THQ: Pre-Owned Games 'Cheats Developers'

looks like we're going around in circles here.

let's break it down into the 2 important questions.

1. Should developers see revenue from used sales? (remember the game has already had it's sale and provided money to the developer, now it's just switching hands and allowing the original owner to make a little money back)

2. If not, should steps be taken to prevent used sales? (this obviously opens up a can of worms regarding reseller rights)
 
eh, how much does a book cost to write? actual costs? How much does an album cost to make? Probably more than a book costs I would guess. How much do these things cost to market? = the big expense.

now compare that to a video game.

How much does it cost to employee 20 to 50 professionals for 3 to 4 years to develop one game? then how much does it cost to market it? You are already out MILLIONS to HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS.

If you were recreating the game engine every single time you make a new game, sure it'd be pretty costly for each game. Too bad that's not actually the case. Many companies will make 1 game engine, then build like 50 games around it. Other companies don't even make a game engine. They just license it out from other companies.

Sorry, but hundreds of millions to make a game. Congrats on not doing any kind of research and think your own opinion is somehow fact. Game budgets don't even go over $100 million. Halo 3? $55 million. APB? $50 million. MGS4? $60 million. The biggest budget so far has been $100 million for GTA4. That was 1000s of employees working on it for over 3 1/2 years. Music licensing alone for that game was probably over $1 million.

Majority of games? Well below $25 million. Only the AAA titles ever seem to even near $50 million and most of that is the stupid advertising. I don't even see the point of advertising a AAA title. It'll advertise itself through word of mouth.
 
Uh no. You aren't buying a license, its a finished product. You can use lawyer speak all you want, your argument is still shit, and video games are still consumer goods.

I'm not saying it's right. I think it's bullshit. But that is what they are pushing for and how other software is already treated.
 
eh, how much does a book cost to write? actual costs? How much does an album cost to make? Probably more than a book costs I would guess. How much do these things cost to market? = the big expense.
A book costs a lot to write, edit, market and actually publish. And probably sells a lot less copies than a video game. Why does this matter? Books also sell for a lot less at retail. It doesn't make games a special case, it just means they cost more and have a larger economy of scale. It's the same situation with different parameters.
 
LOL! n You kids need to stop posting. New cars can lose as much as HALF their value in one year. No games do that.

If you think you can sell a game for half its new price a year later, I'd love to have some of what you're smoking. Retailers can't even get that much for NEW copies of a year-old game, and you expect to get that much for a used copy? Get real son.
 
Batman: Arkham Asylum. Came out 1 year ago. Half the cost now.
Street Fighter IV. 1 year ago. Half the cost now.
Red Faction: Guerilla. 1 year 1 month ago. 1/3rd to 1/2 the cost.
Borderlands. 10 months ago. 1/2 the cost.

Sorry, but show me a $20000 car that costs only $10000 after 1 year. We're talking excellent/good condition with average mileage (10,000-15000 miles).

Also keep in mind that those games are RETAIL PRICE. That means if you have a used copy you want to sell you're going to need to go for probably half of THAT price, which means a game goes from $60 to $15 or less in a year. If you bought a car that's only worth 25% of its purchase price a year later, you got screwed.
 
eh, how much does a book cost to write? actual costs? How much does an album cost to make? Probably more than a book costs I would guess. How much do these things cost to market? = the big expense.
now compare that to a video game.

How much does it cost to make a a movie? Games are not a special case.

It is bad enough already that if you pay $50 bucks for a game that sucks you can't return it, but now they want kill your only avenue of recouping anything, selling it.

How gullible are you, that you want to limit your recourse for dealing with crap games to nothing?

Why would anyone who isn't shilling volunteer to give up all his rights and have none? :rolleyes:
 
"Buying used games is theft. Clean and simple. It's smash and grab. It ain't no different than smashing a window at Tiffany's and grabbing merchandise."

Eh, don't know if I can force this meme much further, but there's little else to add to the debate at this point.
 
How much does it cost to make a a movie? Games are not a special case.

It is bad enough already that if you pay $50 bucks for a game that sucks you can't return it, but now they want kill your only avenue of recouping anything, selling it.

How gullible are you, that you want to limit your recourse for dealing with crap games to nothing?

Why would anyone who isn't shilling volunteer to give up all his rights and have none? :rolleyes:

If they want to take away our right to sell the game, then I demand them to unlock the full game for us to play for 3-5 hours (free of charge), before we make the final decision to purchase it. Not some shit demo, I mean the actual full game.

Shouldn't matter to them. It's the online portion and DLC that they are trying to lock out of use for secondary owners, so giving us all a free trial of the singleplayer shouldn't be a problem.
 
If they want to take away our right to sell the game, then I demand them to unlock the full game for us to play for 3-5 hours (free of charge), before we make the final decision to purchase it. Not some shit demo, I mean the actual full game.

Shouldn't matter to them. It's the online portion and DLC that they are trying to lock out of use for secondary owners, so giving us all a free trial of the singleplayer shouldn't be a problem.

Three to five hours is about enough to finish most single player games these days. It would be pointless to buy it after you played the demo in most cases.
 
Three to five hours is about enough to finish most single player games these days. It would be pointless to buy it after you played the demo in most cases.

Yes and that's their own fault for making the singleplayer that short. Maybe they need to work on that, instead of working on just multiplayer.
 
Back
Top