Top 10 worst things about BF2142

MrGuvernment said:
For me lag is when you say, see someone, then they skip ahead a few feet.

or you fire your gun, and it literally takes 1+ seconds to see it hit something, or you unload a clip into someone and nothing hits them, then they shoot you once and your dead.

And yes, for sure, the lower your ping, the better chance

Someone witha 25ms ping, vs my 100ms is technically 4x faster then i am, which can be the result of me turning a corner, them hearing me, but me not hearinf them until they have shot already knowing i am coming, it happens now and then, this is why often people with higher pings learn to shot just before turning a corner, and then often the dead person screams your a hacker! you wall hack!

When i was in toront and playing cs:s on my uncles cable, with a sub 30ms ping, i played awsome, so the ping can affect ones skill level considerably.

As you stated, many server try to run a game too hard, they dont have the capacity to run say a 32man 100tic server

our squads servers [xXx] have toyed with 100 and 66, we can do a 40man 66 tic no problems, if we go to 100 tic,got to drop it to 32 or less.

i often test lag by blowing up a barrel, or shooting a box that will destruct, if the result is instant - your not lagging.
You seriously have absolutely no idea how client-server connections work in videogames, do you? Does your concept of them involve a voodoo witch or a black mage of some kind? Shooting an environment item to test lag is a ridiculous idea if you don't even know whether environment object physics / events are rendered by the server or by the client...and most internet games render them clientside, so congratulations, you're proving precisely nothing except that your computer has a solid loopback connection. To correct some other points in that mass of misinformation that is your post, no, a person pinging 25ms is not 4x faster than somebody pinging 100ms, technically or otherwise, and no, those 1-second-long delays in rendering are not lag, they're packet loss. The concept of leading enemies based on their footsteps has absolutely nothing to do with latency whatsoever, particularly in a game like Counter-Strike (which is what you apparently base your vast body of knowledge off of) where the game's server side calculations deliberately average movements out to decrease serverside bandwidth usage and even out the playing field latencywise...christ, to correct every point you're wrong on I would pretty much have to just re-write your post, so can we just have everything you said stricken from the internet? That would be swell.
 
Frosteh said:
This guy has hit the nail on the head with a lot of these points.

http://www.desinc.net/bf2142_review

I am totaly dumbfounded how a large company can make design desicions that do things like give a Green/Orange/Red indicator for Ping where anything below 100ms is Green, even if they were forced at gunpoint to use this system (which they're not) then the very LEAST they could do is make the numbers more sensible, like 0ms-30ms = green 31ms-60ms = Orange 61+ms = Red

The fact that you can't refresh a single server (in a list of multiple servers) still, I should really highlight the word STILL as much as possible because these are problems dating back to BF1942.

Dice has this amazing and quite profound ability to make a fantastic game like BF1942 or BF2 and then put in these mind boggling stupid game dynamics which just makes absolutly ZERO sense whatsoever.

anyways... <3


Didn't read the whole thread but I just wanted to make sure people knew.

dumasyy1.jpg
 
hey wait...how did you get that...? (refering to the pic that had numberic pings than color pings)
 
The biggest problem with this game and even BF2 was not being able to connect to the master server. The writer of the article did not mention that.
 
plasma said:
Spaceman hit it on the head. I was hoping that 2142 would be much better, by fixing all the issues in Bf2 and improving on the game all together but I was very let down

Here's my list

No Widescreen

Can't run fast more than about 10ft with or without armor

Weapons are worse than whats in BF2, and its supposed to be 140 years later :mad:

A revolver sidearm with only 6 shoots in the year 2142?:rolleyes:come on!

no jets or plane like aircraft :mad:

whole screen shakes when you run

Still looses connection

mech walkers can't fly or hop short distances :mad:

Hoover tank just blows - no rotatable turret so you can't really shoot on the move, and it handles like garbage, sways all over so its hard to make long range shots because its unstable, no driver controlled coaxial machine gun, and it can't hoover over water

titan mode is kind of stupid, the titat ship is cool, but the whole silo capture thing is dumb

You can turn off screen bob, loads of games "loose" connection, of course the damn walkers can't fly, come on; this isn't mech bastard warrior, there has to be some kind of balance, the hover tank is down to technique and can be devastating when piloted as a hovertank, not a conventional one, and the MG is controlled by a second player, which encourages team-play. This means you don't get mad armour rapeage so easily, and gives infantry more of a chance. Balance.
 
After playing 2142 I prefer it over BF2. Tanks in BF2 made me so angry because the only people who would use them were engineers who would run and repair them as soon as they got hit. In 2142 they made sure to make tanks a formidable foe, but mainly if they were crewed by two people and they were smart. It only takes one shot to the rear from the Engineer's rocket or any AT weapon for that matter to disable it which I am loving. The same thing goes for the mech, a very powerful unit but if careless can be hurt by small arms fire and disabled with one shot.
 
While there are a lot of things like about BF2142 compared to BF2 (namely the easier to fly planes, seems weapons are more accurate) I think they need to do something about the engineer class.

As it stands, an Engineer is clearly the godly class in the Demo. Maybe things will change with unlocks and whatnot. As an engineer you have both a sub machine gun and your rocket launcher (which I can't figure out if its dumb fire or homing). This sub machine gun seems to be nearly, if not as good as the main Assault machine gun, so I really have no reason to play the assault class. Aside from the healing aspect, but in the demo you still can't revive. The scout class is useful, but you pretty much have no versitility without C4/Grenades/Claymores etc.. The heavy armor class is useful for resupply, but the mounted machine gun seems to be "eh", at least without any of the unlocks.

I'm thinking these may actually be completely unfair criticisms, as the full version will definately have more equipment. However, I can see how it would turn off a lot of people to see the Engineer ruling the battlefield.
 
I would say that THE worst thing about BF21whatever are the people that were complaining about how sucky BF2 was, went out and bought BF221whoknowswhat and are now complaining that it stinks.

I recall this American prephrase: Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice shame on me.

After the first instance was "oh so crappy" why on earth would anyone go out and buy the "re-release"?
 
Xaeos said:
While there are a lot of things like about BF2142 compared to BF2 (namely the easier to fly planes, seems weapons are more accurate) I think they need to do something about the engineer class.

As it stands, an Engineer is clearly the godly class in the Demo. Maybe things will change with unlocks and whatnot. As an engineer you have both a sub machine gun and your rocket launcher (which I can't figure out if its dumb fire or homing). This sub machine gun seems to be nearly, if not as good as the main Assault machine gun, so I really have no reason to play the assault class. Aside from the healing aspect, but in the demo you still can't revive. The scout class is useful, but you pretty much have no versitility without C4/Grenades/Claymores etc.. The heavy armor class is useful for resupply, but the mounted machine gun seems to be "eh", at least without any of the unlocks.

I'm thinking these may actually be completely unfair criticisms, as the full version will definately have more equipment. However, I can see how it would turn off a lot of people to see the Engineer ruling the battlefield.

I'd disagree - just try them all out. In the Beta I was engineer all the time for the reasons you stated, up to getting the Anti-tank rifle, but with the demo i've actually realised how incredible the basic support kit is. I'm finding myself coming first in the debriefing with the LMG, support kit and whatever vehicle (though that's less relevant) every single time, with scores of 30-3. Assaulting the titan is absurd with these things, I think you just need to grow accustomed to them; learning how long to hold down fire to maximise accuracy vs. but knowing when to let off to stop the overheat takes a bit but is very much worth it.
I personally would say that the support class is unstoppable when played by someone that knows how, as i've seen, but then there's the risk that they might tone it down, and we couldn't be having that :p
 
I played as support the other night and it is a very good class. I loved how when you go prone the cross hair takes some time to come all the way in. This gets rid of the annoying support players of BF2 who can just run around and still dominate. Also the weapon does not kill as quickly as the support guns of BF2 keeping the game all in balance.
 
What really makes me laugh is all the imbeciles saying "ITS 2142, WHY DO THEY STILL HAVE BULLETS INSTEAD OF LASERS AND REVOLVERS THAT ONLY SHOOT SIX?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!". How the hell do you guys know what kind of technology we will have in 2142? For all we know there could be some sort of huge disaster between now and then that actually makes us take a step backward technologically.

I especially love the little argument about the hover tank that went on in another thread that I read. People were actually arguing about the physics of something that DOES NOT YET EXIST!

I can understand EA-hating, but this is just plain stupidity.
 
Wally said:
The guy's a self-gratifying, opinionated dildo. I was agreeing with him up until, well... the end of the first point.

#2 - no, we wouldn't. We were all meant to be in fucking hovercars and living in space by the year 2000. Shut up.

#3 - today we still use weapons that are over 40 years old, or based on these designs. Look at weapons being designed today, the very cutting edge - they're still bullet & hammer jobs, no fucking lasers. They get introduced into use in say 10 years? that makes 2016, another 40 years on we're still using them, another ten to that... stupid person. It's a single century, for christ's sake. Laser weapons? Pfft. Shut up.

#4 - just absolute nonsense. It's a game, it's made for people to play, not a fucking space simulation with all hands on virtual deck, you penis. And the titans looking different? What, you can't differentiate between massive, glowing red fields of energy and massive glowing blue fields of enegry? Shut up.

#5 - so you don't like the way the game was designed. Fair play. However, the missiles do lock on, and people can kill you when in stationary defenses because you're a clueless tool that'll stand there and let them, apparently - it's the only way they could, those things are so awful. And there is a fucking infantry anti-aircraft weapon. Shut up.

#6 - agreed.

#7 - agreed, but all the green-barred servers i've joined have worked fabulous, so no great problem there.

#8 - what...?

#9 - don't be stupid. you may as well use wallhacks or whatever. It is a game, and as such it is Designed a certain way for a Purpose. He's clearly trying very hard to look for more points to make up a nice round number like 10. Shut up, silly child.

#10 - ha.

Well, that was appalling. I'm really sorry for all of you that agree with this for not being able to try the unlocks or playing on shitty servers, but i'm off to have a fantastic time being a space pirate and exploding enemy ships and running off as it explodes, all cinematic-like.

Yeah, I work for EA no doubt, etc.
Try getting a clue.

QFT This guy took the time to publish a rant about a demo how lame is that?
 
Wally said:
The guy's a self-gratifying, opinionated dildo. I was agreeing with him up until, well... the end of the first point.

#2 - no, we wouldn't. We were all meant to be in fucking hovercars and living in space by the year 2000. Shut up.

#3 - today we still use weapons that are over 40 years old, or based on these designs. Look at weapons being designed today, the very cutting edge - they're still bullet & hammer jobs, no fucking lasers. They get introduced into use in say 10 years? that makes 2016, another 40 years on we're still using them, another ten to that... stupid person. It's a single century, for christ's sake. Laser weapons? Pfft. Shut up.

#4 - just absolute nonsense. It's a game, it's made for people to play, not a fucking space simulation with all hands on virtual deck, you penis. And the titans looking different? What, you can't differentiate between massive, glowing red fields of energy and massive glowing blue fields of enegry? Shut up.

#5 - so you don't like the way the game was designed. Fair play. However, the missiles do lock on, and people can kill you when in stationary defenses because you're a clueless tool that'll stand there and let them, apparently - it's the only way they could, those things are so awful. And there is a fucking infantry anti-aircraft weapon. Shut up.

#6 - agreed.

#7 - agreed, but all the green-barred servers i've joined have worked fabulous, so no great problem there.

#8 - what...?

#9 - don't be stupid. you may as well use wallhacks or whatever. It is a game, and as such it is Designed a certain way for a Purpose. He's clearly trying very hard to look for more points to make up a nice round number like 10. Shut up, silly child.

#10 - ha.

Well, that was appalling. I'm really sorry for all of you that agree with this for not being able to try the unlocks or playing on shitty servers, but i'm off to have a fantastic time being a space pirate and exploding enemy ships and running off as it explodes, all cinematic-like.

Yeah, I work for EA no doubt, etc.
Try getting a clue.

yeswr5.gif
 
Dan_D said:
I wouldn't say its the worst statement ever, and I stand behind it. Many games that work perfectly aren't fun. Go to a computer store or game store and walk down the isle. Tell me how many out of the 100's of titles on the shelves are good games? Tell me how many work pretty good, but are still not fun. I'd be willing to bet that the enthralling and worthwhile games are in the minority.

Sure you and I can both name off a bunch of titles that work great and are fun, but I can also name off several titles that work well and aren't fun too. Doom 3 is one such example. Masterpiece of technical engineering and software development, but it isn't the most fun game out there.

HL2 has a ton of issues, but is fun. I wouldn't call it a technical masterpiece. It takes a ton of patching to make HL2 work worth a crap. It took forever to get rid of the stutter that the game used to have on so many systems.

The amount of flaws a game has are not directly proportional to how much fun they are. Farcry, HL2, FEAR and many more are great games and when they were new, they had a HUGE list of problems.

The BF series does have an almost record setting list of problems, but they are still fun games. My whole point is that while the BF games need work, they are fun. I just think that EA and DICE are lazy and ultimately overly greedy, soul-less bastards that aren't interested in delivering the best product possible. They just want to start making money as fast as possible.


I see what you are saying. I suppose I based my opinions off of the games I play which tend to be the better games only. I know when I walk into a game store I see 100's of games of which I couldn't be bothered with and will never play, limiting my experience with crappy games.

And i think you really hit the nail on the head with compaines being greedy
 
Back
Top