Should I upgrade or start new build?

Taze

n00b
Joined
Nov 2, 2010
Messages
49
1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
Gaming, Web browsing, Office apps.
2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
$600-$700 after tax and shipping
3) Where do you live?
Los Angeles
4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. The word "Everything" is not a valid answer. Please list out all the parts you'll need.
I need a new CPU, Mobo, RAM and possibly a PSU.
5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.
I have an Antec Neo Power HE 550W
Reusing existing items in Sig.
2 x 400GB SATA 2 drives, Monitor, DVD burner, cpu cooler if possible.
6) Will you be overclocking?
A bit.
7) What size monitor do you have and/or plan to have?
22'' 1680 x 1050
8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
Will start purchases next week.
9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? USB 3.0? SATA 6Gb/s? etc.
Crossfire, dual x16 speed slots in CF, 4-6 USB ports and at least one open PCI slot when in CF.
USB 3.0 would be nice but not required. Same for SATA 6GB and RAID 0 support.
10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license? If so, what OS? Is it 32bit or 64bit?
Yes, Windows 7 Pro 64 bit


So, should I bother upgrading my current system? I was considering just upgrading my RAM to 4 or 8 GB on the existing setup. My board is limited to DDR 2 PC6400. How much is my current CPU/RAM holding be back? Should I bother with CF at my resolution?

If I go with the new build, could I use my existing PSU and upgrade when it comes time to get the second card for CF? Let me know if I am missing anything or can provide more info.

Thanks, I appreciate the help. Been a fan of this forum for a while now.
 
Any chance that you can hold off another week or so to buy your parts? I ask because that way you can take advantage of Newegg's January combo deals which will save you money.

To answer your questions: That X2 6000+ is severly holding back your your current GPU. You're better off with a new CPU + mobo + RAM. As for the PSU, if it's older than 3-4 years old, then yeah, time to replace, even if you are planning a single GPU setup. So definitely not suitable for a dual Crossfire setup. Speaking of which, no, CF is not worth it at your resolution.
 
Thanks for the speedy reply and feedback Danny Bui. I can definitely wait a week. :)
 
If I am getting a new PSU, I would like to go the mATX route as I currently have an ATX tower. Could a new PSU and a really small mATX case be factored into this build?
 
If I am getting a new PSU, I would like to go the mATX route as I currently have an ATX tower. Could a new PSU and a really small mATX case be factored into this build?

It could. Do note that many ATX PSUs will work just fine in a mATX case.
 
If you're going Sandy Bridge, then I have to recommend a new power supply.

With your reduced budget, however, I need a bit more time to think about what you should get. Are you willing to go with an AMD Athlon II- or Phenom II-based build?
 
I was hoping I could use the same PSU in the mean time but if I must upgrade then so be it. But I was really trying to go with a Sandy Bridge setup to have a decent upgrade path. Would a mATX board line up in a regular ATX case? Trying to eventually change over to a mAXT case. What CPU options do I have to compliment my current GPU and possible a future upgrade?
 
I was hoping I could use the same PSU in the mean time but if I must upgrade then so be it. But I was really trying to go with a Sandy Bridge setup to have a decent upgrade path. Would a mATX board line up in a regular ATX case? Trying to eventually change over to a mAXT case. What CPU options do I have to compliment my current GPU and possible a future upgrade?

Yes a regular mATX mobo will fit into a regular ATX case. You pretty much have very little options for a CPU and motherboard that'll be worthwhile or capable of upgrading later on. AMD is about to release a new CPU line that's gonna be incompatible with any socket AM3 motherboard in sometime in 2011. AMD generally had a decent record of backwards compatibility with older sockets in the past 4 years but that's not gonna be the case when AMD's Bulldozer CPUs and the needed socket AM3+/AM3b are released. With that said, there's a small possibility that socket AM3+/AM3b might be the standard AMD socket for 2-4 years.

Intel's current Core i5 and Core i7 CPUs are now basically poor buys for the money now that Sandy Bridge is out. In fact, even Sandy Bridge has a short upgrade path considering that its replacement, Haswell, is due out in 2013. So in other words, zero options right now if you want a platform with a long CPU upgrade path (long as more than two years).

Now ignoring that long term upgrade part, you could always go with this CPU + mobo combo which would work nicely with your setup:
$235 - AMD Phenom II X4 955 Black Edition CPU + Gigabyte GA-880GA-UD3H AMD 880G ATX Motherboard combo

Anyway, I concur with tirades: I would recommend a new PSU as well.
 
A new PSU is absolutely unnecessary.

Actually, a new PSU is recommended. If that Neo HE 550 has been used regularly for those four years, then there will be some capacitor aging. It might have deteriorated to the point that the PSU might not be able to output even 500W without having some aspects of its output going out of spec.
 
I have had some instances where my system would freeze inexplicably, usually during heavy gaming. This used to happen a lot with my 8800GTX. I did try once to pop in a new PSU to try and fix the issue but it didn't make a difference. This has only happened once with the new GPU, during a run of New Vegas. I will look at the AMD option. If I brought my limit up $500 could a Sandy Bridge build be possible?
 
If I brought my limit up $500 could a Sandy Bridge build be possible?

Not really. The least expensive worthwhile i5 meant for overclockers plus a motherboard with sufficiently robust components to withstand moderate or higher levels of overclocking will run you well over $350 -- and that's without RAM or a PSU that's sufficient to withstand such levels of overclocking. With a $500 budget for a CPU, mobo, RAM and a PSU you'd pretty much have to settle for only 4GB of RAM if you go the Sandy Bridge route.
 
That doesn't sound too bad. I can work with 4GB for now. I could easily upgrade to 8GB down the road if I need it. Although do I really need more than 4GB? Not doing too many things at once. Would most new games eat up that much?
 
Definitely upgrade, doubling your ram isn't gonna change much I'd imagine:D
 
Are you near a microcenter?

2500k 189
Then snag the mobo, ram, heatsink, and psu from this build:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1576785

$30 - Cooler Master Hyper 212 Plus HSF for LGA 1366 and LGA 1156
$185 - Asus P8P87 Pro Intel P67 ATX Motherboard
$90 - G.Skill Ripjaws F3-10666CL9D-8GBRL 2 x 4GB DDR3 1333 RAM
$110 - Corsair 750TX 750W PSU

$604 in the cart w/o tax or shipping.

I am not sure that the mobo meets your requirement:
9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? USB 3.0? SATA 6Gb/s? etc.
Crossfire, dual x16 speed slots in CF, 4-6 USB ports and at least one open PCI slot when in CF.
USB 3.0 would be nice but not required. Same for SATA 6GB and RAID 0 support.
 
Last edited:
You're not going to have dual x16 CrossFire or SLI with any Sandy Bridge and P67/H67 combination. The processor's onboard PCI-E controller has 16 PCI-E 2.1 lanes that power either one PCI-E x16 port or two x16 ports running at dual x8. However, benchmarks show that dual x8 CrossFire or SLI, depending on the game, is still a decent performance boost.

That said, you don't need to look at CrossFire or SLI for your resolution, as it's more practical to go with a good mid-range or high-end video card like the HD 6850 or GTX 460.
 
Thanks for all the input everyone. So if I go the AMD route, would getting a X6 1090 over a X4 955 give me any noticeable improvements? I came up with this setup:
$319.98 X6 1090T BE, GIGABYTE GA-880GA-UD3H
$49.99 4GB G-Skill RAM

Comes out to $400.49 ;)

This would also involve a new PSU that would be bought separately. Most likely a 750w Corsair. I like their setup.

So would this be more reasonable than a Sandy Bridge setup or even a first gen i5? Is this overkill for my current GPU? I'm not too interested in O/C'ing as I'm only running on air. And during the summer it can get pretty warm here.

Thanks again!
 
Thanks for all the input everyone. So if I go the AMD route, would getting a X6 1090 over a X4 955 give me any noticeable improvements? I came up with this setup:
$319.98 X6 1090T BE, GIGABYTE GA-880GA-UD3H
$49.99 4GB G-Skill RAM

Comes out to $400.49 ;)

This would also involve a new PSU that would be bought separately. Most likely a 750w Corsair. I like their setup.

So would this be more reasonable than a Sandy Bridge setup or even a first gen i5? Is this overkill for my current GPU? I'm not too interested in O/C'ing as I'm only running on air. And during the summer it can get pretty warm here.

Yeah you're not gonna notice a difference with the 1090T over the X4 955 in games and such. Unfortunately, the release of the Sandy Bridge CPUs have pretty much made any AMD CPU close to or over $200 a poor buy since the sheer performance increase offered by Sandy Bridge's 4 cores outweighs, or at least performs at the same level, any advantage that AMD Phenom II X6 CPUs have with their extra two cores. Plus since you're not overclocking, the combo deals for the i5-2xxx series are actually fairly close to the price of that AMD Phenom II X6 setup:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...bCategory=343&SortField=0&PageSize=100&Page=1
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...bCategory=343&SortField=0&PageSize=100&Page=1

So yeah, not a good idea to get a Phenom II X6 CPU.
 
So in the end I decided to go with the setup in my Sig. Thanks again for all the guidance. I'm not too sure about the CPU cooler. It keeps the temps at 59C under prime95. Idle temps are at about 29-34C depending on ambient temps. I picked this up at Fry's so I can still return if a better cooler is suggested. I didn't want to go with water cooling but was tempted to go with the H70. With my luck I'll end up with water all over my new parts :rolleyes:
 
Came out to about $760.00 with tax. A bit over budget but worth it.;)
 
Back
Top