The Official DOOM 3 [H]ardware Guide thread.

Well I just picked up my copy at EB in Fairfax VA and they said mine was the first copy they sold all day. Too bad I am stuck here at work, its staring at me from across my desk. But to the point, I am hoping to get 1024x768 at high detail, does that seem possible with the system below? If not would another 512MB of ram do the trick or am I stuck with at full CPU/mobo/ram upgrade? Thanks
 
Hi I was wondering if you guys think that Doom 3 will even run on my system. My computer is a Pentium 4 2.6 GHz processor with Hyper Threading, 512 Mb DDR ram, and 80gb hd. The only thing I am not sure about is the on board graphics. I have the Intel Extreme Graphics 2 on my computer. They play Halo but not with every thing on. Will this be enough to run Doom 3 on minimum performance?
 
No, "Intel Extreme Graphics 2" should never be considered "Extreme" nor "Graphics". Get a real card
 
Scar1.8T said:
Well I just picked up my copy at EB in Fairfax VA and they said mine was the first copy they sold all day. Too bad I am stuck here at work, its staring at me from across my desk. But to the point, I am hoping to get 1024x768 at high detail, does that seem possible with the system below? If not would another 512MB of ram do the trick or am I stuck with at full CPU/mobo/ram upgrade? Thanks

Heh...I'm going to be going through this as well....I'm taking my lunch break to go pick up the game...and then stare at it for 4 hours
 
CrimandEvil said:
No, "Intel Extreme Graphics 2" should never be considered "Extreme" nor "Graphics". Get a real card

So what your saying is that Doom 3 will not be able to run at all?
 
stunna_75 said:
So what your saying is that Doom 3 will not be able to run at all?


I agree. "IF" it's even able to run at all we are talking slideshow. Onboard graphics are NEVER good..the onboard GF4MX "currently" being the best on the Nforce boards.

You can find a cheap card for well under $100 that will run circles around your onboard graphics...

..assuming of course you even have and APG slot on your motherboard..:(

Best of luck,
Kevin
 
What resolution and quality can you play (smoothly) on these systems?

P4 2GHz, 512mb ram, and

1) GF4 Ti4200
2) ATI Radeon 9800Pro

(I'm just checking if the upgrade to 9800 is worth it. unfortunately, a cpu upgrade is not an option at this time.)
 
My humble opinion about the game,

After playing nearly 2 hours I can say that the obvious comparison is Far Cry...I think I can separate 2 aspects,

1.- Technically speaking...

The game is superb...Graphically , impressive... As an engineering I must say this is a master piece of optimal work..I have a P4 3.2, 1 gb ram , ati radeon 9800pro 128 mb and it runs good at high quality 1024x760..around 40 fps averge with 60 fps in normal corridors and about 30-40 during heavy firefights..An important note ..I had to use the latest official catalysts, because otherwise the game freezed heavy my system..But I have read people running it with low end system and said its amazing..I test medium quality, and really it is superb..also I tested 800x600 res and again great visuals...Far Cry wasnt that optimizied...If you had fps troubles, decreasing quality resulted in worst effects, less vegetation and overall a "lack sensation", compared with high detail..this doesnt happen with Doom 3...Good job Id...good engineering job...

2.- Gameplay...

after 2 hours playing..I have the slight sensation it will bore me..I noticed always the same corridors...the same zombies ( maybe it is because I hate zombies games )...after 1 hour playing Far Cry I was really eager to continue playing...I know ...Far Cry doesnt have the sensation of real living world so good achieved by Doom 3..but really D3 seems hollow an bore...I hope this changes further on...I will absolutely win the game but it isnt what I was expecting...I read Pc Gamer review and thats maybe the problem...they "so blessed" the game that I thought it was superb...I think Pc Gamer wasnt objetive..D3 repeats the Alien Versus Predator 2 formula..with
highly visual tech...
If I had to choose I give Far Cry the 1st place..Its green paradise graphics is complemmented with a good story and gameplay
Nevertheless, D3 deserves being played but like another common shooter...

Now seeing the performance of the game my "terrible" doubt about AMD Xp 3200 with 9800pro 128 mb versus P4 3.0 with 9800pro, the first one recommended High quality in the guide and the second one medium quality, I can say, as I mention before, that with my P4 3.2 ( which is about 10% faster than 3.0 ) I run the game without great troubles in 1024x760 High Quality...In normal running I get almost constant 60 fps..In rooms with lot of visuals it decreases to 45...and in heavy firefights I get nearly 40 ( 35-40 ) fps...Only one time I got 29 fps..after some explosions..really very playable...but even if you play in 800x600 res with High quality, performance really boost and I hardly can see any difference from 1024x760..Nevertheless I will stay with 1024x760...
Thats my humble opinion...I will play it but only after I win Thief
3, which greatly has caught my attention...thanks...
 
stunna_75 said:
So what your saying is that Doom 3 will not be able to run at all?

It's a souped up i740, the first AGP 2x card made. It's a joke.
 
umbramos said:
What resolution and quality can you play (smoothly) on these systems?

P4 2GHz, 512mb ram, and

1) GF4 Ti4200
2) ATI Radeon 9800Pro

(I'm just checking if the upgrade to 9800 is worth it. unfortunately, a cpu upgrade is not an option at this time.)

Well the 9800 pro upgrade would definitely worth it..if you've got the cash for it lieing around. A CPU upgrade would garner you very little in the way of performance, as the HardOCP tests show..the game is MUCH more Video Card dependent than it is CPU dependent.

As far as what you could play at...more than likely you could manage 1024x768 at Medium Quality..you "might" be able to squeeze high Quality at 1024x768..depends on how you want your frame rates to be...

Higher frames and slightly lower quality or lower frames slightly higher quality? the choice is yours of course.. :p

I hope this helped..

legionosh@msn.com

Kevin

P.S. as much as a I like to try to help others, it seems there were SEVERAL people who apparently didn't bother to even read the hardware guide. :confused:

So the Hard|OCP guys spend 60hours over three days doing this guide and these people can't spend 30 minutes (MAYBE an hour, if you're a slow reader or want to take your time studying the graphs and whatnot) reading the guide. :mad:
 
Legionosh said:
Hey now, I used to own one of the i740 cards when they were new..it was "ok" back in the day..well maybe on a good day..lol.. :p

legionosh@msn.com

kevin

So did I. :)

Oh, and you don't want to post your email everywhere. Webspider will grab it, spam ++!

Post it as:

legionosh AT msn.com or something like that :)
 
hi, jus want to kno whether 512MB of ram is enough. I have a p4 2.4c @ 3.4ghz, 512mb corsair xms pc3500, abit is7, and a 6800U. jus wanna kno if i should upgrade to 1gb or is 512mb enough. (money is kind of an issue)
Ty
 
br1zz0 said:
hi, jus want to kno whether 512MB of ram is enough. I have a p4 2.4c @ 3.4ghz, 512mb corsair xms pc3500, abit is7, and a 6800U. jus wanna kno if i should upgrade to 1gb or is 512mb enough. (money is kind of an issue)
Ty

The game requires 384, so considering the rest of your rig, you're probably ok. If I were you, I'd upgrade, but I don't think you're going to NEED it. If you had some lesser vidcard, I'd say you might. Now if you're crazy enough to try running Ultra Quality (which theoretically you could do, if your card was 256MB) you'd certainly need 1-2GB of system ram besides your vid card.
 
I must say I am impressed with this game only having a Northwood 2.0 @ 2.4, i845, Ti4600, and 512MB-2100DDR. Slow when first loading but otherwise everything looks awesome even at 800x600 medium settings. The lighitng in the game (or lack of....hahaha) is rediculous! I cant wait till I upgrade next year and load this bad boy up with ultra settings :D My roomate's 9600 and 2.4C and 512-3200DDR play it just as well though he needed to update his catalyst drivers because of crashes between levels.
 
After reading this article, I was surprised that the Athlon 64 3000 + KT800 combo was selected for the enthousiast system, since its performance is lower (1280 vs 1600) then the equally priced P4 3000 (512K) + i875 combo that was also tested, and only about matched it (1600 vs 1600) when the Athlon 64 3000 was overclocked. Since the P4 3000 (512K) can also manage about 20% more clockspeed, that might even have allowed 1600 with 2x AA on the overclocked 6800 card.

Altrough Newegg may not be amused, could you consider adding a P4 512K + i875 to the overclocking section?

I think a 2.8 @ 3.5 Ghz or a 3.0 @ 3.6 Ghz would offer the best price performance ratio, when matched with an overclocked 6800 card.
 
T8000 said:
After reading this article, I was surprised that the Athlon 64 3000 + KT800 combo was selected for the enthousiast system, since its performance is lower (1280 vs 1600) then the equally priced P4 3000 (512K) + i875 combo that was also tested, and only about matched it (1600 vs 1600) when the Athlon 64 3000 was overclocked. Since the P4 3000 (512K) can also manage about 20% more clockspeed, that might even have allowed 1600 with 2x AA on the overclocked 6800 card.

Altrough Newegg may not be amused, could you consider adding a P4 512K + i875 to the overclocking section?

I think a 2.8 @ 3.5 Ghz or a 3.0 @ 3.6 Ghz would offer the best price performance ratio, when matched with an overclocked 6800 card.

Well....hmm it could have something to do with it being a 64 bit system. Dispite the fact that you're getting slightly lower clock speed, you're pushing a lot more raw power out there than a P4 can really push. I won't say much more about it except that I just don't think P4s handle overclocking as well as A64s do, also A64s are generally cheaper, especially considering you're looking at 2 times the cache (I don't know if the 3000+ has 512 or 1024, but my 3200+ has 1024). It's not all about clockspeed though.
 
I've ran Doom 3 for about...30 minutes with my rig Athlon 64 3200+ 1024KB cache, 1.5GB Kingston DDR 400, and a Radeon 9000 Pro 128MB card. Game set me up at 800x600 medium, which is where I've left it I learned 5 things very quickly:

1)It's friggin dark down there.

2)My aim friggin sucks

3)Zombies hurt when they hit you

4)If you take assloads of damage you start getting blood soaked tunnel vision, which is basically instant death mode.

5)I really wish I could attach the damn flashlight to my gun

Seriously though, I'm officially impressed, Id has outdone themselves, and it even runs well with this 3-4 generation old piece of crap. Now I'm going out to get a Radeon 9800 Pro 256MB.
 
Good Day,

Has anyone tested the new Beta 4.9 catalysts from ATI...which is said to enhance Doom 3...It is true...can someone quantify the improvement??..Thanks
 
Hounder said:
Well....hmm it could have something to do with it being a 64 bit system. Dispite the fact that you're getting slightly lower clock speed, you're pushing a lot more raw power out there than a P4 can really push. I won't say much more about it except that I just don't think P4s handle overclocking as well as A64s do, also A64s are generally cheaper, especially considering you're looking at 2 times the cache (I don't know if the 3000+ has 512 or 1024, but my 3200+ has 1024). It's not all about clockspeed though.

P4's can't overclock well? Take a good look at the sigs on this board, you will find plenty of people OCing (but more likely with the 2.4C or 2.8C than the 3.0).

I believe they used a newcastle (512K L2), and these OC a ton better than the (1M) Clawhammers.

In terms of pricing, the 3000+ goes for $170ish while the 3.0C is $223. About a $60 difference.
 
Scar1.8T said:
Well I just picked up my copy at EB in Fairfax VA and they said mine was the first copy they sold all day. Too bad I am stuck here at work, its staring at me from across my desk. But to the point, I am hoping to get 1024x768 at high detail, does that seem possible with the system below? If not would another 512MB of ram do the trick or am I stuck with at full CPU/mobo/ram upgrade? Thanks


I'm running with specs below except I had to downclock my 9800xt to 475/380 to eliminate artifacting. This biatch is hard on the vid card. I can run anything else 515/415 all day. Mine runs 1024x768 HQ pretty well. We have similiar specs.
 
Is Doom 3 actually good? I heard that its fun at first while you're amazed at the graphics, but then you are hit with the fact that its a polished doom 1 complete with the find the "find the red key, run to the other side of the map and open the red door, kill the monsters, grab the blue key, run all the way back to the other side and open the blue door" gameplay.
 
Koz said:
Is Doom 3 actually good? I heard that its fun at first while you're amazed at the graphics, but then you are hit with the fact that its a polished doom 1 complete with the find the "find the red key, run to the other side of the map and open the red door, kill the monsters, grab the blue key, run all the way back to the other side and open the blue door" gameplay.

ummm.... it makes you a bit more jumpy then I ever remember Doom1 making you feel. Definitely keeps your heart moving.
 
Would I be able to play D3 with at least 1024x768 at HQ (I could probly live with Medium at the least). My specs are in the sig. What would be a better upgrade, another 512mb(333) stick of ram or upgrading my card to a 5900xt. I wanna stick with nVidia since I am familiar with their drivers. TIA!
 
all and all the game isn't my favorite, but the plot is ok, and it'll probably be the first game since q3 to make me upgrade my system for graphics alone. The action feels similar to halo, shoot everything in sight, watch a sequence, complete obj. A etc. The basic theme of bad guys seems similar to half life. It's got a lot of suspense, but the plot doesn't seem to run all that thick. IMO the solo play is nothing to trump as the best game ever.
 
Yea the angry red pixels of the original doom hardly strike fear into people. I have heard its very dramatic and scary and I can obviously see the graphics are impressive but I'm wondering about the gameplay... How are levels styled, objectives? Free-form kind of like half-life or what.
 
Well, I must say that I am rather satisfied so for. I am running the game at 1024x768 with high detail on the CAT 4.9b drivers and it is very playable with my sys clocked back down at 2.4ghz. At 2.6 the game would crash after about 30 minutes but it is solid at 2.4. Never had that problem with any other games before but this isnt exactly an average game. I have noticed some tearing but that is appearantly due to vsync being off, I just cant get the console to come down to turn it on. Also, some of the screenshots I am seeing have the FPS in the top right corner. Is that the same command as Q3, set cg_drawfps 1? If not then how because though the game is quite playable I would like to see what FPS I am getting. Thanks
 
Scar1.8T said:
Well, I must say that I am rather satisfied so for. I am running the game at 1024x768 with high detail on the CAT 4.9b drivers and it is very playable with my sys clocked back down at 2.4ghz. At 2.6 the game would crash after about 30 minutes but it is solid at 2.4.

If I had to guess at what was causing this I would have to say it's prolly what John Carmack stated in his ststement about hardware.Kinda sucks to cuz we all wanna get what we can from our machines and use it.



John Carmack said:
A note on overclocking: it is very likely that overclocked configurations that "play everything else perfectly" will start to show problems on D3 due to new usage patterns. Everyone is of course free to do whatever they want with their own hardware, but don't complain to us...
That Quote came from Here
 
Well, maybe you guys could help me out, I have

P4 3.2 Ghz
Abit IC7-Max3
Geforce 5950
1 GB Ram

I run on High quality with no Antialiasing on, 1024 x 768, I am only averaging 20-30 FPS, is that right? Its still playable by all means, Just seemd like it should be a little higher, more like 30-40FPS

all drivers are updated, and nothing is running in the background

what is going on?
 
Bluntablo said:
Well, maybe you guys could help me out, I have

P4 3.2 Ghz
Abit IC7-Max3
Geforce 5950
1 GB Ram

I run on High quality with no Antialiasing on, 1024 x 768, I am only averaging 20-30 FPS, is that right? Its still playable by all means, Just seemd like it should be a little higher, more like 30-40FPS

all drivers are updated, and nothing is running in the background

what is going on?

Hmm....

Well if I had to guess I would say maybe you have Vsync on?

What drivers are you using?

My 5900SE/XT @ 450/800 get's 43 FPS (w/vsync off) in the benchmark demo1.demo..course I am running an A64 3200+ @2150 Mhz..slightly Oc'd..but the processor has shown not to have as much bearing as you think it should.

EDIT : forgot to add I am also running at 1024x768 @ HQ...also forget about the newest drivers part..I can't read...lol.. :p

I'd say make sure vsync is OFF and maybe install the newest drivers?

best of luck,
kevin
 
Since all Vsync does is control the frame output of the card to match the vertical refresh rate of your monitor, having Vsync on is not going to cause his FPS to be 20-30. Unless he uses a 30Hz refresh rate... LOL

I dont see why people turn VSync off for normal playing. Your refresh rate is how fast your monitor is displaying images. ie: your REAL FPS. If you have a refresh of 85Hz you arent 'seeing' 100FPS no matter what your video card is doing or what your framerate display says. Turning it off allows the card to spit out frames as fast as it can, but your monitor is still only showing you 85 per second. Thats why Vsync is only good for benchmarks, and also why it can cause problems such as tearing.
 
souped said:
has anyone tried running the game on a gf4mx 64mb?..if so how did it run

I play Doom 3 on a laptop with a Geforce 4 440Go (basically a Geforce 4 440MX w/ 64 MB's). It plays on 640x480 with medium details (haven't tried 800x600 with low).
 
-freon- said:
Since all Vsync does is control the frame output of the card to match the vertical refresh rate of your monitor, having Vsync on is not going to cause his FPS to be 20-30. Unless he uses a 30Hz refresh rate... LOL

I dont see why people turn VSync off for normal playing. Your refresh rate is how fast your monitor is displaying images. ie: your REAL FPS. If you have a refresh of 85Hz you arent 'seeing' 100FPS no matter what your video card is doing or what your framerate display says. Turning it off allows the card to spit out frames as fast as it can, but your monitor is still only showing you 85 per second. Thats why Vsync is only good for benchmarks, and also why it can cause problems such as tearing.

Actually my friend noticed a pretty big jump with Vsync in the timedemo..

On : 30's
Off : 50's

That's a pretty big jump so YES having it on can affect framerate.

In regards to it not really mattering whether it's off seeing as how "your monitor can't display it anyway", here's what I have heard/know about the subject :

If your card is capable of 120 FPS, and your referesh rate is at (for example) 85 your card is more or less having to disregard usable frames with Vsync on..since it drops frames that aren't in the "refresh rate" zone so to speak.

In other words, limiting your 120 FPS to 85 FPS (tied to the refresh rate) drops the other 35 frames..in vairous places, and more than likely when you need them most.

Now when your're able to run a constant 85 FPS you should be ok anyway, but in a game where 60 is the cap, and most people will be running well below that on the average, those dropped frames will indeed matter when you need them the most.

Take my friends rig for example. 1280x1024 HQ : 55ish FPS with Vsync off. 35ish FPS with it on. That's a VERY large percent of usable frame rates that are essentially being lost to vsync.

In my own case : 1024x768 HQ : 43 FPS with vsync off. I would hate to see my dismal FPS with it on.

My explanation may be a little vague as I am not an expert on the subject, but that's more or less the way I understand it.

Of course I could be wrong and will admit so if anyone can post a better explanation that proves mine to be utter nonense... :p

I hope this helped somewhat (well either that or made me look like a complete idiot)..lol


Kevin
 
DeepGrey said:
Would I be able to play D3 with at least 1024x768 at HQ (I could probly live with Medium at the least). My specs are in the sig. What would be a better upgrade, another 512mb(333) stick of ram or upgrading my card to a 5900xt. I wanna stick with nVidia since I am familiar with their drivers. TIA!

I tried D3 last night on the following:

P4 3.0GHz Prescott
MSI 865PE Neo2-PLS
512MB RAM
Leadtek 350 TDH (5900xt) 128MB

I tried this at 1024x768@HQ (default settings.. didn't mess with advance settings yet) and it had a lot of trouble. I haven't overclocked anything yet and I didn't measure FPS, but it was very choppy. Graphics were great, but there were quite a few times when everything froze for a second or 2. Will try 1024x768@MQ and see what happens.

EDIT: Don't know what happened last night, but tonight I'm playing 1280x1024@HQ and no problems. Slight jitter once in a great while, but otherwise very smooth. Only change I made was to enable Vsync (had to 'cuz my Sun monitor didn't like it without it and even then it wouldn't work unless it was 1280x1024).

The heat haze is pretty damn cool.
 
hey

im wondering if i should definatly buy doom 3 if my specs are these:

1.6ghz P4
512 mb ram
Msi MX 4000 t-128 (128 mb ddr)
 
9800 pro not overclocked, 2400mhz amd xp, 512mb ram high settings 1024x768...plays great
 
After reading the [H]ardware Guide and now getting to play the game for a few hours, I have to disagree with a few of the statements made by Kyle and crew:

"What we noticed immediately is that DOOM 3 looks incredible even at 640x480!"
The article mentions several times how the game looks better at lower resolutions than other games. I completely disagree. I think it looked just as blocky, and "lo-res" as any other game. My system is an AthlonXP 2100+ with Geforce4 Ti4600 video card, so I tried the game at the recommended res of 800x600, medium quality, but I couldn't stand it. I switched to 1024 med quality and the visuals were soooo much better. I guess I am able to tolerate the lower frame rates more than some, because it doesn't bother me that much. The blocky look at 800x600 bothered me much more.

"Otherwise, all of the lines in DOOM 3 really aren’t noticeably aliased due to the darkness and shadows of the game"
I think the aliasing is visible, right where you would expect it. Yes, the game is very dark, and this helps to some degree, but I was still noticing the lack of AA all over the place. Of course I don't want to turn it on due to the performance hit, but I think it is definitely noticable, just as much as it would be in any other game.

And I also have to disagree with all the reviews on the web that give this game, for example, 98%, or "best game ever" tags. Everybody is way too swept up in the hype of this game. Yes, it's a good game, maybe even a great game. And the visuals are awesome, probably a 1/2 step above anything else out there right now. But I just don't think the overall single-player "fun factor" of the game is that much better than, say, Far Cry, or Call of Duty, or even an old game like Ghost Recon. (I actually liked COD better because of the storytelling aspect and mission-based gameplay.)

Doom 3 is nice, but long-term, I think other games will be getting my playtime. This is basically the same old, mow down the enemies, pick up the cool weapons, scare me with a few monsters jumping out, kind of game. It does look really cool though.
 
Hounder said:
Well....hmm it could have something to do with it being a 64 bit system. Dispite the fact that you're getting slightly lower clock speed, you're pushing a lot more raw power out there than a P4 can really push. I won't say much more about it except that I just don't think P4s handle overclocking as well as A64s do, also A64s are generally cheaper, especially considering you're looking at 2 times the cache (I don't know if the 3000+ has 512 or 1024, but my 3200+ has 1024). It's not all about clockspeed though.

When you mention 64 bit, note that it is not supported on any mayor gaming OS and that is not likely to change before current CPU's are outdated anyway.

Besides, that raw power you mention does not seem to help in this article, as the 3000+ lags below a real 3 Ghz CPU. Its cache does not seem to help either.

For overclocking, most Northwoods, including mine, seem to be capable of at least 25% overclocks, more then any Athlon 64 I know off. Since the memory and the FSB raise with the clockspeed, the P4 also scales better, performance-wise.

When you compare prices, you usually compare CPU + MB bundles, and since i875 and i865 are around longer then KT800, you can buy better boards for less money. Since both bundles are about $300, I think you only need to look at the performance figures, where a stock P4 seems to match an overclocked A64 setup.
 
Back
Top