Students Hurt By The Digital Divide

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I like how this article never considered the obvious solution....quit assigning homework that requires internet access. Problem solved, bajillions of dollars saved. :rolleyes:

As a result, in order to complete digital assignments, these kids are forced to find sources of free Internet access outside of school. While the library is often an option, hours can be limited, particularly in the evening. As the WSJ piece details, many of these students are increasingly turning to free WiFi at places like McDonald’s to complete their homework.
 
Yeah, that's the problem I have with technology nowadays-- We cannot expect every person to afford every technological marvel, device, or access even if it benefits or helps them in some way.

Not everyone has internet access. Heck, my friend is running Windows XP off an old Pentium I computer on 56k still. He cannot squeeze DSL or cable access into his monthly budget given he has three children and a family to support.

It's one of the fears I have that if there is a technology or medical breakthrough that can help someone, that people that really need it and/or can benefit from it, will have no access to it. It's terrible how it is right now because technology should be helping us, not divide us between rich and poor, the haves and have nots.
 
But it's always been that way. Get caught up in something and see how well the court appointed lawyer serves you. If you have money it's not a worry. Same with medical care and many other things. It's always going to be the haves vs nots.
 
Of course another solution to this is to limit the total webtime required and have the schools provide internet enabled study hall ... with the internet permeating every aspect of modern life I don't think it hurts to require some level of internet use ... if we can provide free meals for kids without access to food I am sure we can find a way for some school internet availability (for those in need) ;)
 
In experience Universitys aren't really doing everything digital even though they require internet submissioon of certain parts of assignments... Everything has to be handed in physically to a tiny office with the other 230452930 people (which is a 2.5 hours round trip by train).

Then they decided that you had to hand in stuff digitally...as well. So now. All assignments go into the tiny office and have to be submitted online...:confused:
 
...Wait a minute. If kids are turning to free WiFi places like McDonald's to get their homework done, then they at least have access to a laptop, I would assume. Wasn't there a project to scan and copy data from reliable sources online and make it available offline? It might have been just Wikipedia, but there should be something they could use that would function like that.
 
Get the OASIS going...

I agree with Steve, compulsory education years are prime time for working offline, getting a basic education and writing instead of typing and staring at screens, when possible.

But kids should also have access and libraries. I wouldn't mind if libraries were open until 8 M-Th with government grants.

Every county has electricity, hopefully someday they'll have wireless public internet for $10 a month or some small fee.
 
Not everyone has internet access. Heck, my friend is running Windows XP off an old Pentium I computer on 56k still. He cannot squeeze DSL or cable access into his monthly budget given he has three children and a family to support.
It's none of my business but I don't entirely believe that your friend can't afford good internet access. Usually when people don't have good internet access, it's because.

#1 Ignorant to what's available
#2 Has bad priorities
#3 Happens to live in a area where 56k is the only way to go.

For the most part, internet access is cheap. Does your friend have an iPhone? How can he afford an iPhone and yet limited internet access? Has he tried jailbreaking his iPhone so he could tether it to a laptop and use that for access?

Does your friend smoke? A pack a day costs $5-$7. That would be $25-$35 a week, or $100-$140 a month. That could easily get you unlimited data at home and for that iPhone he might have.

I doubt your friend can't afford good internet access. Most likely he prioritizes it far bellow a lot of other expenses. Not my business but if people are going and buying junk, but complain they can't afford something simple like internet access, then that's just bad priorities.
It's one of the fears I have that if there is a technology or medical breakthrough that can help someone, that people that really need it and/or can benefit from it, will have no access to it. It's terrible how it is right now because technology should be helping us, not divide us between rich and poor, the haves and have nots.
Medical help and internet access are not two things that should be compared. One should be everyone's right, while the other is for the most part a luxury. Not that I don't believe people should have access to the internet. I believe that we should have free WiFi everywhere for people to use. Doesn't matter if it's slow and clunky, so long as it works.

But internet access is so cheap that in many cases it'll cost you a couple of packs of cigarettes per month. May not be unlimited data with speed fast enough to watch HD video, but fast enough to send out emails and browse websites.
 
I probably would have opt'd for one less child so I could get broadband internet. But hey, that's just me.
 
Wasn't there a project to scan and copy data from reliable sources online and make it available offline? It might have been just Wikipedia, but there should be something they could use that would function like that.

They used to be called "textbooks." ;)
 
They used to be called "textbooks." ;)

The skill too look up something without Google is something I fear my children and their peers may not see in school. It feels like we're teaching some stuff that kids can glean while at home. I mean, we don't have a class on how to work a TV, do we?

I love technology myself, but outside keyboarding skills (which could be overcome with a typewriter if you really want to go back that far) I don't feel there is a pressing need to involve the computer in every single facet of life.

Then again, the current state of the country does have a push against the thought.

I don't have a problem with technology, but it seems like there's a push to have it for everything. My state has a bill in the works to re-introduce cursive writing back into the curriculum. Yes, they need to use a keyboard, but it would be very good if they can physically write something if the iPad dies.
 
Agreed that this is crap. My cousins go to school and there is no real net access where they live. Its as simple as that, and its not even a "can not afford it" issue which is an issue its there are no choices other than Verizon wireless or satellite. They always end up at my place down the road on my crappy DSL. at least I have it but still schools should not be making this switch its just a stupid idea. Its like they are setting the kids up to fail.
 
Agreed that this is crap. My cousins go to school and there is no real net access where they live. Its as simple as that, and its not even a "can not afford it" issue which is an issue its there are no choices other than Verizon wireless or satellite. They always end up at my place down the road on my crappy DSL. at least I have it but still schools should not be making this switch its just a stupid idea. Its like they are setting the kids up to fail.

Yeah, I mean, when Comcast bought out NBC, they agreed to provide basic cable internet access to families that are poor (to qualify the familyhas to be eligible for the school lunch program and that's it), but what good is that going to do when there's no broadband ISP available at all?

My parents live in a place where to this day there's no cable services. Hell, they didn't even have official cell phone coverage until 2006. If you want something other than broadcast TV, you can get expensive satellite TV and satellite internet, both of which are fairly terrible. I was lucky to grow up in an era where most people didn't even have dial-up. Although trying to do my homework using my father's encyclopedias from the 1960's was a pain in the ass...
 
What do the children do who don't have a device like a laptop or tablet to grt their homework done?

I think some of this is overblown......the resources are online, not the actual work.
resources that are no doubt available in some physical form in the school library or town library. Or....bingo......your textbook.

the whole fucking educational system has become lazy.
no writing.
limited math.
go look up your assignment on a Wiki or google it.
limited reading and comprehension.

Make the "educators" educate. Not the parents, not the internet.

Or, if the internet is the magical solution, make sure all the children have a device and the access to the magical internet.

Open your checkbook Barack.
 
If schools build the education junk so that Internet access is required, they should also provide a means for access. People are dumb and are going to mismanage their money and even though their children will all grow up to be horrible people, they should get identical learning offerings. The best way to get around that is to just not require it at all. They'll have to learn the tech junk outside of school, but is that a big deal? It probably depends on whether or not you think schools are supposed to give a person life skills in addition to knowledge.
 
I think some of this is overblown......the resources are online, not the actual work.
resources that are no doubt available in some physical form in the school library or town library. Or....bingo......your textbook.

I agree. Technology in education I think is highly over rated, as if shoving technology in the hands of kids will magically make them learn things. Unless you are actually teaching the kid about technology, it's simply where your resources are held. If the limitation on learning/teaching is the technology, then the teaching methods have failed.
 
When I was in highschool I already had broadband at home. There were computers in every classroom and the library with full internet access available for any student to use. I graduated highschool over a decade ago. What the hell is anyone's excuse today?
 
What do the children do who don't have a device like a laptop or tablet to grt their homework done?

I think some of this is overblown......the resources are online, not the actual work.
resources that are no doubt available in some physical form in the school library or town library. Or....bingo......your textbook.

the whole fucking educational system has become lazy.
no writing.
limited math.
go look up your assignment on a Wiki or google it.
limited reading and comprehension.

Make the "educators" educate. Not the parents, not the internet.

Or, if the internet is the magical solution, make sure all the children have a device and the access to the magical internet.

Open your checkbook Barack.

While I would LIKE to argue that writing is obsolete and the only time I typically pick up a pen is to sign my name, I have to agree with its importance and almost everything else you said. There's one big flaw though. The parents. They too have to be involved. Teachers can only do so much, and despite what many parents want to believe, they aren't babysitters.
 
I like how this article never considered the obvious solution....quit assigning homework that requires internet access. Problem solved, bajillions of dollars saved. :rolleyes:

That would have been too easy.

Nowadays, teachers think if technology isn't part of the solution, it's a bad idea. KISS has been laid to rest a long time ago in the public school system (at least where I live).
 
It's none of my business but I don't entirely believe that your friend can't afford good internet access. Usually when people don't have good internet access, it's because.

#1 Ignorant to what's available
#2 Has bad priorities
#3 Happens to live in a area where 56k is the only way to go.

For the most part, internet access is cheap. Does your friend have an iPhone? How can he afford an iPhone and yet limited internet access? Has he tried jailbreaking his iPhone so he could tether it to a laptop and use that for access?

Does your friend smoke? A pack a day costs $5-$7. That would be $25-$35 a week, or $100-$140 a month. That could easily get you unlimited data at home and for that iPhone he might have.

I doubt your friend can't afford good internet access. Most likely he prioritizes it far bellow a lot of other expenses. Not my business but if people are going and buying junk, but complain they can't afford something simple like internet access, then that's just bad priorities.

Medical help and internet access are not two things that should be compared. One should be everyone's right, while the other is for the most part a luxury. Not that I don't believe people should have access to the internet. I believe that we should have free WiFi everywhere for people to use. Doesn't matter if it's slow and clunky, so long as it works.

But internet access is so cheap that in many cases it'll cost you a couple of packs of cigarettes per month. May not be unlimited data with speed fast enough to watch HD video, but fast enough to send out emails and browse websites.

MY thoughts exactly.
 
So umm, there are these places called libraries, they're the last bastion of fight against people like the RIAA/MPAA/other copyright trolls who want information to be levied a surcharge regardless of their form... :)

But yeah, I dunno I assigned homework from the book for one of my classes, the book even goes so far as to state by each homework problem which section to read to find the answer for that problem. I got a student (and I'm sure not the only one) who used Wikipedia instead, I caught him because the terminology used was well beyond what I was teaching in class, he also handed in a printed copy and the font was all janked up and all the hyperlinked word in the wiki article were still underlined. Took all of two seconds to type in part of the first sentence he used to find the wiki article he copied and pasted from. Instead of a grade I wrote at the top "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plagiarism" unfortunately he managed to drop the class before the last day...

My overall conclusion, students are getting too fucking lazy to actually read through information that might not answer the question, but will teach them a little something along the way. Basically the different version of engineering students who would always be the first to ask "so what equation do I use?"





Master [H];1039584224 said:
The skill too look up something without Google is something I fear my children and their peers may not see in school.

One of my favorite "Oh shit I feel old" moments was when I went into a library and couldn't find the card catalog, I asked at the desk where it moved to, and the young gal who was probably on her first job ever as an assistant library person, had to ask one of her older co-workers what a card catalog was... they pointed me towards the row of computers on the wall and asked if I needed any help using them... (I was in my early 30s at the time too... *sigh*)
 
Master [H];1039584224 said:
...
My state has a bill in the works to re-introduce cursive writing back into the curriculum. Yes, they need to use a keyboard, but it would be very good if they can physically write something if the iPad dies.

What the hell. You mean they weren't teaching kids to write in cursive anymore? :eek:
 
Its not overblown when the schools require the kids to do their work online. That's why my cousins come to my home, they actually need the net to do the work. Without it its like us in the old days being told to do an assignment but not having the pen and paper to actually fill it out. I just am not happy with it but there really isn't much I can do about it other than complaints to the school that get filed under the "bs complaint box, file under ignore"
 
What the hell. You mean they weren't teaching kids to write in cursive anymore? :eek:

I'm pretty shocked too, i started it in school when i was in 2rd grade! but then again that was 1990 (IIRC) and a lot has changed...

Schools today are leaning way to far onto technology to teach kids.

There are schools in my area that are giving all students laptops, Ipads ect to do their homework on. If they break it the parents have to pay for it... their F'ing kids!!!! what do you think is going to happen...

"here 10 year old, here's a fancy Ipad / laptop. Don't break it now!" At least we know where all this money for education is going. I've always wondered where hundreds of millions of dollars ends up every year just for the state i live in alone.

but just my two pennies...
 
"A 2008 study by the U.S. Federal Reserve found that teenagers with computers at home were 6 to 8 percent more likely to graduate from high school."

Because teenagers with computers at home have parents who are not complete dipshits. You can add the computer and the parents are still complete dipshits. You have to solve the people, not the technology.
 
"A 2008 study by the U.S. Federal Reserve found that teenagers with computers at home were 6 to 8 percent more likely to graduate from high school."

Because teenagers with computers at home have parents who are not complete dipshits. You can add the computer and the parents are still complete dipshits. You have to solve the people, not the technology.

Yes, but unfortunately people will read that as "holy shit, people need computers to succeed!" instead of "holy shit, kids with shitty living conditions and/or stupid parents are more likely to fail!"
 
Adding computers to the education mix is bad. We as a nation continually keep sliding down the world rankings in education even though we keep throwing more money and technology at the problem. The internet for most people is entertainment. It isn't a necessity. Just like cell phones aren't necessities.
Saying some one's priorities are not correct because they don't put internet access above food or transportation in their budget is foolish. Maybe some people want their kids to grow up doing kid things like playing outside and not I'm front of the computer.
 
When I was in highschool I already had broadband at home. There were computers in every classroom and the library with full internet access available for any student to use. I graduated highschool over a decade ago. What the hell is anyone's excuse today?

This was my thought... I graduated in 2001 and my high school with a cornfield behind it in the middle of Michigan had computers in the library and high speed broadband
 
Adding computers to the education mix is bad. We as a nation continually keep sliding down the world rankings in education even though we keep throwing more money and technology at the problem. The internet for most people is entertainment. It isn't a necessity. Just like cell phones aren't necessities.
Saying some one's priorities are not correct because they don't put internet access above food or transportation in their budget is foolish. Maybe some people want their kids to grow up doing kid things like playing outside and not I'm front of the computer.

I agree that people shouldn't buy computers (or TVs or Cellphones for that matter) if they can't afford them, however computers are integral to most modern jobs so I don't see a problem using them in the curriculum (if they can figure out a way to do that rather than just shoe horning them in)

I think one thing that hurts the competitiveness of the US education system is that unlike business (who steals and shares ideas all the time) we don't do a good job sharing our success stories and processes in education ... that would be more useful trying to figure out a better way to share, leverage, and copy our good ideas to improve education rather than throwing more money at our schools ... it also doesn't help that we have 50 different state approaches to textbooks and curricula ... some standardization from state to state would definitely help ;)
 
MY thoughts exactly.

You can get also get satellite access across nearly the entire lower 48 states at speeds up to 12 down 3 up for $50 a month. You won't have tons of bandwidth but you could easily do what you need for research for school and between 2am-8am each day your bandwidth isn't counted against you so you can grab a download scheduler to setup any big downloads you want without a big hit to your bandwidth.

This service truly covers almost EVERYONE. It covers all the lower 48 and Hawaii and some of Alaska. Here is a map of coverage.



So really , don't tell me you can figure out a way to get coverage. No one HAS to use 56k if they just do some research.
 
He cannot squeeze DSL or cable access into his monthly budget given he has three children and a family to support.
Isn't that something that he should have thought of after having the second and then third child?

When you make choices in life, there are repurcussions, why should the majority pay for the mistakes of a small minority? Made bad decisions and they result in you not having convenient internet access? Well, then hop on the bicycle and get to a hotspot.

Beggers can't be choosers.
 
And IMO our real problem is that "leave no kid behind" is a batshit stupid concept in a globally competative market.

You simply cannot afford to handicap the vast majority for the tiny minority that can't keep pace with the rest of the group. That is what special-ed is for, and if you can't hack it, that sucks for you but there is no reason to not push the rest to be the best they can because they will need that advantage as the world is getting smaller every day.
 
I ran into this very problem myself as my professors assumed that everyone was on campus and I commuted 2 hours to get there. So the professors would be like download this 185mb magazine and have your work ready tomorrow. I would have to wait on campus everyday until 8pm when he would upload the magazine as all was available in my area was 14.4k dial up. So one day he came across the campus around 7pm and he asked me why was I still there if I had a 2 hour commute back home. I explained to him what the problem was and he told me to move on campus or give up school as most of the professors operated that way.

So I ended up dropping out as I was taking care of my father and mother. Would have been nice if he could have linked articles in advance or gave me the name of the physical magazine so I could buy it. But like he said he was doing what was best for the majority. I guess that's how it is.
 
I ran into this very problem myself as my professors assumed that everyone was on campus and I commuted 2 hours to get there. So the professors would be like download this 185mb magazine and have your work ready tomorrow. I would have to wait on campus everyday until 8pm when he would upload the magazine as all was available in my area was 14.4k dial up. So one day he came across the campus around 7pm and he asked me why was I still there if I had a 2 hour commute back home. I explained to him what the problem was and he told me to move on campus or give up school as most of the professors operated that way.

So I ended up dropping out as I was taking care of my father and mother. Would have been nice if he could have linked articles in advance or gave me the name of the physical magazine so I could buy it. But like he said he was doing what was best for the majority. I guess that's how it is.

Anyway you slice it that guy was a dick ... that is what is wrong with a lot of our higher education facilities ... they are built to force students out in the first 2 years ... although we need to challenge students at the post secondary level we don't need to treat them like they are in boot camp either ... I bet if we let business redesign our post secondary curriculum we would get something interesting :cool:
 
Back
Top