Skulltrail for 2014

PCunicorn

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Mar 26, 2013
Messages
1,638
I am thinking of going crazy and getting a Skulltrail with 2 Xeon E5472s. I am curios, how do the E5472s hold up for gaming? I assume one would be Core 2 Quad level, and 2 would be 3770K level or slightly worse than a C2Q depending on the game.
 
For gaming, it's like buying a C2Q.

2 C2Qs can't match a 3770 in games due to the IPC advantage the newer i7s have over the C2Qs and also because games aren't usually heavily threaded. The 2nd processor would likely just sit idle or end up managing your OS/background apps. For games like BF4 which can use more than 4 cores, the relatively lower IPC of the older architecture would probably lower frames across the board.

I'd suppose with rendering applications (but depending on the app), you may see that adding the 2nd Xeon CPU will end up doubling your throughput.
 
I know it's not completely relevant to your original question, but I just completed my own EVGA SR-2 build for extreme overkill fun. I have two Xeon X5680's in it.

The performance is only marginally better in video games when compared my original overclocked first generation i7 920 CPU.
 
10% or less measured increase in FPS using the same graphics card in benchmarks. What MDA said is true, the games just don't aren't programmed to take advantage of more than 1 CPU.

In my case, my current Xeon CPU is very similar to the desktop CPU I upgraded from. I didn't do this build to increase performance though, and I knew about this heading into it.

If your goal is increased performance in video games, you may ultimately be disappointed. I built my computer more for glory and for fun.
 
Here is a link to my HardForum build log. Not very much info there regarding performance or benchmarking... but if you're considering the SR-2 there may possibly be some interesting bits there? I didn't post performance information because the SR-2 is old news and the CPUs are now getting to be 3 generations old.

http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1788025
 
Marginally? What's the margin?

Not enough to spend the money on a skulltrail setup. You really wouldnt even get cool points considering dual socket systems are not mesnt for gaming, and only have advantages in certain applications.

The same amount of money spent on a dedicated gaming rig would yield much better gaming performance.
 
I can get Skulltrail pretty cheap, less then $200, and CPUs are very cheap for it. T_Ski has 2 Quad Core Xeons for $50. The reason I thought of this is because:
Skulltrail, Dual Xeons, 770
Crosshair V Formula (already have), 8350, 7970
 
Build it just for the experience.
Don't build it if you want to game on it and expect more than "it works".

I have a 2600k for gaming, and my last build was an e3-1270 on an X9sca-f for ESXi 5.5 test lab.
 
after much forum spamming i settled on EVGA SR-2 and dual Xeons X5675. never considered going further back to skulltrail, among other things because SR-2 appears to have even better OC potential.

I never believed in gaming benefits of having frame rate above the display refresh rate. with the advent of lightboost and 120hz panels there are limited situations where a beefier CPU actually makes sense, but truth is that being "CPU limited" in a game is pretty rare. I try to reach the panel refresh rate while gaming, and usually i have better returns in buying a faster GPU than a faster CPU.

EVGA should launch a G34 dual mobo with overclocking. Currently only selected 4p mobos from supermicro can overclock on this platform using hacked BIOS.
 
Considering only the most modern games are capable of taking advantage of 4 cores, let alone 8 cores across 2 CPUs, I wouldn't do this for a gaming rig. You're better off buying a modern CPU that's quad core and clocked higher, for the same investment.

Anyways, without being an computer architect, I'm not sure if a single application can take advantage of two CPU's at once anyways due to numa node's. The program would need to be able to span numa nodes. Adding 1 socket is not the same as adding 1 core.

Also, keep in mind we're talking about 7 year old technology here (E5472s). I've been recycling stuff that old. But if you do decide to do it, you have to have memory equally divided amongst both sockets. Dual CPU boards are picky about memory DIMM placement.
 
Last edited:
The more cores the better. Always. Even if a game doesn't use all of your cores, the extras can still be used to watch HD videos on another monitor, or help encode a livestream of the game you're playing for example. More cores = a computer that does many more things at the same time. More cores, more monitors, less cable tv.

If you don't plan on doing anything like that, then the powersaving route with i3's is kinda nice. Those things are beasts for their TDP and their gaming performance is good.
 
The more cores the better. Always.

Umm... yeah... not true at all.

Ipads/iphones have been dual core for along time while many android tablets are going with 4/8 core monsters and the extra cores sit unused while better cores on ipad/iphone do more work.

An example: here is a brand new review of a new samsung tablet, the ipad air which is older than it by quite a bit is consistently faster than it, and at the top of charts.

Just because you can do more things doesn't mean you are and you are sacrificing single threaded performance.

game doesn't use all of your cores, the extras can still be used to watch HD videos on another monitor

Any current i5/i7 will handle doing both of those fine, no need for 2 processors (and realistically the gpu is probably going to be doing alot of the decoding for the video so its kind of a moot point), as well are you honestly going to be actively playing a game and watching hd videos at the same time?
 
Umm... yeah... not true at all.

Ipads/iphones have been dual core for along time while many android tablets are going with 4/8 core monsters and the extra cores sit unused while better cores on ipad/iphone do more work.

An example: here is a brand new review of a new samsung tablet, the ipad air which is older than it by quite a bit is consistently faster than it, and at the top of charts.

Just because you can do more things doesn't mean you are and you are sacrificing single threaded performance.



Any current i5/i7 will handle doing both of those fine, no need for 2 processors (and realistically the gpu is probably going to be doing alot of the decoding for the video so its kind of a moot point), as well are you honestly going to be actively playing a game and watching hd videos at the same time?

I think my "Always" part threw you off. :p Did you miss the part where I recommended an i3? And why even mention tablets, those things are toys. I have a Galaxy Tab 3 and that thing is so boring. And hardware acceleration with respect to flash videos is a crap shoot. It depends on which browser you're using and whether or not you're in fullscreen or windowed mode. Ever checked "Stats for nerds" on a YouTube video? And Twitch.tv for example doesn't use any acceleration because the Core 2 Duos I have that watch HD videos on it sit at 100% utilization.

We're already there. Grandma is checking her email on an i5 quad cores, might as well go the distance. 12 cores 24 threads for all!
 
Last edited:
Marginally? What's the margin?

Not much. Skulltrail loses in pure performance to many of today's much cheaper quads. If you are building it for fun, have at it. If you are building it for performance, you are wasting your money.
 
Wow, nice necro (and derail) geok1ng. BTW guys, I'm not interested in Skulltrail anymore. This thread is 7 months old.
 
Back
Top