Violent Video Games Linked to Child Aggression

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Oh no, here we go again. Every time I read one of these studies about video games being linked to aggression, I have to wonder what is the motivation behind these studies. Seriously, video games have been on the rise for twenty years making it one of the largest industries on the planet. In the same time frame violent crimes have taken a nose dive. Shouldn’t it be the opposite if this study is even partially correct?

In every group, children who were exposed to more video game violence did become more aggressive over time than their peers who had less exposure. This was true even after the researchers took into account how aggressive the children were at the beginning of the study -- a strong predictor of future bad behavior.
 
This article would make Jack Thompson proud.


Full of crap.
 
Bad parents = bad kids. If young children are playing violent games the only one that should take the blame is the parents.
 
of course its false, I'm not even going to read it, they are playing off of simple fears from people and want to score hits for their article.
 
I don't even have to read the article to reply!

There are studies the contradict these statements!
Why don't parents use the ESRB if these statements are true and stop BSing about how these games make their kids do stupider things than they are already doing?
Why dont they do a test about how violent games attract violent people then compair that to violent games that attract non-violent people?

These studies are nothing but crap:mad:
 
It's true violent video games causes violent kids... if it was the parents who played the video games and not spend time with their neglected children.

;)

Thus, even Hello Kitty's Adventure Island causes violent kids too!
 
Well at least there were two differing viewpoints in the article. At best we can say the jury is out.

Here in the UK kids are demonised all the time, for example, year on year the average level of grades has increased. Good news eh? No, according to some, as it shows exams are getting easier. :(

p.s. Steve, some of us remember video games on the rise from over 30 years ago. ;) :D
 
They should do a study where they take 2 families with misbehaving children and have one of the set of parents hit their kid every time he does something wrong and the other parents do nothing when their kid does something wrong.
 
Bad parents = bad kids. If young children are playing violent games the only one that should take the blame is the parents.

Yup, but this is America land of the free! Where parents are free from the responsibilities of raising their children properly. Instead they leave, TV, School, and Video Games to instill beliefs, moral, manners, and to let kids know what is wrong and right.

And the reason for that is because parents cant properly discipline their children anymore. You even look at your kid wrong and here comes social services. Its only going to get worse with the future generations.

Not being able to properly discipline your kids, when are they being bratty, little assholes, and don't listen to a word you say is what makes bad kids. Not video games.

I think its time for parents to start taking off their belts again. To install proper values, morals, some fucking common sense in kids these day.
 
They need to take violent video games away from Osama and his Al Queda.
 
Cancer is also linked to breathing air

Linking does not equal causation so the title is fair (more than fair--the research suggests causality).

The journalist presented alternate viewpoints including disclaimers by the researchers themselves, so the article is (mostly) fair.

The researchers made a point of comparing behaviour before and after an extended period of observation, used more than one input on subjects' behaviour, and had good numbers and controls so the study is fair.

The study did not seek to compare video games with other media, nor to establish a link with violent crime or societal changes (only aggressive behaviour) so the lead-in to this thread and the last part of the article are entirely extrapolation.

Don't read the article if you don't think it's going to agree with your viewpoint but then posting here is less than useful.
 
As a parent and a gamer, I don't think this article is correct, but then neither are the responses here correct either. Raising a kid is tough, especially in todays degraded, everywhere in-your-face pop culture. I shouldn't have to spend so much time keeping my kids away from so much. It wasn't always like that. On the other hand, people are responsible for their actions no matter what they their background.

We definately know that what people are exposed to over time affects them. There is a reason advertisers pay big money for TV commercials. There is a reason we send kids to school to learn and there is a reason you see kids mouthing lyrics to their favorite songs even when they don't realize it. Simply put, what we take in affects us. This is so blindingly obvious that it makes the kneejerk responses here look stupid.

Again, on the other hand, lots of people play games a lot with no problems. As for crime dropping, it will continue to drop every generation as the cohort of young males ages 16 - 30 gets smaller. Its simple demographics.
 
Bad parents = bad kids. If young children are playing violent games the only one that should take the blame is the parents.

I have played violent video games since I was 8 (Doom ftw!). No adverse effects. I'm definitely one of the less aggressive people around, in fact I have never even hurt anyone physically.
 
Old chart but its always good for threads like this:

violencegraph.jpg


And for those interested, read the book Freakonomics for a very interesting and controversial theory as to why crime took such a massive drop in the 90s. :)
 
I have played violent video games since I was 8 (Doom ftw!). No adverse effects. I'm definitely one of the less aggressive people around, in fact I have never even hurt anyone physically.

Emotionally?
 
wow, I'm amazed at the unbiased neutrality here. I can understand some of the arguments against this study, and there are quite a few of them, but claiming a decrease in violence is caused by an increase in video games because they occur over similar time periods is naive to say the least. Seriously, why post things like "I didn't read the article, but here is my reaction." I agree that there are conflicting studies and the jury is out. I'm just offended by stupidity, no matter which side it comes from.
 
wow, I'm amazed at the unbiased neutrality here. I can understand some of the arguments against this study, and there are quite a few of them, but claiming a decrease in violence is caused by an increase in video games because they occur over similar time periods is naive to say the least. Seriously, why post things like "I didn't read the article, but here is my reaction." I agree that there are conflicting studies and the jury is out. I'm just offended by stupidity, no matter which side it comes from.

Agreed.

Again, people should read Freakonomics for what I believe to be a very plausible theory as to why there was such a huge drop in crime during the 90s (hint: it has to do with the year Roe vs. Wade passed).

Either way, videogames have no relation with the crime rate, neither negatively nor positively.
 
In the same time frame violent crimes have taken a nose dive.

I expect to see a rise in crime with this recession, although with gas prices lowering it might not be so bad.
 
street fighter 2 is why i beat my sister up when i was 10.
however
mortal kombat 2 is why i ripped my moms spinal cord out at age 12.
 
I play violent video games but I am not violent. Therefore violent video games do not cause people to be violent. PROVE ME WRONG.
 
Agreed.

Again, people should read Freakonomics for what I believe to be a very plausible theory as to why there was such a huge drop in crime during the 90s (hint: it has to do with the year Roe vs. Wade passed).

Either way, videogames have no relation with the crime rate, neither negatively nor positively.

We might observe a decrease in the overall crime rate even if videogames have some positive, causal link with crimes. To deny the possibility of such a link out of hand reflects more of an irrational reaction than any possibly true correlation.
 
How these kids are ever able to find out that games like that exist in the first place is beyond me.

They're not old enough to understand how to use the internet.
They're not old enough to have friends that play them.
Even if they do, they're not old enough to go out and buy the games, as they don't have their own money, nor are old enough to know any skills necessary to make some, nor are allowed to leave the house without parents.

So how are these children playing these games? If the parents are placing the existence of the games to the children's attention, by specifically forbidding them or play, it's their own fault. Children will go after anything you disallow them - parents who forbid their children to play these games are encouraging them to do so. Thus, the blame lies with the parents.
 
We might observe a decrease in the overall crime rate even if videogames have some positive, causal link with crimes. To deny the possibility of such a link out of hand reflects more of an irrational reaction than any possibly true correlation.

It would be as easy to determine as say, trying to link movies, television, and books with violence (aka - not easy at all).

Can it possibly trigger or encourage violent behavior in an individual, sure, but I tend to think that the problem lies with the person more than the media itself. Considering the hundreds of millions of people who interact with things that are supposedly linked with violence and the incredibly tiny percentage of people who actually engage in it, I think it is a safe assumption to believe that.

At least until proven otherwise. :)
 
I play violent video games but I am not violent. Therefore violent video games do not cause people to be violent. PROVE ME WRONG.

I can't tell if you are being sarcastic or not, so I will just assume you are not for the sake of discussion. Just because there are trends does not mean they hold true for everyone, nor that there is necesarily a causal relationship. Getting theflu vaccine tends to prevent people from experiencing the flu during late fall and winter. Does that mean that it is impossible to get the flu if you gotthe vaccine? of course not.

As far as proving you wrong that you are not violent, how can anyone here claim to know you? We can only look at your previous posts:


"They should do a study where they take 2 families with misbehaving children and have one of the set of parents hit their kid every time he does something wrong and the other parents do nothing when their kid does something wrong. "

from the first page of this topic
 
Every generation has been saddled with the linking of violence with something.....in this century alone the blame for increased acts of violence have been blamed on songs on the radio, records, movies and TV....it's only natural progression to continue to blame video games. I suppose it makes the researchers feel more secure in their endeavors to justify the need for more grants to continue studies of violence. ;)
 
Not being able to properly discipline your kids, when are they being bratty, little assholes, and don't listen to a word you say is what makes bad kids. Not video games.

I think its time for parents to start taking off their belts again. To install proper values, morals, some fucking common sense in kids these day.

Its not that were not allowed to its that its socially taboo now. Last i checked its still legal in all states to spank your kids on the behind.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-spanking#Spanking_laws_in_the_United_States

What i have seen is parents have lost thier backbone and are too interested in being thier kids friends. Its the parents job to be that asshole that says what they dont want to hear and its the parents job to enforce things even they dont want to enforce. Its really sad how much responisbility has been put on teachers to raise children. For many children the only positive role models they will see is in a classroom and teachers practically have thier hands tied with what they can and cannot do making them less affective than they could be.
 
I love these types of articles... When I was younger and I was in high school, I played all of these games, including GTA 3... Well... I never had detention and as an adult I have a perfectly clean record and have impressed many employers who have had the time to work with me...

Of course by the standards of most of these articles, because I thought it was fun to pick up an in-game hooker and watch the car rock back and forth in GTA 3... I obviously must be doing it all the time in the real world as an adult... And lets add the fact that I like to run around with guns and have them lodged into a cats anal cavity in hopes that it works as a silencer (Postal 2 reference)...

Yea you obviously see these things occurring and blamed on video games all the time right? Or was I the only person who played these games and also did NOT do anything like this (let alone become more aggressive)...

All I can say is... GG Article Writes, GG!
 
I like how they took kids in the age range that are naturally aggressive, the troublesome teens and the bratty 9-12 range, which again shouldn't be playing games rated above their age range as it mentions shooters, action, puzzle and so on, it doesn't mention what they were playing though, could have been dead space, and GTA 4 for all we know.

Yet again someone is looking for a scape goat as to why their kids turn out to be mentally unstable, instead of looking at family history, crap parenting, abusive upbringing, trouble at school or hanging out with the wrong crowd, they blame it on the one thing that can't answer back.

I have been playing computer games almost long as I have been on the planet, I think I turned out fairly normal.
 
wow, I'm amazed at the unbiased neutrality here. I can understand some of the arguments against this study, and there are quite a few of them, but claiming a decrease in violence is caused by an increase in video games because they occur over similar time periods is naive to say the least. Seriously, why post things like "I didn't read the article, but here is my reaction." I agree that there are conflicting studies and the jury is out. I'm just offended by stupidity, no matter which side it comes from.

The problem with a lot of these articles is simple. Facts are few and far between, but quotes from credible sounding sources are abundant. I believe most people who visit this site would be interested in a piece of journalism with a little meat to it. Where instead of "Dr. L. Rowell Huesmann, director of the Research Center for Group Dynamics at the University of Michig...blah blah blah Impressive Qualifications" we could read a casefile for even one kid who went from an average pre-teen or teen, into an overly aggresive pre-teen or teen with direct evidence linking the change in behavior to videogames.

There are two things that I always think of when I read articles like this. The first one is the Flying Spaghetti Monster (and the famous http://www.venganza.org/about/open-letter/ letter that started Pastafarianism), and the movie "Thank You for Smoking," where the main character works for a huge tobacco company who employs people with Impressive Qualifications to sit around and figure out ways to obfuscate people's common sense.
 
You should at least look at the paper before judging it.

I agree that some of you could use a dose of analytical thinking. Rejecting the conclusions of the paper without reading it simply because you disagree with the premise or don't want to believe its true is the worst kind of ignorance.


That said, there are some major weaknesses in this study.

1. It is just another correlational finding, i.e., those who play violent games also report more violence.
2. The measure of "aggression" for most of the participants was self-report. Kids don't know what they're talking about half the time and lie the other half. Or maybe that's overstating it a bit.

An alternative explanation for the correlation could be that playing violent games causes kids to think more about violence in general and thereby recognize it more in their life. This would also make them more likely to remember violent episodes and more likely to report them.

Of course, even if this was the case, it could still be that violent games tend to lead to violent behavior. I've played lots of shoot-em-ups in the last ten years and don't consider myself violent in the least, but I do think it likely that violent games affect people. The truth is, nobody knows so stop pretending you do. :^>
 
I like how they took kids in the age range that are naturally aggressive, the troublesome teens and the bratty 9-12 range, which again shouldn't be playing games rated above their age range as it mentions shooters, action, puzzle and so on, it doesn't mention what they were playing though, could have been dead space, and GTA 4 for all we know.

Dead Space... I can't even handle that game as an adult... It freaks me out (fun to watch others play though)... That is the last game in the world that I would hand to my kid if they weren't at least 16...

I agree with you 100% though, most of the kids that commit crimes and then their lawyers blame them on video games are closer to the 16 - 18 age range... Why can't they do a study on the ones that are using this as a scape goat?

Obviously because it's hard to make parents believe. Like you said most kids at the age range they did these tests on, were exactly what you would consider to be more aggressive then when they are younger... So parents will relate to this article and eat it all up while enforcing rules on their kids in regards to playing any games at all, when the real problem is just educating your children and being involved in what they do...

If you can't take the time to be a parent, partake in the discipline that you may not like (as one noted above) but yet have to, then you shouldn't be popping children out in the first place. It's a tough job and somebody needs to do it, and it isn't your child's teacher or your child's automatic baby sitter (TV) it is YOUR responsibility and YOU have brought this upon YOURSELF... So if you think games are to blame, spend some time watching your kid play these games, talk with them, and see for yourself how these games are affecting YOUR child... If you think that every child reacts the same way when subjected to the same content as another child of their same age or even gender, then you are one of the worse lemmings of society that I have ever met (but you surely are not alone)... :mad:
 
They should do a study where they take 2 families with misbehaving children and have one of the set of parents hit their kid every time he does something wrong and the other parents do nothing when their kid does something wrong.

QFT
 
I can't tell if you are being sarcastic or not, so I will just assume you are not for the sake of discussion. Just because there are trends does not mean they hold true for everyone, nor that there is necesarily a causal relationship. Getting theflu vaccine tends to prevent people from experiencing the flu during late fall and winter. Does that mean that it is impossible to get the flu if you gotthe vaccine? of course not.

As far as proving you wrong that you are not violent, how can anyone here claim to know you? We can only look at your previous posts:


"They should do a study where they take 2 families with misbehaving children and have one of the set of parents hit their kid every time he does something wrong and the other parents do nothing when their kid does something wrong. "

from the first page of this topic
Troll successful.
 
They should do a study where they take 2 families with misbehaving children and have one of the set of parents hit their kid every time he does something wrong and the other parents do nothing when their kid does something wrong.

They already are doing that. Look at the crime rates for states that jail parents for spanking their brats and those that do not. Should give you a hint. Well, not really, but it will give you more of an idea of the truth than the opinion they managed to interpret from the study.
 
They already are doing that. Look at the crime rates for states that jail parents for spanking their brats and those that do not. Should give you a hint. Well, not really, but it will give you more of an idea of the truth than the opinion they managed to interpret from the study.

There are no states that jail parents for spanking thier kids. WTF are you talking baout?
 
I play violent video games, the most violent thing I do is kill people in virtual world called team fortress 2. I think i need therapy!
 
Back
Top