The Big 1 Gig

Status
Not open for further replies.
MrDigital said:
Is there anyone here over the age of 16 who can retort my statements without making it have something to do with how much money I spent on my PC?

Seriously, take your head from wherever it is and look at what I have in my PC. If some of the stuff doesn't look familiar to you (likely), look it up. Note the price of it. Use common sense and basic math and determine that I have more than enough money to buy 1GB or more if I wanted it.

As for Phaelinx's comment ending it, if the world only accepted one answer it certainly wouldn't be very great, now would it. I happened to disagree with Phaelinx at the beginning and even more so now.

-MrD
You've still done nothing to further your argument that 1 gig is a waste for gaming. The people arguing against you have actually seen first hand the differences between gaming with a gig and gaming with 512. Your reasoning seems to be that Halo and UT2K4 run smoothly on your system, therefore no games would benefit from additional RAM. Could it be that the people arguing against you are in a better position to comment than you are on this topic? They are, after all, the same gaming junkies who wouldn't know how to use their computer for anything productive.

It is the equivalent of me telling you that all of the things you have in your computer are a "waste" even though I probably wouldn't know the first thing about some of the things you do with your computer. What makes you think you are more qualified than them to discuss appropriate RAM sizes for gaming? Judging from your posts you don't exactly seem like the biggest gamer ever, and that's perfectly fine. However, I consider myself a pretty hardcore gamer and I find it a tad disrespectful that you are telling me my own business(that business being gaming).
 
1GB of RAM is a must for playing games these days. A lot of games are choppy as hell without it. Games that have long draw distances especially. I tried running Far Cry, Battlefield Vietnam and the new MOH Pacific Assult demo with 512MB and then with a GB. The difference was night and day. The choppiness in BV was horrid with 512 and was totally smoothed out with a gig. I'll never use less then a gig again for a game machine. Also, I have an LCD on my front panel that displays avalible RAM and what not and when those games where fully loaded there was barely 100mb left.
 
Sanitarium said:
1GB of RAM is a must for playing games these days. A lot of games are choppy as hell without it. Games that have long draw distances especially. I tried running Far Cry, Battlefield Vietnam and the new MOH Pacific Assult demo with 512MB and then with a GB. The difference was night and day. The choppiness in BV was horrid with 512 and was totally smoothed out with a gig. I'll never use less then a gig again for a game machine. Also, I have an LCD on my front panel that displays avalible RAM and what not and when those games where fully loaded there was barely 100mb left.
Which is exaclty most peoples point in this thread. having a gig or more is not hurting anything. And is not a waste. :)
 
I really hope you don't mistake me for some kid that knows nothing about computers because you are as far off as possible MrD. Really an average gamer obviously knows more then you do about them. And I consider myself "hardcore". So please just go read some other threads gain some Levels and knowledge before you start stuff. Thank You.
 
WuTangClam said:
You've still done nothing to further your argument that 1 gig is a waste for gaming. The people arguing against you have actually seen first hand the differences between gaming with a gig and gaming with 512. Your reasoning seems to be that Halo and UT2K4 run smoothly on your system, therefore no games would benefit from additional RAM.

No, my reasoning is that people WANT to see a difference between 512MB and 1GB because they just spent money on it.

People are extremely influenced by the perceived value of things. People can force themselves to believe that they can see, hear & feel different things that aren't there.

Everyone here that's telling me that it just LOOKS smoother and FEELS faster don't offer any evidence to back that up. Where are the benchmarks that prove 1GB is better than 512MB in all the various games you folks are throwing out?

I'm sure there's got to be plenty of evidence out there that supports the claims that 1GB is better than 512MB, since so many people feel that it's so much better.

-MrD
 
XSNiper said:
I really hope you don't mistake me for some kid that knows nothing about computers because you are as far off as possible MrD. Really an average gamer obviously knows more then you do about them. And I consider myself "hardcore". So please just go read some other threads gain some Levels and knowledge before you start stuff. Thank You.

I didn't mistake you for anything other than what you portrayed yourself to be.

-MrD
 
Believe what you want Mr. D. I started with a P3 machine with 256mb of RAM. I had Win2000. I upgraded to 512mb and noticed a big difference in performance. Later I got Windows XP and an Athlon machine. I upgraded again to 768mb of RAM and again noticed a difference in load times (esp. BF1942) and overall speed of the pc.

I've got a gig of dual stick (512mb x2) RAM now and I haven't noticed much of a difference between 768mb and 1gig (except in Photoshop), however buying a gig of dual sticks is easier and probably cheaper than finding matched 256mb and 512mb sticks and you have to admit that 1 gig is more future proof than 512mb.
 
rdytorave said:
Believe what you want Mr. D. I started with a P3 machine with 256mb of RAM. I had Win2000. I upgraded to 512mb and noticed a big difference in performance. Later I got Windows XP and an Athlon machine. I upgraded again to 768mb of RAM and again noticed a difference in load times (esp. BF1942) and overall speed of the pc.

I've got a gig of dual stick (512mb x2) RAM now and I haven't noticed much of a difference between 768mb and 1gig (except in Photoshop), however buying a gig of dual sticks is easier and probably cheaper than finding matched 256mb and 512mb sticks and you have to admit that 1 gig is more future proof than 512mb.

Sure, it's more future proof. So is buying 3 hard drives even though you won't need the space for another year or two. Or buying a full tower case even though you only have 1 hard drive and 1 optical drive, but hey you might buy more.

Buying computer parts for the future isn't always the best way to invest your money. Considering DDR's life is coming to an end, you may very well not be able to transfer that 1GB of RAM to the next PC you build.

-MrD
 
MrDigital said:
No, my reasoning is that people WANT to see a difference between 512MB and 1GB because they just spent money on it.

People are extremely influenced by the perceived value of things. People can force themselves to believe that they can see, hear & feel different things that aren't there.

Everyone here that's telling me that it just LOOKS smoother and FEELS faster don't offer any evidence to back that up. Where are the benchmarks that prove 1GB is better than 512MB in all the various games you folks are throwing out?

I'm sure there's got to be plenty of evidence out there that supports the claims that 1GB is better than 512MB, since so many people feel that it's so much better.

-MrD

Wow man, do you deny that caching info(GAMES) to the hd page file is as fast as if it were to cache to ram? which is many many times faster than the fastest hd. It doesnt "feel" faster, I know for a FACT that it is faster. If you're a wierdo like me that have about 3 inches worth of programs in the system tray, 1gig of ram is very much more benificiary than 512megs as the swap file doesnt need to resize AS MUCH causing hd lag.
 
Bling said:
i heard you can turn off your page file aswell. there is mixed reports whether it has any effect. i have heard much advise as to doing it. i however am yet to do it. however i do have a gig of ram and have had it since i bought this computer last year. it definately helps. battlefield games run flawlessly on my system compared to my cousins with half my ram


how do you turn off the page file?

and the differance between 512 and 1gb is huge, ill never go back to 512 again.
 
phaelinx said:
Wow man, do you deny that caching info(GAMES) to the hd page file is as fast as if it were to cache to ram? which is many many times faster than the fastest hd. It doesnt "feel" faster, I know for a FACT that it is faster. If you're a wierdo like me that have about 3 inches worth of programs in the system tray, 1gig of ram is very much more benificiary than 512megs as the swap file doesnt need to resize AS MUCH causing hd lag.

Perhaps the issue here is just that. Perhaps 512MB is more than enough for me because I run an extremely clean system. When I want to play a game I close things to make sure my system is dedicated to the game.

I was assuming though that people saying 1GB was better were the sort of people who would close other programs before gaming, to make sure that the game (likely one where people spend hundreds of dollars on high end cards to get 10% more frames per second) got as much of the hardware as possible. Leaving a bunch of programs open and in the systray not only takes memory but also CPU time, plus increases the chances of conflicts and crashes.

I still find it hard to recommend that people buy 1GB for that reason though. The argument here was that games THEMSELVES required 1GB of RAM, not games + applications. I could open 87 copies of MS Word for proof that I needed 2GB of ram.

-MrD
 
jayw28 said:
how do you turn off the page file?

and the differance between 512 and 1gb is huge, ill never go back to 512 again.

Don't turn off the page file. Windows was coded to use it and turning it off actually hurts performance, quite a bit usually.

-MrD
 
I put off upgrading to 1 gb of RAM for a long time. For me, loading a CTF game of UT2004 with all the settings on at 1280x1204 with some AF and AA could take a couple of minutes. Exiting back out to the desktop also took forever. Also, when I started a game, it would lag badly at the beginning of the match. With an additional 512 mb of RAM things have changed a great deal. It never takes over 30 seconds to load a game of UT2004 now, and exiting to the desktop is very fast... just a second or two. FarCry had similar problems. The game would lag badly the first time I shot at a person in the level. The extra RAM fixed that.

Mr. Digital, you asked for proof. I think game load times halved and game exit times cut even more provides all the reason most of us need to upgrade to 1 gb. I was thinking of upgrading my trusty 9800 Pro, but with the memory upgrade, I feel like I can wait a while longer for cards to get cheaper.

I don't see how you can argue with those of us who have had 512, and now have 1024. You just don't know how much smoother things can be until you try it. :cool:

My computer performs better at 3.0 GHz with 1 gb of RAM in UT2004 than it did at 4.0 GHz with 512. That's all I need for proof.
 
Jonsey said:
I put off upgrading to 1 gb of RAM for a long time. For me, loading a CTF game of UT2004 with all the settings on at 1280x1204 with some AF and AA could take a couple of minutes. Exiting back out to the desktop also took forever. Also, when I started a game, it would lag badly at the beginning of the match. With an additional 512 mb of RAM things have changed a great deal. It never takes over 30 seconds to load a game of UT2004 now, and exiting to the desktop is very fast... just a second or two. FarCry had similar problems. The game would lag badly the first time I shot at a person in the level. The extra RAM fixed that.

Mr. Digital, you asked for proof. I think game load times halved and game exit times cut even more provides all the reason most of us need to upgrade to 1 gb. I was thinking of upgrading my trusty 9800 Pro, but with the memory upgrade, I feel like I can wait a while longer for cards to get cheaper.

I don't see how you can argue with those of us who have had 512, and now have 1024. You just don't know how much smoother things can be until you try it. :cool:

My computer performs better at 3.0 GHz with 1 gb of RAM in UT2004 than it did at 4.0 GHz with 512. That's all I need for proof.


even though im trying to take a neutral approach to this debate im going to screw that up by agreeing with this statement whole heartedly. i too have gone from 512mb to 1024mb ram and ive seen a substantial improvement in overall performance and an even greater improvement in all of my games that use quite a bitof memory. and i have 8 programs in my system tray at all times and sometimes even more than that. so i have a good reason for having a gig of RAM. Mr.Digital, plz do yourself a favor and tryout using 1GB of RAM and if you dont like it (which im sure you will) then feel free to use it as a tooth pick or sell it on ebay. have a good day :D
 
you know, this is just a difference of opinion...no one is right...one person may find that 512MB of RAM fits their needs, another might want/need 1GB, its a matter of what your preferences/needs are...this debate may never be settled. As for me, I can't wait for my gig dual-channel kit. I think you should have 1gb if you think you need it. If you don't see a performance boost, okay, then don't get a gig. but if other people are finding things different to what you say, don't criticize them or call them wrong. If games load fast enough for you with 512, awesome! that's your choice, but if we want our games to load that much faster, a gig is perfect. I have photoshop now with 512 ram, and it is slow as heck, it takes like 2 minutes to load. I feel bad for my friend, he's got like 32mbs of RAM and he uses photoshop :eek:!!

well, like i said, this will never be solved, one person's main use is different than another. I'm not taking a side at all, just stating my opinion.
 
Id disagree

there are in fact hard metrics available to guage this for any that bother
and based on their individual usage pattern
there is no need for this to be subjective

again start > run > perfmon.msc
 
MrDigital said:
No, my reasoning is that people WANT to see a difference between 512MB and 1GB because they just spent money on it.

People are extremely influenced by the perceived value of things. People can force themselves to believe that they can see, hear & feel different things that aren't there.

Everyone here that's telling me that it just LOOKS smoother and FEELS faster don't offer any evidence to back that up. Where are the benchmarks that prove 1GB is better than 512MB in all the various games you folks are throwing out?

I'm sure there's got to be plenty of evidence out there that supports the claims that 1GB is better than 512MB, since so many people feel that it's so much better.

-MrD
So we're all simply victims of the placebo effect? What evidence do you have that 1GB is NOT better than 512Mb?

Traditional benchmarks aren't really ideal for testing appropriate amounts of RAM, but here's a link to one anyways: http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/doom3-cpu_6.html
Granted, the differences aren't enormous until the game is set on Ultra Quality, but the differences are there nonetheless.
 
WuTangClam said:
So we're all simply victims of the placebo effect? What evidence do you have that 1GB is NOT better than 512Mb?

Traditional benchmarks aren't really ideal for testing appropriate amounts of RAM, but here's a link to one anyways: http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/doom3-cpu_6.html
Granted, the differences aren't enormous until the game is set on Ultra Quality, but the differences are there nonetheless.

Is there even any video card/system out there that can play in Ultra Quality right now? It seems like it just backs up my statement that 1GB will be necessary in the future but not right now.

-MrD
 
m3rCyLeSs* |SyNeX said:
One word of advise, Learn common sense.

Dont bother replying to my post, i only registerd on the site and posted to humiliate you

Hahaha and what a fabulous job you did, really. BTW chief, "Learn common sense" is three words. Thanks for coming out though.

-MrD
 
MrDigital said:
Is there even any video card/system out there that can play in Ultra Quality right now? It seems like it just backs up my statement that 1GB will be necessary in the future but not right now.

-MrD
As the many nvidia fans would love to point out, my system isn't even ideal for Doom 3 and it runs just fine at ultra quality. I agree with you that 1GB is not absoulutely necessary right at the moment, but saying that 512MB is no better than 1GB and that the extra memory is a "waste" is just absurd.
 
I was suprised to find that 512MB doesn't cut it any more. Sure you can get by on 512MB, but 1 GB helps speed up things and I don't notice lag nearly as much as I did with 512MB.
I try not to game as much as possible but I can't help myself sometimes especially with Doom3 comming out. After getting it I had huge amounts of lag when opening doors and at other points where it was unenjoyable. I put in 1GB not expecting much, but found that my PC is much better and not just in Doom. I don't know if going from single channel to dual made the difference or what but it was a very worth while upgrade.
 
m3rCyLeSs* |SyNeX said:
You must be Illiterate, cant u read what i said?

Im not sure if he can, But I did :p

think this thread has been hashed far enough
and since you just registered to flame MrDigital
and since the thread is now lock
Im sure your leaving is no great loss
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top