Upgrade on a tight budget

Royaltramp

n00b
Joined
Jun 22, 2008
Messages
26
Well I'm looking to upgrade my PC. Partly just because I enjoy upgrading and I want to keep up with new hardware a bit better than I am now, but also because I could do with the extra framerate.

NOTE: I am from the UK. So if you link to products, or give me prices, give me prices in the UK. Thanks.

My current PC (with links):
Asus P5N-E SLI Motherboard
Antec SmartPower 2.0 500W Power Supply (Newegg link because I can't find it on ebuyer anymore, I can't buy from Newegg though since it's US)
Intel E6550 Core2Duo 2.33Ghz 1333FSB Processor
2048Mb Kingston DDR2 667Mhz RAM (2x1024)
Inno3D 256Mb Nvidia 8600GT (No idea why it's £108 now, I swear I got it for £60)
250Gb Western Digital Caviar SATA HDD (Not sure if I have 8Mb cache or 16Mb cache, so I just linked to the 8Mb one)
160Gb Maxtor IDE HDD (God knows what model, especially since Maxtor has become Seagate now, so I won't link you this, got it ages back anyway)
Casecom Black Midi Case w/ Blue LED fans (Cheap I know heh)
Acer AL1916W (The price is lower now, I just can't remember where I bought it)
Logitech G11 Keyboard (Was meant to buy a G15, got the wrong one by mistake, but no big deal)
Saitek GM3200 Mouse (@1600dpi)

I don't have much to spend. Ideally between £100 and £160. But up to about £210. I may upgrade for performance (RAM/Graphics/Cooling, unless I could get a much better processor within budget, and still have some left over, but I doubt it), or for cosmetic reasons (Case, Mouse, Keyboard)

I'm well up for deals, or buying off ebay, though I prefer to buy from ebuyer or other online stores.

Games I'd like to play in "as high as I can manage" settings once I've upgraded:
Crysis
Bioshock
Oblivion (Currently play in 1440x900, max settings, low/no AA)
Company of Heroes
Spore (When it's out)
Far Cry 2 (As above)

I prefer Nvidia, but looking at the 4850 and 4870 has made me open up to the idea of using ATI.

So basically, what would you spend £100-210 on given my current setup?

Thanks in advance! ^_^

-Matt
 
- Buy a better case. Something with better ventilation and not quite so fugly :p. Antec Three Hundred or Coolermaster RC590 should be within your budget
- Buy a better graphics card. Radeon HD4850 would be perfect for you.
 
Thanks for advice. To clarify a bit better on what I use this PC for, since I didn't really say:

- Mostly browsing, MSN, a flashchat application, mIRC and Skype
- Gaming (Looking to be able to play the above games, but I don't actually game *that* much)
- Coding
- Photoshop
- Movie Editing

I've also started downloading a lot recently, and I may end up needing some more storage space, but right now that's not an issue, and I have some 120Gb USB HDD somewhere in my desk.

As far the the 4850 goes, yeah, I'm looking at getting either that or an 8800GT/9600GT. When it comes to cases, I'd probably prefer to spend money on other parts first, and then save up for a nzxt case or an antec 900 or something.

If I went for the cheaper option of an 8800GT, I could get 4Gb Corsair DDR2 800Mhz. Then I could just save up until I can afford an E8400 and a nice nzxt case for my next upgrade. The only issue with the E8400 being that my motherboard limits me to 800Mhz RAM, so I can't overclock it, but then again, I'm not really overclocking atm, tried overclocking my 8600 and didn't get far with that, never done CPU overclocking.

Parts I'm looking at:

Graphics:
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/143325 - Inno3D 8800GT 512Mb (600/1900) (Comes with Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter 2) £109
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/143105 - Point of View 8800GT 512Mb (650,1950) £108
http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=GX-179-SP - Sapphire ATI Radeon HD 4850 512Mb (625/1986) £132

RAM:
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/130429 - 4Gb Corsair DDR2 800Mhz RAM £55

CPU:
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/131823 - Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 2.4Ghz 1066FSB £120 (I believe with standard clocks this will underperform my E6550 in games that only support 1-2 cores though)
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/143290 - Intel Core 2 Duo E8400 3.0Ghz 1333FSB £122 (I can get it for like £108 elsewhere)

Cases:
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/118268 - Antec 900 £67
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/143854 - Antec 300 £38
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/144802 - NZXT Tempest £69
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/119136 - NZXT Apollo £50

Coolermaster RC590 seems to only be in the US/Australia though.

Which of the above would you guys recommend I get, if I were to budget £150-180?

Thanks

-Matt
 
The extra ram isn't going to do that much for you, really. Video card will give you the best bang for the buck. The 4850 is way better than the 8800GT and 9600GT, so there's no point in getting those anymore, really. If you want to focus on movie editing performance, CPU is probably where it's at there, though. But i'd wager a CPU upgrade won't help you at all for games until you upgrade the vid card.
 
I'd get a Q6600 and an HD 4850. Ought to come out to just under £200. Looking at you're current system and budget, I think you'd benefit most from a video card upgrade, as opposed to a better CPU or RAM. So I think it's definitely worth it for you to spend your money on the 4850.
 
I'd buy a new PSU and a new GPU. You current E6550 is still a pretty good CPU, especially if you overclock it a little. I recommend getting a new PSU because the Antec Smartpower is well known for dying under heavy loads, heat and time. The Antec Smartpowers were designed to be quiet PSUs so therefore the the PSU was not allowed to kick in until it reached a pretty high temperature. Unfortunately Antec chose to use fuhjyyu capacitors which required a decent amount of cooling, cooling that wasn't on until it hit a high temp. So those capacitors overheated often and therefore the PSU had a high rate of death.

A new GPU or quad-core CPU will definitely push that Smartpower to its limit. A new PSU won't break the bank:
Corsair 550VX 550W PSU - £55.21 Inc VAT

Grab the 8800GT plus the Corsair and you'll be set. We play at the same resolution and I can tell you for a fact that the 8800GT is more than enough for COH and Bioshock at max settings with AA on.
 
I'd buy a new PSU and a new GPU. You current E6550 is still a pretty good CPU, especially if you overclock it a little. I recommend getting a new PSU because the Antec Smartpower is well known for dying under heavy loads, heat and time. The Antec Smartpowers were designed to be quiet PSUs so therefore the the PSU was not allowed to kick in until it reached a pretty high temperature. Unfortunately Antec chose to use fuhjyyu capacitors which required a decent amount of cooling, cooling that wasn't on until it hit a high temp. So those capacitors overheated often and therefore the PSU had a high rate of death.

QFT. Mine is dead and it was used as a file server.

 
RMA those SmartPowers if you can. They get replaced by EarthWatts, which are much better quality PSUs.
 
Thanks for the replies. I'll defo be getting some RAM, and more than likely an 8800 rather than a 4850. After some consideration I don't think I'll be looking at a Q6600, if I were to upgrade to a quad I'd wait til I could afford a Q9XXX since with the Q6600 I'd actually be getting lower performance on applications that can only handle two cores.

I recommend getting a new PSU because the Antec Smartpower is well known for dying under heavy loads, heat and time.

I'm running on the 500W version, so even if I upgraded my CPU, GPU *and* RAM I wouldn't be coming anywhere near to putting it under strain. Right now I don't have much cash to spare, but when I next upgrade it's an option.

So basically all that remains is: 9600 or 8800GT? And that or an E8400 *first*? Though I'll get both soon enough.

-Matt
 
Again, if its still under the Antec 3yr warranty, get it replaced while you can. You'll get a MUCH better PSU thats less likely to kill all your new parts. The SmartPower2.0's are notorious for failing.
 
I'm running on the 500W version, so even if I upgraded my CPU, GPU *and* RAM I wouldn't be coming anywhere near to putting it under strain. Right now I don't have much cash to spare, but when I next upgrade it's an option

As said by enginurd, that brand of PSUs is well known for failing. Hell you don't even need to heavily load it for it to die. I highly recommend either RMAing it first or get a new PSU altogether.


So basically all that remains is: 9600 or 8800GT? And that or an E8400 *first*? Though I'll get both soon enough.

You don't need a new CPU. Like I said earlier, your E6550 is more than enough especially if you OC it a little bit.
 
Why don't you go with SLI 8800's or get a single 9800x2 or 9800 and a better PSU to power them and call it a day? Since you are on a tight budget the best upgrade you could make to your current system would be a better video card first and foremost. Then get a better PSU to power the video card followed by another set of 2x1gb RAM. Don't waste you rmoney on a new case, another hard drive, a different CPU, or a set 2x2gb RAM.
 
Why don't you go with SLI 8800's or get a single 9800x2 or 9800 and a better PSU to power them and call it a day? Since you are on a tight budget the best upgrade you could make to your current system would be a better video card first and foremost. Then get a better PSU to power the video card followed by another set of 2x1gb RAM. Don't waste you rmoney on a new case, another hard drive, a different CPU, or a set 2x2gb RAM.

Currently looking at the 9800GTX now that the prices have dropped. As far as the rest goes:

- PSU? I don't need a bigger better PSU, the only reason for getting a new one would be on the idea that this one could die. I'm not sure if I can return my current one now though, and I'm not sure I'll have the cash to replace it..
- Another set of 2x1Gb RAM, why? I'm on 667Mhz RAM, leaving me no ability to overclock my CPU if I want to, so when I buy new RAM I'll be buying 4Gb 800Mhz.
- CPU? Currently changed my mind and not looking to upgrade it.
- Case? Wouldn't be wasted money, same for hdd, I've been downloading a ton recently and my space is quickly running out.. And as far as the case goes, mine is pretty badly cooled, but for now I'm just looking at a graphics card.

What do you guys think?

-Matt
 
Why don't you go with SLI 8800's or get a single 9800x2 or 9800 and a better PSU to power them and call it a day? Since you are on a tight budget the best upgrade you could make to your current system would be a better video card first and foremost. Then get a better PSU to power the video card followed by another set of 2x1gb RAM. Don't waste you rmoney on a new case, another hard drive, a different CPU, or a set 2x2gb RAM.

Why go SLI at such a low resolution? A single card will run most games out there at high settings, and SLI will not show in major performance advantage.

Anyway, I personally wouldn't go with a 9800GTX. The 4850 is still a better buy. A Powercolor 4850 costs £117.49 from Overclockers.

The Gainward one is a couple of quid cheaper, but it currently on pre-order.

I doubt that you will be able to get a replacement for the power supply, because they usually only do it (well, that is what I found from most shops here) if the parts are dead or faulty, nothing else. The Antec NSK6580 is a popular choice, because it has both a quality case and a quality power supply.

Overclock your processor as well. You can buy some new memory, but I wouldn't really bother myself. Just run the memory under the FSB speed. Although you will lose a bit of performance, it won't really be a huge amount.
 
If you bought the PSU within 3 yrs, you can return it to Antec and have them replace it with a much better PSU.

Yes, if your PSU is working fine, and you don't have the cash, it will do. Just be aware of this fact: that particular line of Antec PSUs is notorious for not only failing, but taking other parts out with it. So, while you do want a nice high end graphics card, I doubt that your PSU will last much longer once you put it in, since there's only 22A on the +12V rail. Hopefully, the PSU will just die, and you can RMA it back to Antec, and they'll replace it with a much better PSU from the Earthwatts lineup (EA430, the one that comes with the NSK6580). Hopefully, if and when the PSU goes out, it doesnt take your new vidcard with it. I'm not saying there's a good chance of that happening, I'm just saying its a real possibility. So again, I'd look into your warranty situation with Antec, and find out if you can RMA it or not, since you're strapped for cash.
 
Back
Top