The 10-Second Tax Return

I'm a bit lost at this....

How would a flat tax system benefit the wealthy more than the poor? First time I've heard the term progressive taxation, but I'm going to guess that it means the more you get the bigger the percent you pay? (the system we have now) I think the flat tax system would work well because it would put everyone on the same field with the same rules. When you separate like you currently do, it tends to create groups who'll then do things to benefit only their group. It also creates the sense that because you're more successful, you have to pay out more. And when you feel like you're being attacked, naturally you start to think you're singled out and so find ways to subvert it.
Yes and no. Someone making 300k taxable pays the same taxes as someone making 40k taxable... For the first 40k. As you go up in brackets it doesn't reset and your are taxed at the higher % for the whole nut, only thw amount that is on top of the prev bracket... So many people dont get this, is somewhat scary. Flat tax is catastrophic, like the other poster said, it would hit middle income and down very hard.
 
No, I get that there are brackets and that it increases tax for the income in the bracket. It's a bit weird, so I get why some people don't understand that part. But simplified, it could be said that, the more you get the more you pay.

And the 999 plan was retarded.
 
See, you're looking at it with the hard numbers rather than percentage. Personally I think it's better to have the same percentage all around. And have the minimum income rise, with the inflation, afaik, it's been stagnant despite the inflation, which causes that scenario.
He was applying a 10% tax in both scenarios as an example. That is where his "hard numbers" came from. Though pre-tax income at minimum wage would actually be about $1,256.67 a month, 10% of which is $125.67.
 
No, I get that there are brackets and that it increases tax for the income in the bracket. It's a bit weird, so I get why some people don't understand that part. But simplified, it could be said that, the more you get the more you pay.

And the 999 plan was retarded.
Yeah, but that part is key... People take make a little more act as if their income just evaporates and don't actually have a better life than someone making less... And also as if they pay all this taxes that no one else pays.
 
Lets get real about the so called FLAT TAX. It will never happen for one good reason.
The corrupt politicians are controlled by their rich friends and they themselves are all rich. They know a flat tax would hurt the rich more than the poor. With no deductions or loopholes the rich would be screwed even at a flat tax of 10%.
 
Lets get real about the so called FLAT TAX. It will never happen for one good reason.
The corrupt politicians are controlled by their rich friends and they themselves are all rich. They know a flat tax would hurt the rich more than the poor. With no deductions or loopholes the rich would be screwed even at a flat tax of 10%.
It's actually the opposite. I once did the math using census data (10ish years ago), and if we had a real flat tax, everyone would be paying somewhere around 27% tax. This would hurt people with low incomes much more than the rich.
 
He was applying a 10% tax in both scenarios as an example. That is where his "hard numbers" came from. Though pre-tax income at minimum wage would actually be about $1,256.67 a month, 10% of which is $125.67.
But that's what I'm saying, I don't see how that's fair. If it's fair, it should be fair for everyone. You shouldn't be thinking, it's fair because I have less to pay, so it's alright. I'm not saying it's great. The current system, if it worked with none of the loopholes benefits me a lot more but if it were to be against me, I would definitely have the lets get them because they made more money mentality.

Yeah, but that part is key... People take make a little more act as if their income just evaporates and don't actually have a better life than someone making less... And also as if they pay all this taxes that no one else pays.
Well, it always feels that way when money is taken from you.
 
Minus the whole drag on the economy factor of preparing taxes, which is utterly gigantic... Guvments in general like to smear their happily moving along economies in other guvment's faces. Also, how much $$ do they actually make with fines/compliance versus the labor of investigating/prosecuting said fines/compliance?

Don't answer, you're just going to tell me that the government's sole purpose is to propagate more government.

Nope, not going to say that. Federal government is technically broke, though, so they are trying to collect money any way they can. That's what I'm referring to.
 
The problem is with the definition of "rich"

I ain't going to lie - I do well for myself, but I work my balls off for it. But I wouldn't consider myself "rich." I grew up pretty poor, and earned everything I have by myself. I have a nice house, I can afford toys like games, stereos, and phones, and I can go out to dinner with my family without sweating the bills at the end of the month. But I'm driving around in a cheap Camry, I shop frugally, and I don't buy new cars and phones every single year.

However, my income used to be considered "ultra rich" and I still get taxed that way even though I'm not living like Warren Buffett. Alternative minimum tax kicks me in the nuts every year, and takes away all my legitimate deductions that everyone else gets to claim (student loans, child exemptions, daycare, - these are big deductions). My wife and I withhold @ single 0 rates on our W4 and often end up still owing taxes on April 15th. I paid just short of $100,000 in TAXES this year. ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS - let that sink in for a moment...

It's complete bullshit. I don't have offshore loopholes like the ultra rich do. I'm just upper middle class, paying through the nose for the same government services the "poor" receive. We drive the same roads, I pay more than my fair share of the healthcare bill, the government gives equally zero F&%ks about me and everyone else who isn't a billionaire, and I get the same services as everyone else (police, fire, etc.) Like many people, I have no idea how I'm going to pay for my two kid's college educations... So, when people here say a flat tax only benefits the "rich" - recognize that's probably not really true. It benefits regular people like me quite a bit, and anyone in their 20s and early 30s will most likely find themselves in my situation in 15-20 years. A flat tax means a burger flipper at McDonald's has to pay another $300 per year (OMG he might have to skip this year's Iphone release - plenty of money for toys, but the $300 bucks is going to kill him), meanwhile - it's half a year's worth, or more, of a college tuition bill for one of my kids.

Sorry - just not buying the bellyaching for the poor. Get a better job, work a few extra shifts, cook at home a little more, ditch one of your toys that you shouldn't even have in the first place because you're not covering your basic necessities.

/rant off
 
Flat tax does not hurt people. Everyone should contribute. The guy making 400 a week pays 40 bucks. The guy making 4000 a week pays 400. That's fair. I have lived in the poorest areas in the country. Welfare fraud was massively rampant. People collecting in multiple states at the same time. Scamming the system to get smokes and things on welfare dime. I'm not going to go on but there should be lifetime time limits on welfare. It's a safety net meant to help when the world around you crashes not a hammock to get comfortable in "just getting by".

Every flat tax I've seen has been in the 10-15% range. The lowest income bracket is already 10%. The highest is 39.6% at around $415k. A flat tax would be a gigantic blowjob to the wealthy, and have little or no effect on the poor and lower middle class. Now, where are you going to make up that extra income? You would either have to increase the debt by a massive amount, or you would have to cut spending A LOT. And no, getting rid of things like welfare which are a tiny fraction of the budget will not help. You would have to gut the military, social security, and medicare to do it. And the people I see proposing these retarded flat tax schemes would never do such a thing, and often want to INCREASE spending in those areas. The numbers don't add up. In reality, the flat tax rate would have to be MUCH higher in order to be revenue neutral, and even then it would still be regressive.

Welfare is NOT the problem. People need to quit searching for penny's when we are losing dollars elsewhere.
 
I'm a bit lost at this....

How would a flat tax system benefit the wealthy more than the poor? First time I've heard the term progressive taxation, but I'm going to guess that it means the more you get the bigger the percent you pay? (the system we have now) I think the flat tax system would work well because it would put everyone on the same field with the same rules. When you separate like you currently do, it tends to create groups who'll then do things to benefit only their group. It also creates the sense that because you're more successful, you have to pay out more. And when you feel like you're being attacked, naturally you start to think you're singled out and so find ways to subvert it.

See my reply above this one. It would result in a massive tax cut to the rich, and little or no tax cut (and probably an increase) to the poor and middle class. There is a reason why these wealthy politicians are pushing for it. They would get a huge tax cut for themselves and for their corporate donors.

Don't forget, the wealthiest of the wealthy typically already pay a LOWER tax rate than you and me, because they derive most or all of their income from capital gains, and they do not pay FICA taxes since they aren't getting a normal pay check. Millionaires already have a flat tax since the progressive tax brackets stop at a much lower amount compared to their income.
 
That's why there should be a flat tax. It's simpler, and easier to spot that someone didn't do it or didn't do it correctly. With such a simple system, I would think that loopholes should disappear.

I also think that some government stuff should be made smaller or receive less funding, but that's a different thing altogether.

No it is NOT simpler, unless you are a retard at math and can't use a calculator. I can calculate my tax burden in about 10-15 seconds. 99.9999999999% of the time in doing a tax return is on the DEDUCTION side of things, which flat taxes have nothing to do with.
 
The problem with all the tax systems is that everyone thinks someone else should be paying the taxes, not them. If you're making $30K / year, then someone making $60K is rich and they should be paying all the taxes.... The $60K guy says it should be those making more than $100K, etc., etc. No matter how much you make, rich always seems to mean 'someone making more than you are'. I know people making $250K (or more) / year and they're living paycheck-to-paycheck. Those 'rich people' think it's a crime for them to pay as much in taxes as they do when a large percentage of the country effectively pays nothing in federal income taxes (NOTE THAT I'M NOT SAYING THEY DON'T PAY TAXES - - JUST NO FEDERAL INCOME TAXES).

Personally, I think tax systems should and will stay 'progressive' in some fashion. I do think higher earners should pay in more than those making less... HOWEVER, everyone should be paying something in taxes as they're using the system and getting benefits from it.
 
The problem with that is that it acts regressively as the poor get punished by it. Food and rent are much larger percentages of a poor person's income than to the wealthy. Those percentages can make or break some households.

That's why we need a consumption tax (sales) but exempt packaged food, housing and used items that were taxed when they were originally sold.
Poor households wouldn't pay much in taxes since food/housing is their major expense, meanwhile that drug dealer will be paying taxes on the guns and fancy cars he buys.
 
No it is NOT simpler, unless you are a retard at math and can't use a calculator. I can calculate my tax burden in about 10-15 seconds. 99.9999999999% of the time in doing a tax return is on the DEDUCTION side of things, which flat taxes have nothing to do with.


Actually most flat tax proposals eliminate most or all deductions, so you would be eliminating that 99.99999999999% of the time doing the deductions on your taxes.
 
However, I'm also pragmatic and thus base my views on how I see the real world operate. Wealth redistribution by the government does not work. Too many people manipulate the welfare system, so I believe welfare needs to be scaled back greatly. Actually, too many people manipulate the system in general, and with computer tracking of information, there should be no reason why most abuse goes undetected. Minimum wage raises do not work unless they rise the same rate as inflation, and aren't meant for supporting a family anyways. The minimum wage was supposed to prevent teen workers from being taken advantage of. The amount of resources and technology available to us will never be able to support our population with a moderately decent standard of living. All raising the minimum wage would do is put people into higher tax brackets while their adjusted real wages remain the same, and their adjusted spending power actually decreases due to the real higher taxes. The capitalist, restricted democratic republic world is the best system I see for the real world.

False on so many counts. "wealth redistribution" is always looked at negatively when it's taken from the rich and given to the poor. But it's NEVER seen as a negative when it goes the other direction, which is what we have now. If you are against wealth redistribution, then you should be for much more and much higher tax brackets to keep in line with the top income levels. The rich have altered the system using their money and influence so redistribute wealth from the middle class up to them.

As I said before, welfare is NOT the problem. It's a tiny part of the overall budget. You could eliminate it tomorrow and it wouldn't do dick to your tax burden. Yes there is abuse, but it would cost way more to reduce it than you would ever save. Not to mention, that "abuse" is people buying things they probably shouldn't, which actually stimulates the economy. You give $1000 to a poor person, it gets spent immediately. You give that money to a hedge fund manager, and it's going to sit in a bank account somewhere (probably offshore) and do NOTHING for the economy.

And minimum wage absolutely should provide a minimum standard of living. If you are earning minimum wage, you are likely on welfare too because you can't afford to live otherwise. Not everyone can be a doctor or programmer or engineer or teacher or whatever else. There will always be people who cannot earn much more than the minimum no matter how much you yell at them for being lazy. So why should Walmart get to benefit from dirt cheap labor and earn billions in profits, while us the tax payers have to subsidize Walmart employees via welfare? If you are truly against welfare, then you should be for an increase in the minimum wage.
 
Nope, not going to say that. Federal government is technically broke, though, so they are trying to collect money any way they can. That's what I'm referring to.

No they are not "broke". As long as we can service our debt (which we can, easily), then it's a non issue. The debt is just a meaningless number. You can't equate government budgets to household budgets, it does not work that way. We are a monetary sovereign nation. We can wipe out the debt with the stroke of a pen. Our credit rating is perfect. It's quite literally impossible for us to go bankrupt.
 
And minimum wage absolutely should provide a minimum standard of living. If you are earning minimum wage, you are likely on welfare too because you can't afford to live otherwise. Not everyone can be a doctor or programmer or engineer or teacher or whatever else.

I noticed you didn't include manual labor in your point there. Manual labor pays way over Minimum wage. Problem is to many think they are too good to do it these days. Minimum wage is not meant to be a living wage for a family. But I'm stopping there this is heading for the soapbox.
 
That's why we need a consumption tax (sales) but exempt packaged food, housing and used items that were taxed when they were originally sold.
Poor households wouldn't pay much in taxes since food/housing is their major expense, meanwhile that drug dealer will be paying taxes on the guns and fancy cars he buys.

So you want to kill the economy. Brilliant.
 
Actually most flat tax proposals eliminate most or all deductions, so you would be eliminating that 99.99999999999% of the time doing the deductions on your taxes.

The deductions are there for a reason. They encourage certain behaviors. I'm sure we could simplify them, but eliminating them would be stupid. And that still has nothing to do with a flat tax. You could get rid of all the deductions and still have progressive tax rates. If a flat tax proposal also includes elimination of all deductions, then they are talking about 2 separate things.
 
I noticed you didn't include manual labor in your point there. Manual labor pays way over Minimum wage. Problem is to many think they are too good to do it these days. Minimum wage is not meant to be a living wage for a family. But I'm stopping there this is heading for the soapbox.

Not everyone can do manual labor. Tons of people on welfare are disabled or elderly. Most of them still work a job. This myth that people on welfare are just leeches who are perfectly capable of working but choose not to needs to stop. That's a tiny fraction of them and it doesn't freaking matter when we have a military budget the size that we do. There is rampant fraud and abuse and waste within the military. We could eliminate all of that without reducing our defense capabilities one bit, and it would pay for all of welfare and then some. People are focusing so much on non-issues because they are being told to by the people who benefit the most from waste in other areas of the government. Rich people have the middle class convinced that all of their problems are caused by poor people. Think about it. POOR people are the ones taking all the money. Doesn't that sound a bit ridiculous to you?
 
No they are not "broke". As long as we can service our debt (which we can, easily), then it's a non issue. The debt is just a meaningless number. You can't equate government budgets to household budgets, it does not work that way. We are a monetary sovereign nation. We can wipe out the debt with the stroke of a pen. Our credit rating is perfect. It's quite literally impossible for us to go bankrupt.

So if the U.S. owes more than it's taking in, it's not broke? Seriously? If the U.S. wasn't getting money from China by selling Treasuries to them, the U.S. govt. is done.
 
The problem is with the definition of "rich"

I ain't going to lie - I do well for myself, but I work my balls off for it. But I wouldn't consider myself "rich." I grew up pretty poor, and earned everything I have by myself. I have a nice house, I can afford toys like games, stereos, and phones, and I can go out to dinner with my family without sweating the bills at the end of the month. But I'm driving around in a cheap Camry, I shop frugally, and I don't buy new cars and phones every single year.

However, my income used to be considered "ultra rich" and I still get taxed that way even though I'm not living like Warren Buffett. Alternative minimum tax kicks me in the nuts every year, and takes away all my legitimate deductions that everyone else gets to claim (student loans, child exemptions, daycare, - these are big deductions). My wife and I withhold @ single 0 rates on our W4 and often end up still owing taxes on April 15th. I paid just short of $100,000 in TAXES this year. ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS - let that sink in for a moment...

It's complete bullshit. I don't have offshore loopholes like the ultra rich do. I'm just upper middle class, paying through the nose for the same government services the "poor" receive. We drive the same roads, I pay more than my fair share of the healthcare bill, the government gives equally zero F&%ks about me and everyone else who isn't a billionaire, and I get the same services as everyone else (police, fire, etc.) Like many people, I have no idea how I'm going to pay for my two kid's college educations... So, when people here say a flat tax only benefits the "rich" - recognize that's probably not really true. It benefits regular people like me quite a bit, and anyone in their 20s and early 30s will most likely find themselves in my situation in 15-20 years. A flat tax means a burger flipper at McDonald's has to pay another $300 per year (OMG he might have to skip this year's Iphone release - plenty of money for toys, but the $300 bucks is going to kill him), meanwhile - it's half a year's worth, or more, of a college tuition bill for one of my kids.

Sorry - just not buying the bellyaching for the poor. Get a better job, work a few extra shifts, cook at home a little more, ditch one of your toys that you shouldn't even have in the first place because you're not covering your basic necessities.

/rant off
Not that im going to cry you a river here, but AMT can be a problem if left without being adjusted for inflation.. At 100k in taxes you are probably past that issue several times over.
 
False on so many counts. "wealth redistribution" is always looked at negatively when it's taken from the rich and given to the poor. But it's NEVER seen as a negative when it goes the other direction, which is what we have now. If you are against wealth redistribution, then you should be for much more and much higher tax brackets to keep in line with the top income levels. The rich have altered the system using their money and influence so redistribute wealth from the middle class up to them.

As I said before, welfare is NOT the problem. It's a tiny part of the overall budget. You could eliminate it tomorrow and it wouldn't do dick to your tax burden. Yes there is abuse, but it would cost way more to reduce it than you would ever save. Not to mention, that "abuse" is people buying things they probably shouldn't, which actually stimulates the economy. You give $1000 to a poor person, it gets spent immediately. You give that money to a hedge fund manager, and it's going to sit in a bank account somewhere (probably offshore) and do NOTHING for the economy.

And minimum wage absolutely should provide a minimum standard of living. If you are earning minimum wage, you are likely on welfare too because you can't afford to live otherwise. Not everyone can be a doctor or programmer or engineer or teacher or whatever else. There will always be people who cannot earn much more than the minimum no matter how much you yell at them for being lazy. So why should Walmart get to benefit from dirt cheap labor and earn billions in profits, while us the tax payers have to subsidize Walmart employees via welfare? If you are truly against welfare, then you should be for an increase in the minimum wage.

The only "idle rich" are those that inherit their money. And if they don't work hard and smart with that money, they lose it quickly. I don't see it as wealth redistribution when someone works harder and smarter than someone else and is compensated more for it.

The abuse of welfare is an example of the abuse of the system. Abuse of the system in general is the problem. And the abuse falls on the two extremes, the lower middle class and the poor, and the very wealthy. The lower middle class and the poor make a significant part of the population. Securing those votes means catering to what those people want. However, politicians need (want) the support of the rich in order to finance their agenda and lifestyle. Thus they have to cater to the very wealthy as well. And what you end up with is a system that redistributes the wealth from the upper-middle class and middle-middle class to the very wealthy and the poor. Well, more like the very wealthy keep their money and the wealth goes from the upper-middle and middle-middle to the lower-middle and the poor.

Ask yourself why the hedge fund manager doesn't invest that money. Investing money creates jobs and has a high potential of earning money for the investor. We should be encouraging people to invest money into the economy, not discouraging them from doing so.

I am not against welfare. I am against the current scope of our welfare system. If you have been working hard and fall on hard times, fine, receive some help. But if you get married too early and have kids too early before you can properly support your family, that's on you. I should not have to pay for your poor life choices.

Also, as I said, the other problem about minimum wages is that it pushes everyone's wages up into higher tax brackets, but the tax brackets don't shift to adjust for that. And then you end up with an even worse situation than before, but the poor are happy because they get marginally higher wages for 2 years, and then the economy catches up and they're even poorer than before.

The deductions are there for a reason. They encourage certain behaviors. I'm sure we could simplify them, but eliminating them would be stupid. And that still has nothing to do with a flat tax. You could get rid of all the deductions and still have progressive tax rates. If a flat tax proposal also includes elimination of all deductions, then they are talking about 2 separate things.

Like what? Have more kids to get more welfare/deductions? Donate to charity to hide your money from the government?

Not everyone can do manual labor. Tons of people on welfare are disabled or elderly. Most of them still work a job. This myth that people on welfare are just leeches who are perfectly capable of working but choose not to needs to stop. That's a tiny fraction of them and it doesn't freaking matter when we have a military budget the size that we do. There is rampant fraud and abuse and waste within the military. We could eliminate all of that without reducing our defense capabilities one bit, and it would pay for all of welfare and then some. People are focusing so much on non-issues because they are being told to by the people who benefit the most from waste in other areas of the government. Rich people have the middle class convinced that all of their problems are caused by poor people. Think about it. POOR people are the ones taking all the money. Doesn't that sound a bit ridiculous to you?

The elderly should be taken care of by social security, not welfare, and that is an entirely different system that also needs fixing. There may be a lot of disabled people, but they're a small percentage numerically. Additionally, physical disabilities do not preclude you from jobs that purely use your brain.

There is a lot of rampant fraud and waste in all parts of the government, not just defense. All of it should be weeded out. Sure, we can weed it out in the military, and maybe it can pay for welfare as you claim. However, why not weed it out in welfare and military, and lower overall taxes? Surely that isn't too logical for you?
 
So if the U.S. owes more than it's taking in, it's not broke? Seriously? If the U.S. wasn't getting money from China by selling Treasuries to them, the U.S. govt. is done.
Us government is broke.. Like super broke... Servicing the debt is huge expense even at historic lows... This shit will breakdown at some point.. I can't even see it as a question.. Dollar is propped up by our military... Question is how long every other nation will put up with it, and what will happen when they slowly don't.
 
But that's what I'm saying, I don't see how that's fair. If it's fair, it should be fair for everyone. You shouldn't be thinking, it's fair because I have less to pay, so it's alright. I'm not saying it's great. The current system, if it worked with none of the loopholes benefits me a lot more but if it were to be against me, I would definitely have the lets get them because they made more money mentality.
You have to consider what percentage of your income goes to living expenses. For those living in poverty it can be close 100% most of the time. As your wage goes up the proportion of your living expenses to your wage goes down. The question is how much does the income tax impact whatever money you have left over after factoring in your living expenses and lifestyle choices. So to the person making $200k a month in the example having $100,000 left over before taxes, will have $80,000 left after the 10% flat tax. Considering the expenses not factored into the person earning minimum wage, I would imagine that person would have nothing left after that 10% tax is taken out, or even be in the red. Now I don't care how you live your life; $80,000 is a hell of a lot of extra money to have available at the end of every month. This is what everyone means by a flat tax disproportionately affecting the poor, working and middle classes.
 
False on so many counts. "wealth redistribution" is always looked at negatively when it's taken from the rich and given to the poor. But it's NEVER seen as a negative when it goes the other direction, which is what we have now. If you are against wealth redistribution, then you should be for much more and much higher tax brackets to keep in line with the top income levels. The rich have altered the system using their money and influence so redistribute wealth from the middle class up to them.

As I said before, welfare is NOT the problem. It's a tiny part of the overall budget. You could eliminate it tomorrow and it wouldn't do dick to your tax burden. Yes there is abuse, but it would cost way more to reduce it than you would ever save. Not to mention, that "abuse" is people buying things they probably shouldn't, which actually stimulates the economy. You give $1000 to a poor person, it gets spent immediately. You give that money to a hedge fund manager, and it's going to sit in a bank account somewhere (probably offshore) and do NOTHING for the economy.

And minimum wage absolutely should provide a minimum standard of living. If you are earning minimum wage, you are likely on welfare too because you can't afford to live otherwise. Not everyone can be a doctor or programmer or engineer or teacher or whatever else. There will always be people who cannot earn much more than the minimum no matter how much you yell at them for being lazy. So why should Walmart get to benefit from dirt cheap labor and earn billions in profits, while us the tax payers have to subsidize Walmart employees via welfare? If you are truly against welfare, then you should be for an increase in the minimum wage.

First off: Wealth disparity wouldn't be nearly the issue if we didn't live in a global economy. Sure, fewer people own more of the money / assets, but we're all guilty of causing that. Companies are merging and growing into international behemoths.... and driving down costs and therefore competition by doing so. Smaller companies can't compete when there's not enough money in there to make a profit. If a large company sells 50,000 widgets a day and makes $2 per widget, they can find a way to make money. If a small company can only sell 1,000 widgets a day, then that same $2 profit per widget (in order to compete with the behemoth) doesn't make it profitable enough to take the risks. Technology means that those same massive companies are run by fewer and fewer people (as a percentage of the workers). If 50 small companies each have a CEO making $200k per year and have 10,000 total employees, then one international 'behemoth' company having 1 CEO making $10 million per year (and having the same 10,000 employees) isn't any different. That $10 million dollar CEO is getting the same paycheck per employee as the 50 small company CEO's would have.

2nd: Welfare is 6% of the federal budget. It's huge! --- Your argument on the $1000 and the hedge fund manager is pretty ludicrous also. As a percentage of this countries population, the number of hedge fund managers wouldn't fill up a large high school. Give that same $1000 back to the family making $75,000 (that paid it in the first place) and that family would spend it just as efficiently towards stimulating the economy as any poor person would.

3rd: Raising the minimum wage is a temporary fix (very temporary). If I have an employee making $10 per hour, and have to raise him to $15, then it's a good bet that my other employees making $13 are going to want to be making $18 (or more) also. As everyone's wages get ratcheted up, then everything we buy also start costing more to absorb those additional wage costs. Going back to the first point, technology isn't going to sit still either. If an employee that now costs $30K per year starts costing you $45K per year (don't forget about benefits), then how long will it take before some 'behemoth' company comes up with a $45k robot or piece of software that will replace some of those higher priced employees. Already a lot of stores have self-check-out lanes to cut down on the number of cashiers they need. That trend is going to do nothing but accelerate. We may end up paying some people more, but the number of unemployed people will probably climb also. I have a hard time believing a newly unemployed person (due to being replaced / outsourced) is going to be cheering that higher minimum wage when that happens.

Lastly - You talked about it being impossible for us to go broke because we can wipe out our debt with a pen... You do realize that only 40% of our debt is held by other countries / people? The other 60% is held by our own citizens and companies (banks). Just about everyone that has a mutual fund probably has some small part of their money in US treasury debt. You also don't watch the news much.... Try reading up on what's happening in Venezuela right now. They can print their own money and can technically wipe out their debt with a pen also. Look into how well that power is working for them.
 
Nope, not going to say that. Federal government is technically broke, though, so they are trying to collect money any way they can. That's what I'm referring to.

Ah, thank goodness you didn't go that direction, as my forehead wouldn't have enjoyed that beating. That's fair, although with the IRS tragically understaffed, it's an unfortunate academic point.

Tsumi--my motivation on this thread was quite clear as to not have a political bent, and I went out of my way to keep it that way. I find a certain value in helping people understand the constraints of the civic system, so, whether they have a different philosophy to my own, that at least we're coming from an equal understanding of the situation. And describing, in pure terms, what a flat tax system is (and what benefits/detractions it may confer) and what a marginal/progressive tax system is (and what benefits/detractions it may confer) seems an important starting point.
 
Us government is broke.. Like super broke... Servicing the debt is huge expense even at historic lows... This shit will breakdown at some point.. I can't even see it as a question.. Dollar is propped up by our military... Question is how long every other nation will put up with it, and what will happen when they slowly don't.


The US is a colossal debt mess.... But most other countries are in even worse shape. With crap like Japan and Europe adopting negative interest rates, there isn't going to be a shortage of buyers for US debt in the near term. At least we're paying 'something' in interest. If US interest rates actually normalized to historical levels, then paying interest on our debt would be almost impossible. Our interest payments on our current debt is almost the same as our Welfare costs. If interest rates rose to 4 or 5%, our debt service payments (just interest, no principal pay down) would be equal or higher than the defense department budget.

The earlier argument stating "the amount of our debt is meaningless" doesn't work on so many levels. Not even dealing with our Medicare / Medicaid / SS obligations (40 cents of every dollar our government spends is borrowed), we, as a country, run a $40 billion dollar trade deficit each and every month. Printing money or writing off our debt means that inflation eventually runs rampant and that nobody will be willing to take our IOU on that oil or load of TV's we want to buy. Who's going to give us $100 in goods if they know we're only going to pay them back 75 cents due to inflation... or just write their debt off entirely? Taking 'the pen' to our debt (erasing it) only works once. At that point nobody will give us a 2nd chance to do it again.
 
Minus the whole drag on the economy factor of preparing taxes, which is utterly gigantic... Guvments in general like to smear their happily moving along economies in other guvment's faces. Also, how much $$ do they actually make with fines/compliance versus the labor of investigating/prosecuting said fines/compliance?

Don't answer, you're just going to tell me that the government's sole purpose is to propagate more government.

Meh, it's government slash every business and interest group ever lobbying for their loophole
 
Stop, please. China has actually been offloading US treasuries lately, and somehow despite 8 years of Armageddon predictions, somehow we're still here..

As China Dumps Treasuries, World Sees No Better Place for Refuge

My personal conspiracy theory is that the Fed is actually starting to raise our interest rates (very slowly) precisely because of other countries (notably China) starting to sell some of their treasuries. With 40% of our governments' budget being financed as debt, they need to make sure there are buyers out there. I suspect there's going to be some sort of manufactured 'banking crisis' in the next couple of years that requires banks to hold more of their cash assets in reserve... in treasury bonds. That will make sure the banks stay buyers of US government debt as more an more foreign governments get out of owning our debt.
 
The problem with all the tax systems is that everyone thinks someone else should be paying the taxes, not them. If you're making $30K / year, then someone making $60K is rich and they should be paying all the taxes.... The $60K guy says it should be those making more than $100K, etc., etc. No matter how much you make, rich always seems to mean 'someone making more than you are'. I know people making $250K (or more) / year and they're living paycheck-to-paycheck. Those 'rich people' think it's a crime for them to pay as much in taxes as they do when a large percentage of the country effectively pays nothing in federal income taxes (NOTE THAT I'M NOT SAYING THEY DON'T PAY TAXES - - JUST NO FEDERAL INCOME TAXES).

Personally, I think tax systems should and will stay 'progressive' in some fashion. I do think higher earners should pay in more than those making less... HOWEVER, everyone should be paying something in taxes as they're using the system and getting benefits from it.
The difference is the stress when you're only in the 15k a year or less bracket becomes larger than anything you have to face at higher levels. People making 60k, 100k, 250k, all have many, MANY more options than people at the bottom. If you're bringing in 250k and can't make ends meet, that means you don't want to downgrade from the comfortable lifestyle you're accustomed to, the end. Depending on what part of the country you're in and what your situation is, the same is true of 60k and in some cases even 30k. The lower you go though, the more you run into situations where you're basically looking at a slow death via exposure, malnutrition, lack of health care, etc. because your income just can't cover basic amenities no matter how good your budgeting is. You have to make choices between what is more important, rent, or going to a dentist. The idea is people at that level are getting beat up enough already without having to shake them down for pennies on top of that. Everyone else can find ways to adapt.

The problem is with the definition of "rich"

I ain't going to lie - I do well for myself, but I work my balls off for it. But I wouldn't consider myself "rich." I grew up pretty poor, and earned everything I have by myself. I have a nice house, I can afford toys like games, stereos, and phones, and I can go out to dinner with my family without sweating the bills at the end of the month. But I'm driving around in a cheap Camry, I shop frugally, and I don't buy new cars and phones every single year.

However, my income used to be considered "ultra rich" and I still get taxed that way even though I'm not living like Warren Buffett. Alternative minimum tax kicks me in the nuts every year, and takes away all my legitimate deductions that everyone else gets to claim (student loans, child exemptions, daycare, - these are big deductions). My wife and I withhold @ single 0 rates on our W4 and often end up still owing taxes on April 15th. I paid just short of $100,000 in TAXES this year. ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS - let that sink in for a moment...

It's complete bullshit. I don't have offshore loopholes like the ultra rich do. I'm just upper middle class, paying through the nose for the same government services the "poor" receive. We drive the same roads, I pay more than my fair share of the healthcare bill, the government gives equally zero F&%ks about me and everyone else who isn't a billionaire, and I get the same services as everyone else (police, fire, etc.) Like many people, I have no idea how I'm going to pay for my two kid's college educations... So, when people here say a flat tax only benefits the "rich" - recognize that's probably not really true. It benefits regular people like me quite a bit, and anyone in their 20s and early 30s will most likely find themselves in my situation in 15-20 years. A flat tax means a burger flipper at McDonald's has to pay another $300 per year (OMG he might have to skip this year's Iphone release - plenty of money for toys, but the $300 bucks is going to kill him), meanwhile - it's half a year's worth, or more, of a college tuition bill for one of my kids.

Sorry - just not buying the bellyaching for the poor. Get a better job, work a few extra shifts, cook at home a little more, ditch one of your toys that you shouldn't even have in the first place because you're not covering your basic necessities.

/rant off
Great, another "I worked hard at my job and have money, therefore the existence of responsible poor people who also work hard is impossible" post.

nutzo said:
That's why we need a consumption tax (sales) but exempt packaged food, housing and used items that were taxed when they were originally sold.
Poor households wouldn't pay much in taxes since food/housing is their major expense, meanwhile that drug dealer will be paying taxes on the guns and fancy cars he buys.
That still hits the middle class harder than the rich, since they spend more of their income, but as long as food and basic living expenses are exempted, that would be a hell of a lot better than a flat tax. I tend to look at it from the perspective of who gets hit the hardest.
 
I do not support this idea. I also don't support tax withholdings. For one thing, it's an interest-free loan to the government, but more importantly, paying your taxes should be excruciatingly painful. Nobody should celebrate getting a tax refund, which was their money to begin with. They should instead feel pissed off because they have to write a big ass check every year. The more time it takes, the more time you have to consider all the ways the government is wasting your money.

paying your taxes should be excruciatingly painful? Nobody should celebrate getting a tax refund? should instead feel pissed off?

Who got sand in your vagina?

My favorite part of this wonderful romp though a rant of cognitive dissonance is the final line. You suggest that the best solution to combat wasted money is to make sure that the process also wastes your time. Brilliant!
 
Lets get real about the so called FLAT TAX. It will never happen for one good reason.
The corrupt politicians are controlled by their rich friends and they themselves are all rich. They know a flat tax would hurt the rich more than the poor. With no deductions or loopholes the rich would be screwed even at a flat tax of 10%.

This is pretty much completely backwards. Flat tax rates are regressive and hurt poor more than rich.

Loopholes are a problem though, and they are currently preventing our progressive tax system from being fair. Because of this, the largest burden is on the middle (or working) class. The next result is the gap is widening between the upper and middle class and at the same time, pushing the middle class nearer to the lower class (poor).

Sidenote: I find that people conflate the poor with lazy when talking about taxation and trying to discuss merits of any given system. Poor people are perceived as takers in these debates... this is kind of what the rich want you to think.... the poors only survive because the rich make so much and pay so much in taxes. If you replace "poor" with "middle" or "working" class while talking about tax systems, the facts remain the same, but it is easier to identify who is really fucking who.
 
How about make it a 0-second tax return? Flat tax. I even wanted flat tax when I worked for a major tax preparation company.


Flat tax is the way to go. That way nobody gets out of paying their taxes.
 
I'm not going to go on but there should be lifetime time limits on welfare. It's a safety net meant to help when the world around you crashes not a hammock to get comfortable in "just getting by".
PRWORA placed five year lifetime limits on welfare back in '96. Your sources need to update their information.
 
I'm a bit lost at this....

How would a flat tax system benefit the wealthy more than the poor? First time I've heard the term progressive taxation, but I'm going to guess that it means the more you get the bigger the percent you pay? (the system we have now) I think the flat tax system would work well because it would put everyone on the same field with the same rules. When you separate like you currently do, it tends to create groups who'll then do things to benefit only their group. It also creates the sense that because you're more successful, you have to pay out more. And when you feel like you're being attacked, naturally you start to think you're singled out and so find ways to subvert it.
A flat tax will increase taxes on everyone making less than the median income and give as much as a 62% cut for the wealthiest.
I don't know your income, but at a certain point, you'd have to work hard to spend the money you make. Go ahead, taking 10 or 20 million a year and tell me how you're going to spend it all.
A progressive scheme (which is what we've had for all of our lives) means that you leave more money in those making less. They in turn spend that money, which drives the economy.

I've got friends/family making 250k+ and they just put most of it away, because they don't have anything to spend it on. Yes, you could buy 3rd or 4th house, shop at Tiffany's regularly, maybe get a few Gucci bags, but eventually, you've got everything you want.

In the meantime, the lower half of wage earners (who are already struggling) have even less money to buy things they need to survive.
 
999.jpg


#neverforget
Talk about a huge tax increase for those with less money. For someone making 20k/year, they'll be paying 18% in taxes. Currently that person is probably paying less than 9%. This is a great plan if you've got a lot of money. It sucks if you don't.
 
Back
Top