Settle it! 7600GT and x850xt!

Status
Not open for further replies.
bLaCktIGErs91 said:
Exactly.

Posts by f.a.n.b.o.y.s. like him are what ruins these threads :(

All I wanna do is know which card's better in an actual gaming experience.
Agreed. 3DMark05 is basically useless...
 
Eva_Unit_0 said:
x850xt is gonna be faster all around. It's just got more of everything...more memory bandwidth, more pixel pipes (not only does the 7600gt only have 12 pipes but it's only got 8 ROP's), more vertex shaders. And the core clocks are very close.

I currently run an x850xt and the thing is wonderful...it spanks a 6800 ultra around. If anyone has any particular benchmark requests then I'll run them and post the scores...but someone else with a 7600gt is gonna have to pitch in too. Let me know what you want me to run. :)

The issue of SM3.0 is debatable but ultimately it's not worth much...there's not much at all that it can do that sm2.0a can't do. Even HDR is done well on sm2.0a now in a handful of games (source engine, splinter cell: chaos theory). I personally don't see any differences between sm2.0 and sm3.0 paths in games (comparing my old 6800 Ultras to my x850xt). Now I'm certainly a proponent of new technology and I think SM3.0 is neat, but I don't think it's fair to dock the x850 for not having it since it makes no perceivable difference. BTW HDR is NOT a sm3.0 feature...there are plenty of sm3.0 cards that cannot do fp16 blending and cannot do this type of HDR. (geforce 6200 and 6600 families, to name a few). it is a separate feature entirely. Likewise, HDR can also be done using pixel shaders which runs on any dx9 card, such as how valve implemented it.

BTW system is in sig
The Shader technology is older, hence why it the difference is not that great. Despite the memory bandwidth and pipeline advantage. Source Engine uses INT HDR thru the Pixel Shaders, which is different while Splinter Cell Chaos Theory uses an ATI programmed path since it can't use OpenEXR HDR at all, and doest have SM3.0. Try Age of Empires 3, there is a difference there between the SM 2.0 and SM 3.0. As well, the Geforce 6600 (NV43) line is capable of OpenEXR HDR with Blending and Filtering, it's only the Geforce 6200 (NV44) Core that isn't. The entire Geforce 7 line is capable of OpenEXR HDR with Blending and Filtering so it's good.

HDR can be implemented in many different ways, OpenEXR HDR is one way, used in Serious Sam 2, AOE 3, Splinter Cell Chaos Theory, FarCry.

Valve does it through the Pixel Shaders, Bethsheba uses another method in Oblivion.
 
coldpower27 said:
The Shader technology is older, hence why it the difference is not that great. Despite the memory bandwidth and pipeline advantage. Source Engine uses INT HDR thru the Pixel Shaders, which is different while Splinter Cell Chaos Theory uses an ATI programmed path since it can't use OpenEXR HDR at all, and doest have SM3.0. Try Age of Empires 3, there is a difference there between the SM 2.0 and SM 3.0. As well, the Geforce 6600 (NV43) line is capable of OpenEXR HDR with Blending and Filtering, it's only the Geforce 6200 (NV44) Core that isn't. The entire Geforce 7 line is capable of OpenEXR HDR with Blending and Filtering so it's good.

HDR can be implemented in many different ways, OpenEXR HDR is one way, used in Serious Sam 2, AOE 3, Splinter Cell Chaos Theory, FarCry.

Valve does it through the Pixel Shaders, Bethsheba uses another method in Oblivion.

Sorry, I thought the 6600's couldn't do it either. Not like they could do it at playable framerates anyway. Regardless, yeah that's kinda what I was trying to say before...you just went into much better detail than I did. Good explanation.

Still, no one has yet to post any benches...so here's some benches on my X850XT running on the system in my sig. If anyone wants different games (like if anyone knows of a way to benchmark oblivion) then just let me know, or if you want different detail settings.

3dmark05, default settings: 6227
3dmark03, default settings: 12921
CS:S stress test, all details maxed, 1280x1024, 4xAA, 16xAF: 113.4fps
FEAR timedemo, all details maxed (except soft shadows), 1024x768, 4xAA, 16xAF: 24 min, 52 average, 127 max
 
on 3DMark06, my 7600GT(not for long I hope :D) scores 3044 (Atholon64 3000+, 1GB ram). after work I might post some benchmarks of games.
on the 3DMark06 score board the best X850XT PE can acheive is 2221 on almost the same speced PC.
 
kyaku00x said:
on 3DMark06, my 7600GT(not for long I hope :D) scores 3044 (Atholon64 3000+, 1GB ram). after work I might post some benchmarks of games.
on the 3DMark06 score board the best X850XT PE can acheive is 2221 on almost the same speced PC.
Yeah, but were trying to give the Pixel Shader 2.0b card a chance here, if you run 3D Mark 2006 X850 can't complete some of the tests so it will get a much lower score.

Honestly though, I think we should flatout avoid 3D Mark, as 2k5 is too vertex limited so would be stronger on X850 XT, which isn't really indicative of games either.

Try benching popular games such as BF2, COD2, HL2 LC, SC: CT, etc etc...
 
TheOmniscientCreator said:
I already posted mine...you should read the thread :eek:

I was mostly referring to 7600gt scores. And still, no one has posted any game scores with a 7600gt.
 
Eva_Unit_0 said:
Sorry, I thought the 6600's couldn't do it either. Not like they could do it at playable framerates anyway. Regardless, yeah that's kinda what I was trying to say before...you just went into much better detail than I did. Good explanation.

Still, no one has yet to post any benches...so here's some benches on my X850XT running on the system in my sig. If anyone wants different games (like if anyone knows of a way to benchmark oblivion) then just let me know, or if you want different detail settings.

3dmark05, default settings: 6227
3dmark03, default settings: 12921
CS:S stress test, all details maxed, 1280x1024, 4xAA, 16xAF: 113.4fps
FEAR timedemo, all details maxed (except soft shadows), 1024x768, 4xAA, 16xAF: 24 min, 52 average, 127 max
Include some Quake 4 and Doom 3 benches as well though, as F.E.A.R. and Source Engine are very favourable to the R4xx architecture. So it would be fair to provide some balance, 2k5 also emphasis the X850 XT Vertex advantage, however not many games are indeed vertex limited, so at best blah...
 
Personally, I think 3dMark2001 is the best indicator of real world (gaming) performance. (shows the full system performance) Most games scale well with CPU's like 3dMark2001 does.

What games are as intensive as 3dMark2005 & 2006 that only run at like 10-20fps with no actually network, physics, etc. And do you get double and triple the performance just from upgrading from say a SM2.0 to SM3.0 videocard, etc.
 
coldpower27 said:
Include some Quake 4 and Doom 3 benches as well though, as F.E.A.R. and Source Engine are very favourable to the R4xx architecture. So it would be fair to provide some balance, 2k5 also emphasis the X850 XT Vertex advantage, however not many games are indeed vertex limited, so at best blah...
Quake 4 and Doom 3 favor nVidia cards.
 
Thats a very interesting review you found lodingi. They should have overclocked the 6800GT to keep the playing field even, but the 7600GT stuck it to the 6800GT in that review. Its hard to say for sure but im guessing that an overclocked x850xt would be close to that superclocked 7600GT, pulling about even with AA in most games at least. Since its 20$ cheaper right now id say the x850xt is a worthy alternative.
 
I'd rather pay $20 more for the extra features of the 7600gt, sm3 is starting to show up more in games and it's making a very noticable difference.
 
There are a million forums out there with this argument, and not a single review comparing the two cards thoroughly... :(
 
doesn't the 7 series have a different way of shading and doing physics with new features? shouldn't that help later on?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top