Symantec Calls Antivirus 'Doomed'

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The senior VP for information security at Symantec calls anti-virus doomed? Well that's not very encouraging.

Antivirus products are "doomed to failure," according to Brian Dye, senior vice president for information security at Symantec, a security firm and maker of antivirus products. From The Wall Street Journal on Sunday, the antivirus giant said that end-point security technology isn't a "moneymaker" in any way, and highlighted that the company needs to adjust and adapt.
 
"A new and hot virus is out, now you'll need to buy this DLC pack for it or you won't be protected!"

I hope this isn't the kind of adapting they mean.
 
"A new and hot virus is out, now you'll need to buy this DLC pack for it or you won't be protected!"

I hope this isn't the kind of adapting they mean.

They already do this, its called yearly subscriptions.
 
"Yearly subscriptions" are so passé, "supplementary subscriptions" are the new hype and in thing!
 
I hope they stop making it so I can stop using it on stand alone stations. /em looking at you DSS
 
Symantec's garbage antivirus has been doomed since the 1990's. It is and always has been bottom of the barrel and laughing stock of the industry.
 
Symantec's garbage antivirus has been doomed since the 1990's. It is and always has been bottom of the barrel and laughing stock of the industry.

I don't think that's correct, just what a lot of lazy thinkers have spouted over the years.
 
I don't think that's correct, just what a lot of lazy thinkers have spouted over the years.

Been awhile since I used it last, but I do remember it being a P.O.S. on the 100 or so stations we had it on.
 
Been awhile since I used it last, but I do remember it being a P.O.S. on the 100 or so stations we had it on.

I remember years ago how it was absolutely dog shit and should be set on fire. Then over many years of the company eating their own mistakes I remember hearing a lot of good things about it, like how it actually got back to the top of the leader-boards at some points, too.
 
Since 360 came out Norton has actually gone up ALOT in ratings and ability to detect they basically redid the entire software, because of the bad press.
 
I remember years ago how it was absolutely dog shit and should be set on fire. Then over many years of the company eating their own mistakes I remember hearing a lot of good things about it, like how it actually got back to the top of the leader-boards at some points, too.

Can you spare some links to these leaderboards? I'm interested to see.

Since 360 came out Norton has actually gone up ALOT in ratings and ability to detect they basically redid the entire software, because of the bad press.

The bad perception has still continued to follow it to the point where it remains off the table in enterprise environments. Mention Symantec or Norton and watch an entire room of IT executives laugh you out the door. Even those goobers know the proper buzzwords.
 
Regardless of how much they improved their AV, Symantec's shenanigans with auto-renewal fees on credit cards still leaves them on my permanently unforgiven blacklist. Gee whiz Symantec, maybe you would be able to make more money if people weren't still, after all this time, getting unauthorized $49 charges on their credit cards.
 
In my experience, Symantec has been the best AV software in terms of detection in real-time use, but has always had the largest resource footprint. The heuristics engine is especially adept at hogging CPU time, swallowing huge chunks of RAM and causing the disk access to stay pegged.

I have just operated under the assumption that the level of real-time protection was proportional to the resource usage and planned accordingly. For systems that are mission critical and therefore need the most protection, I have just specced them slightly higher than necessary to account for the slowdowns incurred with the AV software. For systems where speed was a higher priority than resilience I have used other products including Avast!, AVG, Kaspersky, and most recently Webroot Secure Anywhere. The last has been a personal favorite of mine.

Since I have installed it on the computers that my wife and son use I have yet to see anything get through. I do routine scans with Malwarebytes on their systems and have yet to catch anything. I have gone through the Webroot logs to see what it has encountered and it has stopped everything before it got in, even a lot of those pesky browser add-ons and redirector junk software like Conduit.

Comparatively, I was running Avast! and AVG on those computers before and at least once a week I was removing junk. I gave up on teaching them safe browsing practices because they are both click-happy and impatient. There are a number of users at work like that, but we have the benefit of locking things down a bit better via group policy there. I tried forcing the two of them onto limited user accounts, but I got tired of having to go authorize every damn legitimate thing they wanted to do...Even Minecraft was a problem on the limited account, I suspect because of its excessive use of the AppData folder.
 
I'll take symantec over mcaffee
360 was/is good. not a hog like it used to be, still too much nagging for my tastes but its been great on my folks' machine(s).
 
I wouldn't touch Norton anti-virus even if I got it free every year >>
 
I've been in the business for over 15 years... the only adjusting and adapting Symantec needs to do is go bankrupt. Its been in the business of ruining every software they put their hands on and like all their software their Antivirus solutions are so bloated that its the first thing uninstalled from brand new computers.

They may know how to create new features, they really suck at implementing them. OPTIMIZATION people... anyone beside 3D engine programmers still understand the principle???
 
There won't be zero-day alerts if these anti-virus software work. In other words, they are simply just another form of bloatware.
 
Maybe he's simply saying the anti-virus part is what's doomed to failure, which is why you need our new Malware Defender, and Web Defender, and Email Defender, and Boogieman Defender add-ons for your bundle them together and they're less than $10 a year* (* each).

Seriously got a new laptop the other day at Best Buy (traded in an XP laptop for $100) and the lady who checked me out told me I get 6 months of free anti-virus, I told her I didn't want it, she looked at me shocked "you don't want it?" said "Yup because I knew there's some bloated antivirus already preinstalled on the computer that I need to remove as soon as I power it up, and I don't need some other anti-virus program that you give me as "free" (Trend Micro)" She gave it to me anyways, like "here you throw away our garbage then" presumably the CDs they have some code on them that identifies the store so they can get a kickback from anyone who pays their subscription. Seriously, if this was back in the day where you actually got a CD of your OS with your computer I would have formatted the hard drive and reinstalled.
 
I think they are right. Their anti-virus program is a waste of resources... That said, I use ESET and it just works the way I think it should. I would also recommend Kaspersky to others and Trend for company-wide usage. Free? Avira or AVG from ninite installs... and that about sums it up. Norton and Symantec can go find a short pier and go for a nice long walk, and maybe a swim out as far as they can go...
 
and what do you use ?:eek:

Good judgement is the only reliable tool. When that fails that's why you haven an AV, but as far as I'm concerned, they all pretty much suck and the reason is that a lot of them are outsourcing virus definitions.

Microsoft's AV solution was going strong when it started but it started to loose some mojo...
 
I don't think that's correct, just what a lot of lazy thinkers have spouted over the years.

No, norton has been horrible since the late 90s. by around 2002, it became so bad it hit the point of the cure being way, WAY worse than the disease. It's actually improved a bit since then, but it was severely bad for quite some time. These days it has middling performance at best, isn't price well, and isn't all that great at protecting the low information user from themselves (maybe that's a different product, but I doubt it).
 
The biggest danger from viruses in this day and age is in mobile. And nobody has anything decent for that yet.

I don't see PC mass consumer AV software as that relevant anymore.

Browsers have really stepped up security configurations and have become a great line of defense. If you stick to one of the major provides of webmail, search, and online file sharing, you should generally be ok.

Also, don't use WinXP.

The #1 source of suspicious software for me was always torrents. I haven't done that in years though because of Steam, Youtube, Netflix, and other better distribution models.
 
Good judgement is the only reliable tool. When that fails that's why you haven an AV, but as far as I'm concerned, they all pretty much suck and the reason is that a lot of them are outsourcing virus definitions.

Non-admin rights for all users. Fixing their system then amounts to blowing away their local profile and logging back in. Your AV choice becomes incidental to the point that you are combating attacks on local user space vs. system-wide.

The biggest danger from viruses in this day and age is in mobile. And nobody has anything decent for that yet.

In the consumer space I somewhat agree. Android has been wonderful at getting abused lately.

I don't see PC mass consumer AV software as that relevant anymore.

Browsers have really stepped up security configurations and have become a great line of defense. If you stick to one of the major provides of webmail, search, and online file sharing, you should generally be ok.

Not in corporate IT. It is still a big issue especially at companies who standardize on Internet Explorer.
 
Non-admin rights for all users. Fixing their system then amounts to blowing away their local profile and logging back in. Your AV choice becomes incidental to the point that you are combating attacks on local user space vs. system-wide.

Until one of your users gets a crypto-locker virus and it proceeds to encrypt everything in their home and shared directories...

Yes, it installs as non-admin just fine.
 
Until one of your users gets a crypto-locker virus and it proceeds to encrypt everything in their home and shared directories...

Yes, it installs as non-admin just fine.

That is when you review your enterprise backup and restore functionality to limit the consequence of these threats. Oh, and its far more likely that the user him/herself deletes those files (what do you mean the AppData folder is important? It just takes up a bunch of space).
 
Until one of your users gets a crypto-locker virus and it proceeds to encrypt everything in their home and shared directories...

Yes, it installs as non-admin just fine.

Thankfully my enterprise hasn't been the victim of that yet, but you are right that some malware folks are wise to the non-admin measure and merely targeting user space instead.
 
The bad perception has still continued to follow it to the point where it remains off the table in enterprise environments. Mention Symantec or Norton and watch an entire room of IT executives laugh you out the door. Even those goobers know the proper buzzwords.

Maybe in the civilian world, but for the DoD those are the only two games in town. That being said, I don't use either, even though they are free for me, I use NOD32 and I am always having to "fix" people's computers when their "free" trail subscription to Norton runs out and it blocks their internet connection until they uninstall or renew. They claim they are "Protecting you from your unprotected computer".
 
My mistake, Norton and McAfee are the only two, Norton is Symantec.
 
Maybe in the civilian world, but for the DoD those are the only two games in town. That being said, I don't use either, even though they are free for me, I use NOD32 and I am always having to "fix" people's computers when their "free" trail subscription to Norton runs out and it blocks their internet connection until they uninstall or renew. They claim they are "Protecting you from your unprotected computer".

The DoD fortunately does not represent the real world. Horrible admins and good ol' boy politics are what is representative of the DoD IT world. There's no other way Symantec gets shortlisted.
 
Top Anti-Virus Programs in the consumer market right now. Not sure why Symantec isn't even tested and didn't dig into why either.

5E0kcXC.jpg
 
Back
Top