Separate SSD drives for OS and Apps?

Joined
May 15, 2005
Messages
29
For years I have been using 3 drives in my systems, 1 for OS, 1 for Apps, and 1 for Docs and Page File.

Does one see the same benefits when using SSD drives? Or does the increased SDD performance obviate dividing functions by drive?

I am going to take the SSD plunge with about $350 dollars to spend. Would I be better off with:

1 30G Vertex (OS) + 1 60G Vertex (Apps)

or

1 80G X25-M (OS + Apps)?

I have lots of RAM. Should I put the Pagefile on an SSD or leave on a spindle drive?

Thanks in advance for the input.
 
I dual boot XP 32-bit and Vista 64, will probably run Vista 64 on the SSD and keep XP on the existing spindle drive
 
You wont really gain anything by splitting your stuff out into multiple drives. I would just get a single large one as it will be the most useful in the future to you. Small drives eventually just become a waste of a SATA connector, so you might as well go with a single large one, and then down the road you can slap another lone in there too.

^^ I don't really agree with the ideology of splitting stuff up into a bunch of partitions like in that linked article. Putting some apps and or games on a magnetic disk just makes them run slow, you want ALL executable stuff on the SSD, and only stuff like ISO's, music, video, etc on a magnetic storage disk. Beyond that partitioning stuff up just runs you into problems later because eventually you will find that you have free space in one drive but the other is full and you will be shuffling things around, etc, etc.
 
I would get a 120gb vertex ssd for games and apps unless you want to run raid on the smaller ones. 30gb is not enough for vista to be comfortable. You will have to dissable swap and hibernation right out the gate or your drive will be almost full.
 
I would keep the OS/data on a regular disk and use the SSD for apps. Makes things simple since no tweaking is necessary. You want to avoid writing to the SSD, so keep the pagefile on the regular drive.

And ditch XP while you're at it. Vista and 7 are where its at. ;)
 
Thanks for the link coo-coo. I like the idea of moving the profiles to a magnetic drive so browser cache and temp files are off the SSD. But I definitely want my games and most demanding apps on an SSD, and I generally try to avoid more than one partition on a drive unless I need something other than NTFS for some reason, so my free space is contiguous. This bit in the comments sounds interesting:
Starting with windows 2000 you can have your drives mounted in this fashion also instead of using a drive letter. The only drive letter you would have to use is C.

1. Backup data in the C:\Users location
2. Delete the content from C:\Users
3. Using Disk Management, Create a partition on another drive to hold this information. Do not assign a drive letter, instead choose volume mount point and specify C:\Users.
4. There you have it. No registry changes neccesary.

This is also a great technique if you need more space on your C volume and don't want to mess with ghosting or imaging to a new drive.
 
30gb is not enough for vista to be comfortable. You will have to dissable swap and hibernation right out the gate or your drive will be almost full.
Yeah, my full install of Vista Ultimate with Media Center comes to ~25 GB! But I used Vlite to remove language packs, Media Center, Windows games, drivers, set no Hibernation, etc., and have it down to a still bloated but I think workable 15-18 GB depending on what I keep.

And I hear you DeathFromBelow, been wanting to try Windows 7 for a while. I thought the beta was closed but I see now Windows 7 RC is available for download. I'll check it out.
 
I would keep the OS/data on a regular disk and use the SSD for apps. Makes things simple since no tweaking is necessary. You want to avoid writing to the SSD, so keep the pagefile on the regular drive.

And ditch XP while you're at it. Vista and 7 are where its at. ;)


This would be a waste of an expensive SSD. Why buy an ssd if you arent going to run your system AND apps AND games from it? It just seems dumb to me to spend that kind of coin, and then not even utilize it. You DEFINITELY want to run the OS and your apps on the SSD. Games ought to go on there but they are large and if anything needs to get kicked off then some games might need to move to a slow disk, but you are really shooting yourself in the foot if you do so. You really don't need to tweak anything in windows 7, and not much in vista either. in any case there is ALWAYS a little bit of tweaking to be done, regardless if you use an SSD or not.
 
This would be a waste of an expensive SSD. Why buy an ssd if you arent going to run your system AND apps AND games from it? It just seems dumb to me to spend that kind of coin, and then not even utilize it. You DEFINITELY want to run the OS and your apps on the SSD. Games ought to go on there but they are large and if anything needs to get kicked off then some games might need to move to a slow disk, but you are really shooting yourself in the foot if you do so. You really don't need to tweak anything in windows 7, and not much in vista either. in any case there is ALWAYS a little bit of tweaking to be done, regardless if you use an SSD or not.

The only real advantage of putting the OS on the SSD is faster boot times. The regular applications that come with Windows are going to open quickly even on a regular hard drive. If boot times are important then yes, put the OS on the SSD. If application launch/loads are all you care about then put the OS/data on a regular drive and use the SSD for apps. The other nice thing about using a regular hard drive for the OS is that you don't get stuttering issues, although newer/higher-end SSDs don't seem to have that problem anymore.

If you're just using it for apps you don't have to do any tweaking at all. If you use it for the OS its a good idea to turn off hibernation and to put the pagefile on a regular hard drive.
 
The only real advantage of putting the OS on the SSD is faster boot times. The regular applications that come with Windows are going to open quickly even on a regular hard drive. If boot times are important then yes, put the OS on the SSD. If application launch/loads are all you care about then put the OS/data on a regular drive and use the SSD for apps. The other nice thing about using a regular hard drive for the OS is that you don't get stuttering issues, although newer/higher-end SSDs don't seem to have that problem anymore.

If you're just using it for apps you don't have to do any tweaking at all. If you use it for the OS its a good idea to turn off hibernation and to put the pagefile on a regular hard drive.

I'd say put the OS on SSD as well..
 
The only real advantage of putting the OS on the SSD is faster boot times. The regular applications that come with Windows are going to open quickly even on a regular hard drive. If boot times are important then yes, put the OS on the SSD. If application launch/loads are all you care about then put the OS/data on a regular drive and use the SSD for apps. The other nice thing about using a regular hard drive for the OS is that you don't get stuttering issues, although newer/higher-end SSDs don't seem to have that problem anymore.

If you're just using it for apps you don't have to do any tweaking at all. If you use it for the OS its a good idea to turn off hibernation and to put the pagefile on a regular hard drive.

The current mainstream drives, the Vertex and Intel-M drives have solved the "stuttering issues," even when running single drives.

DFB, have you used a system with a decent SSD? All Apps open and run faster and smoother. Apps that I dread using on a magnetic drive, like Lotus Notes, work quick and smooth when run from an SSD. At times I get a couple of dozen programs open, and several dozen browzer tabs open with no slowdown whatsoever.

Even with heavy use, the current crop of MLC drives will be long obsolete before they hit their 10K rewrite limit. And a magnetic hard drive of similar age and usage is likely to have died in that time frame also.

The only drawback to SSDs right now is the price. Most but not all people can live comfortably on a 60 gig OS drive, but that is still going to set you back over $200. That is just out of a lot of people's price range right now.

It's like the early days of the internet. Once you tried a faster connection, it was painful to go back to a slower one. Same thing with SSDs.

Don
 
DFB, have you used a system with a decent SSD? All Apps open and run faster and smoother. Apps that I dread using on a magnetic drive, like Lotus Notes, work quick and smooth when run from an SSD. At times I get a couple of dozen programs open, and several dozen browzer tabs open with no slowdown whatsoever.

Yes, I have a 64 GB G.Skill Falcon. I've used it with both the OS installed on the SSD and with the OS on a HDD + SSD as an app drive.

Someday when SDD's are huge and cheap I'll ditch the HDDs, but since I need the space I figured the best thing to do is use the HDD for my OS and data and put all my apps on the SSD for the speed boost.

Putting the OS on an SSD just improves boot times. It doesn't really have any other noticeable effects (I'm talking about the actual OS/Windows programs; programs like calculator don't need an SSD to load instantly :p). By putting the OS on a mechanical drive I get the maximum ammount of space on the SSD for applications and data I need to load quickly while also eliminating the need to tweak anything to avoid extra writes to the SSD. Does that make sense?

I did the same thing for years with my 15,000 RPM SCSI hardware. I used regular 7200 RPM SATA drives for my OS and data and used my 15,000 RPM SCSI drives for programs and projects where the faster drives really help.
 
Last edited:
I like my setup. It's fast as hell and it works. 2 x 120GB Vertexes in R0, 3 partitions. OS, Apps, semi-static storage. 1 WD6400AAKS for music, backups and pagefile.

Highly recommended. The fastest of the Vertexes and everything gets to benefit form them.
 
Yes, I have a 64 GB G.Skill Falcon. I've used it with both the OS installed on the SSD and with the OS on a HDD + SSD as an app drive.

Someday when SDD's are huge and cheap I'll ditch the HDDs, but since I need the space I figured the best thing to do is use the HDD for my OS and data and put all my apps on the SSD for the speed boost.

Putting the OS on an SSD just improves boot times. It doesn't really have any other noticeable effects (I'm talking about the actual OS/Windows programs; programs like calculator don't need an SSD to load instantly :p). By putting the OS on a mechanical drive I get the maximum ammount of space on the SSD for applications and data I need to load quickly while also eliminating the need to tweak anything to avoid extra writes to the SSD. Does that make sense?

I did the same thing for years with my 15,000 RPM SCSI hardware. I used regular 7200 RPM SATA drives for my OS and data and used my 15,000 RPM SCSI drives for programs and projects where the faster drives really help.

Ah, ok, I can see your point. My smallest array is 120 gig, and I don't play a lot of games, so space is not an issue for me. My laptop with the Vertex is just for work stuff, so a 60 gig Vertex is plenty roomy. I think the HD it replaced was only 40 gig anyway.

Don
 
Back
Top