Ubisoft DRM Authentication Servers Go Down

Looks like I'll be going for the free version. Not something I ever do outside of occasionally DLing the pc version of a game after I've already bought the console version, but there's no way I'm dealing with this.
 
They will, of course, turn around and point at all the huge numbers for the "crack" being downloaded to justify the use of such DRM, not even pretending to acknowledge that many of those downloads are because legitimate customers had to download it as a "fix" just to play their game.

Congratulations on creating such a cluster-fuck Ubisoft. Kudos for breaking the stupidity barrier wide open.
 
Let's assume you can afford buying the game, and you are willing to pay for it being a conscious gamer knowing how important it is to support the developers. What would you do in the following scenarios?

1st Scenario:
Game does not have DRM for single-player, or LAN multiplayer. For Internet multiplayer, you need to register your key. You can install it as many times as you want, whenever and wherever. Pirated version is the same, except that you will not be able to install the patches as they come out and you will not be able to play online (at least with legit users, which is likely going to be the majority of online players).

2nd Scenario:
Game has non-intrusive DRM, such as a one-time activation within a couple of days of installing it, or a key or a disk-check. The pirated version does not require typing a key, or keeping a disk in the drive, but you will not be able to install the patches as they come out and you will not be able to play online (at least with legit users, which is likely going to be the majority of online players).

3rd Scenario:
Game publisher treats you as a thief, keeping the leash short and tight. You cannot install the game that you paid for more than a certain number of times. You need to activate each copy you installed before you can launch it. They keep your game-saves hostage on their own servers, which are also required to even play the game, and these servers are likely to go down for hours, let it be scheduled maintenance or unexpected down time. You are more likely to end up not being able to install and play the game that you paid for, whenever and wherever you want. A few years after your purchase, the company may close its doors, together with its activation/savegame servers, and you will loose your game and all your savegames. The pirated version can be installed anytime, anywhere. It does not require an online connection, so you can play offline (e.g., during a long flight), and it saves the games to your local disk, therefore you can back up your savegames, and if you reinstall the game to a new computer that you purchase in the future, you can restore your savegames and continue playing. The pirated game is always yours to keep and install and play whenever and wherever, even if the company is no more. However, you may need to wait for a bit when a patch is released, until someone releases a cracked version, and you will need to look for non-official servers that support this copy to play online, which may be a bit painful.

I don't think you need to be a genius to be able to tell in which case you'd say "enough is enough, f this", and go for an illegitimate copy, even if you want to get the original copy and support the developers. Everything in moderation! I know that there are game developers that sell their games without ANY DRM (Scenario 1), and they still DO sell enough to make a living. I also understand that a company would like to use a non-intrusive DRM, at least to keep the "casual" pirates straight (Scenario 2). As long as I can install and play the game wherever and whenever I want, it's ok with me. But intrusive-DRMs (Scenario 3) that TRY to prevent hardcore pirates from doing what they do, DO fail anyway, and this leaves them as being only a PITA for the people who actually paid for the game. Frankly, pirated versions of games with such intrusive DRMs tend to be relatively more hassle-free than the original game!!! So, would you like to pay to be harassed by an invasive-DRM and potentially loose your game and savegames in the future, or would you rather go for a smoother free ride instead, even though you know that you will not be supporting the company that brought you that game. Then again, do you really WANT to support such a company? A-ha!

And if you do not have the funds to pay for the game, you will not buy the game no matter what, so the developers are indeed will NOT be loosing money if you played a pirated copy. Yes, ethically you should not be playing a game that you cannot afford, but I think in this case letting such a person play a pirated copy is a future investment for the company, since the gamer would get to like this company's games and therefore the company, and when s/he has the money in the future, will be willing to spend it to support them. Because the alternative is that, not being able to play games, they may not become gamers and therefore will not buy games when they have the money to be able to do so. Yes, I know this sounds unbelievably unrealistic and idealistic, but believe me, it is real! Only if the idiotic company-heads could see it, too, instead of listening to the unrealistic and made-up stories told to them by DRM representatives!

The funny thing is, this is nothing but history repeating itself. This already happened in music industry. They said pirates were pirating music so they used DRM. It did NOT work (actually failed miserably). They do not use DRM anymore, and somehow they still make money. Hmmm; interesting. So, what happened all those pirates that were stealing their music and preventing them from making money?

The fact is that, MOST of the people are nice people, who are aware of importance of supporting the source of their entertainment, let it be music, or movies, or games. This means, majority of the people who are willing to pay for an entertainment medium will do so, whether it has DRM or not, and more likely if NOT!

So, the bottom line is, assuming conscientious gamers are present in our society (which they DO)
No DRM = Good for gamers = Good for developers/publishers, BAD for pirates and BAD for DRM companies
Mild DRM = OK for gamers in most cases = OK for developers/publishers, OK for pirates and still good for DRM companies
Intrusive DRM = Horrible for gamers = BAD for developers/publishers! = GOOD for pirates, good for DRM companies
 
Not sure where you're getting that no DRM at all is "bad for pirates". Sure, you need a legit key to play online, but that's the case with almost every Internet multiplayer game, DRM or no. Basically, DRM or not, the game will be cracked and pirates will play it somehow. The only ones who suffer are legitimate users who game companies treat like shit.
 
I don't feel vindicated so much as less punished. PC has been my gaming platform of choice since the original Leisure suit larry. If you know how far back that goes heh. That said though, I have just come to the conclusion that outside mmo's that PC gaming is quickly becoming a lost cause.

If PC gaming dies, then don't be surprised if they then move their piracy focus to the console market.
 
Lol a small Iteration of Socialism. Stupidly Human.
Two fuckers mess up(pirates),
the Big One takes control
Nothing works anymore cause the Big one SUCKS!!!
 
I am talking about the number of new exclusives for PC. Only a couple out of that list are newer (less then 2 years old) and only one is exclusive. Compared to what it used to be, PC gaming has fallen badly. Don't get me wrong, I am in no way happy about the current state of PC gaming, but to say it is going strong is laughable. I have watched more PC gaming communities die off in the past 3 years then I can count..

Exclusives are just plain stupid either way. PC used to have all of them as it was the only platform that was really powerful enough to handle what most people wanted.

Now that the other platforms can handle the power it makes sense from a business standpoint and a consumer standpoint. Same with cell phones and other tech, exclusives suck for the consumer. Some can be good for some businesses but can overall hurt the companies in the long run.

PC gaming is doing just fine with very popular games can can do more on the platform graphically and key binding wise. I am happy with my choice and will be for many years to come. Some games are more fun on consoles to me but the majority of what I play is PC based and will be for a very long time.

Communities die off from lack of support, or the fact that there are so many of them around now. Its very simple to throw up a forum for anything that typically the first one up is the strongest until that game dies off or the community goes down the toilet.

I wouldnt say PC is super strong, but I would not call it failing or even moving backwards at all. It still is leading the fight with technology and things that consoles and other platforms will not have for quite a while. By which time something better will be there on the PC.

While I am glad the DRM is failing, I would not want to see the company fall too far for it. I hope it opens their eyes and makes them re-evaluate their position and make realize DRM like this pushes people to pirate vs legitimately paying for the game. I would not want to see the company tank from it though.
 
When will they stop trying to counter pirates geez. Such a waste seriously.
They should put those resources elsewhere
 
When will they stop trying to counter pirates geez. Such a waste seriously.
They should put those resources elsewhere

yeah, like in releasing more polished products at lower price points without any DRM except a simple CD check

jeez, what a concept
 
i;ll never support ubisoft again

I'll happily support ubisoft again. Once they develop a model that doesn't hurt the consumer. If they drop thier DRM or scale it back to within reason, then I'm perfectly fine with buying from ubisoft again. Saying you'll never buy from them again is bad because it means they have nothing to gain by removing DRM and will only make it worse going forward.
 
Looks like I'll be going for the free version. Not something I ever do outside of occasionally DLing the pc version of a game after I've already bought the console version, but there's no way I'm dealing with this.

So because they have DRM, this entitles you to download it to play it for free? or since you own the console , you should be able to play the PC version free?

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Way to stick it to them!
 
If PC gaming dies, then don't be surprised if they then move their piracy focus to the console market.



it already is on the console market, anyone remember the PS2 and how easily it was to originally use boot disks, then simply USB keys? Sure the 360 was harder, switching DVD drives and such, and PS3 nothing so far, but only time will tell
 
Looks like I'll be going for the free version. Not something I ever do outside of occasionally DLing the pc version of a game after I've already bought the console version, but there's no way I'm dealing with this.

Or you can, you know, buy a copy legally, and get the crack to stop the online checks?

DRM is bad, but pirating isn't exactly better.
 
it already is on the console market, anyone remember the PS2 and how easily it was to originally use boot disks, then simply USB keys? Sure the 360 was harder, switching DVD drives and such, and PS3 nothing so far, but only time will tell

don't forget the PS1 and the dreamcast :D (dreamcast was almost too easy)
 
Why not send Ubisoft a thank-you letter for producing such an awesome game with such hassle-free DRM attached?

I think the point was that rationalizing getting a "free" version isn't right.
 
I think the point was that rationalizing getting a "free" version isn't right.

I understood that. My point was that buying it and applying the crack is a bad alternative, as it helps ensure your future need to do so.
 
if it's not worth paying for, then it's not worth playing

i base my purchases on that simple concept

my non-purchases extend to not pirating the game

i still haven't played MW2 except on a friends computer for the first level and felt bored
 
I understood that. My point was that buying it and applying the crack is a bad alternative, as it helps ensure your future need to do so.

Then don't buy it! Rationalizing piracy is just as stupid as this DRM scheme. You're as bad as them if you do.

Cracking is not piracy if you buy the game. It's a violation of the EULA, sure, but it's a gray area and is not admissible in court.
 
I understood that. My point was that buying it and applying the crack is a bad alternative, as it helps ensure your future need to do so.

Agreed, so the proper method would be to not buy it in the first place :)

Then don't buy it! Rationalizing piracy is just as stupid as this DRM scheme. You're as bad as them if you do.

Cracking is not piracy if you buy the game. It's a violation of the EULA, sure, but it's a gray area and is not admissible in court.

Cracking is not piracy, but I think that if a company really wanted they could probably leverage the DMCA, which has been used in courts.
 
Then don't buy it! Rationalizing piracy is just as stupid as this DRM scheme. You're as bad as them if you do.

Cracking is not piracy if you buy the game. It's a violation of the EULA, sure, but it's a gray area and is not admissible in court.

Except for the ass raping you'll get from the DMCA.
 
The overwhelming majority of multi-platform titles come out on PC months later then any console. It used to be the opposite of this, if you had been gaming as long as you claim you should know this. Given how much longer PC gamers are having to wait on average vs what it used to be, I stand by my claim that PC gaming is no where near as strong as it used to be. Have you walked down the PC games isle lately? It is pretty barren compared to consoles. The overwhelming majority of the titles are either mmo's or things that came out on a console months previous.

Yeah, the PC aisle is barren, at Gamestop, it is fine at BB and other stores. This is not because of a lack of titles or sales. This is because PC titles can not be effectively repurchased and sold used, and that is where game specialty stores like Gamestop make most of their money. So they have chosen to minimize their participation in the PC game market. Steam, Stardock, D2D have all reinforced this position as well, so the store-front space for PC games has shrunk even more because of this.

Besides, in reality it is mainly First Person Shooters, Action Games, Simple Simulations, Sports Games, and to a slightly lesser extent Role-Playing Games that the PC is heavily multi-platformed. Pretty much all other PC genre's, such as Turn-Based/4x Games, RTS, and High-complexity Simulations, are not particularly multi-platformed and are still very strong on PC.
 
if it's not worth paying for, then it's not worth playing

i base my purchases on that simple concept

my non-purchases extend to not pirating the game

i still haven't played MW2 except on a friends computer for the first level and felt bored

I normally agree with this but unfortunately the logic breaks down here. Most games are fine being evaluated under a value/cost rubric, but in this situation you can't buy Assassin's Creed 2 without voting "yes" on the DRM. I'm normally anti piracy, but for example, I was quite pleased to see the staggering amount of Spore piracy even though I had no interest in the game myself. Sometimes game companies need to be taught a lesson.
 
Except for the ass raping you'll get from the DMCA.

That's true, but I'll just take my receipt to court and tell Ubi to shove it. :-P

I always believed that Fair Use and DCMA are very contradictory and insulting to our intelligence.

I can see DoJ and their cohorts in the RIAA go "What? Of COURSE you have the rights to back up your stuff. *snicker snicker*"
 
That's true, but I'll just take my receipt to court and tell Ubi to shove it. :-P

I always believed that Fair Use and DCMA are very contradictory and insulting to our intelligence.

I can see DoJ and their cohorts in the RIAA go "What? Of COURSE you have the rights to back up your stuff. *snicker snicker*"

This has been specifically addressed by the courts (wiki link):
However, in a number of cases involving DVD decryption courts have held that there is no fair use defense in circumvention cases. In Universal City Studios v. Reimerdes, 111 F. Supp. 2d 294, 322 (S.D.N.Y. 2000), the court stated that 「f Congress had meant the fair use defense to apply to such actions, it would have said so.」[5]


As such you would be subject to the following penalties:
(a) In General. — Any person who violates section 1201 or 1202 willfully and for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain —

(1) shall be fined not more than $500,000 or imprisoned for not more than 5 years, or both, for the first offense; and
 
Wow haha - just saw this thread and remember all the gung ho Pro-DRM people in the gaming section of [H].

Sure am glad I stayed away from this crapstorm known as Ubisoft ;)
 
Actually Ubisoft is a genius! It cost money to maintain servers and bandwidth, right? So they sell the game, make record millions in AC2 sales, then run away with the money with a non-existent server, leaving us with coasters.

They didn't lose any money at all! :D

Brilliant! But screw actually making the game - depending on how clever they are, they could have only paid to pre-render a few trailers, fired all the devs, and sold people dics with 7 odd gigs of the trailers repeated over and over. That is how you make a profit.
 
As such you would be subject to the following penalties:

(a) In General. — Any person who violates section 1201 or 1202 willfully and for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain —

(1) shall be fined not more than $500,000 or imprisoned for not more than 5 years, or both, for the first offense

What commercial advantage and private financial gain would I get using a crack to play a game I bought?
 
What commercial advantage and private financial gain would I get using a crack to play a game I bought?

it's not that, they want to scare you

when you're at the screen to download the crack, you're not gonna say to yourself

"OH NO NOT TEH DMCA" and not click it are you? ;)\

the DMCA is a joke and has been abused into oblivion
 
it's not that, they want to scare you

when you're at the screen to download the crack, you're not gonna say to yourself

"OH NO NOT TEH DMCA" and not click it are you? ;)\

the DMCA is a joke and has been abused into oblivion

Yeah exactly.

I mentioned a couple posts ago I think the DCMA is an insult to our intelligence and I'd even go as far as say Fair Use is an entrapment designed to make software, music and DVD owners complacent about backing up their data only to be snared by the law, fined for profit.
 
Yeah exactly.

I mentioned a couple posts ago I think the DCMA is an insult to our intelligence and I'd even go as far as say Fair Use is an entrapment designed to make software, music and DVD owners complacent about backing up their data only to be snared by the law, fined for profit.

I didn't think about that "fined for profit" thing when I posted that, but you're right, they hope if they get juries to agree to large enough verdicts, they can deter people from pirating, but it hasn't happened, and the music industry has said their income has been cut in half. I think I posted a story along those lines and Steve posted it on the front page.

I guess that's a little off topic though, but that's one example of how they are abusing the DMCA and doing what you said, fining for profit.

Game developers just want their DRM NOT just to deter piracy, but to prevent secondhand sales as well.

As far as I'm concerned, all their DRM is doing is making me NOT buy their games.

I'm not really going to discuss cracks in detail, but they have their place for the paying customer who has bought the game and doesn't want to deal with a disc check.

As it is, I rarely use my DVD drive anymore, because I buy all my games on Steam.
 
What commercial advantage and private financial gain would I get using a crack to play a game I bought?

lol. The retail price of the game is your private financial gain. Sorry, but it's been tried and failed. Keep lying to your self to help you sleep at night though.
 
lol. The retail price of the game is your private financial gain. Sorry, but it's been tried and failed. Keep lying to your self to help you sleep at night though.

???

he said he'd crack a game after he paid for it

nowhere did he say he'd pirate the game

where's your logic?
 
Back
Top