Technology-Free Classrooms Improve Courses?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The geek side of me seriously wants to call B.S. on this article, but there is a part of me that thinks there just might be something to what is being said here. Is tech really that distracting in the classroom?

Banishing the gear improved the course, he argues. "The students seemed more involved in the discussion than when I allowed them to go online," he told me as the summer term wound down. "They were more attentive, and we were able to go into a little more depth."
 
Well considering whenever I was around a computer in the classroom, I was on here...
 
You can always find something more interesting online than what you are currently doing. Cut off that external source of fun and you might not have any choice but to be engaged by what's happening in the room.

I was always a pretty good daydreamer, though...
 
If not properly managed, yes, it is a distraction. But we can't go back to candle light and ink wells.

Get kids on computers as early as possible. Make them use the computer as much as possible.
 
Anyone who has attended a college class in the last 5 years should be able to attest to this. The really good professors at my undergrad would ban laptops from the classroom. I agree that they are a massive distraction.
 
Doesn't suprise me if its true. What really puzzels me is that the County i live in wants to move is "dropout/behavior issue" school to pure digital and layoff or reassign 200 teachers.

Digital education is lame, i mean, mathblaster didn't do crap for me, while pencil and paper did
 
Anyone who has attended a college class in the last 5 years should be able to attest to this. The really good professors at my undergrad would ban laptops from the classroom. I agree that they are a massive distraction.

i'd argue the opposite in a sense. If i actually gave a crap about the class or the professor was engaging i didn't need my laptop.

professors that complain i can't help but liken to the music industry in a sense, they don't know how to adapt so they bitch and moan.
 
i'd argue the opposite in a sense. If i actually gave a crap about the class or the professor was engaging i didn't need my laptop.

Beyond that, students (especially college) need to learn to get things done in spite of distractions. At some point, you'll be in an office with a computer. It would seem better to fail a couple of classes to get the point, rather than be fired with cause.
 
i actually agree with this, atleast in lectures i think many times computers do very little to enhance what is being taught while ofcourse they give a very tempting opportunities of distraction.
 
If you as a professor cannot capture the attention of your PAYING students over the computer, then you shouldn't be teaching.

Conversely, since they are paying, as long as they aren't distracting others & volume is muted quite frankly if you want to play call of duty while attending your lecture, go for it... you are after all paying for that seat.

When you're PAYING to be there, you will be engaged because you WANT to learn it... unless of course everything being said is already known to you or is available online etc... This is just professors crying because they don't want to update their lectures and stay relevant, they just want to keep drolling out the same tripe year after year... if students can find everything contained in your lecture online, how can you possibly expect them to be engaged? Show them something new.
 
If you as a professor cannot capture the attention of your PAYING students over the computer, then you shouldn't be teaching.

Conversely, since they are paying, as long as they aren't distracting others & volume is muted quite frankly if you want to play call of duty while attending your lecture, go for it... you are after all paying for that seat.

When you're PAYING to be there, you will be engaged because you WANT to learn it... unless of course everything being said is already known to you or is available online etc... This is just professors crying because they don't want to update their lectures and stay relevant, they just want to keep drolling out the same tripe year after year... if students can find everything contained in your lecture online, how can you possibly expect them to be engaged? Show them something new.

There is that inflated sense of entitlement which so many students suffer from today.
 
When you're PAYING to be there, you will be engaged because you WANT to learn it... unless of course everything being said is already known to you or is available online etc... This is just professors crying because they don't want to update their lectures and stay relevant, they just want to keep drolling out the same tripe year after year... if students can find everything contained in your lecture online, how can you possibly expect them to be engaged? Show them something new.

Ah, a grave misconception Ryan. Just because you paid, or your parents paid for tuition to take the class does not mean that you will want to learn or be interested. Plenty of students go to class and can't wait for it to be over because they just don't care or came to college to party or are generally uninterested in the subject, and simply required by curriculum to take the class. Also, while it is the professor's responsibility to deliver the material in an interesting fashion, he alone is not responsible for holding the students' interest resulting in a student actually learning something. That responsibility is most definitely shared by the student.

But in any event, what I wanted to say is more that I agree with the article. Everyone here who has been a student knows this to be true. This is why in the past there were always separate lecture and lab classes -- if a course required physical application. One can argue that most computer related courses are all about application -- and this is one of the exceptions where it is true, unless the class itself is theory related. But it is also only appropriate for specific subjects, not generally applicable to all classes. You learn far more if you are focused on the teacher and what they are saying. Writing things down also helps you to remember. The only distractions at that point are the other students around you -- which is a natural distraction and far healthier than your laptop or phone.

The only other case than a specific tech related subject where i would argue that using a laptop/computer is applicable is if you are taking a course over a web interface, remotely. At that point most people doing so aren't going to pay for such a class if they aren't going to pay attention and watch whats going on. They are less likely to be surfing the internet during a remotely viewed class like that.
 
If you as a professor cannot capture the attention of your PAYING students over the computer, then you shouldn't be teaching.

Conversely, since they are paying, as long as they aren't distracting others & volume is muted quite frankly if you want to play call of duty while attending your lecture, go for it... you are after all paying for that seat.

When you're PAYING to be there, you will be engaged because you WANT to learn it... unless of course everything being said is already known to you or is available online etc... This is just professors crying because they don't want to update their lectures and stay relevant, they just want to keep drolling out the same tripe year after year... if students can find everything contained in your lecture online, how can you possibly expect them to be engaged? Show them something new.

if only students think like this, but sadly, I doubt even half of the students nowadays even care who is paying about their studies.
 
Ah, a grave misconception Ryan. Just because you paid, or your parents paid for tuition to take the class does not mean that you will want to learn or be interested. Plenty of students go to class and can't wait for it to be over because they just don't care or came to college to party or are generally uninterested in the subject, and simply required by curriculum to take the class.

Then let them fail? It's NOT the schools job to beat the student over the head with a hammer and force them to learn. Their only responsibility is to provide the necessary tools for success, and it is the students job to succeed. However I think many professors aren't providing their students with the necessary tools for success...

Students need to take some responsibility for their failure, the school should do *nothing* to prevent them from failing if they don't care. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink...
 
Anyone who has attended a college class in the last 5 years should be able to attest to this. The really good professors at my undergrad would ban laptops from the classroom. I agree that they are a massive distraction.

really good professors shouldnt give a shit, they dont care if you're there or not, they are not there to babysit you thru the course. those that are there to learn will do learn, and those wasting space will drop out.
 
If you as a professor cannot capture the attention of your PAYING students over the computer, then you shouldn't be teaching.
Really? You think because they're PAYING that their attention should be held that much more? What about a class with a "boring subject" that the student is only there because he needs a C so he can get that general education requirement out of the way? Oh no, a teacher should be teaching to every student and make sure all attentions are met, lets ignore than the fact that all the students who want a good grade are paying attention, and all the students that are majors in that subject are paying attention, and really the only ones not paying attention are those who would rather be else where and they only reason they're PAYING is because they need that class. Lets ignore the fact that you if you change your methods to captivate one type of student, you will usually lose a different type.

While I will agree there are some professors out there that are so extraordinary with their methods that anyone will pay attention, sometimes the subject matter really isn't terribly exciting. I mean there's only so much you can do with teaching someone how to do integration by parts, At what point do you say they shouldn't be teaching? If only 50% of the students pay attention? 75%? 90%?

Conversely, since they are paying, as long as they aren't distracting others & volume is muted quite frankly if you want to play call of duty while attending your lecture, go for it... you are after all paying for that seat.
Absolutely I agree. However how do you propose they not distract others? Flashing images on a computer screen doesn't catch the eye of everyone behind/to the sides of them? Does the teacher get to be distraction free too? Or does he not count? Little movements, twitches, light under the breath giggles while reading a text. There are lots of little distractions that can fuck it up for everyone else who actually IS trying to pay attention.

When you're PAYING to be there, you will be engaged because you WANT to learn it... unless of course everything being said is already known to you or is available online etc... This is just professors crying because they don't want to update their lectures and stay relevant, they just want to keep drolling out the same tripe year after year... if students can find everything contained in your lecture online, how can you possibly expect them to be engaged? Show them something new.
Spoken like someone who's got the "I'm smarter than most of my teachers" mentality. Again, really you're PAYING to be there... have you looked at colleges lately? Quite a few of those PAYING to be there are there because they want to get through, not because they want to learn it. Look at classes you HAVE to take, I remember I didn't want to take half of them, and I really didn't care if I learned any of it, I simply wanted to get through them so that I could get to the classes that I DID want to learn.

But yeah you're right, since most information is available in wikipedia, why even bother with teachers. I mean shit while we're at it why even teach anything in the book? I mean seriously you can totally fucking read it yourself, so why bother with that. Simply teach something else, then say "ok do the book problems, you can read it and understand it all yourself", and have a nice day.
 
EDIT: I agree, LET THEM FAIL. College is cutthroat and overpacked with major budget cuts(here in cali anyway). Every student sitting next to me is potential competition. weeding out the lazy and unmotivated from those that want to succed seems like a good idea to me
 
It's just as much on students as it is the instructors. I can't fucking stand it when teachers insist on using technology that is ILL-EQUIPPED for teaching (aka - Computers -> PowerPoint presentations). There are far too many instructors who decide to use PowerPoints. There's nothing inherently wrong with doing this, but what happens more often than not is that this lets the instructors be lazy. They put text after text after text on slides and all they do is repeat back what the slide says. I can see this being possibly the only way to teach something that is rote memorization like history, but for anything which requires thorough understanding and analysis (aka - math or engineering) then you HAVE to be going through examples on chalkboard/whiteboard.

Reading != learning. Doing == learning.

Getting rid of the ability for students to be easily distracted will help, but it's just as much on teachers to use the best tools to facilitate learning, and in most cases, computers + PowerPoint presentations (or we can go back a few decades and say overhead projectors + lectures printed on film) are pure shit. When you teach something like math, you have to do it yourself in front of your students so they understand, not read it to them.
 
I'll tell you what, the year in college I didn't have internet or TV at home I was the best student I ever was. Now I know that is different to tech in the classroom, but I think it still is relevant in that technology is a huge distraction for some of us. But not all. So if a course is offered in 10 time slots, make one technology-free.
 
I'll tell you what, the year in college I didn't have internet or TV at home I was the best student I ever was. Now I know that is different to tech in the classroom, but I think it still is relevant in that technology is a huge distraction for some of us. But not all. So if a course is offered in 10 time slots, make one technology-free.

Pretty spot on IMO. Look at how many people are texting or talking on the phone in everyday life situations not paying attention to anything, whether walking down the street, waiting in line, or god forbid driving. If life is unable to keep your attention (or in the case of texting and driving... if YOUR life is unable to keep your attention) what makes anyone think it really is the teacher's fault for being unable to hold your attention.
 
Anyone who has attended a college class in the last 5 years should be able to attest to this. The really good professors at my undergrad would ban laptops from the classroom. I agree that they are a massive distraction.

That does not make them "really good". It entirely depends on the subject matter. Certain classes there is a LOTTTTT of notes to take and without a computer to type them there is almost no chance you get all the information.
 
As someone on both sides of the fence, I push for moderation for tech in the classroom. A few powerpoint slides to drive a point home, to illustrate an idea or to give contextual information is good technique. All slides, all the time or conversely just droning on about the same minutia is a recipe for failure.

Oh and to the people how say let the students fail... Yeah, you can't. No, I mean you literally can't if you want to keep your job. Most universities are run like the average fortune 500 business (don't like it, well that is a whole other argument) and they have to make money to continue. If one fails too many students and too many evals come back negative... don't be surprised if a long uncomfortable talk by the dean of the dept is in the future.
 
Oh and to the people how say let the students fail... Yeah, you can't. No, I mean you literally can't if you want to keep your job. Most universities are run like the average fortune 500 business (don't like it, well that is a whole other argument) and they have to make money to continue. If one fails too many students and too many evals come back negative... don't be surprised if a long uncomfortable talk by the dean of the dept is in the future.

Yeah big myth... especially if they're tenured.

Its not about how many you fail, it's about the total percentages that pass. So yeah the few who can't pay attention, don't do homework, play Call of Duty during class, won't really register as more than a blip in any teacher's evaluation.
 
That does not make them "really good". It entirely depends on the subject matter. Certain classes there is a LOTTTTT of notes to take and without a computer to type them there is almost no chance you get all the information.

You can type faster than you can write? Interesting.
 
Well that might be true... when comparing poorly deployed "gear orientated" class room to a classroom with up to date book and a competent teach. The problem is up to date book cost more than the computers and competent are few and far between. The majority of the teachers do the minimum to get tenure then cost after that. How many of you had a teacher that read the news paper through every class, or that slept in the class? How many handed out papers and went into their office to correct papers? How many actually knew the subjects or just read small highlighted portions out of the books? How many sub-par teachers does it take to make a horrible law like No Child Left Behind almost a necessity.

You want to see how bad schools can get check out Detroit Michigan. You are more likely to be in jail then graduate at the age of 18 and they have some of the highest paid teachers.

Online books and homework is still fine and saves the schools likely billion of dollars each year, but you need a competent teacher to back it all up.
 
College students these days just want the piece of paper. They think that simply having a diploma is the key to a successful career and life.

They don't want the foundation of knowledge that's intended to spark a lifelong pursuit of learning. That is the truth of a real college education.

If they can skate their way through classes, dicking around on their laptops, or cell phones or listening to music instead of paying attention to lectures, they'll do it. Why actually pay attention, when they can just copy notes off their classmates, or raid the dorms/frathouse/sororityhouse files collection.

Its these kind of people that dilute the college educational experience for those that truly want to be there. Then, when they graduate, they find out that simply having a diploma isn't enough, and find themselves in the unemployment line and then blame others by saying "what gives?".

You don't need a laptop in the classroom. You don't need to be talking or texting on your cell phones. You don't need to be listening to your MP3 player. If you aren't interested enough in learning to pay attention, then GTFO. Spoiled brats if you ask me.

I could have done just as well as I did, earning both of my engineering degrees by bringing only a pencil and a pad of engineering paper to class. No laptop. No calculator. Nothing. When I needed a computer, or a calculator, I used it. But it was never needed in class.
 
I partially agree to letting kids fail for slacking. But distractions do no good either. Professors that ban computers aren't doing a bad thing. You don't shove food in front of the glutton, and tell him to do his homework without looking at distractions.
 
I'm currently in a Switching and Wireless basics class as I post this. I think this class would be a little tougher without all the technology up in hurr :p
 
Yeah big myth... especially if they're tenured.

Its not about how many you fail, it's about the total percentages that pass. So yeah the few who can't pay attention, don't do homework, play Call of Duty during class, won't really register as more than a blip in any teacher's evaluation.

Bwhahaha. Wow. Way to miss the point. Then again, maybe at YOUR school at YOUR dept a few blips don't really matter; however, at my university they absolutely do.

First, not all professors are tenured. In fact, the trend now is to hire only lectures because it is cheaper and if they start to get out of line the dept can fire them without hassle. A scant 23% of my total overall dept is tenured.

... and you know I guess that conversation that my dean had with me after I failed three students, deservedly so, my first teaching semester was all a dream.... yes, a very vivid dream in which I had my ass chewed out for failing too many students. I will make sure to mention that to the dept head next time I see him.

I just hope you don't plan on entering academia since it's obvious you have little to no grasp on the politics at work.
 
Back
Top