Silent Semi-Budget Gaming PC

  • Thread starter Deleted member 72990
  • Start date
D

Deleted member 72990

Guest
Hey guys,

I'm trying to piece together the cheapest gaming PC i can build that is near-silent and still very fast. I already have a case on the way (Silverstone LC-13B HTPC case) but i need to order the rest of the stuff. Also my goal is to make this PC as silent as possible, and would mostly prefer components (motherboards, video cards) to be fanless or designed to be quiet.

I'd say my budget is 600-700 for everything (including power supply)

What about something along these lines:

Core 2 Duo E7300 ($119)
SLI or Crossfire motherboard (~$150)
2x Geforce 9600 GT or 1x Radeon 4850
1x 640 GB SATA hard drive
4x 1Gb Crucial Ballistic DDR2 1066 ($25 from newegg after rebate)
Corsair 650 W quiet power supply ($100)
Samsung 22x dvd burner ($20)
Aftermarket CPU Heatsink (~$50)

I'm willing to consider any alternatives to the above.

Thanks!
 
that was at the top of my list on newegg, it was a great price, i think $159 after rebate but they are sold out. I will keep it in mind for when it comes back :)

Is my choice of CPU too far at the low end to keep up with dual 4850s? I plan to overclock it but I know that will only get me so far.
 
is there any particular reason beside the price that makes you go for 4 x 1GB ram at 1066 rather than 2x2gb?

I mean there's plenty of low price ddr2 800 2x2gb kits right now.
Like G.Skill Pi Black, Patriot Viper 6400LLK...

check http://www.frostytech.com/top5heatsinks.cfm
for their ranking of low noise heatsinks....

as for bottlenecking, probably depend on what settings you use when gaming. Also you can drop down to a pair of 4830 cf too...
 
is there any particular reason beside the price that makes you go for 4 x 1GB ram at 1066 rather than 2x2gb?

I mean there's plenty of low price ddr2 800 2x2gb kits right now.
Like G.Skill Pi Black, Patriot Viper 6400LLK...

check http://www.frostytech.com/top5heatsinks.cfm
for their ranking of low noise heatsinks....

as for bottlenecking, probably depend on what settings you use when gaming. Also you can drop down to a pair of 4830 cf too...

No, the price is really the only reason why i'm going for 4x1GB. 4GB of 1066 Ram for about $25 total seems to be pretty sweet. Is there a reason why i should consider 2x2gb (better latency??)

P.S. thanks for the heatsink link. That scythe heatsink in #1 spot looks massive, i like it!

As for game settings, I'd like to run them at the max settings i'm capable of on a 22" LCD monitor (i havent bought one yet), with high AA and AF enabled.

Whats the benefit of a core 2 duo with 6 mb cache as opposed to 3mb? Does that make a big difference in games?
 
I have a Visiontek 4850 and when the fan gets going its pretty loud, just FYI. I know the sapphire is even louder but has better cooling. I don't think you will be able to play Crysis on max with a 22" LCD at 1680x1050 with a 4850 from what I have read.
 
How good is the cooling in your case? All of those passively-cooled components are going to produce a lot of heat.

For the E7300, you don't need RAM faster than DDR2 800. I suggest that you instead go with the G.Skill 2x2GB DDR2 800 CL5 kit, as mail-in rebate amounts don't translate into instant savings at checkout. There's no noticeable performance benefit to using CL4 memory, so unless you could pick up some for $40 before rebates, don't bother.

For your gaming demands, you should look at one of the HD4870 or GTX 260 models. For AA/AF, you may want one of the newer models -- the 1GB HD4870 or the GTX 260 Core 216. However, I've seen few of those cards with anything resembling a passive cooling solution (which I wouldn't recommend, as these cards run hot already under load with their stock coolers).

L2 cache really doesn't make much difference in games. At a 1680x1050 resolution, most games are more dependent on the video card than the processor.
 
If noise is a priority, never go SLI or Xfire - only get one decent GPU. As the previous poster said, two cards, even passive cards, will generate more heat which will require more overall cooling which means more noise.

And get an Intel chipset motherboard not an nVidia SLI board as they are more stable. (And last I looked they ran cooler). A P35 or similar would be good for you.

But I'm don't think that your objective of making your PC "as silent as possible" while keeping it a powerful gaming machine is realistic on a budget. You're moving into the realm of the silence enthusiast and you're going to have to spend for it. For example (and this really only applies if you really are serious about noise) :

- You will have to replace all your case fans (i.e. to Yate loons or Nexus or low speed S-FLEX's or similar) and use silicone/rubber fan gaskets and silicone/rubber fan mounts to hold them in place while keeping them isolated from the case.
- A temperature controlled automated fan controller like the T-Balancer is essential because most of the time your fans will be running less than 750rpm, but you'll occationally need them to go faster if you're gaming for long periods of time or stress testing.
- You will need to isolate your harddrives ideally through a combination of hard drive enclosures and rubber band suspension (or just use a silicone pad).
- You will also want a silicone gaskets for your PSU.... (actually, anything with moving parts will need to be isolated and vibration dampened)
- This might be overkill but the last time I had a 775, I deliberately got 2 x 2GB DDR2 because they produced less heat, required less cooling, which means less noise, than 4x1GB DDR2.
- Your PC will still make some noise, so make sure your case is reinforced by acoutic dampening material...

I could go on, but you get the picture, a powerful gaming machine that is as quiet as you can make it (without spending huge amounts of money) is not going to be a budget PC.
 
No, the price is really the only reason why i'm going for 4x1GB. 4GB of 1066 Ram for about $25 total seems to be pretty sweet. Is there a reason why i should consider 2x2gb (better latency??)

Well with all slots filled there's more stress on the motherboard and memory controller to go with more heat, so I would advice against it. Plus with 2x2gb you still have room for the future should you decide to run 8gb ram. The patrio viper 6400LLK runs at cas4 timings and are currently $49.99 with a $20 mir at newegg.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820220293

Even though the voltage states 2.1v, I'm actually running them at 1.8v with my ud3p mobo without issue. According to tomshardware's review, they overclock nice should you decide to do so.
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/ddr2-ram-memory,2079-6.html


I agree with the posts above that if you want to play full settings for a 22", you should look at a 4870 1gb or gtx260 instead.

The gtx260 (I have a bfg oc maxcore) runs a bit quieter to my ears when compared to a friend's 4870 512mb.

Cpu cache won't make any noticible difference.
 
If i get a better core 2 duo, the one with 1333 mhz FSB, would it be in my best interest to get 1066 mhz ram to give me more headroom to overclock, or would that 800 mhz memory with tighter timings be better, and just adjust the clock ratio in the bios?

P.S. I should rename this thread to Semi-Silent Semi-Budget PC.
 
Also, some things worth noting:

The 2 video cards will be situated right in the middle of the case, with a 92mm fan blowing on them from the front of the case. The case will have 1 92mm intake fan and 3 80mm exhaust fans. The fans are all rated at 18db or less. There will be 1 hard drive and 1 optical drive, both will be acoustically dampened. The hard drive will be in a 5.25' bay below the optical drive and away from the video cards. The case is designed such that the power supply draws in air from the outside of the case and then discharges out the back of the case.

Here's my parts list so far (exluding case and fans):

CORSAIR CMPSU-650TX 650W ATX12V / EPS12V SLI Ready CrossFire Ready 80 PLUS Certified Active PFC Power Supply - Retail $99

2x - Kingston HyperX 2GB 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 1066 (PC2 8500) Desktop Memory Model KHX8500D2/2GR - Retail $48.98

GIGABYTE GA-EP45-UD3P LGA 775 Intel P45 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail $136.99

Intel Core 2 Duo E8500 Wolfdale 3.16GHz LGA 775 65W Dual-Core Processor Model BX80570E8500 - Retail $187.99

2x Customer Reviews for GIGABYTE GV-R485MC-1GH Radeon HD 4850 1GB 256-bit GDDR3 PCI Express 2.0 x16 HDCP Ready CrossFire Supported Video Card - Retail $380

Total cost $853.98 + still need aftermarket heatsink for CPU
 
Are you interested in modding? One thing I can say is that depending on the case you are using it might be a good idea to strap in two 92mm fans in the back and a single 120mm in the front. This will help minimize fan vibration if you get medium or low noise ones (Yate Loons, Nexus, Noctua, Scythe) but will still push as much air or close to as much.
 
Note that a passive GPU generates the "identical" amount of heat as the same GPU with active cooling. And that heat needs to be removed somehow.

Most people going for a quiet PC will not have any fans under 120mm especially in a gaming PC. Those tiny fans at high speed will be noticable no matter what their marketing says, and you've got 4 of them. And if you're going Xfire with twin passive 4850's, you're going to be relying solely on those 4 80/92mm screamers to keep your overall system cool. The 4850's produce a lot of heat and your 80mm fans "will" have to be high rpm to be effective. Making it even worse is that you will have two hot 4850's next to each meaning that they will require even more cooling.

What does this mean?

You're going to have a heck of a noisy system, and it's not going to be the gentle type of loud it's going to be that really annoying high pitched type of noise.

If you really want SLI or Xfire, I suggest you look for a decent gaming case with decent airflow and large fans.
 
i'm entertaining the idea of just getting 2x Radeon 4870s with giant coolers on them and calling it a day.

I think you guys are probably right about all of this. I'd hate to get 2 passive video cards only to have them fry.
 
Pick up a e5200 instead of the e7300 and put the rest into the gpu choices, thats if your overclocking. E5200 is a beast and worth buying over the e7200/e7300 imo, even more if your overclocking. What more can you want from a 80 buck chip? :)
 
i'm entertaining the idea of just getting 2x Radeon 4870s with giant coolers on them and calling it a day.

I think you guys are probably right about all of this. I'd hate to get 2 passive video cards only to have them fry.

Didn't mean to discourage you here. You can handle Xfire and you'll have a hell of a powerful semi-quiet setup with two passive 4850 (or even twin 4870's but they make more noise).

But it just means that case choice is probably one of the more important decisions you'll have to make as you'll need good airflow. Maybe an Antec 1200 or a Silverstone FT01 or similar... Up to you as choosing a decent case is more of a personal thing (as long as it has decent airflow and quiet fans). Regardless, good luck in whatever you pick. :)
 
If i get a better core 2 duo, the one with 1333 mhz FSB, would it be in my best interest to get 1066 mhz ram to give me more headroom to overclock, or would that 800 mhz memory with tighter timings be better, and just adjust the clock ratio in the bios?

P.S. I should rename this thread to Semi-Silent Semi-Budget PC.

Some figures:

Danny Bui said:
Stated FSB/4 = Actual FSB
Actual FSB x 4 = Stated FSB
Multiplier x Actual FSB = CPU Speed
1:1 Ratio: 2 x Actual FSB = RAM Speed
1:1 Ratio: FSB = 1/2 RAM speed

Note that C2D systems don't see a performance increase with any ratio higher than 1:1

E5200:
Multi x Actual FSB, Stated FSB, RAM Speed = Clock Speed
12.5 × 200Mhz, 800Mhz, DDR2-400 = 2.50Ghz <<== Stock speeds
12.5 × 266Mhz, 1066Mhz, DDR2-533 = 3.32Ghz <<== Easy OC
12.5 × 300Mhz, 1200Mhz, DDR2-600 = 3.75Ghz <<== Excellent OC

E7300:
Multi x Actual FSB, Stated FSB, RAM Speed = Clock Speed
10 × 266Mhz, 1066Mhz, DDR2-533 = 2.66Ghz <<== Stock speeds
10 X 333Mhz, 1333Mhz, DDR2-667 = 3.33Ghz <<== Easy OC
10 X 350Mhz, 1400Mhz, DDR2 700 = 3.5Ghz <<= Excellent OC
10 × 400Mhz, 1600Mhz, DDR2-800 = 4.0Ghz <<== If you're extremely luckly

E8400:
Multi x Actual FSB, Stated FSB, RAM Speed = Clock Speed
9 x 333Mhz, 1333Mhz, DDR2 667 RAM = 3.0Ghz <== Stock Speeds
9 x 400Mhz, 1600Mhz, DDR2 800 RAM = 3.6Ghz <== Easy OC
9 x 450Mhz, 1800Mhz, DDR2 900 RAM = 4.0Ghz <== Excellent OC
9 x 500Mhz, 2000Mhz, DDR2 1000 RAM = 4.5Ghz <== If you're EXTREMELY lucky

Ideally, you buy faster RAM so that you don't have to adjust the RAM settings on your own while overclocking. DDR2 800 RAM is a generally good choice as you would still be able to obtain a decent overclock with it, but DDR2 1000 RAM is handy for overclocking processors with the 1333MHz FSB. The only time that I would recommend DDR2 1066 RAM is if you can find it for around the same price as, if not lower than a similar set of DDR2 1000 RAM.
 
Back
Top