Since when does "refurbished" mean "used"?

DaRuSsIaMaN

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Messages
1,216
I thought that a refurbished product was supposed to be basically new but somehow fixed up after having a defect. But from looking at newegg's reviews, it's clear that you might get a refurbished product that has been heavily used, and they don't do anything to clean it up. Has this always been a risk you take with refurb products?

I wanted to grab the refurb g510 keyboard, but now I'm really not sure. I would be pissed off if my keyboard arrived with scratches and other signs of use.

Do you guys know if I were to get it and then the one I received was all filthy and I wanted to return it, would I have to pay for shipping it back AND a "restocking fee"? Is that how NE rules work?
 
I've paid for new and clearly gotten used open box. NewEgg has gone down the toilet.
 
Refurbs can be unused returns or heavily used like monitors. I tend to think of it like Dysons, that the product has been brought back to new condition, but they don't always do this, and I agree, not right to sell used open box returns as new.
 
that the product has been brought back to new condition, but they don't always do this,

Exactly, they obviously don't actually do this, or at least not necessarily. So my question is, is this just a NewEgg failure, or is that the industry standard for refurbished? I thought that refurbished meant that it IS guaranteed to be like new. I thought that was the industry standard.
 
if you want new, buy new.

Last year, I purchased two video cards from the egg as new, and I got used; one clearly had fingerprints on the back of the card, and the plastic coating ripped, the other, looked scratched as well as having the plastic torn off and it didn't work. seemed like they were just restocking returned equipment without checking the boxes. Now when I order, I include a message that any product ordered new and appears used will be returned. I haven't received any more used products since then.
 
Now when I order, I include a message that any product ordered new and appears used will be returned. I haven't received any more used products since then.

Do you think that might work with ordering refurbished?

Also, what are their rules on returning it for something like that? If you wanted to return those video cards that you bought "new", did you have to pay for shipping and also a "restocking" fee?
 
Last year, I purchased two video cards from the egg as new, and I got used; one clearly had fingerprints on the back of the card, and the plastic coating ripped, the other, looked scratched as well as having the plastic torn off and it didn't work. seemed like they were just restocking returned equipment without checking the boxes. Now when I order, I include a message that any product ordered new and appears used will be returned. I haven't received any more used products since then.

Thanx going to do that too for now on. ;)
 
Refurbished means not new, period. I don't believe it has ever implied anything else, however some companies, will in detail describe, what refurbished means when it comes to their products. However with newegg it's different, they are supplied by many companies, for which refurbished means different things, and that brings different standards. Further more, products can be refurbished by the manufacturer or by a 3rd party, which again complicates things further. I don't think, it's unusual for a refurbished product to have scratches.

If you want new, you should buy new, refurbished can be a hit or a miss.


From Wiki
Different companies and industries may have different types of "refurbished" products. Since the electronics industry doesn't have a firm, widely accepted definiton of "refurbished", its exact meaning may vary from one product to the next, or one company to the next.[3] In various cases "refurbished" may be synonymous with "used", "reconditioned", "remanufactured", "recycled", "repaired", or "like new". Merchants do not often specify the exact reason an item is "refurbished", so buyers may be assuming some of the same risks of buying used equipment.
 
If you want new, you should buy new, refurbished can be a hit or a miss.

YOU even read the thread? People have been getting used crap when specifically purchasing NEW products.

ie 670gtx purchased NEW which was doa, stickers removed and finger prints all over does not constitute new.

Im done with NE, amazon now for web purchases.
 
YOU even read the thread? People have been getting used crap when specifically purchasing NEW products.

ie 670gtx purchased NEW which was doa, stickers removed and finger prints all over does not constitute new.

Im done with NE, amazon now for web purchases.

Yes, I have read the thread just fine, it's you however, that have not. I was replying to the OP, and not joining the off topic discussion started by someone else. If you want to talk about getting used product instead of new, you should start your own thread.
 
Refurbished means not new, period. I don't believe it has ever implied anything else, however some companies, will in detail describe, what refurbished means when it comes to their products. However with newegg it's different, they are supplied by many companies, for which refurbished means different things, and that brings different standards. Further more, products can be refurbished by the manufacturer or by a 3rd party, which again complicates things further. I don't think, it's unusual for a refurbished product to have scratches.

If you want new, you should buy new, refurbished can be a hit or a miss.


Thank you, that helps.
 
ive purchased hundreds of items from newegg. every item that was listed as new was indeed new, never an open box or a return. i have purchased 2 refurb items from newegg. my ps3. which was flawless. perfect condition, the only gripe was it came with the first gen controller, siaxis not dualshock. i looked hard and couldnt find any indication that it was a refurb except that it came in a brown box. the 2nd item was a logitech driving force GT steering wheel, i got that 2 weeks ago for 55$ sells new in stores for $120..... occasionally $99 on sale. This one was nearly flawless. had a few small marks ON THE BOTTOM of the clamps where it holds the thing down to the table. which i would expect..... both have worked great for several hours. the ps3 for 2 years.....no issues at all. =) love them both and i saved some serious coin =) if i do the math.... its enough to buy that PNY GTX 670 that was on sale yesterday........ =)
 
I've never had used items sold as new to me from newegg. Amazon on the other hand has sent me 3 other peoples returns as new items, one even had the other persons rma shipping label on the box I got.

Refurbished could also be items that had been in use a while and were fixed by a manufacturer under warranty and then manufacturer sells the broken but now fixed part to newegg who then sells them to us.
 
I got a Cooler Master Hyper TX3 from newegg two days ago. The package was re-taped closed and the heatsink was missing the "Remove Before Install" sticker from the base. The box of accessories was also opened though everything was included.

I purchased this as a "NEW" item from them and clearly it had been returned by someone. After being on hold for about an hour with customer service, I gave up and accepted the situation.
 
Wow what an atrocity, any comment from that Newegg rep on the forum? My last purchase which is my current system was thru them about 2 1/2 years ago..but after reading this, if this is really they way they operate now, I'd never make another purchase from NewEgg again.
 
I think the issue is that only people who have problems make thread slike these. I've ordered hundreds of things from NE and never had a problem. Even my open box stuff has been 95%+ or better.
 
I think the issue is that only people who have problems make thread slike these. I've ordered hundreds of things from NE and never had a problem. Even my open box stuff has been 95%+ or better.

Of course only the people that have problems mention it in threads like these. Why would someone post about a problem if they were happy with the service they receive and have no problems?

I have been buying from them for 7-8 years, and like you, everything has been great for me, only recently am I encountering problems. Along with the HSF issue, I also bought a motherboard in November and it was missing sata cables and I/O sheild. It took them 9 days to get them to me and no, it was not used or refurbished.
 
Last edited:
don't like a retailer? don't buy from them. Everything I have gotten from newegg was new an in sealed containers
 
newegg has gone down the toilet in recent years... i've quit using them as my #1 option for computer parts or electronics. Amazon has far and away won me over on price and service. Newegg isn't much better than Best Buy imo.
 
From NewEgg...you buy new...and you seldom get it. Might as well shop open box or refurb since that is what "buying new" off NewEgg gets you nowadays.

I've always received new products when ordering new products from newegg.
 
New Egg just put back return from peoples without even check them, and many time they resell it as new item. If only Amazon.ca will have the same choice as Amazon.com
 
I ordered an open box Corsair TX850 for peanuts two years ago and received an AX850 model in a TX box.

Thank you, Newegg.
 
Newegg doesn't check their returns I don't believe.

I ordered a "open box" Asus monitor a couple months ago. When I received it I noticed it had HORRIBLE backlight bleed...like, completely unusable. When I called Newegg for an RMA I told the rep that the monitor was nonfunctional and needed to be returned to Asus for repair/replacement (wish I had done that instead - paid $200 for a Asus 24" ProArt - didn't even think about it). When my RMA arrived I was shocked to see the exact same monitor a couple hours later was then back in stock in the open box section. That told me all I needed to know. Newegg didn't give a damn about it not working properly and just put it back up online.

Got to be careful with this stuff...but I do have to say that Newegg was really cool about it...bought two open box monitors back to back. Each had free shipping and each was paid for when I sent them back, so besides time wasted it at least didn't cost me anything. However, do note that I bought TWO open box monitors and they BOTH went back...
 
They have to be cool about it. I think the problem is, newegg knows some huge percentage of what they get back was user fault or preference. Like you think a GPU does not work but you forgot the 6 pin power. They also probably noticed like many companies that some things dont work for one person but are fine for another. Like maybe your case just runs hot, or another person just wont push a GPU ever so they will never notice it artifacts. And finally some people just put up with just about anything. Alot of guys here get a monitor then run it through a gamut of back light bleed, and dead pixel tests then send it back, but 90% of the world has no clue and will chug right through dead pixels. So they just figure send it out a couple times and someone will keep it.

Of course then there are the products that really are messed up.

But really homedepot and others do this same stuff, you take anything back they just throw it up on the shelf, I have even said to them this is bad then watched them throw it into the cart for the department, which means that guy will just put it back on the shelf at the end of the day.
 
So what you're saying is that it is the duty of every customer to covertly disable a product they intend to RMA thereby forcing a repair?
 
Think about what people do while typing on their keyboards. I would never ever buy one refurb or used. Maybe a speaker. Maybe even a desk. But not a keyboard.

Or a mattress, or a chair, or toilet paper....
 
Think about what people do while typing on their keyboards. I would never ever buy one refurb or used. Maybe a speaker. Maybe even a desk. But not a keyboard.

Or a mattress, or a chair, or toilet paper....

The toilet paper has been refurbished to "like new" quality, I swear....

Good point is raised.
 
I thought Refurb could mean used or not, just that it had a defect at one point and was corrected.
 
I always thought refurbished to mean not new - possibly repaired. Beyond that I never assumed anything. I treat refurbished purchases as I would used item purchases regardless.
 
Refurbished means used and refurbished by the manufacture or a 3rd party.
Never has been anything other than that.
 
I agree with the newegg defenders on this thread. Everything I've ever bought from newegg new has been new.
 
I don't get refurbished because I don't want to get something really used. If you buy refurbished and get something that was fixed up really nice, your just lucky.

Refurbished is just newegg acting as a middle man for a used product. It's like the FS forum here, some people take shit care of their stuff and lose all the boxes. Some people take great care of it and package up it all up nicely when reselling it. I'd just get something from the FS forum if your looking to save a buck by not buying new. Then you know what your getting.
 
Refurbished means used and refurbished by the manufacture or a 3rd party.
Never has been anything other than that.

Exactly. AND it means it should be in working order. Quoted from Wiki for what its worth....


The main difference between "refurbished" and "used" products is that refurbished products have been tested and verified to function properly, and are thus free of defects, while "used" products may or may not be defective. Refurbished products may be unused customer returns that are essentially "new" items, or they may be defective products that were returned under warranty, and resold by the manufacturer after repairing the defects and ensuring proper function.
 
remember googlegear? That's when these companies were at their best. Without competition, you clearly get duped on occasion. Some more than others...
 
Refurbished can also be stock sent back to the manufacurer (overstock)
More often than not it typically is reconditioned items and if a reseller is selling it then it could be used items as well

Take the following examples:

1. You return a receiver to Yamaha for repair, they send you another receiver and then fix the one that you sent in and sell it as refurbished (B stock).

2. You buy a TV from best buy and it does not perform as expected. They test it and it works so they sell it as open box item

3. You buy a PC from Dell and you cancel the order before it ships. They place the new PC in the depot as they can no longer sell it as a built to order and it does not match their standard config.

If you are going to buy refurbished, you are better off going to manufacturer imho and not a reseller.

That's deep, dude. Why didn't I think of this?

Sometimes you just have to spell it out for the people that just don't get it...
 
Back
Top