So Intel has Quad Core, what about AMD?

Met-AL said:
Exactly. Thanks to Intel and the Core2 we all can get more processing power for our buck. CPU prices were getting insane the past year and hardly any performance improvements were being made and the prices were still holding.

Yes, that's why AMD F@ns who'd never buy an Intel Processor should have been cheering C2D so they can buy their beloved Athlons cheaper.

Intel wouldn't have priced C2D at those levels if they weren't playing the take back market share game. If their market share looked like it did in 2004, I'd bet Core 2 Duo wouldn't have shipped at those wonderful prices at all.
 
Donnie27 said:
Again dewd, that's driven by competition=P Without Competition, there's no Xxxxx, FXxx or $ X $ to talk about.

Not something I'd lose sleep over. As I said, they're generally unstable, hot and overpriced processors, that exist by the grace of the competitor having a better model. With or without these processors, the competitor still has the better processor.

You make my argument stand up very well. Without Competition there's nothing for AMD to get desperate about.

There is though. Companies still have to make money. And in order to do so, they have to sell products.
In the case of CPUs, the hardware doesn't really wear out. You can easily use a CPU for about 10 years without a problem.
Now, if AMD would never make a faster CPU again, they'd be in financial trouble in no time, because people would just continue to use their old CPUs.
The hardware-market is rather unique that way. It has to compete against itself because the only way to make people buy new stuff, is to make the old stuff look outdated.
Since I've been into the computer world pretty much since day 1, I've lived in an Intel-only world for many years, and still I found myself buying new processors every few years. If anything, my upgrade-frequency has gone down, because the fierce competition between Intel and AMD isn't making them bring out faster CPUs.
Heck, the only CPU I wanted was the Itanium. New, revolutionary, tons of potential... But competition made sure it didn't get off the ground, so we're still playing with inferior x86 toys... Because if anything, fierce competition entails short-term business strategies.

So no, my vision of how the CPU-market works does not coincide with yours.
 
Donnie27 said:
Yes, that's why AMD F@ns who'd never buy an Intel Processor should have been cheering C2D so they can buy their beloved Athlons cheaper.

Intel wouldn't have priced C2D at those levels if they weren't playing the take back market share game. If their market share looked like it did in 2004, I'd bet Core 2 Duo wouldn't have shipped at those wonderful prices at all.

The whole fansim thing amazes me, and you are one of the best examples of fanism I have come accross.

The only thing I am a fan of is my money. When I plan a build, I set a budget and then go researching and reading reviews to find out what performs the best for my budget. For my last build, it was a very easy choice as the Pentium 4D's really sucked, but if I were to build today, it would be a closer choice between the X2 and Core2. Both companies have their CPU's competively priced to be within the same ballpark as each other, excluding the FX-62 which is several times more expensive then the comparable performaning Core2.
 
Scali2 said:
Not something I'd lose sleep over. As I said, they're generally unstable, hot and overpriced processors, that exist by the grace of the competitor having a better model. With or without these processors, the competitor still has the better processor.



There is though. Companies still have to make money. And in order to do so, they have to sell products.
In the case of CPUs, the hardware doesn't really wear out. You can easily use a CPU for about 10 years without a problem.
Now, if AMD would never make a faster CPU again, they'd be in financial trouble in no time, because people would just continue to use their old CPUs.
The hardware-market is rather unique that way. It has to compete against itself because the only way to make people buy new stuff, is to make the old stuff look outdated.
Since I've been into the computer world pretty much since day 1, I've lived in an Intel-only world for many years, and still I found myself buying new processors every few years. If anything, my upgrade-frequency has gone down, because the fierce competition between Intel and AMD isn't making them bring out faster CPUs.
Heck, the only CPU I wanted was the Itanium. New, revolutionary, tons of potential... But competition made sure it didn't get off the ground, so we're still playing with inferior x86 toys... Because if anything, fierce competition entails short-term business strategies.

So no, my vision of how the CPU-market works does not coincide with yours.

http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=35947

But, said principal analyst Malcolm Penn: "ASPs steadfastly refused to recover, not helped by a ruthless and ongoing AMD-Intel microprocessor price war."

Competition is making Intel and AMD produce both faster and cheaper processors.
 
Donnie27 said:
http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=35947



Competition is making Intel and AMD produce both faster and cheaper processors.

I disagree.
Back in the day, I went from 386 to 486 to Pentium in the course of about 5-6 years. And I really *had* to, because software pretty much demanded it.
And in those days, AMD wasn't really a player in those markets at all. I bought my 486 when AMD was selling its 386DX-40, and bought my Pentium 133 even before AMD brought out its 5x86 or whatever its name was (which was basically some kind of 486 retrofitted to the Pentium-socket, performance-wise it was a joke).
My last PC (XP1800+) lasted me more than 4 years, and even then I didn't upgrade because I had to. I did it because I wanted to. You see, I'm a programmer, and I'd like to toy about with 64-bit code and multicore.. so I bought one of those. Other than that, there wasn't much point in upgrading...
And I can see that my current PC will last me another 4 years easily.
CPUs just don't evolve that quickly anymore. Or well... they do evolve... back in the day it was more of a revolution... integrating FPU, going superscalar, adding cache, MMX/SSE instructions, clockspeeds doubling with every new generation...

Now we only have 64-bit and multicore, which isn't much of an impact because software doesn't demand it. Singlecore 32-bit CPUs are already fast enough for most things, even gaming.

Pricewars yes, better CPUs, no... Although Core2 could be a nice start... but the past few years with Athlon64 and Pentium 4/D, really didn't get anywhere, performance-wise (while AMD finally managed to compete with Intel for top performance, which they never could in the earlier days like I described above).
 
Met-AL said:
The whole fansim thing amazes me, and you are one of the best examples of fanism I have come accross.

The only thing I am a fan of is my money. When I plan a build, I set a budget and then go researching and reading reviews to find out what performs the best for my budget. For my last build, it was a very easy choice as the Pentium 4D's really sucked, but if I were to build today, it would be a closer choice between the X2 and Core2..

Then you have no idea what a Fan is:) I've said hundreds of times I'm a F@n of my wallet FIRST and foremost. I've bought more AMD than Intel processors simply because most of the time AMD had the cheaper product. Back in the BBS days, the word "F-A-N" was short for Fanatic. AMD Fanatics don't buy Intel and Intel zealots don't buy anything from AMD. I'll quickly admit to being Biased but a Fan, don't think so.

I didn't like not only the Pentium D's, but the whole PresHott BS, hehehe. I stuck with my old Northwood and then added an AMD A64 3500+ to be used mainly for Games. Since I had two computers, I didn't need Dual Core. Oh wait, I'm an Intel Fan I made a mistake buying an AMD processor, I must have thought it was VIA LOL!

When the X2 launched I only bitched about its PRICE, not performance. X2 kicked the crap out of Intel performance wise. But AMD missed a chance to kick Intel in the Nads with their high assed Prices on the X2s, hehehe. If saying such things makes me a True blue Intel guy, please tag me as such.

Both companies have their CPU's competively priced to be within the same ballpark as each other, excluding the FX-62 which is several times more expensive then the comparable performaning Core2.

I Absolutely disagree! AMD has to thank their lucky stars for Fans......Their fastest processor is somewhere nearer a $300 C2D performance wise. Then the 4800+ and 5000+ cost more LOL! E6300 is the Bang for Champ and might be the best bang for the Buck processor in history in THIS SECTOR. It can be transformed into a $1000+ processor pretty easily. So folks even mentioning it in the same breath are FOS IMHO. My buddy who works for AMD said AMD got their hands on a working C2D about the same time HP, IBM and the other large OEMs did. They knew about the Ass whippin' they were about to get, just as Intel did when they bought a bunch of Opterons. That's not "fansim" or fanaticism, that's a fucking fact;) Been to priewatch lately? 4800+ and 5000+ cost more than the E6600, that's a joke.
 
Scali2 said:
I disagree.
Back in the day, I went from 386 to 486 to Pentium in the course of about 5-6 years. And I really *had* to, because software pretty much demanded it.
And in those days, AMD wasn't really a player in those markets at all. I bought my 486 when AMD was selling its 386DX-40, and bought my Pentium 133 even before AMD brought out its 5x86 or whatever its name was (which was basically some kind of 486 retrofitted to the Pentium-socket, performance-wise it was a joke).
My last PC (XP1800+) lasted me more than 4 years, and even then I didn't upgrade because I had to. I did it because I wanted to. You see, I'm a programmer, and I'd like to toy about with 64-bit code and multicore.. so I bought one of those. Other than that, there wasn't much point in upgrading...
And I can see that my current PC will last me another 4 years easily.
CPUs just don't evolve that quickly anymore. Or well... they do evolve... back in the day it was more of a revolution... integrating FPU, going superscalar, adding cache, MMX/SSE instructions, clockspeeds doubling with every new generation...

Now we only have 64-bit and multicore, which isn't much of an impact because software doesn't demand it. Singlecore 32-bit CPUs are already fast enough for most things, even gaming.

Pricewars yes, better CPUs, no... Although Core2 could be a nice start... but the past few years with Athlon64 and Pentium 4/D, really didn't get anywhere, performance-wise (while AMD finally managed to compete with Intel for top performance, which they never could in the earlier days like I described above).

I like Audio, Video and Photos first, then Games. My last 2400+ sucked and my P4 2.6C was a beast. It lasted me for 3.5 years. I wanted better Game performance so I bought a 3500 and it served me well.

I still disagree, without competition you have collusion and we'd all be paying sky-high prices for all CPUs. This was the case when AMD and Intel were *Chummy* with each other. If Intel weren't competing with AMD performance wise, there'd be no 4 X 4, AMD wouldn't need it. I've always trans-coded Photos and Converted Raw video files. Sorry Scali but I see a BIG time different in my P2 350 and doing something in 8 hours, that would some time crash after 6 hours of wasting time. Now a similar file can be done in about 30 mins. Or manipulate 8MP Pics in real time.

It's kind of funny though. I remember when the Holy Grail was 60 FPS Average for Quake 2 LOL! Even see a 700 FPS time demo?
 
Donnie27 said:
I still disagree, without competition you have collusion and we'd all be paying sky-high prices for all CPUs. This was the case when AMD and Intel were *Chummy* with each other. If Intel weren't competing with AMD performance wise, there'd be no 4 X 4, AMD wouldn't need it.

4x4 still has sky-high prices. Besides, it will be slower than the cheaper Kentsfield. So what good does it to anyone?

I've always trans-coded Photos and Converted Raw video files. Sorry Scali but I see a BIG time different in my P2 350 and doing something in 8 hours, that would some time crash after 6 hours of wasting time. Now a similar file can be done in about 30 mins. Or manipulate 8MP Pics in real time.

First of all that's probably an ideal case, because movie encoding generally makes full use of dualcore. With any singlecore software (most software), you immediately cut the performance scaling in half.
Other than that, the P2 was still in the 'good ole days'. My example of the 1800+ is closer to what I mean. Somewhere around that time, performance stopped scaling, even though (or because of it?) Intel and AMD got closer, hence more competitive.
Like you said, the P4 2.6 was a fine machine for years. My brother still has a 2.4 GHz Northwood, which we sometimes game on... Playing Far Cry on it in 1024x768 with full detail is not a problem at all. Playing DVDs, surfing the web, photo editing etc.. it does it all quite nicely.
Media encoding is one of the few exceptions where a new CPU actually gives you a tangible increase (if you don't include the dual CPU systems that have been available for longer... a system with two 2.6 GHz Xeons from a few years back will still be quite good at encoding video... the difference with a modern dualcore won't be all that impressive).
 
I think I'll wait :D

amd1vx.png
 
Donnie27 said:
Then you have no idea what a Fan is:) I've said hundreds of times I'm a F@n of my wallet FIRST and foremost. I've bought more AMD than Intel processors simply because most of the time AMD had the cheaper product. Back in the BBS days, the word "F-A-N" was short for Fanatic. AMD Fanatics don't buy Intel and Intel zealots don't buy anything from AMD. I'll quickly admit to being Biased but a Fan, don't think so.

I didn't like not only the Pentium D's, but the whole PresHott BS, hehehe. I stuck with my old Northwood and then added an AMD A64 3500+ to be used mainly for Games. Since I had two computers, I didn't need Dual Core. Oh wait, I'm an Intel Fan I made a mistake buying an AMD processor, I must have thought it was VIA LOL!

When the X2 launched I only bitched about its PRICE, not performance. X2 kicked the crap out of Intel performance wise. But AMD missed a chance to kick Intel in the Nads with their high assed Prices on the X2s, hehehe. If saying such things makes me a True blue Intel guy, please tag me as such.



I Absolutely disagree! AMD has to thank their lucky stars for Fans......Their fastest processor is somewhere nearer a $300 C2D performance wise. Then the 4800+ and 5000+ cost more LOL! E6300 is the Bang for Champ and might be the best bang for the Buck processor in history in THIS SECTOR. It can be transformed into a $1000+ processor pretty easily. So folks even mentioning it in the same breath are FOS IMHO. My buddy who works for AMD said AMD got their hands on a working C2D about the same time HP, IBM and the other large OEMs did. They knew about the Ass whippin' they were about to get, just as Intel did when they bought a bunch of Opterons. That's not "fansim" or fanaticism, that's a fucking fact;) Been to priewatch lately? 4800+ and 5000+ cost more than the E6600, that's a joke.

My bad, I figured by the way you carry on about this whole thing that you were the president of the Intel fanclub and were feeling very vindicated now after going through the Netburst era. Sorry for thinking that, I apologize.
 
Donnie27 said:
say stupid stuff like Cheering for AMD is like Cheering for the 49ers.

:( I am a 49er and a AMD !!!!!! :(

Go Niners... we can still win the division by the way ;) also we have 5 Superbowl wins and ZERO loses.. no other team can match that.

Anyways... 4x4 looks awesome, I'll prolly get it... but many congratz to Intel for the C2D/C2Q :)
 
Scali2 said:
Well, technically I'd say AMD should have recalled the Athlon64 aswell.
The memory controller on most of them is bugged (even the new DDR2 ones), and only works when you underclock the memory, when you use 4 strips of RAM.
I'm quite sure that the 1133 MHz P3 would have worked aswell if you'd just underclock it.
AMD just can't afford to recall products, so they don't. Which is not a good thing.

What are you smoking? My box works fine with 4 sticks of ram.
 
Robstar said:
What are you smoking? My box works fine with 4 sticks of ram.

Just because yours works, doesn't mean there aren't any problems.
There's lots of people who could only run 4 sticks at DDR333 speeds, while officially it should be a DDR400 controller. And even those who can run at DDR400, often can't get their system stable with 1T command rate, so they have to settle for 2T, no matter how good the ram is they use.
And with DDR2 it's the same story... it should be a DDR2-800 controller, but with most sticks, you can't get it to run stable at more than DDR2-667. While these same sticks work at 800 speeds just fine in an Intel system.

I think AMD should have fixed this, and exchanged the broken processors. But they did neither, so far.
 
Scali2 said:
Just because yours works, doesn't mean there aren't any problems.
There's lots of people who could only run 4 sticks at DDR333 speeds, while officially it should be a DDR400 controller. And even those who can run at DDR400, often can't get their system stable with 1T command rate, so they have to settle for 2T, no matter how good the ram is they use.
And with DDR2 it's the same story... it should be a DDR2-800 controller, but with most sticks, you can't get it to run stable at more than DDR2-667. While these same sticks work at 800 speeds just fine in an Intel system.

I think AMD should have fixed this, and exchanged the broken processors. But they did neither, so far.

Sorry Scali, but your just wrong here. I have an AM2 system running two DDR2 stcks overclocked at DDR21000 speeds. Solid as a rock here... Maybe your referring to 4 sticks?

As far as competition goes, I can see your point, and it is perfectly valid, but (cough, cough) I have to agree with Donnie, on this one.

I understand fully the need to replace x86, but Itanium was not the solution. It would have simply put a global monopoly in Intel's hands. Now the way things look to be going as of the time of this writing is Future architectures will have a programmable Streaming processor dedicated to SIMD code.... That will be orders of magnitudes faster then what is on the market today. This was one of the driving forces of AMD buying, ATi, and is the reason Intel is designing an embedded GPU on there side. This sounds like a better solution in the end, for the sake of openness.
 
scali said:
The memory controller on most of them is bugged (even the new DDR2 ones), and only works when you underclock the memory, when you use 4 strips of RAM.
...
There's lots of people who could only run 4 sticks at DDR333 speeds, while officially it should be a DDR400 controller.

duby229 said:
Sorry Scali, but your just wrong here. I have an AM2 system running two DDR2 stcks overclocked at DDR21000 speeds. Solid as a rock here... Maybe your referring to 4 sticks?

Obviously I am. Try to pay more attention when reading my posts.

duby229 said:
I understand fully the need to replace x86, but Itanium was not the solution. It would have simply put a global monopoly in Intel's hands.

How do you figure it would be a monopoly?
x86 is Intel's architecture aswell, and that's not a monopoly either.
I'm sure AMD would move to Itanium clones if that's where the market is going.
And I'm sure that Intel can't get a true monopoly on Itanium, because they would be forced to allow clones, if their marketshare would be too large.

duby229 said:
Now the way things look to be going as of the time of this writing is Future architectures will have a programmable Streaming processor dedicated to SIMD code.... That will be orders of magnitudes faster then what is on the market today. This was one of the driving forces of AMD buying, ATi, and is the reason Intel is designing an embedded GPU on there side. This sounds like a better solution in the end, for the sake of openness.

We'll have to see about that. Such processors have very limited use. Don't bet it all on one horse. Besides, I don't see how the Itanium architecture would be in the way of such a development.
 
I read the whole thread, I just skipped past that one sorry.

As far as the monopoly thing goes, it would take the federal government getting involved, and making a court order. If you remember the same thing already happened to x86 years ago. Since then the agreements that were made then have been maintained privately between the two companies, and have been challenged in court several times by both sides... But as of this writing the agreement still stands in some form. I don't know what would happen for sure if the industry adopted ia64, but I do know that Intel would fight it, just like any sane company would.

I just wanted to throw it out there as a current possibility. That whole concept may end up getting scrapped between now and tape out. It may not work well, or even at all... I don't know for sure. I simply wanted to put it out there for the sake of presenting alternatives to a Itanium based Intel monopoly, that is enforced by federal patent, and copy write laws....
 
duby229 said:
As far as the monopoly thing goes, it would take the federal government getting involved, and making a court order. If you remember the same thing already happened to x86 years ago. Since then the agreements that were made then have been maintained privately between the two companies, and have been challenged in court several times by both sides... But as of this writing the agreement still stands in some form. I don't know what would happen for sure if the industry adopted ia64, but I do know that Intel would fight it, just like any sane company would.

But nothing changes, Intel still fights x86, as you say yourself. In fact, Intel is fighting VIA over x86 right now.
Other than that, I don't really care about Intel getting a monopoly on x86 or Itanium...
It'd just mean that other companies would have to work harder and come up with their own superior architecture.
I find that better competition than the current cloning. It would just need a revolution in the software-world, where you write (mostly) architecture-independent code. Although x86-64 already steers in that direction anyway... MS made a lot of checks in their C++ compiler, removed the inline assembly feature, and .NET obviously is architecture-independent by default. So most code that you write with Visual Studio should already run on IA64 with little or no modifications. And therefore also on most other architectures.
 
Met-AL said:
My bad, I figured by the way you carry on about this whole thing that you were the president of the Intel fanclub and were feeling very vindicated now after going through the Netburst era. Sorry for thinking that, I apologize.

No biggie, I get called an Intel F@n all the time, ask Duby229?. I'll tell you right now and you can save this. If K8L kicks ass and is priced nicely, I'll be on it like a fat dewd on a Ham. I didn't think Northwood sucked and I was disappointed big time with Prescott based CPUs and that Intel seemingly held back Pentium-M Chipset wise, so I bought AMD.
 
duby229 said:
Sorry Scali, but your just wrong here. I have an AM2 system running two DDR2 stcks overclocked at DDR21000 speeds. Solid as a rock here... Maybe your referring to 4 sticks?

As far as competition goes, I can see your point, and it is perfectly valid, but (cough, cough) I have to agree with Donnie, on this one.

I understand fully the need to replace x86, but Itanium was not the solution. It would have simply put a global monopoly in Intel's hands. Now the way things look to be going as of the time of this writing is Future architectures will have a programmable Streaming processor dedicated to SIMD code.... That will be orders of magnitudes faster then what is on the market today. This was one of the driving forces of AMD buying, ATi, and is the reason Intel is designing an embedded GPU on there side. This sounds like a better solution in the end, for the sake of openness.

Donnie27 slips off chair and busts chin on desk creating a nasty gash on his chin, LOL! :D Save this post, I agree with Duby:)
 
duby229 said:
I read the whole thread, I just skipped past that one sorry.

As far as the monopoly thing goes, it would take the federal government getting involved, and making a court order. If you remember the same thing already happened to x86 years ago. Since then the agreements that were made then have been maintained privately between the two companies, and have been challenged in court several times by both sides... But as of this writing the agreement still stands in some form. I don't know what would happen for sure if the industry adopted ia64, but I do know that Intel would fight it, just like any sane company would.

I just wanted to throw it out there as a current possibility. That whole concept may end up getting scrapped between now and tape out. It may not work well, or even at all... I don't know for sure. I simply wanted to put it out there for the sake of presenting alternatives to a Itanium based Intel monopoly, that is enforced by federal patent, and copy write laws....

Oh well, I knew it couldn't last long :D Itanium is a specialized product and at least Intel markets it as such. As I told you on the AMD side of the forum, I'm sick of all of these companies acting like Enthusiasts = Suckers with Deep pockets. Or High-end Gamer = Idiot with more money than brains. That goes for ALL COMPANIES, with NO exceptions, from crazy folks trying to sell $300 NICs, $800 Video cards or Intel or AMD $1000 plus Processors, One Quad or Two Duals.

Look, you think Itanium is a bad Idea, you're not alone. I think an Expensive, hot power hungry, and little 4 X 4 space heater is not what AMD needs right now. AMD is still doing well and would be better off not publicly worrying about Intel. That's something only their Engineers should be doing.

Still, November is almost gone, where's AMD's mighty $ X $?
 
My girlfriend has 4 sticks of DDR2 running in her AM2 system, and its overclocked like mad too..... and rock solid stable .... seriously, that cheap little AM2 system (cost like 120 bucks total) is the easiest OCer I ever put together, and damn perfect stability.

And regarding the comment made above about how performance stopped scaling b/c intel and amd started competing with each other.... what a load of bullshit....

performance stopped scaling because of physical limitations that BOTH companies were bumping into. The power leakage and transistor density problems really fucked both comps over, and from what I'm reading, there isn't much room to go smaller past the 32nm node either.... so really, it doesnt matter if they were competing or not (which doesnt apply here at all....)
 
Donnie27 said:
Itanium is a specialized product and at least Intel markets it as such.

It is now, but it doesn't have to be. It's just an architecture, like x86 is. There are various different versions of the x86, aimed at mobile computers, desktops, workstations, servers etc. The same could be true for Itanium, if there was a market. x86 is just in the way of creating a desktop market for Itanium at this time. Intel did originally have desktop-Itaniums on its roadmap though, but because of recent developments regarding x86-64 and Core2, they have disappeared (Itanium is the reason why originally Pentium 4 would be the last x86 ever, and Intel was reluctant to enable x86-64 support).
One thing that's interesting about Itanium is that its cores are very compact (the high transistorcount of the Itanium is mainly because of the large caches and 256 bit buses, which the desktop version wouldn't have). This makes them very suitable for multicore processors.
 
brucedeluxe169 said:
And regarding the comment made above about how performance stopped scaling b/c intel and amd started competing with each other.... what a load of bullshit....

performance stopped scaling because of physical limitations that BOTH companies were bumping into. The power leakage and transistor density problems really fucked both comps over, and from what I'm reading, there isn't much room to go smaller past the 32nm node either.... so really, it doesnt matter if they were competing or not (which doesnt apply here at all....)

Then why don't these problems seem to affect the GPU-market?
GPUs evolve at a much faster rate, probably because both the main competitors are about equal in size, so they don't compete as fiercely... And they aren't tied to a specific architecture, so they can be far more creative in finding newer and more efficient solutions.
 
Scali2 said:
Then why don't these problems seem to affect the GPU-market?
GPUs evolve at a much faster rate, probably because both the main competitors are about equal in size, so they don't compete as fiercely... And they aren't tied to a specific architecture, so they can be far more creative in finding newer and more efficient solutions.

I kind of disagree with you and Bruce on how much the Processor has evolved or can scale. My P2 350 sold for more than my 2.6C. For almost $100 more, my C2D shows that it is from 125% to 200% faster LOL! Prescott scaled and still sucked. I think the scaling issue is not relative to only CPU MHz/Speed but how it does its job. It scaled perfect if it can do the job at half the speed IMHO.

I was impressed when that trans-code of 200 photo took 24 mins instead of 46. I was shocked when unoverclocked I did it in 8mins LOL!

Having to use two processors to out gun one is weak, doesn't matter if it's Intel or AMD. I'll take the one every time. Well, it might matter to f@ns?
 
Donnie27 said:
My P2 350 sold for more than my 2.6C.

I'm not talking about price... Price depends on so many things. I'm just talking about performance.

Donnie27 said:
I think the scaling issue is not relative to only CPU MHz/Speed but how it does its job.

I never said it was about MHz/speed.
I'm talking performance aswell.
I guess it's hard to explain when you've not actually gone through the whole process of XT, 286, 386, 486, Pentium etc.
Back then the improvements were huge... Much larger and more powerful applications, GUIs, multitasking OSes, virtual memory etc... And ofcourse games made huge leaps forward... Games still make huge leaps forward, but mainly with the GPU.
Stick an recent GPU into a 3-year old Pentium or Athlon, and it will still play most games quite well...
And the OSes haven't really evolved much since Windows NT 4.0.
 
This whole Intel/AMD !!!!!!-ism thing makes me laugh. It's this simple: When it's time to upgrade, you buy the best CPU you can afford, period. Currently that's the C2D line. For my last system, it was an AMD Opty. If K8L rocks Intel's socks when it's time to upgrade again, I will buy that. Currently I am happy as hell with my E6600, it simply destroys anything AMD has to offer right now. That's not !!!!!!-ism, that's fact. If AMD can get back on top, they will become the best option again. These are CPU's guys, not religions.
 
Calefaction said:
This whole Intel/AMD !!!!!!-ism thing makes me laugh. It's this simple: When it's time to upgrade, you buy the best CPU you can afford, period. Currently that's the C2D line. For my last system, it was an AMD Opty. If K8L rocks Intel's socks when it's time to upgrade again, I will buy that. Currently I am happy as hell with my E6600, it simply destroys anything AMD has to offer right now. That's not !!!!!!-ism, that's fact. If AMD can get back on top, they will become the best option again. These are CPU's guys, not religions.

Well said.
 
Scali2 said:
I'm not talking about price... Price depends on so many things. I'm just talking about performance.



I never said it was about MHz/speed.
I'm talking performance aswell.
I guess it's hard to explain when you've not actually gone through the whole process of XT, 286, 386, 486, Pentium etc.
Back then the improvements were huge... Much larger and more powerful applications, GUIs, multitasking OSes, virtual memory etc... And ofcourse games made huge leaps forward... Games still make huge leaps forward, but mainly with the GPU.
Stick an recent GPU into a 3-year old Pentium or Athlon, and it will still play most games quite well...
And the OSes haven't really evolved much since Windows NT 4.0.

I still have my 16MHz computer and does a commie 64 in 1983 count? One more time, I remember when the holy grail was 60 FPS for Quake 2.
 
Calefaction said:
This whole Intel/AMD !!!!!!-ism thing makes me laugh. It's this simple: When it's time to upgrade, you buy the best CPU you can afford, period. Currently that's the C2D line. For my last system, it was an AMD Opty. If K8L rocks Intel's socks when it's time to upgrade again, I will buy that. Currently I am happy as hell with my E6600, it simply destroys anything AMD has to offer right now. That's not !!!!!!-ism, that's fact. If AMD can get back on top, they will become the best option again. These are CPU's guys, not religions.

QFT!
 
Donnie27 said:
I still have my 16MHz computer and does a commie 64 in 1983 count? One more time, I remember when the holy grail was 60 FPS for Quake 2.

Well, if that's all you have to counter the arguments I gave, I guess that says it all.
 
Scali2 said:
Well, if that's all you have to counter the arguments I gave, I guess that says it all.

Sorry, I gave up, didn't mean anything negative though:)
 
Anyone who fights over which processor is better clearly is married to his right/left hand. Get a fucking life.
 
Anyone who bitches/fights (gets mad and uses vulgarity like "get a fucking life") about people fighting about processors is married to his right hand! :) lol

I'm kind of excited b/c I'm hoping since AMD released 3 different price points, it might speed up the release of Intel's cheaper quad cores.

IE:
QX6700 vs FX-74 @ $1000
Q6600 vs FX-72 @ $800 (or less hopefully for Intel ! )
Q6400 vs FX-70 @ $600 (once again hopefully for LESS!)
Q6300 ! maybe? $300?!

The Q6400/Q6300 might copy the E series 6400/6300 and have only 2x2Mb, instead of the 2x4mb of the QX6700, and then it could be cheaper and beat the AMD price points by a lot hopefully!!
 
chrisf6969 said:
Anyone who bitches/fights (gets mad and uses vulgarity like "get a fucking life") about people fighting about processors is married to his right hand! :) lol

I'm kind of excited b/c I'm hoping since AMD released 3 different price points, it might speed up the release of Intel's cheaper quad cores.

IE:
QX6700 vs FX-74 @ $1000
Q6600 vs FX-72 @ $800 (or less hopefully for Intel ! )
Q6400 vs FX-70 @ $600 (once again hopefully for LESS!)
Q6300 ! maybe? $300?!

The Q6400/Q6300 might copy the E series 6400/6300 and have only 2x2Mb, instead of the 2x4mb of the QX6700, and then it could be cheaper and beat the AMD price points by a lot hopefully!!

That's the ticket!
 
drizzt81 said:
As I mentioned in the AMD subforum, the Heise news post is far from certain about ultimate being the only Vista OS that supports 2P. Their wording is that "apparently" the non-ultimate versions of vista do not support more than one socket. There are other sources that suggest that all, but the Home basic and below versions of Vista support 2P.

While you may be dead-set on Vista, if the 2P-requires-ultimate rumor is indeed true, WinXP Pro can be purchased for ~$120 or less as OEM version, which will run 2P systems without any problem and supports quite a variety of games, applications and other hardware.

The other part is, you'll need Vista UE because it has NUMA support and none of the other versions don't;)

$ X $ will show just who loves AMD the most. You have to be true Green Arrow through and true to spend that much money for something that NOT top of the line LOL!
 
Back
Top