Should You Worry About Data Rot?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Should you worry about data rot? I don’t know, can you dig around your desk / office and find burned CDs almost a decade old? How do you store your important data? Do you migrate your data to new formats?

Data rot refers mainly to problems with the medium on which information is stored. Over time, things like temperature, humidity, exposure to light, being stored not-very-good locations like moldy basements, make this information very difficult to read.
 
I just recently went through all my burned disks looking to "re"-backup anything worth keeping. I couldn't believe all the accumulated junk I had saved. I reduced the last 6-7 years of stuff by 75%. All the files were intact.......and most of the disks were generics.
 
I was just recently going through some compact discs that I burned in late 1999 and a bunch of them had what looked like corrosion on the inner metallic layer. I was able to get most of the data off of them and onto an external HDD but there are a few things I lost :(
 
I started burning stuff exactly about a decade ago.

Still haven't found a single case of rot...

Not that I don't ever expect to... I've been using Quickpar to keep 100% parity back-ups of anything I hope to have last for any amount of time...

I've been using Pioneer burners almost exclusively (exclusively for the last six years, though...), otherwise I just tend to use whatever media...

YMMV, but the shelf life in my experience has been good... And I have ~11,000 burned discs, with ~2,000 additional blanks to be burned someday... (HDs are just too convenient, so my burning days maybe are over...)

From my experience the rot concern is overblown... (I'm actually pleasantly surprised to say that...)
 
in a word.. no I don't worry about it. If it was that important, I'd be saved in multiple locations. I did happen to pick up a spindle of CDs that was sitting near the window.. and sure enough the part that was always in the sun was faded out and non-working.
 
ah heck, if you're just backing up porn or something, just put it on torrents. i'm sure plenty of people would be happy to keep the torrent alive and well for you to retrieve later.

in all seriousness, i'm a little surprised that usb flash drives weren't included in the discussion. i would like to know how long it takes for one of those things to retain data integrity.
 
The first CD I burned ever was in 1996, and it still works, and most of whats on there is useless
 
slowly organizing and going through all my old cd's hoping to have everything cleaned up by the time my windows 7 cd comes in. Pretty much everythings working except some scratched nlited XP disks that I just throw around.

I'm with monkey on this I have reduced so much wasted garbage while going through everything.
 
I use Taiyo Yuden media for backups. Never had an issue with anything corroding, including all the really old stuff.
 
I disagree with the author on using online as a form of backup. His example is a photobucket type website where hosting for strictly pictures is free and profit is derived from mainly advertising. A reputable service for data backup can last a very long time but it almost cost money. Personally, I burn to optical, keep a copy on my hard drive, and sometimes upload online.

My original burned CD of Starcraft: Broodwars which has a good 10+ years on it still works fine too.
 
I started burning CDs back in 1997. The only ones that have "rotted" are some audio cds that stayed in my truck and heat got to them. Most of my data backups have been kept in my desk which is inside in a climate controlled environment. Except for a few discs with old projects I created for college that I sometimes use for reference when setting up a database, 90% of what I have I should kick to the curb.
I can not remember the last time I burned a CD or a DVD. I now have so much hard drive space on multiple machines, that I have no need to back up to cd or dvd. For transportation of media that is not sent over the net, I have thumbdrives and a notebook.
 
Maybe it's just me, but I really don't trust my data sitting on ANYTHING archived. CDs, Tapes, Hard Drives, whatever.

It's got to be actively backed up in a production server somewhere... And then you have ARCHIVE servers if you need historical data.
 
Yeah, I still do a DVD backup of my documents and few other things once every 6 months or so, but I got crapped copied over 5 different backup harddrives, heh
 
ah heck, if you're just backing up porn or something, just put it on torrents. i'm sure plenty of people would be happy to keep the torrent alive and well for you to retrieve later.

With retention policies at most usenet providers at over a year and rising, I've actually suggested usenet to people before. Don't know if I'd even trust encryption on anything personal, but if it's just a movie, songs, etc, just post 'em, and you'll know they'll be around for a year... End of the year, download 'em again if need be, then just re-post them again...

Chances are someone else will be thankful for it, too...
 
I have exactly once CD with important crap on it. Fortunately for me I've never had anything of significance to keep on the computer outside of family photos, and that's whats backed onto the CD. I have a bunch of videos and programs floating around on my drives, but nothing that I can't find again if I had a crash.
 
Like above, the only discs I've had go bad were ones that were in the car for an extended period of time (heat). Of course scratches will kill a disk quick too.
 
One of my first ever burned CDs was a recording of a band I was friends with. The CD is over 11 years old now. For kicks I went back and played it, and it still plays fine. I didn't take any special steps to preserve it either, that's for sure.
 
Maybe it's just me, but I really don't trust my data sitting on ANYTHING archived. CDs, Tapes, Hard Drives, whatever.

It's got to be actively backed up in a production server somewhere... And then you have ARCHIVE servers if you need historical data.

That would be bordering on anal me thinks...
 
I've slowly been moving all my stuff back onto large HDD from old CDs and DVDs or downloading newer versions of old stuff and just downloading it (anime, movies, music and programs), heck if anyone ever busts me for it I'll stick the non working CD/DVDs in their face and say "Fine, replace this!". What really worries me right now are Blu-rays, I mean we already had one recall early in Blu-rays live with an issue where the discs would rust way to soon.
 
I haven't backed anything up on optical media for a while now. With so many hard drives, including a couple externals, my entire house will have to burn down before I'll actually lose something!
 
i dont care for his comment about hard disks only lasting about 5 years. I've got some ancient IDE hdd's that still run fine. If you are that worried about losing your data, its time for RAID.
 
I still have my old CD and DVD discs, but about 1 year ago during a main rig upgrade my old rig turned into a light server running Xp64 with 5 x 500gig hd's in raid 5. I copied all iso's and loose data onto it from my old discs onto that. I recently ran out of room and had to upgrade to 5 x1tb. When I did that all discs were still readable, the oldest being from the mid to late 90's.
I do keep all my discs in their jewel cases, inside a box, in a relatively cool and dry room. So they have not been exposed to undue heat, light, or moisture.

I do not however, have a way of accessing about 40gigs worth of Win 3, NT, and Win9x images, as well as various loose data off of my LS120 disks. I need to look around and find a LS120 eide drive since I have no idea what happened to either of the two I used to have. I have been putting it off since I have no use for the images, and I believe the rest of are little more than random downloaded utilities and porn from the mid to late 90's.
 
Nowadays if I want something stored I copy it on my external offline backup drives and/or server. It was really a long time ago that I even backed something to CD's, even DVD's.
 
I have data on some discs that are close to 10 years old (with some data stretching back to the mid-to-early 90s), and in a few weeks I'll be spending a day or two going over them and re-burning them on newer media. I'll also be doing some additional error protection using PAR technology, so instead of each DVD having just content, it'll have content with PAR files as well so, if they get scratched to some degree I'll still be able to recover the data later on... just in case.

Takes a little bit longer, but, my philosophy has always been if it's worth my time to acquire it, it's worth the time to burn it or archive it so, putting some extra time and effort into doing it the right way isn't a problem.

When I get done from this project I'll have everything I've acquired since roughly 1993 or so safely stored for the future on new media that's verified, error checked, and error corrected to the max... ;)
 
Save those moisture packets.. they seem to help with this sort of thing.

I'm a hard drive backup type and haven't had any issues.

Longterm storage is simple.. Just grab a book and start writing out ones and zeros .. presto :D
 
The real problem lies in newer formats. With a CD or a DVD, if there’s an error, often it’s non-recoverable, and you’ve just lost all your information.

And if you set a giant magnet next to some media like VHS...

CDs/DVDs are wonderful storage. I have a few music CDs from the 1980s and they sound incredible. All my data from 1999-2002 and beyond is pristine. Old 20 GB IDEs are gathering dust compared to them (well, they were stored but I had a laugh with them in June, some mp3s I hadn't heard in 7 years but they were burned in my brain. Exploring full albums of some artists now that I hadn't thought about).
 
I used to store data on optical media, CD-R's and DVD-R's in binders and store in closet.

6mo-2years later, many are unreadable, unreadable sectors etc. Verbatim DataLife mostly, Some generic Office Depot Media, some Taiyo Yuden Fuji branded discs. Doesn't seem to matter.
 
I used to store data on optical media, CD-R's and DVD-R's in binders and store in closet.

6mo-2years later, many are unreadable, unreadable sectors etc. Verbatim DataLife mostly, Some generic Office Depot Media, some Taiyo Yuden Fuji branded discs. Doesn't seem to matter.
I should clarify, big difference in pressed retail optical media, and burned media where the data storage layer is a dye that has it's chemical property changed slightly from the energy of a laser.
 
I guess you haven't had a kid that wanted to see what would happen if they put a CD in the microwave.. or used them as frisbees.. you don't always get a disc back that you can even put in an optical drive.
 
I guess you haven't had a kid that wanted to see what would happen if they put a CD in the microwave.. or used them as frisbees.. you don't always get a disc back that you can even put in an optical drive.
When you have kids, you become conscience about where to put things so that they are out of reach of little ones but accessible to those who need. Financial data, family photos/data, firearms, medicines, etc. lots of things need special care. If the data backups are considered important or critical, they can be kept safe.
 
This always makes me laugh. In its not commercial data, then if you havent needed to access it for 5 years or so then chances are you dont need it or its not important.

A hi-fi forum I am a member of had a question about which CD-R had the longest life. This person wanted to make sure his collection of vinyl 'needledrops' lasted for generations to enjoy.

I pointed out to him that they only needed to last his lifetime as I assured him, his grandchildren will not want to keep grandpas dusty old collection of 5000+ 30 year old CD-Rs and they will be heading for the landfill about the same time his coffin was going into the ground.

He was a bit upset at this realisation.

One mans precious archive is anothers pile of old musty crap in the garage!
 
I got CDs from 1995 that still run just fine, I got burned media from 1998 that still contains data
 
Back
Top