Some thoughts on storage for a new system, comments please.

elleana

2[H]4U
Joined
Apr 15, 2006
Messages
2,590
Am going to be setting up a new system pretty soon, and am mulling over my hard disk setup. This system won't be needing storage - I have a separate file server set up for that. I'll be using it for gaming, watching movies at 1080p and general surfing etc. While budget isn't really a concern, I would like to get the best bang for my buck, and not pay double for a hypothetical 10% increase in performance.

I'm looking for quick startup times, snappy response in loading applications, especially media player applications. I know there will be lots of limiting factors, but since I'm getting a new system drive I'd like to minimize any potential bottlenecking here.

I know everyone advocates raptors for blazing fast performance, but what is the margin that raptors can give over say, the latest single platter 320gb wd drives? The problem I have with raptors is that the storage capacity is pretty limited - 150gb can fill up awfully fast, even if it just used as a system drive. A possibility would be to use the raptor as the os partition and add another drives to put programs on. Would that increase performance? (PS I know raid is pretty good as well but at this point I'd rather not have to mess with setting up an array)

I'd welcome and comments/suggestions/thoughts. I apologize in advance if this topic has been beaten to death already, but the search function isn't very helpful.

(Random question that doesn't really fit - what effect will partitioning have on performance? Let's say having two partitions on one drive, with one partition for the os and the other for programs.)
 
$299.99 300GB Velicoraptor:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136260
That's the new elite drive with the Raptor name

$89.99 Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD6400AAKS 640GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136218&Tpk=WD+6400AAKS
That's a pretty fast budget drive that is extremely popular right now. More storage, less cost, might fit you more. Only 2 platters makes it fast.

I provided Newegg links b/c everyone loves Newegg. I don't buy my drives from there because of the way they prep them for shipping (bubble wrap). I experience higher fail rates from Newegg than from ZipZoomFly. I use ZZF for my HDD needs.
 
$299.99 300GB Velicoraptor:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136260
That's the new elite drive with the Raptor name

$89.99 Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD6400AAKS 640GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136218&Tpk=WD+6400AAKS
That's a pretty fast budget drive that is extremely popular right now. More storage, less cost, might fit you more. Only 2 platters makes it fast.

I provided Newegg links b/c everyone loves Newegg. I don't buy my drives from there because of the way they prep them for shipping (bubble wrap). I experience higher fail rates from Newegg than from ZipZoomFly. I use ZZF for my HDD needs.

Be careful using ZZF, though. They used to be great, but now they're mediocre at best.
 
$299.99 300GB Velicoraptor:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136260
That's the new elite drive with the Raptor name

$89.99 Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD6400AAKS 640GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136218&Tpk=WD+6400AAKS
That's a pretty fast budget drive that is extremely popular right now. More storage, less cost, might fit you more. Only 2 platters makes it fast.

I provided Newegg links b/c everyone loves Newegg. I don't buy my drives from there because of the way they prep them for shipping (bubble wrap). I experience higher fail rates from Newegg than from ZipZoomFly. I use ZZF for my HDD needs.

So I'm guessing that the triple price doesn't really equate to a threefold increase in performance...

What about ghe WD3200 vs WD6400?
 
So I'm guessing that the triple price doesn't really equate to a threefold increase in performance...

What about ghe WD3200 vs WD6400?

Nope, no 3x the performance.

The newer single platter WD3200AAKS performs about the same as the WD6400AAKS. However, getting one of the new single platter WD32000AAKS is a bit of a crap shoot since WD decided to reuse the same model number as the older WD3200AAKS which uses two platters. As a result, many stores don't differentiate between the new and old version of the WD3200AAKS.

So if you want to know for sure that you're getting a fast drive, get the WD6400AAKS
 
It's also worth noting that in a review by (IIRC) StorageReview (or possibly Anandtech), the WD3200 (single platter version) isn't quite as fast as you'd expect based on expectations from the WD6400. The reason they got from WD was that they tuned the 3200 firmware for better acoustics and power consumption at the cost of some performance.
 
1080p files are huuuuge. (~15 gigs/2hours). So any decent library of movies/TV/games/whatever, is going to require space. Leave room for future expansion, if youre going RAID ensure you can increase the array's capacity at some later date.
 
1080p files are huuuuge. (~15 gigs/2hours). So any decent library of movies/TV/games/whatever, is going to require space. Leave room for future expansion, if youre going RAID ensure you can increase the array's capacity at some later date.

My HD movies are gobbling up space at an alarming rate. 15-25gig per movie :eek:
 
I know tell me about it. And now there is Dolby 5.1, 1080p pr0^H^H^H "anatomy" content out there as well.
 
Out of curiosity, what sorts of codecs/settings are you using for HD encodes (ripping with AnyDVD I assume, or is there something else out there)? What kind of encoding performance?
I'm not willing to sink money into Blu Ray stuff yet, but I'm curious what to expect if I did.
 
Back
Top