The Media Center Extender Shootout

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you plan on using a Vista Media Center Extender in your home for movies, music and photos, the crew at Engadget HD have a shootout posted today comparing three different models (including the Xbox 360).

Vista Media Center really sets itself apart from any other DVR solution out there, and the single greatest advantage Vista Media Center (VMC) has over the other options -- like the TiVo HD -- is the ability to have multiple Media Center Extenders. There really isn't any other option out there that will allow you to watch premium HD cable in every room of your house while at the same time centralizing all your media in one place.
 
The problem with the Xbox is it doesn't play Divx/Xvid. My last few experiences with linksys have not been good (routers), but maybe I'll give them a shot again on something different. By the time I buy one though I'm sure something better will be available.
 
I signed up to the forums specifically to post this response. MythBox, is a linux based PVR that has all the features of its competitors and more and is totally free.
People should look first before making any decision about a PVR.
 
yea unless VMC's can extend your DVD library, i wouldn't call any of them "centralizing" your media..
 
I signed up to the forums specifically to post this response. MythBox, is a linux based PVR that has all the features of its competitors and more and is totally free.
People should look first before making any decision about a PVR.

I like the idea of a MythBox except that I don't want a PC in my living room, even if the case does look nice. They are big and even quiet fans can be somewhat noisy to me.

I like the idea of putting an xbox or a ps3 in my living rooms since I play games, but also using it to play media streamed from the network.

A PS3 with a linux distro seems like a nice possibility. It would play games, blue ray, and streamed media. It wouldn't be able to capture like a tivo system though. Hmmm
 
yea unless VMC's can extend your DVD library, i wouldn't call any of them "centralizing" your media..

My DVD library is mostly on hard drive storage now. HD will present a problem though once I switch up to that. $3k-$4k for a 10TB system.
 
I like the idea of a MythBox except that I don't want a PC in my living room, even if the case does look nice. They are big and even quiet fans can be somewhat noisy to me.

I like the idea of putting an xbox or a ps3 in my living rooms since I play games, but also using it to play media streamed from the network.

A PS3 with a linux distro seems like a nice possibility. It would play games, blue ray, and streamed media. It wouldn't be able to capture like a tivo system though. Hmmm

So you wouldn't even buy one from Moneual or build a thin one that is passive cooled? They make cases that are designed to look like the TiVo.
 
Hadn't seen the Moneual HTPC, it seems really nice. Just wish they could capture digital cable or sat tv in HD. ATI has their digital cable tuner, but you have to buy it with a PC. Who wants to do that? I'd much rather build my own.

An HTPC makes sense for me simply because it's a PC and allows me to spend time configuring it :)

I need a 10,000 media budget first though to do what I really want.
 
there are ways to get the DVD library to work on an extender. people over at "the green button" have it working, there are more than one way as well.


I love but i have a HTPC @ my TV so no need for an extender. I wish the extender would also do live TV, but then again, you can just use the TV for live TV, since the extender will allow you to setup and view recordings.


If i had more than a 1 bedroom apartment i might buy an extender :) if i did it would be the xbox360 or HP mediasmart LCD TV
 
fuck extenders. they use to be cool when pc's all cost at least $600, but nowadays you can build a small cheap system for $350... and it will always be more useful then an extender device....
 
Extenders... Waste of money. The only issue with HTPCs is that we lack proper video/sound cards to output 7.1 LPCM and TrueHD / DTS-HD MA streams over HDMI.

With that said, the PS3 kills the Xbox 360 as a media center (I know, it's not an extender; and no, I don't own either). The only problems the PS3 has as a media center is that it lacks MKV playback (like the Xbox 360) and user-encoded x264 content must meet certain specifications, and the other issue is with PS3 Linux: the hardware is VERY poorly documented, so writing drivers for them is not going to happen for a very long time. As such, out is the idea of using your PS3 as a Linux media center.
 
Back
Top