The Windows Era Is Over

It would be ignorant to say windows cannot make a comeback. MS has come from behind in many markets. In fact they are one of the only companies in the world that can do it so many times.
 
In America the Samsung Galaxy phones are the most popular Android phones. What's the most popular Windows phone, the cheap low end Lumia 520 & 521? So here at least Android are the high end phones that are more expensive than the average computer, while the barely better than a flip phones are Windows phones.

Maybe in poor developing countries low end Android phones are the most popular, but if they are hooked on Android now, they are more likely to stay with Android when they can afford a better phone. Those people may not even have a desktop at all, everything they do is going to be on Android.

Low end Android devices make up the majority sold in the US as well. Phones like the GS3, GS4, and GN2 make up under a fifth of Samsung's total smartphone sales. The rest are low end. The old iPhone 4S still outsells the GS4, and the iPhone 5 took under a week to sell what the GS4 did in an entire month.

Again, the majority of Android phones sold are in the low end. High end Android phones are a niche, both compared to low end Android devices and iOS devices. The difference in internet traffic and even Google's own mobile ad revenue (they make several times more from iOS than they do their own Android) also reflect this, given that low end devices aren't used the same way for online and apps that something like an iPhone, an HTC One, or a GS4 would be used.
 
Exactly. While MS slept, Android out-Windowed Windows, when Google applied the same strategy to mobile devices as MS used to gain a PC monopoly --- making the O/S ubiquitous, able to run on many diverse models of hardware -- from branded, high end devices down to whitebox, generic, chinese greymarket junk. The apple faithful cried "fragmentation" as if it would be Android's downfall but didn't understand the longview Google was shaping.

Like it or not, "fragmentation" is Android's biggest curse as well as its biggest blessing. The same fragmentation that allows it to be carpet bombed on every low end piece of hardware is the same one that puts a hard ceiling on application quality. Accounting for the different hardware and OS configurations is much worse than the compatibility issues developers have had to deal with in Windows. Part of it is Microsoft having much better development tools and backwards compatibility than Google.

On top of the resulting increased development and QA costs, Android is also among the least profitable ecosystems out there. The impetus for high quality applications isn't there for Android like it is for iOS, Windows, or OS X, and it partly comes down to fragmentation (easy side-loading, aka piracy, is the other).

What motivation is there when cross-platform developers on average make 4x as much on iOS, and it costs more to account for the various configurations out there. A powerful unified platform with paying customers is much more appealing, which is why the other platform has much better software.

Fragmentation and the low end is seriously holding Android back, and unfortunately cheap devices running Gingerbread or older are the vast majority.
 
The small changes in Windows 8.1 is not the fix most people are looking for, at best it just makes Windows 8.1 slightly less irritating to use.
The only fix that would cause me to upgrade from Windows 7, is a full return of the start button that functions like it did in every previous version of Windows. Make the Metro interface a menu choice that I can ignore or even remove.

It's real simple, keep Metro for phones & tablets, but make it completely optional for the desktop.

I predict a VERY long life for Windows 7 unless Microsoft comes to thier senses.

So, A minor UI change makes a OS crap? seriously? and A few changes that are easily done (in the manor that you want) with a simple google search - and soon as a built in setting? Lazy much?
Sure they probably shot themselves in the foot trying to force people to use the new UI; (not a good move IMO) but Seriously people BUY a F*@ing clue. Win 8 is effectively win 7.5 (ie win 7 with optimizations, updates and a UI changes) and if they would have labeled it such it would have been much less of a circus.
But anyone saying it sucks and also loves win 7 is mental! If you are posting here and can't get off your ass (of can't figure out) to Google some simple UI changes to suite your personal likes . . Then you should loose ALL HardOCP cred and privileges.
Hell I have given a few WIN8 newbies ONE free start menu program and they now forget they are NOT using win7 . . . and are slowing learning all of the other perks hidden in win8 while they are not stressing over the UI change. (I expect some will no longer need it for long)
All of this "death of the PC" is overstatement, and bullcrap.
Most professionals CAN'T use tablets and often not even most low end laptops. For most others a laptop is needed (a tablet can supplement nicely though, but not replace)
A full keyboard, with a big (or multiple) displays, with allot of memory and a good CPU for some is a must!

MAC's give people computers that are mostly user "proof" keeping things simple and nicely useable. (nice the new versions (read OSX) of the OS has a Unix core so for the first time people can do some advanced things with it - they did put a nice UI on it and sold the crap out of it! something the Linux people should look closer at)

Windows is the default winner as it simply does what people want, runs most everything natively and you can do more or less what you need to do. (good mix of basic to advanced user) For good or bad this middle ground is very useful. Bonus for being on most new PC's, having the largest software library, and widest support of hardware.

Linux Not bad at all but still suffering from fragmentation of brand (distro There is no single Linux OS that people can point to), the look/feel, the limited software library's (commercial), the open source programs often are poor seconds (but functional) to commercial versions. Too much seems to depends on the distro! and which you embrace (there are 100?) http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/1b/Linux_Distribution_Timeline.svg . And the dream of open source really is not a rosy as people though it would be, with some becoming more closed and proprietary. Great for the developer or limited controlled workstation . . but still not main stream.
 
Linux Not bad at all but still suffering from fragmentation of brand (distro There is no single Linux OS that people can point to), the look/feel, the limited software library's (commercial), the open source programs often are poor seconds (but functional) to commercial versions. Too much seems to depends on the distro! and which you embrace (there are 100?)

You can't point to a single version of Windows either. It's hardly a problem. Aside from that Ubuntu/Mint has been #1 for like 8 years now, which is the recommended platform for Valve's Steam Client.
 
You can't point to a single version of Windows either. It's hardly a problem. Aside from that Ubuntu/Mint has been #1 for like 8 years now, which is the recommended platform for Valve's Steam Client.

Um, sure you can, other then the DOS/win95 branch (now defunct) and the NT branch there has really been only one branch of windows. (the differences in minor version is mostly software/service packages/availability - not going to give 32bit and 64bit versions to you :p)
When you say windows you are talking about a Rev number of a single product over time (ie vista, 7, 8) not a totally separate concurrent distributions with different default kernels, software library's, UI's and compatibility's,. (the server versions of windows you may get a point there - but we are not talking about them are we - it is consumer PCs)

And you said #1 can't be #1 in a vacuum . . so, there are more? :) what's #2, #3 #4? They are all Linux and have strong followers also.
Ubuntu is currently the #1 for general use and a good one, but no way it was definitively top for 8 years.
What about Fuduntu? it is a great newish one - lots of laptop support?
Or Arch for speed anti bloat?
Red hat for your home/small business server?
BackTrack for security?
etc . .

each with a different flavor, often UI, etc . . skills on one are not 100% transferable to another. and with people having a Frigging Moo over a simple "start" menu changing what the hell would they say over a entirely different UI? commands? etc
I personally do not have problems with them but we are not talking about powerusers here! we are talking about the average PC person.
And that was my point.
 
Fragmentation and the low end is seriously holding Android back, and unfortunately cheap devices running Gingerbread or older are the vast majority.

Update your misinformation.

http://thenextweb.com/google/2013/0...ce-from-gingerbread-and-its-34-of-play-users/

android_june_2013-730x341.png
 
The Android fragmentation isn't strictly from a software standpoint ... there is a lot of variation in hardware, screen sizes, control schemes, etc ... those may be very user friendly but they do make it harder to code universal apps and debug them ;)

That must be why they've yet to hit one million apps in the market and 50 billion app downloads yet...
 
I have used a lot of apps across many different versions of android and found almost all of them work almost all the time. I don't get the problem. Windows has tons of different hardware. My biggest problem with android has and probably always will be the issue with carriers locking devices and forcing you to root to get rid of their garbage bloatware. With windows it was something you could remove easily enough but with android some carrier junk can cause severe problems. For insance the current software on an Evo 3D forces you to keep sprints own GPS called telenav, and for whatever reason at some update it became impossible to set the default GPS to google nav, yet it is possible and easy to do by accident to set the default gps to telenav. So every time you try to navigate you have to be asked what to use. This is the one area google needs to clamp down on.
 
Nothing is going to replace my PC. No tablet or phone is going to ever be good enough to do my home gaming or show watching. They would be absolutely horrible for my work. Smartphones and Tablets have their place, but these idiots that think they're going to replace PCs are just out of their minds.

MS's sales and the PC sales are down because a lot of people don't like Windows 8. Also, Intel, being the sole provider of PC processors these days, since AMD isn't putting forth anything that actually competes, has been stalling the performance climb of PC processors. There really isn't any reason to buy a new PC if you have a 3 year old Sandy Bridge, or even Nahalem, system. It's really that simple. If MS were to backtrack a bit and get rid of this stupid tablet interface, they'd get a lot of sales back. If Intel were to actually release something that pushes performance forward, they'd have some good sales growth. Right now, PC sales are stagnating because we're really going nowhere. Why is it these so called 'experts' can't see this?

I agree, my friend said he no longer uses his computer since he got his ipad. Now I don't have an ipad but I tried to use my android tablet for a bit and got completely frustrated and immediately went back to my pc. I think I was trying to post something on this forum, or similar. I just can't work nearly as quickly on a tablet as I can on a pc with a nice mouse and keyboard. For example long press on home to change apps is MUCH slower than win-tab or alt tab.

Ok so that's because I have no keyboard on the tablet, sure so if you added one then it would have been ok, except for the fact that I have to zoom in all the time to read, then scroll etc. Ok that could be fixed by making the tablet larger, say 14". Great now I have to carry around a 14" tablet and keyboard. Or get one of those fancy tablet laptops. Yea thats it. Now I just need to network my tablet to my printer and it will be all good. haha.

I dunno, I think it could happen still, but what you would see is docking stations and basically using the tablet like a PC (large screen mouse and keyboard etc). Currently tablets are too slow to due heavy lifting but I don't think they will be in the future.
 
Like it or not, "fragmentation" is Android's biggest curse as well as its biggest blessing. The same fragmentation that allows it to be carpet bombed on every low end piece of hardware is the same one that puts a hard ceiling on application quality. Accounting for the different hardware and OS configurations is much worse than the compatibility issues developers have had to deal with in Windows. Part of it is Microsoft having much better development tools and backwards compatibility than Google.

On top of the resulting increased development and QA costs, Android is also among the least profitable ecosystems out there. The impetus for high quality applications isn't there for Android like it is for iOS, Windows, or OS X, and it partly comes down to fragmentation (easy side-loading, aka piracy, is the other).

What motivation is there when cross-platform developers on average make 4x as much on iOS, and it costs more to account for the various configurations out there. A powerful unified platform with paying customers is much more appealing, which is why the other platform has much better software.

Fragmentation and the low end is seriously holding Android back, and unfortunately cheap devices running Gingerbread or older are the vast majority.

It is not that difficult to make Android applications. What you describe is incompetence, not a problem with Android.

Windows has the same "fragmentation", I would add because it too can be installed on a wide variety of hardware configurations.
 
Um, sure you can, other then the DOS/win95 branch (now defunct) and the NT branch there has really been only one branch of windows. (the differences in minor version is mostly software/service packages/availability - not going to give 32bit and 64bit versions to you :p)
When you say windows you are talking about a Rev number of a single product over time (ie vista, 7, 8) not a totally separate concurrent distributions with different default kernels, software library's, UI's and compatibility's,. (the server versions of windows you may get a point there - but we are not talking about them are we - it is consumer PCs)
[/B]

What the hell are you smoking? The kernel versions in Windows are numerous. Just as they are in Linux. With fundamental changes in the driver model occurring between 95, and Vista. You don't have to "give" me anything as everyone knows there are fundamental differences between the 32bit and 64 bit versions as well. On top of that you've got the 16-bit to 32-bit switch over.
 
MS's sales and the PC sales are down because a lot of people don't like Windows 8.

Winner Winner chicken dinner!

I was considering buying a new laptop till I tried the Win8 Samsung my 'ol lady owns.

What a horrid OS! Prior laptop had Win7pro and it was decent and I'd be happy with it, Win8 just plain sucks even with some aftermarket patch to make it look like Win7 and stuff I stripped out.

Memo to MS- Its a damn computer not a tablet.

Andriod OS? Not on your life. I have a Galaxy media device that likes to fire up the GPS and Wi-Fi all by itself and phone home even after I disabled a bunch of stuff. I trust MS far, far more than I trust Google.
 
What the hell are you smoking? The kernel versions in Windows are numerous. Just as they are in Linux. With fundamental changes in the driver model occurring between 95, and Vista. You don't have to "give" me anything as everyone knows there are fundamental differences between the 32bit and 64 bit versions as well. On top of that you've got the 16-bit to 32-bit switch over.

Again you are missing it. Win95 is 17 YEARS OLD!@#! and can't be part of the conversation since it has been unsupported for over 10 years.
32 bit version of widows now a subset sold for legacy only and will be depreciated as soon as possible so a dead end.

The conversation you are arguing about is about CURRENT consumer OS's, Current sails, Current fragmentation, current adoptions.

Fact, there are ALLOT of Linux Distros. Different kernels, different, UI's, Different organizations! !!!!!! No unified UI, Sales effort, etc . . So fragmented.

Windows is sold by a single company, single sales, similar UI, etc the difference between enterprise, pro and home is price and included software.

With windows you are talking incremental versions over time with Linux you are talking distant concurrent distros.
so why are you arguing? there is nothing to argue about here.
 
Memo to MS- Its a damn computer not a tablet.
I just got back from the big family vacation at the beach, we rented a house and had a lot of folks there with 5 kids from 8 to 14. We had a number of tablets, a couple of 4th gen iPads, 7” Android devices, even a Windows 8 tablet not mine, my sister-in-law liked my Samsung Ativ 500 so much she bought one last month. It was interesting to observe when we were gathered in the family area of the house a few times with everyone using their various devices. Many times an individual would be looking at something on a device and someone else wanted to see it and the device would be handed over to the curious party. A couple of the kids had their own 7” Android devices, and were curious to play with Samsung Ativs. I was asked to load a number of games on the Ativ as the 11.6 screen can be more enjoyable than a 7” device. It still amazes me how the kids instantly picked up Windows 8 on a tablet with just a little guidance.

It’s often said that those that like Windows 8 don’t consider the viewpoints of others. In my case I actually have seen various people of various skills and ages interact with Windows 8 on hybrid tablet and truly believe that even with all of the bad PR and other issues facing Windows 8, Microsoft HAD to do what they did otherwise there surly were going to lose the next generation of computer users. I’m not saying that Windows 8 by any stretch insures that Microsoft will have many of the next generation of casual computer users with its hybrid approach, but without this approach it would be a certainty that Windows would lose average users. I think a lot of the issue with Windows 8 has to do with preconceptions and familiarity. Kids don't think about Start Menus or free floating windows, etc. In some ways I think that Windows 8 would be more accepted if 8 were the first version of Windows to ever be released.

In time the distinction between tablets and conventional PCs will fade. Tablets like all other technologies will evolve and grow and become more powerful and capable than they are today, doing ever more that people have traditionally to do with conventional PCs.
 
I just got back from the big family vacation at the beach, we rented a house and had a lot of folks there with 5 kids from 8 to 14. We had a number of tablets, a couple of 4th gen iPads, 7” Android devices, even a Windows 8 tablet not mine, my sister-in-law liked my Samsung Ativ 500 so much she bought one last month. It was interesting to observe when we were gathered in the family area of the house a few times with everyone using their various devices. Many times an individual would be looking at something on a device and someone else wanted to see it and the device would be handed over to the curious party. A couple of the kids had their own 7” Android devices, and were curious to play with Samsung Ativs. I was asked to load a number of games on the Ativ as the 11.6 screen can be more enjoyable than a 7” device. It still amazes me how the kids instantly picked up Windows 8 on a tablet with just a little guidance.

It’s often said that those that like Windows 8 don’t consider the viewpoints of others. In my case I actually have seen various people of various skills and ages interact with Windows 8 on hybrid tablet and truly believe that even with all of the bad PR and other issues facing Windows 8, Microsoft HAD to do what they did otherwise there surly were going to lose the next generation of computer users. I’m not saying that Windows 8 by any stretch insures that Microsoft will have many of the next generation of casual computer users with its hybrid approach, but without this approach it would be a certainty that Windows would lose average users. I think a lot of the issue with Windows 8 has to do with preconceptions and familiarity. Kids don't think about Start Menus or free floating windows, etc. In some ways I think that Windows 8 would be more accepted if 8 were the first version of Windows to ever be released.

In time the distinction between tablets and conventional PCs will fade. Tablets like all other technologies will evolve and grow and become more powerful and capable than they are today, doing ever more that people have traditionally to do with conventional PCs.

I don't think anybody is arguing against Win8 on a tablet. It's putting a tablet/phone interface on a desktop that is the problem.

Those mobile interfaces are a compromise to accommodate small screens. It's crippling to a desktop.
 
Many people seem to boil down the problem of Windows 8 to that of not having the Start button.

I'm curious, what exactly do people use the Start button for that makes it to be missed so much that Windows 8 is ruined for them.

I'm using Windows 8 now on my laptop and my main gaming desktop, and sometimes I would look for it due to force of habit to start some function or program that used to be in the start menu during the XP to Windows 7 days, but then I remember that I have it either as a shortcut or pinned to the taskbar. Other than that I can't really say I miss it, or that Windows 8 is ruined because it's missing.
 
I don't think anybody is arguing against Win8 on a tablet. It's putting a tablet/phone interface on a desktop that is the problem.

Those mobile interfaces are a compromise to accommodate small screens. It's crippling to a desktop.

The appropriateness of the Modern UI on desktops is obviously a highly debated subject. 8 obviously had some weaknesses in this area that I think 8.1 addresses rather thoroughly though of course more could be done. It's hard for me to say that the desktop is crippled especially with 8.1 simply because I've used 8/8.1 for so long with keyboards and mice with desktop apps just like I have prior versions of Windows.

I think the big issue for many a tablet is a tablet and a desktop is desktop folks is the lack of on an in the box Start Menu. In a number ways even on a desktop the Start Screen/App Screen in 8.1 is superior to the Start Menu. Unlimited short cuts and the ability to sort and categorize apps a number of ways is great even on a desktop. The major things not really there are hierarchal folders and its always full screen. Indeed if there were a an option to set the Start Screen to a 1/3 or 1/4 of the screen I think that would finally solve the bulk of the complaints. I was kind of hopping that that option would be there in 8.1, it has been mentioned a lot as an improvement to the Start Screen.
 
The conversation you are arguing about is about CURRENT consumer OS's, Current sails, Current fragmentation, current adoptions.

Fact, there are ALLOT of Linux Distros. Different kernels, different, UI's, Different organizations! !!!!!! No unified UI, Sales effort, etc . . So fragmented.
QUOTE]

Um the Linux kernel is published by the same guy. There is only one vessel for a kernel release. Now people can patch it if they want. But no distro of any popularity will do that without providing a pull request to the kernel anyway. Even Google will be switching to the same kernel that the desktop users use today (supposedly happening with Android 5.0). If anything there is far less fragmentation when it comes to just the Linux kernel.

Yelling "fragmentation" isn't a get out of jail free card. You actually have to provide examples that make sense.
 

And that massive lowest common denominator is holding the platform back. The point still stands. A third of devices running Gingerbread or lower is huge.

On top of fragmentation you still have lower profits. Even big developers like Blizzard and 2K that can afford bigger dev teams are avoiding Android, and EA recently announced that their biggest individual revenue stream comes from the iOS app store.

Even Google makes more money off of mobile advertising from iOS.

Android is a money sink in cross-platform development costs when QA costs much more than developing for a unified platform, it has fewer users running capable hardware, and cross-platform developers on average make 1/4 of what they make on iOS.

There are many reasons why software on iOS is so much better than it is on Android, but in the end it all boils down to money. There is a lot to consider when even Google is making more money off of iOS.
 
When do Android and iOS devices become fully managed by Active Directory or some other centralized administrative control mechanism? Until centralized management happens on some other competing platform, Blackberries with BES (*barf*) and Windows operating systems aren't going to disappear completely. Of course, there's not very much Windows 8 in enterprise networks at the moment and there are some attempts to manage iOS and Androids coming along.
 
The conversation you are arguing about is about CURRENT consumer OS's, Current sails, Current fragmentation, current adoptions.

Fact, there are ALLOT of Linux Distros. Different kernels, different, UI's, Different organizations! !!!!!! No unified UI, Sales effort, etc . . So fragmented.
QUOTE]

Um the Linux kernel is published by the same guy. There is only one vessel for a kernel release. Now people can patch it if they want. But no distro of any popularity will do that without providing a pull request to the kernel anyway. Even Google will be switching to the same kernel that the desktop users use today (supposedly happening with Android 5.0). If anything there is far less fragmentation when it comes to just the Linux kernel.

Yelling "fragmentation" isn't a get out of jail free card. You actually have to provide examples that make sense.

But, I did not say it was a "get out of jail free card" I said it was a factor that is inhibiting adoption. A normal user does not SEE Linux as a unified front as they do with OSX or windows (even as we all know it is NOT as simple as that)
Cherry-picking this or that does not change the result.
I am not Dissing Linux at all, I used just about every OS. But, you can't say get/use Linux to most people as easy as Windows and OSX. This effects the masses not power users. Also the "problems" with windows 8 does not effect powerusers either only the "normal" user as they can't separate a minor UI change or tweak from the underlying OS.
 
Already happening. Mum replaced her computer with a smartphone today. A computer that she hasn't touched more than 3 or 4 times in the past year. It was cheaper for her to upgrade to a smartphone and use the data connection on that for internet than it was to keep an internet connection at home for one computer.

Maybe not an enterprise example, but certainly a good example of the erosion that is happening on the home front. Business use isn't terribly far behind. I'm seeing more tablets with docking stations being used in doctors offices and other corporate IT type environments.

Neither of those are really corporate IT. If you want to say that there are some uses for Tablets in a Doctors office, sure. But one, they're not doing everything on a tablet and they're more of a small business and you can bet that their billing and insurance work is all done on PCs, not tablets.

As for Coporate IT environments, I don't see many using tablets. Marketing loves using ultra portables and thus they'll probably love an iPad with a keyboard, but IT people? We ALL want a desktop or laptop (preferably both). Tablets and phones are great for short emails, simple tasks, and games. In a pinch, I can use my phone or a tablet to log into a server or even onto a PC, but in both cases, it's completely and utterly painful.

Personally, the only time I want a laptop is in a meeting and maybe when traveling (though if I'm on vacation, a phone and/or tablet are fine).

Sorry, but PC's aren't going anywhere in the workplace. If you can do your job on a tablet, then you don't do anything on your computer.

Now if you're a photographer, I can see where a full size iPad could be handy. Super High Res and with the right camera hardware a very large view screen. Probably not bad for some simple editing. But none of htem are dumping their PC either.
 
Back
Top