SpaceCoalition.com

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,708
With us less than 24 hours to the second to last Space Shuttle mission launch, you don't have to think far outside of the box of what all the Space Shuttle and its brave crews have given us over the past decades. In fact, SpaceCoalition.com would have you "Think Outside of the Circle." A quick look at the video will have you realizing just how valuable our space program has been and will hopefully continue to be, hopefully.
 
Last edited:
One small step for man, one giant expense for everyone else.

But I hope they get a replacement built and flown soon. We can't be stuck on this little rock forever.
 
All science aside, I would trade just about anything and everything for a chance to go to space. Although to quote Fry, I just didn't have the grades. Or the physical endurance. Plus I threw up a lot, and nobody liked spending a week with me.

But with this being the last shuttle launch, hopefully we can at least see an increase in unmanned space research. There is just so much that we don't know, it would be a damn shame.
 
This is not the last shuttle launch. This is the last launch for Discovery. Endeavour is scheduled to launch in February. Atlanits is tentativly sheduled for June and will be last shuttle launch.
 
Knowledge has no price.

While I can't deny the advances made in technology during the space program, I also can't see how we can put that much money into a program that nets such a small percentage of development in today's computer age. Simply saying that the money focused on specific endeavors during this particular time period maybe better spent. Space will need to be explored, but right now?
 
This is not the last launch. It got pushed anyways.

Yup. The final Shuttle is slated for a late Feb early March liftoff.

http://www.nasa.gov/missions/highlights/schedule.html

Date: Feb. 27 +
Mission: STS-134
Launch Vehicle: Space Shuttle Endeavour
Launch Site: Kennedy Space Center - Launch Pad 39A
Launch Time: 3:35 p.m. EST
STS-134 Description: Space shuttle Endeavour will deliver an EXPRESS Logistics Carrier-3 (ELC-3) and an Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer (AMS) to the International Space Station.
 
This is not the last shuttle launch. This is the last launch for Discovery. Endeavour is scheduled to launch in February. Atlanits is tentativly sheduled for June and will be last shuttle launch.

Atlantis was retired back in May 2010, but is the rescue shuttle they have on standby in case of an emergency.
 
If not now, then when?

Exactly.

NASA is a tiny fraction of the federal budget. It wouldn't cost much more to design a new heavy lift vehicle and start colonizing the Moon or push on to Mars, but instead we keep spending $8 billion or so a year to go nowhere.
 
We won't be leaving the circle till NASA makes a real effort to look beyond giant towers of explosive fuel requiring an army of scientists to operate. Just sayin.
 
While I can't deny the advances made in technology during the space program, I also can't see how we can put that much money into a program that nets such a small percentage of development in today's computer age.

Uh, what do you think started the "Computer" age...

Good thing Christopher Columbus didn't think that way for Spain's sake...

Talk about pushing what could be done with what was then current state of the art technology in ship technology...

We can all see how that ended up going nowhere by looking at what the UK eventually leveraged sailing ships into creating...

Whoever is the first to be able to get to the resources in the asteroid belt and use them is going to OWN the solar system. A single large iron asteroid will have multiples of the Earth's entire iron reserves. Much less the trace elements like iridium and other elements in extremely short supply on Earth...
 
No. The space shuttle is one of the most ridiculously expensive platforms for sending cargo in to space that we have ever built. It was so expensive from the get go that Russian intelligence agencies were convinced it was a tactical weapons platform. They did the math and discovered it was so insanely not cost effective, that we had to be using it for some other purpose like a weapons platform- they just couldn't believe we were that stupid. Surprise, we were!

Now after Billions down the drain, the private sector is finally to the point of bringing us cost effective space transportation. Don't let the special interest groups like Lockheed and Boeing convince you the space program is dead, just their insanely overpriced involvement is dead....
 
I'm just curious why we bothered with a space station built to support to human occupants if were just going to stop sending people into space.
 
Liquid/solid rocket fuel is NOT the way to travel if we as humans are serious about exploring space. Too heavy and cost prohibitive.

Still waiting for warp drive to show up.......
 
I'm always torn by the space program. On the one hand, I've been a space/scifi nut since I was a kid, having grown up on Star Trek and the like, so it seems a natural thing to support. On the other, it does seem like we've wasted an awful lot of time dicking around in low Earth orbit since the early 1970s. I don't dismiss all that we've learned about our universe, but come on... where's that pioneer spirit? What happened to actual exploration?

Screw it. I'm gonna go watch The Mars Underground and Defying Gravity again and get pissed off that the only sense of exploration to be had is from documentaries and science fiction.
 
While I can't deny the advances made in technology during the space program, I also can't see how we can put that much money into a program that nets such a small percentage of development in today's computer age. Simply saying that the money focused on specific endeavors during this particular time period maybe better spent. Space will need to be explored, but right now?

Look dork the space program has netted trillions of dollars to the American economy over the decades. Many of the items you use everyday came directly from NASA research and development. Your's is the same old ignorant argument they've been BS'ing everyone about for 40 years. Get a clue will you?
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venture_Star This is the next step. We have to use chemical propellant for now, so we should try find ways to make it more efficient. Taking up mere armfuls of payload at a time (Soyuz, Orion had it not been aborted) is a step backward. Throwing a crew directly to Mars atop a massive boondoggle rocket is likewise a step backward. The future of manned spaceflight lies in earth orbit. The assembly of larger vehicles in orbit before departure is the only sane way to go about planetary exploration. I support the creation of a heavy lift vehicle because activity is preferable to inactivity, but I really feel the shuttle will be missed more than anyone yet fully comprehends.
 
Look dork the space program has netted trillions of dollars to the American economy over the decades. Many of the items you use everyday came directly from NASA research and development. Your's is the same old ignorant argument they've been BS'ing everyone about for 40 years. Get a clue will you?

Wait, what? Are you telling me that other countries have invested trillions of dollars into our economy for the space program? No? It has been tax dollars from you or from what I can only tell from your adolescent remarks would be your parents' tax dollars. I am simply saying with unemployment hovering around 10% still and the economy limping along that spending more on space exploration doesn't seem fiscally responsible right now.

I acknowledge the fact that many items we use today were developed due to the space program but my ability to use a spork at a hospital cafeteria due to billions of dollars spent to develop it is a little out of date. I also recognize one floor up from that same hospital cafeteria kidney dialysis machines owe their design to NASA's technology advances. I can't deny that, it is fact.

But if you are going to tell me I have been making the same argument for the last 40 years then you are wrong. I am glad that you are okay spending more money on sending outdated spacecraft into space while our country needs a little bit of a priority shift. (commence political spinoffs)
 
mankinds one and only goal after solving all the shitty problems in the world should be no where else other than space and the cosmos
 
Is it possible to somehow use an atomic/nuclear explosion of some sort for a massively incredible boost in velocity in some direction?

Nah.

To me, NASA just seems like the place where the company knows it's not yielding anything because it can't, but tries to hang in to provide all those intelligent super-smart genius' jobs so that they can live. (I know this is not true, but it seems like it [or feels like it].)

And yeah, whatever happened to exploration? Where's the adventure in all this? :( You have to take risks with adventure, and if the characters in the story die, so what? (If they're willing to take the risks of flying into space in the first place, -- playing with their lives, you know -- then they ought to be willing to have a recorded adventure in exploration! HAH)

You know, I would just about be willing to sacrifice myself to travel away from Earth on a one-way trip, recording and sending back as many journalistic and observatory data possible. It would be lonely, yes, (and I know what some of you would load up on) but I imagine it would be a very awing (or "awesome") experience.

The world ought to build a craft that can generate oxygen and food, kind of like in that one [horror] sci-fi movie where they have to take this fusion thing into the sun to revive it before the sun dies.. and the captain of the last crew's attempt that crashed on a planet nearby to the sun slaughters everyone aboard and just at the last minute the main character manages to successfully complete his objective before being consumed by the sun.. (Hmm, now what was the name of this movie? :eek: I thought the title had something to do with sunlight...)
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venture_Star This is the next step. We have to use chemical propellant for now, so we should try find ways to make it more efficient. Taking up mere armfuls of payload at a time (Soyuz, Orion had it not been aborted) is a step backward. Throwing a crew directly to Mars atop a massive boondoggle rocket is likewise a step backward. The future of manned spaceflight lies in earth orbit. The assembly of larger vehicles in orbit before departure is the only sane way to go about planetary exploration. I support the creation of a heavy lift vehicle because activity is preferable to inactivity, but I really feel the shuttle will be missed more than anyone yet fully comprehends.

You can build things in orbit using heavy lift vehicles too. Even the Apollo missions had some orbital assembly before they fired the Earth departure stage. A truly reusable single-stage-to-orbit spacecraft like Venture Star would be great for getting people up to orbit, but heavy lift rockets are still preferable to a reusable orbiter for any construction in orbit. Why? Because you can do more of the construction on the ground where it's safer, easier, and far cheaper.

NASA sent up Skylab with a single Saturn V launch. It was 1/4 the size of the International Space Station and cost about $7 billion (vs $100 billion for the ISS).
 
I'd rather see us spending the money on space research and exploration than on many of the wasted programs currently being funded by our government. I'm not sad to see the shuttles go. I'm just disappointed that we don't have anything to replace them with. It feels like we are dropping the ball by putting this stuff into the private sector.
Mars, for our current level of technology, is just too far out of reach for manned missions. I believe we should continue to move forward with robotic exploration missions, and start working toward a base on the moon. Imagine all the innovation and technological leaps created by just building a base. But unfortunately this all takes vision and sacrifice, both of which are hard to come by in this day and age.
 
It makes you wonder the advances that could have been made if we hadn't been at war for the last 10 years.

Might Fusion power be a reality.
 
No. The space shuttle is one of the most ridiculously expensive platforms for sending cargo in to space that we have ever built.
Much like why the space shuttle is dying, you can blame the birth on it, and that's member of congress/senate/president. Originally the Space Shuttle was supposed to be much smaller, however one particular 3 letter acronym of the US needed it the size it is so it would hold a particular spy satellite they had at the time.
 
You can build things in orbit using heavy lift vehicles too. Even the Apollo missions had some orbital assembly before they fired the Earth departure stage. A truly reusable single-stage-to-orbit spacecraft like Venture Star would be great for getting people up to orbit, but heavy lift rockets are still preferable to a reusable orbiter for any construction in orbit. Why? Because you can do more of the construction on the ground where it's safer, easier, and far cheaper.

NASA sent up Skylab with a single Saturn V launch. It was 1/4 the size of the International Space Station and cost about $7 billion (vs $100 billion for the ISS).

Yeah I've nothing against heavy lift rockets if they work, but I worry about the amount of different failure modes. If a Delta II with some rinky-dink commercial payload fails: bummer. If a major component of a space platform or interplanetary expedition has to be popped after 80-120 seconds because a ten dollar part failed... that's harder to swallow. Also with heavy boosters, you're throwing away a lot. The guys at Lockheed Martin thought a reusable SSTO vehicle would work for lifting, and NASA put almost a billion dollars worth of faith in their decision. Let's take another crack at it.
 
excellent. we need more money for a space elevator anyway.
More money for a http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Launch_loop I say, gets rid of all of those little problems a space elevator has, like actually getting something to climb the thing, slowly, and getting power to it, and having it be strong enough, etc. Whereas this could launch enormous amounts as quick as a rocket, direct from electricity from the ground, and more then enough energy to do so is stored in the loop itself, and no new materials needed, and about the same cost to build, and less cost to launch something. As long as you can keep the thing stable. :)
 
Face it: it takes tons of energy to lift something that high into the atmosphere of Earth. Matter is created nor destroyed, but I'm sure one method is more efficient than the rest. How can we find this out? :(
 
Im impressed that there wasn't the usual waving American flag anywhere in that film :p
 
We won't be leaving the circle till NASA makes a real effort to look beyond giant towers of explosive fuel requiring an army of scientists to operate. Just sayin.

They have, it's in a huge building in Texas where Franklin Chang-Diaz is working on his high-tech VASIMR rocket. Unfortunately it still has to get into space but there are several other private firms also working on getting into space. Unfortunately it's going to take more some time and money.
 
Although that is true, Atlantis has also received authorization to fly on June 28, 2011, STS-135, as a stop-gap resupply to the ISS.

http://www.nasaspaceflight.com/tag/sts-135/

I doubt it flies at this point given the lead time it takes to prep a mission and the lacking funds. I know some NASA workers and govt work in general and they wait until there's an OK from higher ups before beginning anything. In this case without the funding they're not doing that necessary prep work so even if they get the funds released it might be too late to make the launch date. The window for launch prep start will close somewhere around mid January (6 month lead time). If they don't have the money by then consider the mission scrubbed.
 
Back
Top