Sharp LC-32GP3U vs. Dell 3007WFP

harmattan

Supreme [H]ardness
2FA
Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
5,302
I took a pretty big dive a couple weeks ago and purchased the newly-released Sharp LC-32GP3U. For those unfamiliar, this is a 32" 1080p, 6ms response, high-contrast ratio LCD with some accoutrements focused on gaming - it's marketed as a "gaming" LCD HDTV. Full specs can be found HERE

I am very pleased with its performance. I did originally intend to use this LCD for console gaming and light movie watching, but since I recently got a pretty substantial home theater setup with a 46" LCD, the GP3U is now primarily used for PC gaming and internet browsing. Gaming is superb on this LCD and lag is non-existant... for the resolution.

That said, I have the opportunity to sell the GP3U for nearly what I paid for it ($1200). I'm having second thoughts about not originally going with a monitor that can do higher resolution than 1900x1080, specifically the Dell 3007WFP. My system spec is high enough to run most games at 2560x1600, and I expect to be upgrading again this year once G100/R700 and Nehelam are released. Is running at higher resolution a substantial advantage over 1900x1080, enough to merit giving up my GP3U and buying a 3007WFP? Understood it's subjective and I'd be losing 2" screen space, but I am unfamiliar with running at 2560x1600 vs. 1900x1080. Also, would there be any other benefit to moving to a 3007WFP? :confused:

Thanks in advance
 
2560x1600 is a hair under two times the resolution of 1920x1080. It's a huge difference and you better have a stellar machine if you play games. I wouldn't use a TV for a computer screen if you paid me. So ya, I'd say get the 3007.
 
Thanks for the input on the resolution difference - that's what I was thinking as well. A couple things I do like on the GP3U is the faster response time to the 3007WFP (6ms vs. 12ms), higher contrast ratio, and all the inputs. The inputs in particular have me going since it seems high-end next gen cards will be able to stream audio as well as video through hdmi. Since the GP3U has an attached speaker (and I can't hook up a larger speaker system due to space issues), audio through hdmi would be useful. Geez, I really wish I could see both displays side-by-side for comparison... or at least hear from someone who has used them both.

Again this is subjective, but I feel the screen quality on the GP3U is superior to my older 2405FPW. The better response time in particular is noticable.

As stated, my system can handle 2560x1600 on most games now, and I expect to upgrade to another high-end system over the next couple months.
 
Do have any pics of the TV and 2405FPW that you can show us?

I'm also pondering the TV or 30" screen question. I currently leaning towards a combo of TV+smaller LCD screen.
 
You asked, so I'll answer.
Read this carefully cuz I prolly wont be back this way again to answer any questions.
I'm d-e-e-p in a new RPG expansion called "Shivering Isles" and it has complex plot, excellent graphics.
And when I'm done with that, the "Mask of The Betrayer" is waiting for me to break shrink-wrap on its box.
OK, if anyone disagrees with what I'm now gonna say here, my answer is "Relax, have a beer" ....

Approx 20 months ago I paid Dell $1920 (price included Overnite Air) for the 30" Dell 3007WFP.
It never disappointed me from Day One. It was my everyday workhorse "PC Monitor & Gaming Panel".
I experimented with different resolutions, and found out these things:

When you crank-up your Rez to 1600x1200, you enter what I like to call "Photograph-quality Country"----cuz everything looks sharp as a razor. Beautiful.
At 1600x1200 rez, Gaming is a blast cuz scenery in hi-end Games like Oblivion is really, really fine. 1600x1200 Gaming is indeed like entering Photo.-quality country.
Next, I cranked my Dell 30" 300WFP up to the next-higher rez (1920x1200)----and found there was only a very-slight increase in Pic-quality.
Next I cranked up to top rez 2560x1600 and found two things:
Pic-quality went up a little (not tremendous, which surprised me) and performance dropped like a rock.

Clearly, going above 1600x1200 yields less n' less "noticeable-increase in visual quality". (The key-word here is "noticeable").
I guess its something like the horsepower race in Cars. Just because you can afford to pay the $$-----dont mean you go faster and faster as you crank your car Horsepower higher and higher.
Cuz when you reach a certain point on the "Horsepower Curve"-----further increases in HP give less n' less Speed increase
And likewise------going higher than the magic 1600x1200 rez "sweet spot" it becomes harder n' harder to get a noticeable increase in Pic quality.
IMO its not worth the $$ you have to invest. Basically, all you'll be doing is burning-$$ for "bragging rights".

So, in 2008 when a new bigger panel hit the market, I moved up from the Dell 30" and never looked back.
Running always at 1920x1080, my awesome new 32" Sharp 32GP3U combo "PC Monitor&Gaming Panel" is absolute dream come true.
Gaming screens are awesome at its Photo-quality 1080P rez, and as a PC that 1920x1080 Text is crisp, clear, sharp.
I'm one happy camper. Going on 2 months and not a glitch, not a complaint, wether used for Gaming or PC work.
Does that mere 2" increase (30" to 32") make a difference put them side-by-side? Lemme answer this way.... My 32" Sharp makes my 30" Dell look small.
:D OK, thats it, Shivering Isles rpg awaits me on my awesome 2008 Sharp 32GP3U :D Good Luck with whatever you decide to do.....
 
I don't have any pics of the 2405FPW on hand, but may post some later - I need to do some RDP testing with dual monitors and may hook it back up. At present, it's just taking up space in my back room. It's really obsolete now however with the advent of the 2407WFP (and the just-released 2408WFP)

Thanks for the sanity check Zak (and the setting recommendations in the review thread :) ). I was just looking for some objective comparison between the two monitor/LCDs. The GP3U is really a great "monitor", but I'm worried my PC's power is being wasted at 1920x1080... I think I'll go "relax and have a beer" now (or six).
 
Again this is subjective, but I feel the screen quality on the GP3U is superior to my older 2405FPW. The better response time in particular is noticable.
The 2405FPW is the worst monitor I've owned. My 2007WFP is much better, and should be similar to the 3007FPW.
 
Back
Top