Zangmonkey
Supreme [H]ardness
- Joined
- Jul 6, 2005
- Messages
- 5,895
http://www.quora.com/Bitcoin/Is-the-cryptocurrency-Bitcoin-a-good-idea
Best article so far, by an actual economist.
He makes some excellent points but also ignore some. Notably that deflation can be defused by the effects of non-convertibility. In this regard, those two points are certainly both possible but likely mutually exclusive. As public concern over convertibility (or really, any test of the currency) will encourage holders to divest. Those willing to exchange goods for bitcoins will react by increasing prices.
Likewise, the convertibility of any currency is a function (in part) of confidence. The USD retains it (in part) because we back the treasury with things like aircraft carriers and nuclear weapons which will prevent some outside force from dismantling the currency system. --This is inherent in the bitcoin system. No external destabilizing force affects the rate of bitcoin "production". The volume increases a function of time and effort (mining). That is, it can only grow relative to how many people are willing to expend REAL resources (electricity) to produce it. In this way, they do exchange it just as an artisan exchanges his time/effort.
It certainly smells ponzi to me, but many things are. It's very interesting nonetheless and I've wasted money "exploring" before....