poison5151
n00b
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2012
- Messages
- 9
Hi all! Long time reader, first time poster here. Thanks to this forum, I've built a 48-drive filer for enterprise use at a 10th of the cost and 3x the performance of commercial solutions. That used Hitachi 2TB drives, RAID10, 2 Supermicro chassis, and hasn't had a single drive failure at a 24/7 workload in 2 years!
Now I'm moving on to conquer the next challenge: a home server. I've picked up a 6U XRackPro and will be using a Norco RPC-4224 as the chassis. Typical usage will be to rip/store Blu-Rays and backup home machines.
My two key decision points are the OS and hardware vs. software raid.
As far as the OS, difficulty of administration is not a concern - I'm a RHCE and pretty sure I can handle Solaris / ZFS / FreeBSD. Things that ARE concerns:
1. Stability. For a while, I will be rolling the dice and not backing up the data elsewhere. I am not very comfortable with software that has many or severe bugs, doesn't have a stable release, is run by one guy a la FlexRAID, has no support, or doesn't have a strong community. I can deal with something very stable that has lacking support.
2. Compatibility. I plan on running several apps that run on multiple platforms (e.g., sabnzbd). I don't want to spend days trying to compile things on a totally obscure platform.
3. Performance. The output of the entire thing will be a massive windows share that I can easily and directly access from the HTPC. I've read that people have had better performance with sharing stuff from Windows natively rather than using Samba on a *nix platform. Either way, my network speed (gigabit LAN) should be the constraint, not the server-side software.
Now, if #1 is fully met, I can throw a 1U Windows server into the rack to accomplish #2 and #3 by installing apps there and hosting the Windows share. However, the server itself will needless to say need a way to access the share on the Norco box, whether iSCSI or some other means.
As far as the RAID decision, I like the flexibility and performance of hardware raid (looking at you ARC-1882i with HP SAS Expander), but it comes with a price tag. Not to mention that it's probably overkill for my usage scenario. My main concern with any solution is that the data is safe (double parity). Also, since I will be buying drives as needed rather than all at once, online array resize is a must.
Believe me, I've read and considered many, many threads on this forum. But the lack of a FAQ / sticky makes it hard to objectively compare solutions and I'm afraid I've got analysis paralysis. So, what do you guys think? What OS and RAID type should I run? What's worked and hasn't for you? All responses are appreciated ...
Now I'm moving on to conquer the next challenge: a home server. I've picked up a 6U XRackPro and will be using a Norco RPC-4224 as the chassis. Typical usage will be to rip/store Blu-Rays and backup home machines.
My two key decision points are the OS and hardware vs. software raid.
As far as the OS, difficulty of administration is not a concern - I'm a RHCE and pretty sure I can handle Solaris / ZFS / FreeBSD. Things that ARE concerns:
1. Stability. For a while, I will be rolling the dice and not backing up the data elsewhere. I am not very comfortable with software that has many or severe bugs, doesn't have a stable release, is run by one guy a la FlexRAID, has no support, or doesn't have a strong community. I can deal with something very stable that has lacking support.
2. Compatibility. I plan on running several apps that run on multiple platforms (e.g., sabnzbd). I don't want to spend days trying to compile things on a totally obscure platform.
3. Performance. The output of the entire thing will be a massive windows share that I can easily and directly access from the HTPC. I've read that people have had better performance with sharing stuff from Windows natively rather than using Samba on a *nix platform. Either way, my network speed (gigabit LAN) should be the constraint, not the server-side software.
Now, if #1 is fully met, I can throw a 1U Windows server into the rack to accomplish #2 and #3 by installing apps there and hosting the Windows share. However, the server itself will needless to say need a way to access the share on the Norco box, whether iSCSI or some other means.
As far as the RAID decision, I like the flexibility and performance of hardware raid (looking at you ARC-1882i with HP SAS Expander), but it comes with a price tag. Not to mention that it's probably overkill for my usage scenario. My main concern with any solution is that the data is safe (double parity). Also, since I will be buying drives as needed rather than all at once, online array resize is a must.
Believe me, I've read and considered many, many threads on this forum. But the lack of a FAQ / sticky makes it hard to objectively compare solutions and I'm afraid I've got analysis paralysis. So, what do you guys think? What OS and RAID type should I run? What's worked and hasn't for you? All responses are appreciated ...