Vermont DMV Caught Using Illegal Facial Recognition Program

Status
Not open for further replies.

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
More and more agencies seem to be treating state statutes as guidelines rather than actual law. Admittedly, a lot of passages can be broad or simply unintelligible, but Vermont’s DMV has no excuse here: Title 23 (Motor Vehicles), Chapter 9 (Operators’ Licenses) makes it perfectly clear that they are barred from using biometrics for identification purposes. But despite that, the state has been caught red handed running searches on behalf of various law enforcement agencies.

Documents obtained by the American Civil Liberties Union of Vermont describe such a program, which uses software to compare the DMV’s database of names and driver’s license photos with information with state and federal law enforcement. The program, the ACLU says, invites state and federal agencies to submit photographs of persons of interest to the Vermont DMV, which it compares against its database of some 2.6 million photos and shares potential matches. Since 2012, the agency has run at least 126 such searches on behalf of local police, the State Department, FBI, and Immigrations and Customs Enforcement.
 
Beaurocrat A wasn't paying attention to what Beaurocrat B was doing as usual.

Since state law says biometrics can't be used, the evidence will become inadmissible and any connecting evidence to said biometrics thrown out. For example if they ID's the potential perp and then traced his phone calls to the scene of the crime, the photo ID information and phone calls would be inadmissible because the phone call history would not have been possible without violating the law in the first place.
 
Beaurocrat A wasn't paying attention to what Beaurocrat B was doing as usual.

Since state law says biometrics can't be used, the evidence will become inadmissible and any connecting evidence to said biometrics thrown out. For example if they ID's the potential perp and then traced his phone calls to the scene of the crime, the photo ID information and phone calls would be inadmissible because the phone call history would not have been possible without violating the law in the first place.
You don't think they hide the inadmissible evidence that could lead to a mistrial? I mean it's not like they've ever done that before.
 
You don't think they hide the inadmissible evidence that could lead to a mistrial? I mean it's not like they've ever done that before.

A good defense lawyer will track down where all supporting evidence came from to see if it was legally obtained. And if the information is "fuzzy" he can press for it. This is why the stingray trials were thrown out because police departments didn't want to reveal the secret sauce of their surveillance.
 
John Doe is flippin' creepy

1495739350hhzi2ezcjg_1_1.jpg
 
Did you grow up with smartphones? It's called abuse and privacy laws/unreasonable search and seizure.
Unreasonable search is about your property and persons not your likeness. You also don't own your photograph taken by the DMV as principal ownership of pictures belongs to the photographer not the subject unless expressed otherwise or taken without notice. It's sort of why such a specific addendum is included.
 
A good defense lawyer will track down where all supporting evidence came from to see if it was legally obtained. And if the information is "fuzzy" he can press for it. This is why the stingray trials were thrown out because police departments didn't want to reveal the secret sauce of their surveillance.
A good defense lawyer cost good money. Something poor people don't have. Many people live paycheck to paycheck and can't even afford to miss one day of work to plead their case...:(
 
Unreasonable search is about your property and persons not your likeness. You also don't own your photograph taken by the DMV as principal ownership of pictures belongs to the photographer not the subject unless expressed otherwise or taken without notice. It's sort of why such a specific addendum is included.

Was it clearly stated in the TOS?
 
A good defense lawyer will track down where all supporting evidence came from to see if it was legally obtained. And if the information is "fuzzy" he can press for it. This is why the stingray trials were thrown out because police departments didn't want to reveal the secret sauce of their surveillance.
A good defense lawyer cost good money. Something poor people don't have. Many people live paycheck to paycheck and can't even afford to miss one day of work to plead their case...:(
I think the bar should be, will a public defender do the due diligence necessary to check the evidence. If not, then don't assume this happens regularly
 
http://legislature.vermont.gov/statutes/section/23/009/00634

This writer and the ACLU need to go back to school.

The Department of Motor Vehicles shall not implement any procedures or processes for identifying applicants for licenses, learner permits, or nondriver identification cards that involve the use of biometric identifiers.

They are using these for criminal investigations.

Last i knew a criminal investigation is a process, and a license is authorization to operate a vehicle. are these the same thing? or have I gone crazy?

ON THE SIDE:

wtf man don't circulate articles that are fucking stupid

Broadly speaking, people of color are disproportionately impacted by biometric law enforcement tools, and in Vermont, there’s no exception. Compared to the state’s driving population, African-American Vermonters were seven times as likely to be searched for through this program, and Hispanic twelve times as likely, as their white counterparts.

“In addition to violating Vermont law, DMV’s facial recognition program invades Vermonters’ privacy, disproportionately targets people of color, places immigrants at increased risk of harm, and lacks due process protections to prevent further abuse,” James Lyall, the executive director of the ACLU of Vermont, said in a statement.

WTF NO.

I will say this ONE TIME.

IF PEOPLE OF COLOR/IMMIGRANTS ARE SEARCHED MORE THAN OTHERS IT IS PROBABLY BECAUSE THEY ARE THE ONES DOING THE CRIMES.

STATISTICS ARE NOT RACIST.
 
Last edited:
I will say this ONE TIME.

IF PEOPLE OF COLOR/IMMIGRANTS ARE SEARCHED MORE THAN OTHERS IT IS PROBABLY BECAUSE THEY ARE THE ONES DOING THE CRIMES.

STATISTICS ARE NOT RACIST.

While we are at it lets not forget to get DNA samples from all fraternity members and athletes since they are more likely to rape on campus than anyone. Lets search the PCs ans phones of males Caucasian family members when a new child is brought home since statistically they are the most likely to molest them. Innocence until proven guilt is obviously a backwards ideal of a era long since passed. Lock up first ask questions later as long as its not me.
 
I will say this ONE TIME.

IF PEOPLE OF COLOR/IMMIGRANTS ARE SEARCHED MORE THAN OTHERS IT IS PROBABLY BECAUSE THEY ARE THE ONES DOING THE CRIMES.

STATISTICS ARE NOT RACIST.

Statistics may not be racist, but your if statement damn well is.

(you can use statistics to find out why)
 
offtopic but since VT licenses were always so basic, without holograms until very recently, SWIM used to remake license by hand in photoshop and print on high quality material, use old license for backing, and magically turn 21 in college to buy beer.
 
Statistics may not be racist, but your if statement damn well is.

(you can use statistics to find out why)

So let me get this straight. If I am using a database of pictures of people's faces and a police officer with a warrant walks up to me and says, "hey run this through your system for me" and i notice that the person is black, I SHOULDN'T check the color of that person under "race" to make the search go faster? you know because there is 2.6 MILLION PEOPLE TO MATCH. I'm now the racist person because a black person committed a crime?

Are you off your rocker?
 
So let me get this straight. If I am using a database of pictures of people's faces and a police officer with a warrant walks up to me and says, "hey run this through your system for me" and i notice that the person is black, I SHOULDN'T check the color of that person under "race" to make the search go faster? you know because there is 2.6 MILLION PEOPLE TO MATCH. I'm now the racist person because a black person committed a crime?

Are you off your rocker?


Dominicans and other people from tropical parts of the world are not "black" people. If they choose to only search "black" people you may miss your person or grab the wrong one. So yes your scenario is inherently racist. I'm going to assume to you a spade is a spade, right?
 
Dominicans and other people from tropical parts of the world are not "black" people. If they choose to only search "black" people you may miss your person or grab the wrong one. So yes your scenario is inherently racist. I'm going to assume to you a spade is a spade, right?

Seeing as how I never mixed any races, nor said anything about Dominicans in any of my prior arguments, I'm going to assume that YOU in fact are the one who doesn't know the difference between Dominicans and black.
 
Seeing as how I never mixed any races, nor said anything about Dominicans in any of my prior arguments, I'm going to assume that YOU in fact are the one who doesn't know the difference between Dominicans and black.

You can hide behind semantics all you want and moving the goal posts changes nothing. I'm going to borrow a page from your playbook, I've dealt with your type all to frequently and know what you are up to.
 
So let me get this straight. If I am using a database of pictures of people's faces and a police officer with a warrant walks up to me and says, "hey run this through your system for me" and i notice that the person is black, I SHOULDN'T check the color of that person under "race" to make the search go faster? you know because there is 2.6 MILLION PEOPLE TO MATCH. I'm now the racist person because a black person committed a crime?

Are you off your rocker?

I have no fucking clue what argument you are trying to make or how this in any way validates what I quoted of you earlier.

Let me say it more precise for you. You are a flat out racist and you are trying to peddle your racist shit here.

You are claiming that more people of color are searched are and its probably because they do more crime. Then you are throwing in a bullshit line that equates to "Stats dont lie". Show those fucking stats then
 
I have no fucking clue what argument you are trying to make or how this in any way validates what I quoted of you earlier.

Let me say it more precise for you. You are a flat out racist and you are trying to peddle your racist shit here.

You are claiming that more people of color are searched are and its probably because they do more crime. Then you are throwing in a bullshit line that equates to "Stats dont lie". Show those fucking stats then

Seeing as how you cannot correlate information shows me that i cannot make you understand now matter what I do.

The scenario I posted shows exactly what I am talking about.

Here ill help you

https://www2.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2009/data/table_43.html
http://www.ciaworldfactbook.us/north-america/united-states.html

300 mil people
12% black
79% white
(not doing other races because I'm taking a WILD guess your only focused on black because that's your agenda)
Crimes
3 mil black
7 mil white

Thats 8% of of the black population commiting crimes
Thats 3% of the white population committing crimes

Do some fucking research
 
Last edited:
Statistics may not be racist, but your if statement damn well is.

(you can use statistics to find out why)

First of all, the "article" says: "African-American Vermonters were seven times as likely to be searched for through this program"

This means that the police are actively searching for suspects with the database information. The problem is, the black population is more likely to be searched for as, statistically speaking, they are more likely to commit a crime.

NO SHIT they would be searched for more. How you people can't understand this, I don't know.

Second, there was nothing racist about his statement. See above. Statistics can't be racist.
 
The point is that the government's stats are bullshit anyway, for more than one reason. Just like their justice system. Using them to build your premise makes your premise flawed from the foundation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top