The Key to Science Is Being Wrong

Hehe, now go look up the actual science behind the actions of the transistor.

Yes, it was discovered by accident, but it was understood through <SCIENCE>

And that science is the Quantum Tunneling effect, which is exactly the same effect that governs Radioactive Decay.


I was studying electronic theory when you were still pissing your pants.
I know the theory and I have made a 30 year career of it.
The team lead by Shockley was NOT concerned with radioactive decay.
They were trying to unlock the secrets of the semiconductor crystal. This is how scientific discovery really happens. You study an effect and seek to find the cause. Once you know they cause you can manipulate the effect for your own purpose.
 
You just want to see Fail and Skribbel go at it. :D Once payment thing is fixed, I'd pitch in for a membership for GenMay for this guy. Not sure how long that will be as they've already said it isn't a priority.
LMAO.
We don't need another political troll in there. But I can definitely see Skribbel's join forces with Deathprincess and shaking things up a bit. I will gladly pay for a year for him too. If he brings the funny, it will be worth it.
 
<3

You need to join General Mayhem on this forum as soon as they fix the payment issue.


You just want to see Fail and Skribbel go at it. :D Once payment thing is fixed, I'd pitch in for a membership for GenMay for this guy. Not sure how long that will be as they've already said it isn't a priority.

I dunno...it sounds sort of scary over there.
 
Yes, the eminent scientist Neil DeGrasse Tyson labels himself as an agnostic.

Actually he thinks of himself as neither (re-watch the video). He stated since there's no word for his own brilliance for the common folk to attach him to, think of him as agnostic (my words, not his). His exact words are....
"If* I had to find a word that came closest, it would be agnostic."----- "At the end of the day, I'd rather not be any category at all".
I say it like that because I like to keep facts neat & tidy. I guess my point from earlier was that most intelligent people (IMO) understand they don't know shit and until they know shit, don't pretend to know shit (read: religion)! However they're forever seeking the unknowns = Science!

A (meaning without) gnostic (meaning knowledge)
Origin of AGNOSTIC - Greek agn&#333;stos unknown, unknowable, from a- + gn&#333;stos known.

I believe the word "unknowable" is the key point here and not "without knowledge". You see, from the knowledge that we currently have, (intent to create/designer/a creator/etc) it's currently unknowable.


But really what he means is he found no compelling evidence that would lead him to being a theist.
No, what he really really means is there is none, not that he didn't find it, but there is none, nothing, at all! Anyone claiming it's there is full of shit and not based within reality. He's just being nice about it.

And yet how inconsistent the man is in his thinking.
This is Neil on Sir Issac Newton:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=danYFxGnFxQ
LOL...you're stretching your thought process awfully thin with that conclusion. It could be he respects Newton so much because the guy was figuring out crazy things in the 1600's. You see, he could just respect him on his profession and not his personal beliefs. You see, it's like the idea of separation of church and state today.

Basically Neil goes on and on about the towering intellect of Newton. And is truly in awe of Newtons accomplishments in the sciences.
Yet he forgets one great truth about Newton. Sir Issac Newton was a theologian first and a scientist second. Newton was a man of profound faith in God. Newton wrote as much about Christianity and theology as about science.
Newton found no conflict with science and Christian theology. This is because God as ultimate cause gave everything in the universe meaning.
Well you see, Einstein is someone I hold in awe and that doesn't mean I agree with everything he did. I mean, I'm not going to leave my wife and marry my cousin anytime soon. Or that I'm going to write a letter to the president of the United States of America requesting the largest bomb the world has ever seen be made, immediately (all things he did).

I guess my point is we're humans, some of us overlook peoples faults and admire their (professional) accomplishments instead.

How is it that Newtons believe in God did not ruin his scientific objectivity?
Because it was the 1600's? I don't know, I give up....lol.

According to Tyson, religious belief harms the scientific endeavor. :confused:
Now, that is one sound theory, goodnight! (and you had a sample size of one)
 
The key to a good article is to have proper paragraph breaks, that just looked like a block of text, wtf!

"It doesn't make any difference how smart you are, who made the guess, or what his name is. If it disagrees with experiment, it's wrong. That's all there is to it." Feynman was absolutely right
Unless of course you have trolling neutrinos... "Faster than light, u mad bro?" ...
in layman's terms, sometime the experiment is wrong, and in that case Feynman is not right.
 
You just want to see Fail and Skribbel go at it. :D Once payment thing is fixed, I'd pitch in for a membership for GenMay for this guy. Not sure how long that will be as they've already said it isn't a priority.

Could start a race to see which comes first. Fixing the payment options or folding 500k on a Compaq.
 
Heck, if we are going on the amount of times I've been wrong, I would have made a great scientist!

I think the idea is to realize that you might always be wrong, and not to count how many times.
 
I get this strange feeling that you're implying that my Compaq and it's amazing 766 MHz Celeron processor is slow. :(

On a single core CPU...at the speed... you'd probably get a healthy 300pts a day. So it would only take around 4.5 years! Do it for science! :D
 
I get this strange feeling that you're implying that my Compaq and it's amazing 766 MHz Celeron processor is slow. :(

Is SkribbelKat your folding@home name? I'll start up my client with your user name. We'll get you into GenMay!
 
I was studying electronic theory when you were still pissing your pants.
I know the theory and I have made a 30 year career of it.
The team lead by Shockley was NOT concerned with radioactive decay.
They were trying to unlock the secrets of the semiconductor crystal. This is how scientific discovery really happens. You study an effect and seek to find the cause. Once you know they cause you can manipulate the effect for your own purpose.

Sparky, I didn't claim it was discovered by studying radioactive decay, I said it was understood by studying the principles that govern radioactive decay.

Don't get your panties in a twist when you don't grok what I wrote.
 
A good scientist must be -more- than willing to be wrong.
A good scientist shouldn't care whether they are right or wrong.
Religion and Moralist are in decline.
Into the trash bin were they belong.
 
On a single core CPU...at the speed... you'd probably get a healthy 300pts a day. So it would only take around 4.5 years! Do it for science! :D

I bet it would stop working before 4.5 years is over. It is like getting close to 13 years old already which has got to be around 15 years older than me even!

Is SkribbelKat your folding@home name? I'll start up my client with your user name. We'll get you into GenMay!

I haven't folded anything yet. :( I really should though...its just that leaving a computer on makes me worry about fires and my pet kitty taking over the world.
 
Skribbels are, unfortuantely, a litter of kittens waiting to happen because insurance companies seem to think that everyone should make more of themselves before they pay for stuff to actually fix that. :(

But anyway, it does seem scary over there. Maybe when I'm older. :p
 
Basically Neil goes on and on about the towering intellect of Newton. And is truly in awe of Newtons accomplishments in the sciences.
Yet he forgets one great truth about Newton. Sir Issac Newton was a theologian first and a scientist second. Newton was a man of profound faith in God. Newton wrote as much about Christianity and theology as about science.
Newton found no conflict with science and Christian theology. This is because God as ultimate cause gave everything in the universe meaning.
How is it that Newtons believe in God did not ruin his scientific objectivity?
According to Tyson, religious belief harms the scientific endeavor. :confused:

Tyson himself did discuss about how religion stopped Newton from further discovery, either you chose to ignore it or I guess you have not came across that discussion.

Newton was not able to explain how the presence of multiple objects in the solar system mess with the orbits of the planets. He invoke the presence of god or a divine being when he hit this stumbling block. Had Newton not believed in god and was convinced that there has to be a logical explanation, he would have easily came up with perturbation theory himself which was just an extension of calculus which Newton himself came up with.

I just don't understand why you religions folk have to stir things up everytime people discuss about science. Science and religion is two completely different matters. Science is about how nature works. Religion is your personal belief system. You are free to choose what religion to belief in, but science don't are what you want to belief or not, nature works the way it works regardless of what you want to belief.

When you mix them up, god becomes something people invoke everytime they stumble upon something they do not understand or are not able to explain. Science cannot do that. Science have to keep looking for a more fundamental understanding of how nature works, and we have to be comfortable with the fact that there are things that we still do not understand and it will be that way for awhile. You cannot invoke god everytime you cannot explain something logically.
 
Too many "scientists" these days are worried more about grants than facts, and will manipulate facts to attain the grants. Arrogance and pride cloud the judgement of many so that they'll defend their findings no matter how flawed. For far too many, science becomes their religion, and they become overly zealous about their pet theories, and often seem to forget that theories are NOT fact. Science is becoming like politics...more about money and power than their original objectives.
 
The key to a good article is to have proper paragraph breaks, that just looked like a block of text, wtf!


Unless of course you have trolling neutrinos... "Faster than light, u mad bro?" ...
in layman's terms, sometime the experiment is wrong, and in that case Feynman is not right.

That whole thing was blown way out of proportion and no one was really taking it seriously.


Too many "scientists" these days are worried more about grants than facts, and will manipulate facts to attain the grants. Arrogance and pride cloud the judgement of many so that they'll defend their findings no matter how flawed. For far too many, science becomes their religion, and they become overly zealous about their pet theories, and often seem to forget that theories are NOT fact. Science is becoming like politics...more about money and power than their original objectives.

When a scientists puts fourth claims it is the duty of other scientists to criticize those claims and find flaws in them, the originator of the claims will attempt to defend his theory and find flaws in the criticism. If the criticizes are legitimate the theory is either reworked or dies. Just because a scientist is firmly arguing for or against something does not make them zealous, it is their duty to put fourth the best arguments they can.

I think you need to look up the definitions of the words "fact" and "theory" before making such claims.

tldr; religion doesn't even lift.
 
Tyson himself did discuss about how religion stopped Newton from further discovery, either you chose to ignore it or I guess you have not came across that discussion.
Newton was not able to explain how the presence of multiple objects in the solar system mess with the orbits of the planets. He invoke the presence of god or a divine being when he hit this stumbling block. Had Newton not believed in god and was convinced that there has to be a logical explanation, he would have easily came up with perturbation theory himself which was just an extension of calculus which Newton himself came up with.
In Newton's time Theology was "the queen of the sciences".
God was always held as the first cause. Sciences was an honest endeavor of observation and reason. Newton didn't have radio telescopes, super computers or the Hubble telescope at his disposal. So there were things he couldn't observe. He saw effects but baseless theories were not science. (see the contrast to scientists today?)
I just don't understand why you religions folk have to stir things up every time people discuss about science. Science and religion is two completely different matters. Science is about how nature works. Religion is your personal belief system. You are free to choose what religion to belief in, but science don't are what you want to belief or not, nature works the way it works regardless of what you want to belief.

You religious folk?
You can claim to be not religious but human being are innately religious. Every tribe, every people has some type of belief system. Be it an animistic, pagan, or an mainstream religion. And for anyone to claim to be the exception is ridiculousness. You can reject any that has metaphysical beliefs; but then you make science you religion.
Else typically most create a satisfying mish-mash of ideas and ideologies. Be it scientific explanations or warm fuzzy feelings.

If you ask me that is more strange than believing the Bible which the ideas of has been the cornerstone of western civilization hundreds of years.

When you mix them up, god becomes something people invoke every time they stumble upon something they do not understand or are not able to explain.
Science cannot do that. Science have to keep looking for a more fundamental understanding of how nature works, and we have to be comfortable with the fact that there are things that we still do not understand and it will be that way for awhile. You cannot invoke god every time you cannot explain something logically.

Boy, you are exhibiting some very sloppy reasoning here.
If there is something religious people can't explain they say "God did it".
I agree. If you are consistent in what you belief God is then the first cause so that is true.

But scientific theories lend NO BETTER explanation for things that are unobservable and unmeasurable. Scientist postulate a theory which is just their guess. I don't care how you choose to expand upon a theory, what leaps are made from it, etc, etc.
It still provide no empirical evidence that can prove anything. So it is NO BETTER than saying "God did it". And these theories are transient once enough criticism is leveled against them for lacking evidence or defying logic. Then a new one is postulated (or the old modified) and that is the prevailing science of the day.

One of the biggest criticisms of the Bible is that it was written by men so it cannot be of divine origin.

Science is written by men and leaving your core beliefs on such shifting sands really calls for some self examination.
 
Too bad science jettisoned the idea of being wrong when environmentalism took hold.

DDT is poison. It softened the shells of baby eagle eggs. I don't care that the effect didn't happen the first five treatments. I don't care that it only worked when they used a 1200% concentration compared to the strongest concentration used in actual applications. I don't care that there are metrics that show that millions upon millions have died from diseases like malaria as a result of the banning of DDT usage.

All that matters is that the narrative is pushed forward, and don't even get me started on the fact that people who question the theory of global warming are compared to flat-earthers and called "deniers"(aren't those kinds of labels supposed to be reserved for religious zealots?).
 
Science is written by men and leaving your core beliefs on such shifting sands really calls for some self examination.

Who came up with and wrote religious doctrines? Because I'm stumped! Honestly though, wow, I could dissect your entire post into oblivion but I just don't have the time nor the will to at the moment. Plus I'm sure it'd be for nothing in the end.

So I will just say this, religion was also written by men....derp....derp...just written (made up) by men thousands of years ago that knew so very little when compared to today's men. Where Science is updated second by second, minute by minute, hour by hour.

Leaving your core beliefs to half assed books and fables told/written thousands of years ago is way (like light years way) worse than accepting current Science. You can't pray your way out of things in the real world, today's world.


You can claim to be not religious but human being are innately religious
Were! and mostly because stories were passed down from generation to generation to fill the voids at the time. Science fills it now. Non-believers are the biggest growing section of humanity....right now! Religion as a popular belief, its days are numbered. It'll always be around but as people get wiser less and less will accept lies and truths. Good-Day!
 
Were! and mostly because stories were passed down from generation to generation to fill the voids at the time. Science fills it now.

That is a terrifying statement from any human being. Science is not, nor ever should be, a belief system to explain the unexplained. Science and philosophy are supposed to be mutually exclusive in terms of resolving unexplained phenomena.

Science is never supposed to require faith. Faith is supposed to be reserved for those situations in which science is unable or insufficient in providing a rational basis for why something happens.

Unfortunately, as I mentioned above, science has become so horrifically corrupted that it has turned into a new kind of cult worship. We already saw the impact in the eugenics movement of the early 20th century, and it never died. It merely went dormant, and has awoken in recent decades, largely labeled as the "environmental" movement. Those who deviate from the groupthink are labeled as uneducated rubes, idiots, and "deniers". The very word "skeptic" is now seen as an epithet.
 
That is a terrifying statement from any human being. Science is not, nor ever should be, a belief system to explain the unexplained. Science and philosophy are supposed to be mutually exclusive in terms of resolving unexplained phenomena.

Science is never supposed to require faith. Faith is supposed to be reserved for those situations in which science is unable or insufficient in providing a rational basis for why something happens.

Unfortunately, as I mentioned above, science has become so horrifically corrupted that it has turned into a new kind of cult worship. We already saw the impact in the eugenics movement of the early 20th century, and it never died. It merely went dormant, and has awoken in recent decades, largely labeled as the "environmental" movement. Those who deviate from the groupthink are labeled as uneducated rubes, idiots, and "deniers". The very word "skeptic" is now seen as an epithet.

Well said.
You will notice people that define themselves as "skeptics" will have great problems with ANYTHING connected to a orthodox religious of any kind; but will swallow any scientific postulations without question.
 
That is a terrifying statement from any human being. Science is not, nor ever should be, a belief system to explain the unexplained. Science and philosophy are supposed to be mutually exclusive in terms of resolving unexplained phenomena.

Not sure how me saying science/facts/observable theories replacing totally BS stories is scary? I didn't say Science was a belief system either. What I'm saying is that fictional stories of yesteryear are being replaced with today's facts, not doing that is scary, not the opposite.


Science is never supposed to require faith. Faith is supposed to be reserved for those situations in which science is unable or insufficient in providing a rational basis for why something happens.
Again, never even said this so not sure where you're going or coming from. However I can't phracking wait for religion to never be an option/answer for anything unexplainable anymore. If something is unknown, figure it out, don't just say "it must be God" and that's that. :rolleyes:

Unfortunately, as I mentioned above, science has become so horrifically corrupted that it has turned into a new kind of cult worship.
Religion has been the most corrupted thing on this planet since we could start making shit up tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of years ago. Nothing to date can ever top religion in pure corruption and killings, nothing! So I'm not sure how there always being bad humans on the planet doing stupid shit makes Science any less credible or religion (outdated myths) more credible. It just makes no sense. Read: Overall good, not bits and pieces that suite your agenda.

We already saw the impact in the eugenics movement of the early 20th century, and it never died.
We saw the mass killings over religious faiths and that never died.
Those who deviate from the groupthink are labeled as uneducated rubes, idiots, and "deniers". The very word "skeptic" is now seen as an epithet
You mean like Galileo Galilei telling the church they were wrong and that the Earth was not the center of the universe which went against their teachings....so they remedied it by locking him away for the rest of his life? Like that stuff? :rolleyes: Yes, religion is much morally just compared to everything else. I mean, since it's not made up by humans like anything else....oh wait, it is!


"I refuse to prove that I exist,'" says God, "for proof denies faith, and without faith I am nothing." - lol
 
Well said.
You will notice people that define themselves as "skeptics" will have great problems with ANYTHING connected to a orthodox religious of any kind; but will swallow any scientific postulations without question.

I know it's said all the time about this show, but South Park just nailed both atheists and people who view science as a religion in the storyline where Cartman traveled to the future to get a Nintendo Wii. Given enough time, people will somehow pervert the scientific method into a ritual, and those who question untested hypotheses will be branded heretics.
 
If something is unknown, figure it out, don't just say "it must be God" and that's that. :rolleyes:

The snipped parts aren't worth responding to. This isn't really, either, except to demonstrate the ignorant elitism that the cult mentality of science has for philosophy. I'll give you a suitable response:

If something is unknown, provide a tested theory, don't just sneer and scoff at anyone who comes up with a supernatural suggestion. If you don't hold a religious belief, that's up to you. Stop being a dickhole to anyone who doesn't share your views on religion. That's called bigotry.
 
Well said.
You will notice people that define themselves as "skeptics" will have great problems with ANYTHING connected to a orthodox religious of any kind; but will swallow any scientific postulations without question.

And...actually that's wrong too but I'm starting to see the pattern arising now. Facts are facts, lies are lies. Science is ever changing, a book never changing but yet filled with more fiction than a Harry Potter book is all the proof any sane person would ever need. I'm not skeptical about religion, I know for a fact every single religion on this planet (alive or dead) is false. It's easy to come to this conclusion, they were derived from man and never proven and never even last.

Religions change like the Earths climate. Slow to humans but very fast on a larger scale. Worship the Sun God Ra, he was worshiped for ten times as long as allah or jesus ever will be. He must be the one true God, yet no one worships him......today....weird!
 
We saw the mass killings over religious faiths and that never died.

Actually, my bad. This is entirely worth responding to. Why are you deflecting away from the deaths of tens of millions that can be easily linked to the attitudes perpetuated by eugenics groupthink in order to attack religion, which isn't the topic?

Answer: you're unable to defend the moral dilemma of eugenics, being a branch of science. You are attempting to switch the focus of discussion as a defensive move for a system you hold sacred: science.

In other words, you're treating science like any religious zealot treats their religion. You are what you mock. You are the other side of the coin. You're the mirror image. You're a perfect example of what I was talking about. You are no better than any hateful religious acolyte.
 
The snipped parts aren't worth responding to. This isn't really, either, except to demonstrate the ignorant elitism that the cult mentality of science has for philosophy. I'll give you a suitable response:

If something is unknown, provide a tested theory, don't just sneer and scoff at anyone who comes up with a supernatural suggestion. If you don't hold a religious belief, that's up to you. Stop being a dickhole to anyone who doesn't share your views on religion. That's called bigotry.

You insult me for saying "figure it out" and then in the next paragraph say exactly what I said with "provide a tested theory" . LOL....what? However what's the only thing on this planet I and millions other see with no testable (observable) theories? ;)
 
Or just simple logic. I'll provide a :rolleyes: as well.

Does the simple logic also include concealing the source of a quote as being a humorous science fiction novel? I love Hitchhiker's Guide, but have found that anyone who quotes it as part of a serious discussion about religion, philosophy, or science is not particularly intelligent.

So far, my findings remain consistent. ;)
 
Actually, my bad. This is entirely worth responding to. Why are you deflecting away from the deaths of tens of millions that can be easily linked to the attitudes perpetuated by eugenics groupthink in order to attack religion, which isn't the topic?

I accept your apology. I thought I answered this by there is and will always be bad people in the world both religious and otherwise. Religion still killed more people than any other ideology throughout existence. Shit, if God is to be taken seriously (Not), he killed more people in the bible than anyone else....lol. Also, I'm pretty sure religion has been the the topic so....:rolleyes:


Answer: you're unable to defend the moral dilemma of eugenics, being a branch of science. You are attempting to switch the focus of discussion as a defensive move for a system you hold sacred: science.
For your eugenics and science are evil claim. Go reread your bible, history, and watch alternative news today. The stupid people on the planet are stilling killing more people than anyone else over fictional BS. I rest my case.


In other words, you're treating science like any religious zealot treats their religion. You are what you mock. You are the other side of the coin. You're the mirror image. You're a perfect example of what I was talking about. You are no better than any hateful religious acolyte.
LOL,and you sir just have no clue what you're talking about and are attaching me to things that make you feel better and/or in your mind help you to gain any kind of credibility in this debate. I question everything in Science, the reason I question nothing anymore in religion or see it as plausible isn't because I'm biased, it's because there's nothing there.

And since I hold the same feelings as Einstein, Neil Degrasse Tyson, Darwin, Thomas Jefferson, Bill Nye, Carl Sagan, Richard Dawkins, Edgar allan poe, Mark twain, Napoleon Bonaparte, Thomas Paine, and almost every other intelligent human being that ever lived, I stand fast.

Does the simple logic also include concealing the source of a quote as being a humorous science fiction novel? I love Hitchhiker's Guide, but have found that anyone who quotes it as part of a serious discussion about religion, philosophy, or science is not particularly intelligent.

So far, my findings remain consistent.
Actually, I just thought it was funny as hell which is why I added the LOL. However I have also found that anyone even bringing up the idea that religion is plausible in 2012 is not particularly intelligent. ;) Nice try though. ;)
 
Does the simple logic also include concealing the source of a quote as being a humorous science fiction novel? I love Hitchhiker's Guide, but have found that anyone who quotes it as part of a serious discussion about religion, philosophy, or science is not particularly intelligent.

So far, my findings remain consistent. ;)

A failing man will dismiss everything he can't argue (99% of the points made) and yet focus the conversation towards the one part, which in the larger picture, is completely irrelevant, as well as adding insults, to make a very small point. I would say that is a man angered but with no leg to stand on and a man that would resort to such trivial tactics is a weak man. ;)
 
For your eugenics and science are evil claim.

I never said anything of the kind. I never said either were evil. I only claimed that the field of eugenics is the first, most visible example of science becoming cult worship through groupthink and denigration of all who do not adhere...that it involves an incredible moral dilemma...and that it can be traced as a major contributor to the international attitudes that led to the slaughters of tens of millions throughout the 20th century.

And you? You still refuse to even address eugenics, resorting only to pathetic strawmen because you can't handle the points I actually laid out, or even the original point: that science never should be treated as a belief system. Every single discussion of disastrous scientific fads has you deflecting away to "yeah, but religion...". That phrase is the primary tool of those who have replaced all semblance of spirituality with fervent belief in the sanctity of science...except that science requires no sanctity. It either is, or it isn't.

Humanity has excelled by balancing supernatural belief with provable scientific theories. Those who attempt to eliminate the former will only serve to corrupt and break down the system by which the latter are achieved.
 
Humanity has excelled by balancing supernatural belief with provable scientific theories. Those who attempt to eliminate the former will only serve to corrupt and break down the system by which the latter are achieved.

Demonstrably false. Where is "supernatural belief" found in nuclear physics? Astronomy? Mathematics?
 
Back
Top