Sugo case owners, post your HSF setup

there is something wrong with me and I can t just buy an NT06 for my sugo. I am considering the aerocool dominator or maybe the enzotech ultra-x:

Aerocool_dominator_big1.jpg
1-Ultra-X.jpg


I think either should fit without the fan... am I right ? Anyone have experience with either ?
 
Burnin8r,

People buy the NT06-Lite instead of the NT06. The 'Lite' version doesnt have the fan. What people sometimes do though is take and mount a 120mm fan under the NT06-Lite heat sink fins and have the fan blow air up through the fins. Using the right psu (Corsair 520w, 620w and the short cabled Silverstone PSUs) turned (or flipped as some are saying) in a way where the air is entering the psu and then blown out the back and out the case.
 
The enzotech ultra X and the areocool dominator use bigger heat pipes than the NT06 / NT06 Lite which is why I want to use those instead of going with the same heat sink as every other sugo owner.

Again, I am asking if anyone has any experience with them... thanks for the lecture tho.

xilent-blade-xl.jpg


I am also considering the XilenceBlade Pro... the height is 75mm without the fan
 
Sugo SG01B-W, NT06-E, DFI Lanparty Jr P45, Intel Q9550.

Overall, its not to bad, very cramped in the CPU area though. Just got the quad and it runs HOT. At stock speeds and voltage, its around 65C full load, which to me seems pretty warm as it is only spec'd to go to 71C. Northbridge gets around 50ish, PWM gets really really hot, mid 60s too.

-I tried sticking a 92mm fan under the NT06. Very very little if any difference. My powersupply has a 135mm fan under it and it does a pretty good job.
-I stuck a 40mm fan on the Northbridge to cool it. It stays about 42 now.
-The PWM is the trick.. once I get air moving over the PWM my CPU temps drop by 10C-12C.

Now, how the hell am I supposed to cool that sucker with the case closed. Nothing fits.
 
Sugo SG02-f, NT06-E, P5Q-EM, E-8400

My PSU is enermax 625w modu 82+. I've come to realize this was a bad choice. At maximum load from my system PSU fan only reaches 900 rpm. It does not move enough air by itself. Plus it's only rated for 40c temps. I wanted to try attaching a fan to underside of nt06. Previous poster did not get good results from this. Can someone advise is this a good idea to cool PSU/cpu. Would a 120mm fan work best? Obviously I want as quiet as possible. Is it a Good idea to attach this fan to cpu header for variable speed as cpu heats up? Fan will need to be 4 pin right. Any fan recommendations? Should it be pointed up? Previous poster said -The PWM is the trick.. once I get air moving over the PWM my CPU temps drop by 10C-12C. What does this mean? What is PWM? Asside from my HDD fan, I should be using chasis fans as air intake right? That's assuming I can lower my temps by attaching a fan to my NT06-E.
 
I finally got a response regarding the AeroCool Dominator and I don t think it is going to fit.

The rep I was dealing with said it is 95mm tall without the fan, I believe no cooler taller than 83mm will fit.

the enzotech is a few more dollars than I wanted to spend but I think it will be worth it...
 
Sugo SG02-f, NT06-E, P5Q-EM, E-8400

Will outfitting my NT06 with 120mm fan allow me to upclock cpu to 3.6 Ghz?
 
Hate to necro this post, but its either this or start a new topic.

My SFF
Sugo SGO2B-F
AMD X2 5200 @ 3.04 GHz v1.36
Tul TRS780-M1
2x 2GB OCZ Fata1ty DDR800 @ 868 MHz, T2 5/4/4/18-22
Sapphire HD 4850 512 MB (Dual Slot Cooler) @ 710/1240
Asus Xonar DX
500w Antec Neo Power Modular PSU
250GB Seagate Barracuda 16 MB 7200 RPM 3.0 Sata HD
LG 22x DVD±RW/lightscribe
CPU Cooler - Xigmatek Apache CD901
GPU Cooler - Stock
Case Fan - Silverstone FM 121
TIM - Zalman ZM-STG1

I am wondering what temps, everyone else is getting for their CPU, preferably AMD X2 owners. I get about 32-38C idle depending on ambient temps in the room and max load temps of 60-66C.

Ok I must state the Xigmatek Apache is very poorly lapped and trying to lap it is virtually impossible due to the design of the base. The HSF is compressed aluminum, but hey I paid $12 for it. Under full load I can feel the FM 121 pushing out a lot of heat and I have to state the PSU does not have an exhaust fan on it... if I had known this before hand I would've gotten another one, but it has 3 +12v rails, and that's what sold me and it costing only $50.

I'm debating if its worth getting another HSF.

Ah, forgot to mention I have 2 80mm MASSCOOL - exhausting and the 1 stock Silverstone 90mm - intake on the HD bay.

I dont have any pics atm, broke my old 5.0 coolpix =(
 
I'm thinking of using a Scythe Shuriken on my upcoming SG02F build... but according to the frostytech articles (http://www.frostytech.com/top5_lowprofile_heatsinks.cfm), the Zalman CNPS8700 is much better at cooling. Since the 8700 is also a bit lower, it shouldn't compete for air as much with the PSU. Of course, the Zalman costs about twice ($60 vs $30 CAD) as much as the shuriken, so the choice is difficult.

Does anyone have experience with both of these in a sugo case?

If I yet the Zalman, I will probably leave the speed at a comfortable level (without making it TOO loud, but still cool best as possible). I'm trying to OC a E5200, so extra cooling is always welcome :)

Edit: Also, has anyone tried the Thermalright AXP-140?
http://www.ncix.com/products/index.php?sku=35664&vpn=AXP-140&manufacture=THERMALRIGHT&promoid=1030
 
From alot of folks, the Zalman is noisy as hell, even at low speeds so I decided to skip it and go with the Scythe
 
From alot of folks, the Zalman is noisy as hell, even at low speeds so I decided to skip it and go with the Scythe

I have a feeling that it's mostly with onboard PWM, which sets the CPU fan to high most of the time (as opposed to the 8700's included fan controller). If you look at the frostytech articles, CNPS8700 at lowest settings is apparently dead silent, and cools almost as well as Shuriken on high settings (~3 degress difference), but at high speed cools much better (4~8 degrees lower). Since this is the first time I've seen definitive testing to compare them, I am curious to see if other people have any experiences with them.

Edit:

The main thing for me for the 8700 is that it looks better with the LED fan (I will mod a window in my case most likely), and the fan is lower (less competition for air with PSU), and it cools better, apparently. The shuriken costs half as much, and cools almost as well (not factoring in PSU competition), so it makes my decision hard.
 
Low speed 8700NT is fine, 1400rpm above is not. What you can do is put a resistor on it and plug the 4pin into a 3pin header, thereby making it a static rpm fan and not dynamic so it doesn't ramp up and down.
 
Low speed 8700NT is fine, 1400rpm above is not. What you can do is put a resistor on it and plug the 4pin into a 3pin header, thereby making it a static rpm fan and not dynamic so it doesn't ramp up and down.

1400rpm is not very high, considering 8700 goes from 1200-2300rpm..

have you tried the included manual fan controller?

how well does it cool at 1400rpm in a sugo case?
 
1400rpm and above is what the 8700NT will be hitting very often whenever any load is put on (depends on CPU of course. Was using a Phenom 9600 and Athlon X2 5800). It has been catching dust for over half a year but it did do a a slick job cooling in a Lanbox. I don't think it came with a controller and can't be bothered to dig for it. You can also do a fan mod for it and replace the stock LED crapshit for something else, like a Noctua P12. SilentPCreview has instructions.

As well, I believe there are 2 models for this. 8700NT LED with the silver fins that is PWM, and the red 8700 that is manual fan.
 
I have the 8700 in my SUGO2B and so far I have been ~70% satisfied.
Some things I found in my installation:

Installation was a PITA. The cooler must be installed while the motherboard is in the case. I couldn't find a way to slide it on while it was installed. In addition, I had to bend the bracket that holds the cooler down in order for it to grab the frame-thing. Shouldn't have had to...

Using the thing plugged into the mobo, it ran at 100% all the time. TOTALLY unnecessary for my stock e6300. Instead, I used the included fan controller and set it to minimum. Cools fine, very quiet.

It is quiet, and gives plenty of clearance with the psu:
DSC00039.jpg

Even though the fans fight for air...

I like it because it is small, and does not get in teh way of anything.
 
Thanks for the info and pic!

Do you know if there is enough room on the CPU side of the case to mod a side fan or attach a back fan on it for more cooling?

Has anyone tried OCing in their sg02 cases? How effective is the cooling solution (air cooling plz) you used?
 
No there is not enough room btw the mobo and case side for a fan.
 
I managed to slip in a 80mm fan to help get some fresh air to the HSF to help my OC temperatures. Right now im at 3.6ghz stable on stock voltage on my E8500

sidecool.jpg
 
I just got my build done (yay!).. and I got a similar setup as Freezebyte with the side 80mm fan (GELID Wing 8 UV fan). It drops my mobo temp about 10 deg, and CPU about 4~5 deg...

With a E5200, right now I'm still testing stability for 3.6ghz... but I'm hitting a temperature barrier. It's going up to 72 deg C.. and intel's thermal specs only go up to 74.1 deg C

Does anyone have any ideas to help the CPU temperature? I'm only at 1.384V, and I want to hit at least 3.8Ghz :(

Do these temps look normal? I used the Zalman 8700 (manual fan controller)'s included thermal paste, if that makes a diff.

If I could squeeze another bit of cooling in, I might hit my target 3.8~4.0ghz :D
 
Update:

I did some testing for temperature...

Setup: P5E-VM, 9800gtx+, E5200, Zalman 8700

OC:
- 288 x 12.5 = 3600MHz
- Vcore: 1.4250V (1.408V w/ vdroop)
- 8700 going at ~1450RPM

- With case closed, I get 37 deg idle, 73 load, 29 on motherboard (thanks to side fan), 37 GPU, 33 HDD.
- With the case cover off, temps were just a tad lower (1-3 degrees at most for CPU)
- With the 80mm side fan flipped (now drawing hot air out), the motherboard temp went +9 deg (to 38... not too high) and everything else stayed relatively the same.
- With the PSU flipped so there's no competition for air with the HSF, temperatures went down very slightly (~1 degree from case cover off)
- With the PSU on top of the case instead of inside (temporary solution of course), CPU temps dropped a good 8~9 degrees, so I could continue overclocking without hitting a temperature wall :D
- With fan turned up to highest RPM (sounding like a jet engine) with PSU outside the case, CPU temp went down another 1 degree (lol)

From that, I conclude that while PSU/HSF compete for air... the fact that the PSU is right over the HSF, even if it's got no fan on the underside when flipped, makes it hard for the 8700 to get enough air for cooling. Since I got my DVD drive on the bottom slot, and a half length fan controller on the top slot (will show pic later)... if I could get my cables into the space between the video card and the front of the case, I might be able to fit a 120mm or even 140mm fan on top of the 5.25" drive bays for intake on the top. What do you guys think?

As for case temp... using a front bay temp monitor, I get about 28 degrees (ambient 21-23) in the case when the PSU is in the case, measured above the RAM... and about 23-24 degrees with the PSU sitting outside the case, measured above the HSF. Air coming out the back of the PSU (OCZ ModXstream 500W) is about 30 degrees. Would it be a good idea for me to try and flip the PSU fan? Anyone tried this?

Another idea I had was to somehow divert the airflow from the PCI fans to the CPU area (since my 9800gtx+ almost forms a wall between the CPU and the other side of the case)... but it's a really tight fit already...
 
Back
Top