SMART returned NOT OK... Now passes fine.

Zoson

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Aug 4, 2001
Messages
6,113
I've never seen a SMART error before, so I'm not sure what to make of this.

I bought a pair of 1TB Samsung Spinpoint disks and Raid0'd them. Two days later one of the disks threw "NOT OK" to SMART and the NVRaid tool told me that the disk was facing impending doom.

Freaking out, I moved all the stuff I had on it onto another array. I ran Bart's Stuff test, HDTACH and several other IO loaders while running SMART tests. It's now been several days since the original error, and the disk in question has passed SMART OK hundreds of times since.

Should I treat this as a fluke? Or should I be sending the disk back?
 
Modern hard drives have error correction built into the drives. Depending on the problem, and how long the drive took to fix it, your situation is not too unusual. That is part of what SMART monitors.

Run the Samsung diagnostics on the drive. It it reports ANY issues, then replace the drive. If not, then check it again in a couple of months. If it checks ok, then you just had a hiccup.

Don
 
Thanks for the reply DonDon. As an update, the disk fried Sunday night. It literally shot fire from several of the mosfets on the logic board. RMA'd and already on its way back to the egg.
 
Thanks for the reply DonDon. As an update, the disk fried Sunday night. It literally shot fire from several of the mosfets on the logic board. RMA'd and already on its way back to the egg.

Was there any hot lesbian porn on it? It may of been too hot for the drive :p

just kidding. Sorry to hear that dude, that really sucks. I've literally seen hard drives and motherboards catch on fire before though, its always kinda freaky.
 
yeah, imagine my surprise when my computer suddenly made a loud pop and my 1tb disk looked like a tricked out 1960's flaming hotrod.
 
Back
Top