Upgrading C2D MBP HD, what to get?

Rombus

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 12, 2001
Messages
3,285
I think im going to pop a new HD into my C2D MBP, currently it has a 5400 160gb drive in it.

Im trying to decide if i want to get a 320GB 7200mb 16 mb cache WD Black, or the 500GB 5400rpm 8mb WD Blue, Im leaning towards the WD Black since its cheaper and faster, but i want to hear any suggestions or experinces others have before i pull the trigger.

Also, while im at it, think this would be an good ram purchase to top out the ram in the system?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820145193
 
4GB isn't the max amount of RAM you can put in the machine. 6GB is the maximum IIRC.

Personally I'd get the 500gb drive since 500gb is a lot more space than 320gb. I tend to fill up my HDDs pretty quick though so its your call really. Plus I think the 5400 rpm drive might net slightly better battery life and lower heat output.
 
When did 6GB start working in the MBP? I've got the latest version (unibody) and 4GB is the max.

As for the HD upgrade, I recommend the 320GB 7200RPM. I put one in my MBP and am very pleased with the performance improvement. It's not earthshaking, but definitely noticeable.
 
I can't imagine a 4GB Dimm is cheap.

Newegg also has a 500GB 7200rpm drive, but it's rarely in stock. You have to sign up to be notified and then jump on it quick. It's like $120 or so. I went with a 320GB 7200rpm drive for my Macbook. I don't notice any significant battery drain or heat compared to the other drive.
 
I can't imagine a 4GB Dimm is cheap.
It ain't! I passed on it. $250+ wasn't worth it to me for the extra 2GB. I'll stick with my current 4GB for now.

The 320GB 7200RPM drive is about the best price/size/performance HD for a laptop. Tough to beat $70 for it. That 500GB version costs nearly $100 more... when it's in stock as you noted.
 
Thanks for all the suggestions guys, i went with the 7200RPM 320GB WD Drive and the 4 GB (2x2GB) of ram. 119 total shipped.

Whats funny is i was looking though my previous newegg purchases, and i found the one in '06 when i first got my MBP, I paid 110 for a 1GB stick, its crazy how cheap prices are now.
 
It ain't! I passed on it. $250+ wasn't worth it to me for the extra 2GB. I'll stick with my current 4GB for now.

The 320GB 7200RPM drive is about the best price/size/performance HD for a laptop. Tough to beat $70 for it. That 500GB version costs nearly $100 more... when it's in stock as you noted.

yeah, $250 is a lot of money, especially when I'm not sure you'd see big gains in a laptop between 4GB and 6GB.

I'm surprised that drive is so expensive. The first time I saw it, it was only $120, but I guess supply and demand is keeping it expensive. I agree though, for $70, the 320GB is a pretty good deal. That's all I put in my laptops anymore (Macs/PC's/whatever).
 
Back
Top