THQ: No More Mediocre Games

John_Keck

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 3, 2010
Messages
379
Ian Curran, THQ’s executive of global publishing, claims mediocre video games are not cost-effective anymore. Publishers either need to aim high and create the next big thing, or play it safe with low-cost development instead. I wonder what THQ has planned.

“There’s no room for them. You’re either a standout, best in class, or you die. We won’t bring bad games to market anymore. You can’t spend $30, $40, $50 million on a bad game and expect to make a return.”
 
How about 1 last patch for Supreme Commander/Forged Alliance?
Step up to the plate THQ...
 
"We won't bring bad games to market anymore."

They say that like I should believe they INTENDED to make bad games in the past. As if they were sitting around bored with all their masterpieces and thought "Hey, I wonder what it would be like to produce an absolute turd?" Nobody TRIES to produce a bad game. It's not like someone decided to spend millions of dollars on Psychonauts knowing that it wouldn't sell from the beginning. If someone is investing millions of dollars into a game, someone thinks it's a good game.
 
"We won't bring bad games to market anymore."

They say that like I should believe they INTENDED to make bad games in the past. As if they were sitting around bored with all their masterpieces and thought "Hey, I wonder what it would be like to produce an absolute turd?" Nobody TRIES to produce a bad game. It's not like someone decided to spend millions of dollars on Psychonauts knowing that it wouldn't sell from the beginning. If someone is investing millions of dollars into a game, someone thinks it's a good game.

Yeah I think games are just getting ridiculously expensive and it's one of those things. "Hey we could spend a buttload of money and probably not be able to compete with MW2, or we could spend half that and make something OK that sells well"

Way to aim high.
 
considering how hard it is to compete in the gaming market, I can see where they are coming from. Look how well pop-cap games are doing, Im sure THQ will go the way of small time developers.
 
Wow, how insightful. i never thought releasing a bad game would result in poor sales!

Here I was thinking it was the pirates and lack of DRM causing poor sales. silly, silly me.
 
You know it's not even a matter of bad games. It's making games that don't even work. To this day I still see lots of review where the only complaint is that the game is just unfuckin playable due to control issue or AI balancing. Whatever the game is make the lead developer sit down and play the game all the way through.
 
Metro 2033...they made/produced a pretty good game.

Maybe that's why this comment came about...
 
It took THQ this long to realize that "make shitty products" is a poor business model?

Gotta give them credit for finally figuring it out at least, I suppose. Hopefully the rest of the industry pays attention; there are only one or two developers out there who don't need to learn this lesson.
 
Does everyone remember the times when games would get released unfished and need massive patching before the game would work properly but at the same time make a decent amount of money? I think they are just telling us that that model isn't really going to work anymore.
 
I think the problem with the video game industry is its youth. First of all, who has the money to invest in a new game? Corporations. How many corporations are known for innovation? Very few. How many of those corporations have people who know what it takes to produce a good game controlling production and purse strings? Even fewer. Of the pool of knowledgeable developers, how many are suitable for administration of a game company? You can probably count them on your fingers.
 
Does everyone remember the times when games would get released unfished and need massive patching before the game would work properly but at the same time make a decent amount of money? I think they are just telling us that that model isn't really going to work anymore.

No, the model of releasing incomplete games that need a ton of patching but at most get one or two isn't going to work any more. A lot of games just get a few initial patches if not just one and that's it, on to the next game even if there are glaring bugs. Games will sell for years if they are good and properly supported.
 
No, the model of releasing incomplete games that need a ton of patching but at most get one or two isn't going to work any more. A lot of games just get a few initial patches if not just one and that's it, on to the next game even if there are glaring bugs. Games will sell for years if they are good and properly supported.

you told me no but you went on to say the exact same thing in more detail...
 
Well if they can make games just as good as their WWE and UFC it shouldnt be a problem...I think the UFC is their cream of the crop...
 
Thank goodness.

There are WAY too many games out there. I just don't have time to play every game I want to buy. They need to stop producing the quantity and make a very small selection of well developed games.

They seem to have a decent handle on this, now. Metro 2033 is excellent. The last Red Faction game was very well developed and a lot of fun. It was only missing a good story. The next Red Faction's gameplay better be polished as hell, since I imagine they still haven't found a good story to throw into the series this late in the game.

Oh, and Homefront sounds kick ass. They're really making up for Red Faction's one short coming! Check this trailer out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D5yyWZ2Z6Ps&hd=1
 
There have been quite a number of just great games that have come out in the last year. Batman AA, Dirt 2, Metro 2033, Just Cause 2, BC2. Now we Starcraft 2 and Mafia 2 on the way. Rage, Portal 2 on the way. Honestly if you have time to play all this stuff then you need to go outside more often anyway.;)
 
besides the obvious stupidity here on THQ's part for this statement, i'm kinda intrigued.

**in my opinion** THQ has made both good and bad games in the past. i loved dawn of war 1, red faction 1, and a few others. but yeah there have been some crap - red faction 2 comes to mind. what a freakin disaster...

but on the other hand they have some talented developers. they've now got relic who did homeworld 1 and 2 (god i love those games!) as well as Volition....i can't help but love the guys that brought us freespace and freespace 2.

so as John says who posted the article...i wonder what they have up their sleeve?

me wants freespace 3 and homeworld 3!!! GIMMIE GIMMIE GIMMIE!!
 
It took THQ this long to realize that "make shitty products" is a poor business model?

Problem is is that that's very subjective...

I still feel that Far Cry 2 was GOTY... Very few others felt that way about it... The game was very polarizing, with you either loving or hating the game, and seemingly most hating it...

Whereas at the same time some of the most successful games (GTA, EA Sports, CoD...) are titles I have little interest in... I finally just played CoD1, and while I did end up liking it (the first third of it just about made me forget it, but I came back to it six weeks later...), it still didn't encourage me to immediately play COD:UO, 2, 4, 5, even though I already own them...

Unfortunately "shitty products" is too subjective for them to use it as a criteria...

What they really need to focus on though is a game working properly out of the box... Widescreen is probably the majority of users these days... H+ FOV needs to be the standard out of the box... Once that's standard, Eyefinity/surround will already at least halfway work right, too...
 
"We won't bring bad games to market anymore."

They say that like I should believe they INTENDED to make bad games in the past. As if they were sitting around bored with all their masterpieces and thought "Hey, I wonder what it would be like to produce an absolute turd?" Nobody TRIES to produce a bad game. It's not like someone decided to spend millions of dollars on Psychonauts knowing that it wouldn't sell from the beginning. If someone is investing millions of dollars into a game, someone thinks it's a good game.

I have to wonder sometimes. Somewhere along the way, someone has to realize that the game they're making is a stinker. Do they continue just because they've already invested so much into it and it's too late? Does this mean that THQ will invest 20 or 30 million in a game, find out it sucks, and then just throw it away? Seems like you'd want to release it anyway and at least recoup some of your investment.

I was watching the newer Willy Wonka movie with my kids a few days ago. Didn't anyone tell Johnny Depp during filming to be less gay and creepy? I guess it's not only crappy games that get released rather than scrapping the whole shebang.
 
There have been quite a number of just great games that have come out in the last year. Batman AA, Dirt 2, Metro 2033, Just Cause 2, BC2. Now we Starcraft 2 and Mafia 2 on the way. Rage, Portal 2 on the way. Honestly if you have time to play all this stuff then you need to go outside more often anyway.;)

Batman AA is surely well over a year old by now and contains, at best, 10 hours gameplay if you really go nuts searching for all the achievements. It's worth every penny but it's hardly a time sink. Dirt2 is also about 9 months old and gave me 40 hours before I had aced every single player race and dabbled in some multiplayer. Metro is a linear single player, story driven corridor shooter that is over and done with in a matter of hours. Just Cause 2 is.. well crap, to be honest but it's a nice tech demo for 30 mins to show friends. BC2 is the only real time sink in that list.

I thought the last year was pretty light on 'games worth playing through' to be honest. The lack of any decent MMOs in the last few years has left most of my gamer friends twiddling their thumbs.
 
You might think Burton/Depp films are crappy, but they've raked in over a billion dollars worldwide.

Then again, as I said, I've seen the other side of that coin. FC2 was an absolute turd by the typical word-of-mouth, but I'll argue it's GOTY material...

Like i said, unfortunately "crappy" is subjective. The only way to possibly gauge it is to release pre-beta-alpha-omega works-in-progress that are years away from release that have a billion bugs to determine interest. Since it's a crapfest of bugs at that point, interest will more than likely suck.

Then again, Spore probably could have been improved had they gauged interest on it in the form it was when released...
 
THQ's bread & butter was the wrestling games. They need to go back and step their "game" up with that platform again because wrestling games suck nowadays
 
So they just figured out you shouldn't spend $50M on a game if your sales projections say your only going to sell 4M copies at $60 each? ($24M in sales.) I believe I know some 1yr accounting students who could teach these guys and others a few things about running a company.
 
Somebody should tell this to Cryptic and their half ass devs.

Star Trek Online is a good example of what happens when devs rush out a game to make a quick buck.
 
Trust me, devs dont rush if they are not being rushed.
Bad projects carry on due to poor research/management and survival instinct, dont bite the hand that feeds.
 
Does this mean game developers will finally stop shoveling shit our way?

I really hope so.
 
To add: The movie industry has been doing this for years. Why should game developers stop making craptastic games?
 
So they just figured out you shouldn't spend $50M on a game if your sales projections say your only going to sell 4M copies at $60 each? ($24M in sales.) I believe I know some 1yr accounting students who could teach these guys and others a few things about running a company.

lol, the irony. Try $240 million.
 
Don't only 20% of games make any profit? 80% is made by the top 20% or something. There was an article, google it.
 
Back
Top