The CD Turns 30 Today

Single-bit pulse-density modulation has a lot of problems Redbook-spec PCM simply doesn't have. The problems Redbook CD audio has are minor and mostly inconsequential: reduced effective bit depth at lower amplitudes, but bit depth is still pretty good even at very low amplitudes, and quantization noise, which is effectively eliminated with sufficient dithering techniques. We've gotten quite good at dither in the past 30 years, to the point where we can get an effective 19 to 20 bits per sample from a 16-bit word.

It's all masturbation at the end of the day, anyway. 12-bit/38 KHz PCM would've been just fine. What we got with Redbook borders on overkill as far as theoretical quality is concerned, which makes the push for higher-resolution consumer formats of severely questionable merit.

I almost agree, I mean sure, the high end DACs and filters definitely make a difference, the better ones do a good job of imitating the analog media sound quality but, higher bit depth and sampling rate still goes a long way to improve accuracy, almost to the point that even cheap DACs/filters can reproduce the quality that was only able to be achieved by analog just a few yeas ago. SACD and DVD-A are excellent in that regard, but you need to know what analog sound actually sounds like in the first place to tell the differences. Filters do not fix it...


An informative study was done on the topic of analog vs. digital trying to explain the differences in percieved sound quality of audio pre-digital and post digital: Harmonics. The one thing digital media doesn't reproduce is the even order harmonics. DAC's and comb filters produce odd order harmonics which do not exist in 'nature', hence the 'un-natural' sound audiophiles often complain about, where-as analog media produces even order harmonics that definitely make the music sound 'natural'. Some manufacturers have since tried to emulate this quality, with a few different tricks (Creative Labs---crystallizer for one) but have had little actual success. The way to mimic it is to have a tube amp pre-amplifier circuit after the digital media source, since tubes create their own even order harmonics. (This was the effect 'Via-Vinyl' codecs were trying to reproduce a few years back).

All in all: Happy Birthday CD!
 
The problem was it sounded really bad so it actually made it easier to sell higher end turn tables and cartridges. Although the PCM recording process had been around for a while (on modified Beta and VHS tape machines) all the music engineers only knew analog and it took them years to get digital to sound “OK” but it really never sounded better than vinyl, CD never achieved the audio range of analog or vinyl. It wasn’t until Sony came up with SACD that digital was able to reproduce and exceed the frequency spread of analog.

Nooo don't be that one "pro analog" guuy! :p It's not true at all. Easy example, vinyl cannot easily go below 30hz, due to the groove depth making the disk more fragile and the motor. CDs can do below that easily with no ill effect. Analog media decays and breaks, CDs (unless poorly manafactured) don't, and can be 1:1 copied. Analog, though in theory has this "unlimited dynamic range and frequency" it actually doesn't, reality and physical properties get in the way and cause much more limited results. Analog has fuzzyness about it which some people like, but it's not due to some intrinsic betterness, more due to low quality and decay softening everything. Like how soft focus makes people look "better", it's not due to the quality of the photo.

If analog was indeed better, find all the studios still using analog? Outside of a few hermits on the edge of a hippy convent, there aren't any. Record something digitally, and it sounds like it sounds. Pass it through a load of disks, and through 100 units, it still sounds like it sounded when you hit record years before. Record something analog, it sounds like an analog of the original due to the limitations of the media. It has variances due to the physical variances, then, along every part of an analog signal chain you lose quality. The sound decays and decays every time you do anything, then stays on physical media, rotting, decaying more, losing sharpness and becoming more and more muddy and noise filled until you kill the whole thing. The transfered through another inprecise method, gauging out a line with a needle, instead of a literally perfect 1:1 copy. Lots of recording equpment was invested to reduce this effect, or based off the properties of it.

The simplest way to kill all analog vs digital arguments is this: digital can sound like analog, analog can never sound like digital. Analog recording and playback are beyond dead, outside of a few nostagia seekers. Digital is better in every conceivable way, easier to use, easier to manipulate, easier to store, send, use, listen to etc. :D
 
Nooo don't be that one "pro analog" guuy! :p It's not true at all. Easy example, vinyl cannot easily go below 30hz, due to the groove depth making the disk more fragile and the motor. CDs can do below that easily with no ill effect. Analog media decays and breaks, CDs (unless poorly manafactured) don't, and can be 1:1 copied. Analog, though in theory has this "unlimited dynamic range and frequency" it actually doesn't, reality and physical properties get in the way and cause much more limited results. Analog has fuzzyness about it which some people like, but it's not due to some intrinsic betterness, more due to low quality and decay softening everything. Like how soft focus makes people look "better", it's not due to the quality of the photo.

If analog was indeed better, find all the studios still using analog? Outside of a few hermits on the edge of a hippy convent, there aren't any. Record something digitally, and it sounds like it sounds. Pass it through a load of disks, and through 100 units, it still sounds like it sounded when you hit record years before. Record something analog, it sounds like an analog of the original due to the limitations of the media. It has variances due to the physical variances, then, along every part of an analog signal chain you lose quality. The sound decays and decays every time you do anything, then stays on physical media, rotting, decaying more, losing sharpness and becoming more and more muddy and noise filled until you kill the whole thing. The transfered through another inprecise method, gauging out a line with a needle, instead of a literally perfect 1:1 copy. Lots of recording equpment was invested to reduce this effect, or based off the properties of it.

The simplest way to kill all analog vs digital arguments is this: digital can sound like analog, analog can never sound like digital. Analog recording and playback are beyond dead, outside of a few nostagia seekers. Digital is better in every conceivable way, easier to use, easier to manipulate, easier to store, send, use, listen to etc. :D

I pretty much understand all of what you're saying except for the parts about analog and digital recordings, sound, frequencies, motors, decay, and fuzzy speakers. The hippies and hermits are awesome though so I completely endorse the product or service in this post.
 
I pretty much understand all of what you're saying except for the parts about analog and digital recordings, sound, frequencies, motors, decay, and fuzzy speakers. The hippies and hermits are awesome though so I completely endorse the product or service in this post.

Can I use you on the box art? Well as long as you can do a "dual thumbs up, dual pointing whilst winking dressed as a nun in a refined yet totally slutty way" pose! :D (market demographics suggest this is key)

Though, in the spirit of full disclosure it was partly euphemisms about incontinence pills and investment bankers. :(
 
Can I use you on the box art? Well as long as you can do a "dual thumbs up, dual pointing whilst winking dressed as a nun in a refined yet totally slutty way" pose! :D (market demographics suggest this is key)

Though, in the spirit of full disclosure it was partly euphemisms about incontinence pills and investment bankers. :(

Skribbels don't do slutty, but nuns are okay as long as they can fly and play an electric guitar. Did you say incompetence pills?
 
An informative study was done on the topic of analog vs. digital trying to explain the differences in percieved sound quality of audio pre-digital and post digital: Harmonics. The one thing digital media doesn't reproduce is the even order harmonics
PCM can reproduce whatever is sampled, up to the Nyquist frequency, and with as much precision as is afforded by the format's word length at a given amplitude. Even-order harmonics? You bethca. Odd-order? No problem. Whatever you want, basically. At the end of the day, it's all periodic, and PCM does periodic just as well as any analog format (with dither). There's no signal that an analog format can represent that a digital format cannot. It's just a matter of getting word lengths and sample rates high enough to overcome whatever obstacles you're trying to overcome.
 
I still borrow music CDs from the library..

Nothing wrong with that. Hell, my dad does the same. If mine had selection of Dance/Electronica I wouldn't mind grabbing a few myself. Unfortunately it doesn't so I'm stuck with listing to Pandora or ElectricFM.
 
I pretty much understand all of what you're saying except for the parts about analog and digital recordings, sound, frequencies, motors, decay, and fuzzy speakers. The hippies and hermits are awesome though so I completely endorse the product or service in this post.

You ever noticed how "audiophile" grade turntables are NEVER EVER direct drive? Yeah...platter rumble sucks ass as does wow / flutter. I'm all about digital, but not compression, I wish people could purchase un-fucked-with copies of the studio masters regardless of file sizes since 1TB+ drives are not that expensive anymore.
 
PCM can reproduce whatever is sampled, up to the Nyquist frequency, and with as much precision as is afforded by the format's word length at a given amplitude. Even-order harmonics? You bethca. Odd-order? No problem. Whatever you want, basically. At the end of the day, it's all periodic, and PCM does periodic just as well as any analog format (with dither). There's no signal that an analog format can represent that a digital format cannot. It's just a matter of getting word lengths and sample rates high enough to overcome whatever obstacles you're trying to overcome.

Do you really understand sample folding at 1/2 nyquist frequency? 44.1Khz, stereo PCM gives 22.05Khz per channel, the fold is around 11Khz, and aliasing occurs between 9KHz and 13Khz. This produces an odd order harmonic inherent in the CD medium at just under 1/2 the audible frequency range. Oversampling still does not fix the CD issue.

The only thing that comes close to fixing it is a higher sampling frequency in the source recording, and even then odd order frequency harmonics occur in the range of the amplification circuitry.

This is a subject that has been argued and reviewed over and over by the brightest audiophiles in the world...if you are one of the 'digital is better' 'transistor is better people' you will not understand why the argument is made.
 
Do you really understand sample folding at 1/2 nyquist frequency? 44.1Khz, stereo PCM gives 22.05Khz per channel
No. The sample rate is 44.1 KHz for both channels. It doesn't get 'split' between the two channels. The Nyquist frequency is thus 22.050 KHz. Aliasing occurs near the Nyquist frequency (beyond the audible range), which anti-aliasing filters negate. This isn't something oversampling is intended to fix.

If what you were saying were true, the following would also be true:

A) The highest representable frequency for Redbook CD audio would be ~11 KHz.
B) The bit rate for Redbook CD audio would be 705 Kbps.

Neither are true.
 
Not to mention the fact that very very few transducers in the history of speaker technology can accurately reproduce a 20khz signal without injecting far more distortion than half way decent electrical component. And I'm thinking of maybe a small electrostatic would the only thing with low enough mass.



This is a subject that has been argued and reviewed over and over by the brightest audiophiles in the world...if you are one of the 'digital is better' 'transistor is better people' you will not understand why the argument is made.

And how do these bright golden ears explain how a record player can, which is electronics, reproduce some special aura, that electronics apparently can't measure? How can it produce it, but not be measurable?

Heck I'm still waiting to see the blind test where people can pick red book over 320kbps MP3 (and I mean more then the expected 50% guessing rate).
 
You ever noticed how "audiophile" grade turntables are NEVER EVER direct drive? Yeah...platter rumble sucks ass as does wow / flutter. I'm all about digital, but not compression, I wish people could purchase un-fucked-with copies of the studio masters regardless of file sizes since 1TB+ drives are not that expensive anymore.

I have no idea what any of that means...well except maybe the profanity parts and the 1 TB drive...which I need for a laptop someday. :)
 
I have no idea what any of that means...well except maybe the profanity parts and the 1 TB drive...which I need for a laptop someday. :)

Ok, a direct drive turntable (like one a DJ uses) uses a stepper motor directly coupled to the platter that the record sits on. When the motor is engaged it creates a very low frequency "rumble" which then of course is picked up by the pickup and is then sent through the amps to the speakers. For the "critical listeners" this is audible and very undesirable, ravers on the other hand won't even know its there and won't give a shit. :)

WOW and flutter are something else you don't want - basically if ANYTHING changes the speed the platter is spinning at (either 33 1/3 or 45rpm) it will (if bad enough) come across as timbre changes in whatever you are listening to and that is bad news. So, your $10k+ turntable is belt driven with a stupid thick platter, sitting on shock absorbers with auto leveling, an isolated motor and the whole thing weighing in at around 200 or 300 pounds or more...BUT...it will NEVER be 100% constant, it might be constant to the threshold of human hearing, but I guarantee even the most expensive turntable will have some WOW and or flutter if only because of atmospheric changes (temp, humidity, etc) changing (no matter how small) the tension of the belt coupled to the platter and motor.

Lets not even get into styli types, spherical, oblong, or "sharp" and the different kinds of pickups that those styli are coupled to, or the types of amps being used such as tube amps vs solid state. I will say this, (asbestos suit equipped) I don't really care for tube amps, to me they are "sloppy" especially on the low end but they are a lot more forgiving when overdriven, Solid state amps "clip" when overdriven and that is bad joo-joo.

I was a DJ for years and vinyl is just a pain in the ass, I do not find the pops, clicks, and hiss of even a record in good condition "romantic" like these "audiophile hipster turds" do - to me it detracts from the music which is why I'm all about digital...but I want digital that is DONE RIGHT.
 
Ok, a direct drive turntable (like one a DJ uses) uses a stepper motor directly coupled to the platter that the record sits on. When the motor is engaged it creates a very low frequency "rumble" which then of course is picked up by the pickup and is then sent through the amps to the speakers. For the "critical listeners" this is audible and very undesirable, ravers on the other hand won't even know its there and won't give a shit. :)

WOW and flutter are something else you don't want - basically if ANYTHING changes the speed the platter is spinning at (either 33 1/3 or 45rpm) it will (if bad enough) come across as timbre changes in whatever you are listening to and that is bad news. So, your $10k+ turntable is belt driven with a stupid thick platter, sitting on shock absorbers with auto leveling, an isolated motor and the whole thing weighing in at around 200 or 300 pounds or more...BUT...it will NEVER be 100% constant, it might be constant to the threshold of human hearing, but I guarantee even the most expensive turntable will have some WOW and or flutter if only because of atmospheric changes (temp, humidity, etc) changing (no matter how small) the tension of the belt coupled to the platter and motor.

Lets not even get into styli types, spherical, oblong, or "sharp" and the different kinds of pickups that those styli are coupled to, or the types of amps being used such as tube amps vs solid state. I will say this, (asbestos suit equipped) I don't really care for tube amps, to me they are "sloppy" especially on the low end but they are a lot more forgiving when overdriven, Solid state amps "clip" when overdriven and that is bad joo-joo.

I was a DJ for years and vinyl is just a pain in the ass, I do not find the pops, clicks, and hiss of even a record in good condition "romantic" like these "audiophile hipster turds" do - to me it detracts from the music which is why I'm all about digital...but I want digital that is DONE RIGHT.









que???
:confused:




:confused:






:confused:









NERD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:p
 
Back
Top