myself will Bulldozer offer equivalent or better performance at a $149 price point when compared to the i5 2400 I am left with a good bit of fear, uncertainty and doubt. It just doesn't seem to be in the cards and even if it is I bet the TDP of Bulldozer won't compete with Sandy. At least I have a few days to mull the decision over and decide if I really need the new CPU.
 
Yeah, the lack of official word by AMD really doesn't leave much room for hope that the Bulldozer CPUs will be competitive enough. It may be a case of the when the old Phenom CPUs were released: The Phenom CPUs performed better than the older AMD CPUs but just couldn't quite match up to the Intel CPUs at the time. It wasn't until the Phenom II CPUs hit that AMD had cost-competitive as well performance-competitive CPUs against Intel's current CPUs.

So it may be a case of us waiting till Bulldozer II hits before AMD is really competitive.

EDIT: Shit, just saw these right now (Jeez don't check hardware news for a few days and you miss the really good stuff):
http://www.hardocp.com/article/2011/09/13/amd_bulldozer_fx_model_8150_cpu_overclocking_preview

http://www.anandtech.com/show/4767/pricing-revealed-for-first-amd-bulldozer-fx-chips

A bit more hopeful now actually..
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the links to some current updates on the FX chip lineup. I find it interesting that the 6 core FX-6100 is expected to cost around $190 which may or may not be indicative of the performance.

I could stretch what I spend from $149 to $179 and get a core i5 2500k from Microcenter while I am in Atlanta. You indicated that the extra $50 is definitely worth it when comparing the i5 2400 to the i3 2100. What about the extra $30 when comparing the i5 2400 vs the i5 2500k? I'd be pretty amazed to see the 4 core or 6 core Bulldozers hang with the i5 2500k but that is speculation on my part.

The issue with waiting for Bulldozer is that I won't be near a Microcenter in October or November and I'd end up paying higher prices for the CPU. I am really leaning towards the i5 2400 and curious about the i5 2500k. Either of them should cover my needs for quite a few years to come.
 
What about the extra $30 when comparing the i5 2400 vs the i5 2500k? I'd be pretty amazed to see the 4 core or 6 core Bulldozers hang with the i5 2500k but that is speculation on my part.
If you're overclocking, totally worth the $30. Not overclocking, not worth the $30. At stock speeds, the two CPUs perform similar. The Core i5 2500K does have faster onboard video but that $30 difference can easily pay for a faster dedicated video card with the Core i5 2400.
 
Well now that I am down in Alpharetta I started to nose around the Microcenter online flyer. This i5 2500k bundle jumped out at me as an option 2500k with Gigabyte GA-Z68X-UD3H-B3 ($289.98 bundled)

As they list it in the online flyer, not the web link, that is a savings of $130 ($70 off of the 2500k and $50 off of the mainboard)

The one thing that concerns me is that the GA-Z68X-UD3H-B3 appears to have 7 phases on the voltage regulator but I'm not sure it that is a potential issue. Tempting....
 
Last edited:
Well now that I am down in Alpharetta I started to nose around the Microcenter online flyer. This i5 2500k bundle jumped out at me as an option 2500k with Gigabyte GA-Z68X-UD3H-B3 ($289.98 bundled)

As they list it in the online flyer not the web link that is a savings of $130 ($70 off of the 2500k and $50 off of the mainboard)

The one thing that concerns me is that the GA-Z68X-UD3H-B3 appears to have 7 phases on the voltage regulator but I'm not sure it that is a potential issue. Tempting....

Not an issue unless you're planning to overclock the CPU past 4.4GHz or so. Overclocks of the i5-2500K to the 4.2 to 4.4 GHz range are easily achievable on a motherboard with only six phases on the VRM. In fact, some boards with only 10 phases on the VRM overclock better than some with 18 phases on the VRM.
 
On a hunch I checked the motherboards section of [H]ard|OCP and what did I find but a review of the GA-Z68X-UD3H.:D Dan (possibly the same Danny Bui that responded to my initial post?) and Kyle had some issues with the RAID controller and UEFI Bios but that won't impact me. As far as the overclocking goes my plan would not be to go crazy and try to push the limits. If I could hit 4.2gHz to 4.4gHz I'd be thrilled. To be honest this would be my first foray into overclocking and it is a bit exciting. The old salts of overclocking might cringe to hear me say that since overclocking an i5 2500k is nothing like OC'ing on earlier generations of CPUs.

Thank you very much to Danny and E4g1e for providing your input. I'll let you know shortly what I decide to do.
 
Nope, different person.

Good luck!

I figured I might be reaching a bit making that association between 'Dan' & 'Danny Bui'. ;)

I went ahead and pulled the trigger this morning: i5 2500k for $179.99 and the Gigabyte GA-Z68X-UD3H for $119.99 after a combo purchase promo. If you gave me a stick I don't think I could beat that. Now I just need to buy a few more parts and get started on the build.

Thank you for the input. See you around in the forums.
 
I figured I might be reaching a bit making that association between 'Dan' & 'Danny Bui'. ;)

I went ahead and pulled the trigger this morning: i5 2500k for $179.99 and the Gigabyte GA-Z68X-UD3H for $119.99 after a combo purchase promo. If you gave me a stick I don't think I could beat that. Now I just need to buy a few more parts and get started on the build.

Thank you for the input. See you around in the forums.

Where'd you get that combo at again? :cool:
 
Where'd you get that combo at again? :cool:

At the Microcenter in Duluth Georgia. Store pickup only unfortunately to get their incredible prices on Sandy Bridge CPUs. They have a number of stores around so check them out at 23 Microcenter Locations Nationwide

They also have a bundle combo with the i7 2600k where they knock $80 off of any Z68 motherboard. The 2600k is a bit outside of my price range and I don't do anything that would really push that caliber of CPU so I passed on that option.

With Microcenter they key is to be close enough to give a location a visit because the really great deals on CPUs are in store only. I was traveling on business to Atlanta so that is how I took advantage of it.
 
Back
Top