Tesla Hits First Profitable Quarter Ever

You know I just don't find it fun to be stuck out in crummy weather. Then Musk decides he needs to go on he offensive.
http://arstechnica.com/business/2013/02/tesla-new-york-times-trade-shots-over-coverage/
Also they're untrustworthy because of the lease deals which would make old Madoff blush.

Oh...the whole kerfuffle with the reviewer. And yes, the lease deals are being marketed very poorly and their cost to own calculations are lame, but to compare that to Madoff? Sounds more like you've got an axe to grind against Tesla :p
 
This.... also a lot of the expensive to get gas is rather bad for the environment, like in Alberta.

This is true to a certain point but so is getting power from coal. which represents 40% of the generation stack in the US. The idea that this car is green is pretty questionable when you factor in the carbon that is used to get the coal out of the ground transported to your generator and then of course burning it to generate electricity.

Unless you are in a Nat Gas generation region like California or Texas and some others you are actually contributing quite a bit to carbon pollution.
 
How have they already been proven to be untrustworthy?

I think the biggest issue with the Model S is the batteries are easily bricked and cost $40k to replace which is not covered under it's 8 year warranty.

Other than that, I haven't heard of too many issues with the car. I'm in the bay area as well, and there are tons of these things out and about. I know a few folks that have them as well and they love them. The way I see it, if you have the money, may as well pick one up for that geeky factor. But if you can only have 1 car, you are probably better off not going with a Model S.
 
For those with experience with electric cars, how expensive, rather, how much energy does it take to charge them up?
 
For those with experience with electric cars, how expensive, rather, how much energy does it take to charge them up?
well, my friend has driven a volt now for almost a year and says he pays 20-25 bucks a month. He was paying 100-150 bucks a month for gas, previously, but now never needs it :p
 
I think the biggest issue with the Model S is the batteries are easily bricked and cost $40k to replace which is not covered under it's 8 year warranty.
800px-%22Citation_needed%22.jpg


For those with experience with electric cars, how expensive, rather, how much energy does it take to charge them up?
$2-4 for a 100-mile charge. So, estimate (at most) $12 to go 300 miles (the range of the Model S).
 
Well, the "ten years" part is misleading, they were in "stealth development mode" for the first five, only making *ANY* revenue starting in 2008.
 
I bought $2800 worth of TSLA stock on april 30. Up $800 in one day :D
Still has room to rise. It's in a 2010-like AAPL pump mode right now.
 
Crap, hit "Post" too soon. Mods: feel free to merge my posts.)

And they were ready to be profitable solely on the Roadster when they decided instead to invest more heavily in the S, keeping them in the red until now.
 
This is true to a certain point but so is getting power from coal. which represents 40% of the generation stack in the US. The idea that this car is green is pretty questionable when you factor in the carbon that is used to get the coal out of the ground transported to your generator and then of course burning it to generate electricity.

Unless you are in a Nat Gas generation region like California or Texas and some others you are actually contributing quite a bit to carbon pollution.

I calculated the numbers on it once, and it was still better than conventionally powered vehicles.

Petroleum makes up 1% of the power generation that hits the grid in the U.S.
Coal: 44.9%
Natural Gas: 23.4%
Nuclear: 20.3%
Hydroelectric: 6.9%
Other renewables: 3.6%

1.) So, yes, a good portion (66.2%) of the power in the electric grid comes from sources generating air pollution, but still, that is lower than 100%, in a conventional car.

2.) A good portion of that is relatively clean Natural Gas instead of petroleum in a conventional car.

3.) Large scale gas turbines with heat recovery can gain efficiencies in the 60+% range, as compared to 30 to 35% in a typical gasoline car.

4.) Then you have to subtract out transmission losses.

So, while not perfect, electric cars are better than traditional ones, and will become better with time as our grid, and its power composition improves. And if that's not enough for you, you can always sign up for a green power only electric plan (though that will likely cost you a good amount more)
 
Zarathustra[H];1039866278 said:
I calculated the numbers on it once, and it was still better than conventionally powered vehicles.

Petroleum makes up 1% of the power generation that hits the grid in the U.S.
Coal: 44.9%
Natural Gas: 23.4%
Nuclear: 20.3%
Hydroelectric: 6.9%
Other renewables: 3.6%

1.) So, yes, a good portion (66.2%) of the power in the electric grid comes from sources generating air pollution, but still, that is lower than 100%, in a conventional car.

2.) A good portion of that is relatively clean Natural Gas instead of petroleum in a conventional car.

3.) Large scale gas turbines with heat recovery can gain efficiencies in the 60+% range, as compared to 30 to 35% in a typical gasoline car.

4.) Then you have to subtract out transmission losses.

So, while not perfect, electric cars are better than traditional ones, and will become better with time as our grid, and its power composition improves. And if that's not enough for you, you can always sign up for a green power only electric plan (though that will likely cost you a good amount more)


Don't forget that centralized generation is much easier / cheaper to keep clean. Even modern coal plants are much much cleaner then you think, and are sbject to controlls, regulations, reporting and inspections far far beyond ICE vehicles.

on your point 3.) It is not appropriate to compare ICE vehile engine peak effieicies to generation efficiencies. ICE motors spend alot of time wasting energy, idling, braking, running at non-peak effiency. That's why proper comparisons are done on a energy required / energy used basis. (hence MPG-e, which is actually misleading in itself for a couple reasons...)
 
well, my friend has driven a volt now for almost a year and says he pays 20-25 bucks a month. He was paying 100-150 bucks a month for gas, previously, but now never needs it :p

And as I understand it, the Volt is less efficient as it s carting the traditional drivetrain around with it, adding extra weight.

At 12 cents per kwh (national average for off-prime time of use billing) we're talking ~$3.40 in electricity to drive 100 miles.

In an equivalent car (let's choose an M5, getting 17MPG highway using Premium) at the national average price for premium gas ($3.874) driving 100 miles would cost you $23 in gas.

But heck, let's compare it to an econo honda/toyota/malibu thingie getting ~30mpg with regular gas ($3.549 national average). Then we are talking $12 in gas to drive 100 miles.

IMHO that's really not bad.
 
800px-%22Citation_needed%22.jpg


$2-4 for a 100-mile charge. So, estimate (at most) $12 to go 300 miles (the range of the Model S).

Umm.. it's one of the hot topics among Tesla owners.. all you need to do is google Tesla Brick. The problem is when the battery is fully discharged, that is it. Tesla has responded to this saying to always leave your car plugged in each night and has also responded saying that the Model S is much harder to brick than the roadster, but from actual OWNER testing, this is not the case. The Model S while idle consumes significantly more power than the roadster while idle even though Tesla says the Model S can sit idle for 11 months vs I think it was 2 months of the roadster before bricking.

From ACTUAL owners:
http://www.teslamotors.com/forum/forums/battery-drain-model-s-vs-roadster

I know 2 people that own both the roadster and the model S, and one of them has bricked his roadster TWICE! Once right after a charge from one of his homes to work which was about 3 miles away! Granted this was VERY early on in the roadster release when there were problems galore, but the problem IS there. And with the Model S draining faster than what Tesla states in REAL world use, it's a very real issue.

The folks that buy these 100k+ cars don't baby their cars. They are essentially toys for them, and as such, when they go on vacation, they can be left outside unplugged for prolonged periods of time.

That said, the guys I know that have Tesla's still love them and are happy to be 'beta' testing some of the features.. especially in the case of the roadster. Tesla has also taken measures to prevent this issue with the owners. The cars have a call home feature which notifies Tesla when the batteries are low. Tesla then attempts to contact the owner to have them charge their cars.

Anyways, you don't need to believe what I say.. I don't really care. You want to believe what Tesla releases, that's fine. The battery lasts 11 months on idle.
 
Zarathustra[H];1039866278 said:
I calculated the numbers on it once, and it was still better than conventionally powered vehicles.

Petroleum makes up 1% of the power generation that hits the grid in the U.S.
Coal: 44.9%
Natural Gas: 23.4%
Nuclear: 20.3%
Hydroelectric: 6.9%
Other renewables: 3.6%

1.) So, yes, a good portion (66.2%) of the power in the electric grid comes from sources generating air pollution, but still, that is lower than 100%, in a conventional car.

2.) A good portion of that is relatively clean Natural Gas instead of petroleum in a conventional car.

3.) Large scale gas turbines with heat recovery can gain efficiencies in the 60+% range, as compared to 30 to 35% in a typical gasoline car.

4.) Then you have to subtract out transmission losses.

So, while not perfect, electric cars are better than traditional ones, and will become better with time as our grid, and its power composition improves. And if that's not enough for you, you can always sign up for a green power only electric plan (though that will likely cost you a good amount more)

Im in the Nat gas industry, so I wasnt counting Nat gas at all. I was speaking more to the areas in the country where they are predominantly coal only.
 
bah hit post on accident.. but wanted to add that 20% +/- is not predominant.. its a minority.. coal is the elephant in the room environmentalists dont want to mention when talking about how green the electric car is. If we shifted more generation into Nat gas I would agree with you.
 
or nuclear for that matter.. and before the tree huggers come in.. renewables are not sustainable..
 
Anyways, you don't need to believe what I say.. I don't really care. You want to believe what Tesla releases, that's fine. The battery lasts 11 months on idle.
[citation acquired]

Thanks. Learned something new!
 
Umm.. it's one of the hot topics among Tesla owners.. all you need to do is google Tesla Brick. The problem is when the battery is fully discharged, that is it. Tesla has responded to this saying to always leave your car plugged in each night and has also responded saying that the Model S is much harder to brick than the roadster, but from actual OWNER testing, this is not the case. The Model S while idle consumes significantly more power than the roadster while idle even though Tesla says the Model S can sit idle for 11 months vs I think it was 2 months of the roadster before bricking.

From ACTUAL owners:
http://www.teslamotors.com/forum/forums/battery-drain-model-s-vs-roadster

I know 2 people that own both the roadster and the model S, and one of them has bricked his roadster TWICE! Once right after a charge from one of his homes to work which was about 3 miles away! Granted this was VERY early on in the roadster release when there were problems galore, but the problem IS there. And with the Model S draining faster than what Tesla states in REAL world use, it's a very real issue.

The folks that buy these 100k+ cars don't baby their cars. They are essentially toys for them, and as such, when they go on vacation, they can be left outside unplugged for prolonged periods of time.

That said, the guys I know that have Tesla's still love them and are happy to be 'beta' testing some of the features.. especially in the case of the roadster. Tesla has also taken measures to prevent this issue with the owners. The cars have a call home feature which notifies Tesla when the batteries are low. Tesla then attempts to contact the owner to have them charge their cars.

Anyways, you don't need to believe what I say.. I don't really care. You want to believe what Tesla releases, that's fine. The battery lasts 11 months on idle.

and if you dont change the oil in a ICE car youll kill the engine....

nothing new here

also if you dont plug your e-power car in at lest once a month.... well you may have bigger issues then kill the pack
 
These cars pose a threat to the elderly, young, and disabled. They have no noise to warn you that they are coming and you can get hit by one accidentally.
 
I saw a Model S turn off of a gravel road the other day... I thought it was a Maserati at first, till I noticed the T logo on the trunk lid.
 
These cars pose a threat to the elderly, young, and disabled. They have no noise to warn you that they are coming and you can get hit by one accidentally.

ah yes, the "I'm too lazy to pay attention to my surroundings" ;) If people didn't walk down the middle of parking isles, step off sidewalks without looking both ways, etc. then there wouldn't be a problem.

The one area I do feel bad for is the blind. They rely on their hearing and these new cars make that a lot more dangerous. That is going to require additional advancements in crosswalk technology and possibly even handheld detection devices that they can carry. Sure, a lot of the responsibility needs to be on the drivers to begin with, but at the same time I think we have made things too easy on the pedestrians to think they always have the right of way and need to be protected. Just look at all the people walking along looking at their phones and listening to headphones when they should be paying better attention...
 
or nuclear for that matter.. and before the tree huggers come in.. renewables are not sustainable..

one word Thorium

LFTR would solve all of that but people scared of any thing the N word
 
These cars pose a threat to the elderly, young, and disabled. They have no noise to warn you that they are coming and you can get hit by one accidentally.
lol, this argument is absurd IMO... the cars can still make noises to warn people around them
 
lol, this argument is absurd IMO... the cars can still make noises to warn people around them

Electric Cars and Hybrid Cars in EV mode will be required by law to make noise on the exterior. Of course the government can't help but f it up and the sound is ridiculous. But it will serve its purpose.
 
Of course the government can't help but f it up and the sound is ridiculous.
Have you heard the sounds they currently make? I was like "WTF" when I heard them... they sound so strange... but I guess that's the point, to make people take notice. I imagine some sort of standard sounds will become commonplace though, and people will get used to it. Really, I just think it's a small issue. Nobody wants completely silent death machines zooming around pedestrians... well, most people don't anyways :D
 
lol, this argument is absurd IMO... the cars can still make noises to warn people around them

Even more absurd is the fact that no one with a gas powered car has ever ridden behind some elderly/youth/etc in the parking lot of a store and they were still completely fucking oblivious to everything around them?

Only the blind get a pass IMO, because they are actively trying to pay attention, however a 2000+ pound car rolling over freshly poured asphalt is still going to make some sort of noise, maybe not as much as an engine but the blind I'm sure could also pick that up, and the noise only gets louder the faster the car is going.
 
Even more absurd is the fact that no one with a gas powered car has ever ridden behind some elderly/youth/etc in the parking lot of a store and they were still completely fucking oblivious to everything around them?
I think for the most part they feel they have the right away. In some cases they may be subconsciously wanting others to plow into them, to get off work and cash in on insurance or settlement, I've even seen people attempt suicide in front of full-speed busses... people can be very careless!

I do feel like as more and more vehicles become EVs, the competition for sound will decrease, and in cities especially we'll have a bit less stress overall because of it - and that is the #1 killer, right? lol, maybe I'm just overly optimistic.
 
one word Thorium

LFTR would solve all of that but people scared of any thing the N word


Wow I'm surprised anyone here knows about breeders. Bravo man. We need to be spending way more money on liquid-metal cooled breeder reactors instead of this light bullshit.
 
Wow I'm surprised anyone here knows about breeders. Bravo man. We need to be spending way more money on liquid-metal cooled breeder reactors instead of this light bullshit.

molten salt is FAR better then liquid metal cooled
 
great news for telsa, electric cars and the energy movement in general... I hope it helps encourage others and pushes car tech forward at a faster rate

Right. Because nothing says "ENERGY EFFICIENCY!!!" like a $100,000 luxury car.
 
This is true to a certain point but so is getting power from coal. which represents 40% of the generation stack in the US. The idea that this car is green is pretty questionable when you factor in the carbon that is used to get the coal out of the ground transported to your generator and then of course burning it to generate electricity.

Unless you are in a Nat Gas generation region like California or Texas and some others you are actually contributing quite a bit to carbon pollution.

Which says nothing of the fact that the electricity grid is already stretched thin. There is no capability for the grid - at least in the US - to sustain in any significant fashion a measurable increase in the use of electric vehicles.

The entire idea is an utter pipe dream.
 
Zarathustra[H];1039865797 said:
Well, Maybe if you live in the Midwest where people drive longer distances this is a problem.

For me? Not so much. My longest drive in a day is to work, 17 miles away.

All of my friends who I see with any regularity live within 10 miles.

Its a good thing you represent about 10% of the population. What do you suggest for the other 90% ?
 
Also would like to point out that CO2 is not pollution, just in case anyone in this thread is confused about that.
 
I meant liquid sodium. Nice takeaway from my post though..

well the big guys like GE are pushing liquid metal fast breeders which is what i thought meant :p but they still want to use the U fuel cycle
very different animal from MSR based Thorium cycle reactors
 
Back
Top