Updated i7 Build Needing Criticisms

NExUS1g

Gawd
Joined
Aug 15, 2004
Messages
554
1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
High-end gaming, Photoshop, 3DSM/Maya.

2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
Open.

3) Where do you live?
Portland, OR

4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. Please be very specific.
See below.

5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.
N/A

6) Will you be overclocking?
I would like to, but only what's possible with stock cooling.

7) What size monitor do you have or plan to have?
22"-24"

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
Near future (within 6 months).

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? etc.
No requirements here other than the 1366 socket.

This will be two systems and the prices and parts reflect as such.

G.SKILL 6 GB (2 x 2GB DDR3 1333 MHz
Timing 8-8-8-20
$170 per kit x 4 kits = $680

Intel Core i7 920 2.66 GHz LGA 1366 Quad-Core
$300 x 2 CPUs = $600

ASUS P6T Deluxe/OC Palm (1600)
$340 x 2 = $680

Seagate Barracuda 1TB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s
$110 x 2 = $220

BFG GTX 280 1 GB 512-bit GDDR3
$400 x 2 = $800

BFG Tech ES SERIES ES-800 800W Continuous @ 40°C
$140 x 2 = $280

ASUS VW246H Black 24" 2ms(GTG) HDMI Widescreen LCD Monitor
$300 x 2 = $600

SONY Black & Gray 8X BD-R 2X BD-RE 16X DVD+R 5X DVD-RAM 8X Blu-ray DVD-ROM
$400 x 2 = $800

RAZER Copperhead Tempest Blue mouse
$55 x 2 = $110

Logitech G15
$90 x 2 = $180

Antec Twelve Hundred Black Steel ATX Full Tower Computer Case
$180 x 2 = $360

Vista Ultimate 64-bit
$320 x 2 = $640

Symantec Norton Internet Security 2009 3 PC license
$70

Total of $5,730 ($2,865 ea)

At $2,865, I think I'm getting a very good system. Typically I like to spend about $2,500 on a system (it seems to be the magic number of price:performance), but the extra RAM is running me over on that. I believe that Windows Vista allows me to use a high-speed USB drive as an extension of the RAM -- like a page file. If it in fact exists, how well does that work? Will it allow me to go with the 6 GB of RAM per system cutting its cost in half?

Thanks in advance.
 
G.SKILL 6 GB (2 x 2GB DDR3 1333 MHz
Timing 8-8-8-20
$170 per kit x 4 kits = $680

$680 is far too expensive. But perhaps you're not calculating it properly. And when you say 2x2GB, that's seems to be refering to what you call a (4GB) "kit". If so, don't you mean $170 x 3 = $510. And even $510 for 12 Gigs looks a bit expensive.

BFG GTX 280 1 GB 512-bit GDDR3
$400 x 2 = $800
I think the price will go down after the New Year so you'll probably save some cash here.

SONY Black & Gray 8X BD-R 2X BD-RE 16X DVD+R 5X DVD-RAM 8X Blu-ray DVD-ROM
$400 x 2 = $800
What? That's a complete ripoff. Suggest you use another etailer for your quotes or pick a different blu ray player. Mine Blu Ray DVD writer handles HD DVD, writes to Blu Ray discs, runs very quietly and is a fraction of the price of yours. Unless this Sony Blu Ray player is something really really special, I suggest you reconsider.

Vista Ultimate 64-bit
$320 x 2 = $640
You should be able to pick an OEM version of Windows Ultimate 64 for $180. And at the moment New Egg has some sort of $50 cash back on top of that brining it to $129.99 (in USD).


It could be that you're looking at prices from rather expensive shops. I would recommend that you have a look at the prices on reputable etailers like New Egg.

p.s. definately get a 3rd party heatsink cooler.
 
$680 is far too expensive. But perhaps you're not calculating it properly. And when you say 2x2GB, that's seems to be refering to what you call a (4GB) "kit". If so, don't you mean $170 x 3 = $510. And even $510 for 12 Gigs looks a bit expensive.


I think the price will go down after the New Year so you'll probably save some cash here.


What? That's a complete ripoff. Suggest you use another etailer for your quotes or pick a different blu ray player. Mine Blu Ray DVD writer handles HD DVD, writes to Blu Ray discs, runs very quietly and is a fraction of the price of yours. Unless this Sony Blu Ray player is something really really special, I suggest you reconsider.


You should be able to pick an OEM version of Windows Ultimate 64 for $180. And at the moment New Egg has some sort of $50 cash back on top of that brining it to $129.99 (in USD).


It could be that you're looking at prices from rather expensive shops. I would recommend that you have a look at the prices on reputable etailers like New Egg.

p.s. definately get a 3rd party heatsink cooler.


This is a Blu-ray burner, not just a reader if that makes any difference.

The prices are from newegg.com. Should I consider other sites like Tigerdirect?

The RAM is a typo. I meant 2x3 GB kits instead of 2x2 GB kits. Total of 12 GB of RAM or 6 GB per system. I'm sorry for the mix up.

What's the differences in the licenses between retail and OEM versions of Windows Vista? I was considering the retail price, not the OEM price.
 
The OEM version is tied to the motherboard you install it on. This means that if you buy OEM, you will need to call up MicroSuck and beg for another activation if/when you upgrade. OEM is non-transferable.

Any OEM product does not include a manual, pretty box, other BS. It is usually a disc in a paper disc sleeve.
 
This is a Blu-ray burner, not just a reader if that makes any difference.

The prices are from newegg.com. Should I consider other sites like Tigerdirect?

The RAM is a typo. I meant 2x3 GB kits instead of 2x2 GB kits. Total of 12 GB of RAM or 6 GB per system. I'm sorry for the mix up.

What's the differences in the licenses between retail and OEM versions of Windows Vista? I was considering the retail price, not the OEM price.



With regards to the RAM, you are going for 6 GB RAM per machine right? Decent triple channel DDR3 (6GB) goes for around $200 to $225. So about $400 to $450 for two machines.


The LG GGW-H20L is also a Blu Ray burner. Just a lot cheaper. And can handle HD_DVD as well. But it does not say "Sony" on the case.

As for Vista, there should not be any physical differences between retail and OEM. OEM versions are cheaper because they are targeted at people who are going to build systems and "this (OEM) software is intended for pre-installation on a new personal computer for resale.". As for further differences in licenses, I don't know... All I know is that when I change my hardware I just reactivate my OEM version and it's a lot cheaper so I'm happy. But if you wish to pay three times as much for complete peace of mind, up to you, but I don't think it's worth it.
 
With regards to the RAM, you are going for 6 GB RAM right? If so, that's only $170x2=$340, which is even less that your original quote of $680. Unless you're talking about 12GB, in which case I'll say you really don't need 12GB, well unless you have specific needs I'm unaware of...


The LG GGW-H20L is also a Blu Ray burner. Just a lot cheaper. And can handle HD_DVD as well. But it does not say "Sony" on the case.

As for Vista, there should not be any physical differences between retail and OEM. OEM versions are cheaper because they are targeted at people who are going to build systems and "this (OEM) software is intended for pre-installation on a new personal computer for resale.". As for further differences in licenses, I don't know... All I know is that when I change my hardware I just reactivate my OEM version and it's a lot cheaper so I'm happy. But if you wish to pay three times as much for complete peace of mind, up to you, but I don't think it's worth it.

The amount is my mistake. Somehow I figured for 12 GB per system instead. Also in my OP; I am doing 3DSM/Maya which typically includes working with files of an extremely large size. I would like to have 12 GB per system for that reason, but I'm willing to settle on 6 GB per system.

Since Blu-ray is Sony's technology, I felt it was better to go with Sony's branding. I am assuming that it is OEM in that case. Am I wrong in assuming this?

The OEM version is tied to the motherboard you install it on. This means that if you buy OEM, you will need to call up MicroSuck and beg for another activation if/when you upgrade. OEM is non-transferable.

Any OEM product does not include a manual, pretty box, other BS. It is usually a disc in a paper disc sleeve.

Thank you very much for clearing that up. I already have to call in on my retail version of XP pro after so many activations, so no difference there really. (retail of XP Pro only cost me $20 from MS employee store :D -- but the employee has pursued other interests and no longer works there. :()
 
I'm curious to know why you need 2 machines? Will each of these machines be doing the same tasks? Gaming, Photoshop and Maya?
 
I think the powersupplies may be overkill, unless you plan on going SLI later on, I would think a 620W would work, and be cheaper. Also I wouldn't get the p6t motherboard with the palm device, unless you know you need the palm device, it's really a worthless Overclocker's toy though, so get the regular p6t deluxe and save 20-30 bucks on each mobo.

*Edit* Use this to calculate the power you need, it's a power supply calculator, you enter the parts you plan to use and it tells you how many watts you need. And then add maybe a hundred on top of what it tells you to be safe and allow for future upgrades.
 
I think the powersupplies may be overkill, unless you plan on going SLI later on, I would think a 620W would work, and be cheaper. Also I wouldn't get the p6t motherboard with the palm device, unless you know you need the palm device, it's really a worthless Overclocker's toy though, so get the regular p6t deluxe and save 20-30 bucks on each mobo.

*Edit* Use this to calculate the power you need, it's a power supply calculator, you enter the parts you plan to use and it tells you how many watts you need. And then add maybe a hundred on top of what it tells you to be safe and allow for future upgrades.

Future SLI is definitely going to be a consideration. I'm not going SLI right now because of the lack of support for it; it doesn't justify the cost.

Also the motherboard change saved a total of $80 so thank you very much.

After using the site you provided -- very good site; it's bookmarked :) -- the requirement for power is 567 watts + 100 watts you recommend is a 700 watt PSU. With SLI it is 746watts. This is figuring for 100% load so the power supply seems perfect for future expansion. Thanks for the heads up though, and I'm putting this all down in case I made a mistake and missed something.
 
Here is the updated system:

G.SKILL 6 GB 3x2GB DDR3 1333 MHz
$170 per kit x 2 kits = $360

Intel Core i7 920 2.66 GHz LGA 1366 Quad-Core
$300 x 2 CPUs = $600

ASUS P6T Deluxe
$300 x 2 = $600

Seagate Barracuda 1TB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s
$110 x 2 = $220

BFG GTX 280 1 GB 512-bit GDDR3
$400 x 2 = $800

BFG Tech ES SERIES ES-800 800W Continuous @ 40°C
$140 x 2 = $280

ASUS VW246H Black 24" 2ms(GTG) HDMI Widescreen LCD Monitor
$300 x 2 = $600

SONY Black & Gray 8X BD-R 2X BD-RE 16X DVD+R 5X DVD-RAM 8X Blu-ray DVD-ROM
$400 x 2 = $800

RAZER Copperhead Tempest Blue mouse
$55 x 2 = $110

Logitech G15
$90 x 2 = $180

Antec Twelve Hundred Black Steel ATX Full Tower Computer Case
$180 x 2 = $360

Vista Ultimate 64-bit
$170 x 2 = $340

Symantec Norton Internet Security 2009 3 PC license
$70

Total of $5,340 ($2,670 ea)
 
Here is the updated system:
Intel Core i7 920 2.66 GHz LGA 1366 Quad-Core
$300 x 2 CPUs = $600

Should be able to pick those up for ~$280
ASUS 24" - I'd consider spending more on a nice Dell, if you are dropping $400 on a Blu-rap burner, spend the same for a monitor :p
$350-450x 2 = $700-900 -100 to -300

SONY Blu-ray change to LG/ something more reasonable in price ~$250'ish
$250 x 2 = $500 +300


Antec Twelve Hundred If you are going to spend ~$200 on a case, I would consider picking a much more aesthetically pleasing Lian Li (personal opinion) A70B/A71B for full or V1200B for mid. ~$210-250
$225 x 2 = $450 - 100

You could save a couple hundred dollars (possibly) this way/ break even with current spec, and I think you will have a much much better looking setup in the end, the new Dell monitor models + black Lian-li = really sexy!
 
Cases are subjective, so get what you like. Though, its good to check out other cases in your same price range, since you are spending a lot.

Stick with the BFG ES-800. It has more power on its +12v rail(s) than the entire TX750. :p Plus, its very good quality and a great price.
 
How about this blu-ray drive? It's 150 dollars cheaper, and does the same thing, plus it reads hddvd, which although you probably won't need doesn't hurt. Also, are you sure you need to burn (i.e. make) blu-ray discs? If not, you can get a blu-ray reader and dvd-burner for like $100, this one by LG reads blu-rays, and writes to all DVD and CD formats and is $99. Also, the manufacturer doesn't matter, just about any blu-ray drive is going to function exactly like any other with similar specs.
 
Back
Top