Scrunched-Up Dimensions Untangled

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Stephen Hawking may have been the one who theorized the presence of extra dimensions, but it was mathematician Shing-Tung Yau who worked out the mathematics for what he calls "Calabi-Yau spaces"

It's because the best theory they've been able to come up with for the universe's grand design requires 10 dimensions to make all the mathematics come out right. Because we can only perceive three dimensions of space and one dimension of time, they suggest that the other six dimensions curled up into near-nothingness when our universe took shape.
 
M-theory uses 11 dimensions. Take that Yau!

[Head hurts. Nap now.]
 
You have to love how this particular field of science can prove things. They come up with 'the key to understanding the design of the universe', but for their math to work they have to assume there are at least 10 dimensions - so poof, they say there are at least 10 dimensions and suddenly there are 10 dimensions or more and their math works out fine.

Plus, I can't be the only one that looks at the math for this and doesn't think 'That's beautiful!' like they constantly keep calling it in that article.
 
You have to love how this particular field of science can prove things. They come up with 'the key to understanding the design of the universe', but for their math to work they have to assume there are at least 10 dimensions - so poof, they say there are at least 10 dimensions and suddenly there are 10 dimensions or more and their math works out fine.

Plus, I can't be the only one that looks at the math for this and doesn't think 'That's beautiful!' like they constantly keep calling it in that article.

its called theoretical physics for a reason you tool. just because we can't prove it 100%, does that mean that we shouldn't bother? its about taking the best educated guess possible, developing that theory as much as possible, and trying to find out experimentally if there is any validity to it. thats the whole point of CERN by the way, to test some of these theories.
 
Stephen Hawking was certainly not the first one to theorize extra dimensions, unless he was alive and doing physics in the early 1920s, that is (hint: he wasn't).

You have to love how this particular field of science can prove things. They come up with 'the key to understanding the design of the universe', but for their math to work they have to assume there are at least 10 dimensions - so poof, they say there are at least 10 dimensions and suddenly there are 10 dimensions or more and their math works out fine.

Plus, I can't be the only one that looks at the math for this and doesn't think 'That's beautiful!' like they constantly keep calling it in that article.

So, can you give me a reason why there aren't more than the four dimensions we experience every day? This isn't math that was invented purely for ten dimensions, it's math that is used to explain physics we already observe that happens to be exactly solvable in that number of dimensions whereas no exact solution exists for any fewer. (This is why they call it beautiful, by the way. It's only beautiful in comparison to what it looks like in fewer dimensions. :D)
 
You have to love how this particular field of science can prove things. They come up with 'the key to understanding the design of the universe', but for their math to work they have to assume there are at least 10 dimensions - so poof, they say there are at least 10 dimensions and suddenly there are 10 dimensions or more and their math works out fine.

Plus, I can't be the only one that looks at the math for this and doesn't think 'That's beautiful!' like they constantly keep calling it in that article.

The math is beautiful....symmetry is beautiful....that is my opinion, but I like differential geometry. I can appreciate things like the Banach-Tarski paradox not because of the surprising results, but because of the math involved. Most people just do not understand the language of mathematics to see what the big deal is, so they are only impressed by the conclusions of the statements.

This is only a model. You don't have to like the math or the model for it to be useful. If people went with that, quantum field theory would never exists because most people do not like to think of the world in terms of probabilities that are only resolved when measured by an intelligent being. And yet, that is precisely what QM says happens and the theory agrees with measurement to an absurd degree. You don't have to like this....but if you want to make faster processors you have to deal with it.

All models are wrong, some are useful. If a theory gives us results that agree with experiment, then it is a good theory. If a theory does not give rise to experimentation, then it is a bad theory in my opinion, but could still produce beautiful mathematics.
 
EVERYONE knows there is 12 dimensions.. WTF has this guy been?! :)


Seriously, this stuff is so over my A.D.D. infested brain I can barely read through the article. I am just glad that there are people lucky enough to grasp math and that it makes my life easier in the long run because of it.
 
its called theoretical physics for a reason you tool. just because we can't prove it 100%, does that mean that we shouldn't bother? its about taking the best educated guess possible, developing that theory as much as possible, and trying to find out experimentally if there is any validity to it. thats the whole point of CERN by the way, to test some of these theories.

This whole subset of science is unprovable. You can call it theoretical to try to cover up that it's all guesses that aren't really based on anything solid, but don't try to give an air of confidence about something pulled out of thin air. If you assume something, and then your assumption doesn't work out a normal person says 'Yeah, I obviously messed up.' but these guys want to say 'Well, there must be more dimensions, yeah that'll make my other assumptions still correct so I'll go with that.'

Take chemistry - now there is an actual field of science that you can take a theory, implement, and actually see if an outcome is what you expected. There's no way to disprove or prove extra dimensions - if somebody disproves 10 dimensions being able to account for everything then somebody else will just come along and say "Well, maybe there's 11 dimensions then! Quick, fund me for a few years, and I'll test that."
 
The answer to everything is 42. How could you guys not know this.
 
This whole subset of science is unprovable. You can call it theoretical to try to cover up that it's all guesses that aren't really based on anything solid, but don't try to give an air of confidence about something pulled out of thin air. If you assume something, and then your assumption doesn't work out a normal person says 'Yeah, I obviously messed up.' but these guys want to say 'Well, there must be more dimensions, yeah that'll make my other assumptions still correct so I'll go with that.'

You obviously missed that whole thing where string theory has correctly predicted experimental results. Honestly, if you don't know squat about the subject, you're in no position to question its veracity.
 
This whole subset of science is unprovable. You can call it theoretical to try to cover up that it's all guesses that aren't really based on anything solid, but don't try to give an air of confidence about something pulled out of thin air. If you assume something, and then your assumption doesn't work out a normal person says 'Yeah, I obviously messed up.' but these guys want to say 'Well, there must be more dimensions, yeah that'll make my other assumptions still correct so I'll go with that.'

Something doesn't have to be provable to be useful. Time for a little thought experiment.

Take the geocentric Ptolemaic system for example, which assumes that the earth is the center of the universe and that all things revolve around it. This model can be used to correctly determine the paths that planets take across our night sky. The fundamental principals are incorrect and the math is far more complex than with the heliocentric Copernican system, but it gives you the correct answer.
 
WTF, is Hawking a one trick pony now? Hey let me make some overly generalized statement that people have been making for years and get credit for it, or look someone else writes a book on a subject which I mentioned in my book (which ironically came from the same guy, its just he wrote a scientific paper about it... not a book before now), and he gets credit for discovering it all!! I am so over Hawking as any source of genius.

Looking back now, I remember Futurama & Simpson's too, spoofing Hawking by having him take credit for everyone's idea, didn't really click until now though.
 
I'm reminded of this quote from Farscape, episode "I Shink Therefore I am"

Rygel: I've been around long enough to know how ignorant I am. I don't assume the universe obeys my preconceptions. Huh! But I know a frelling fact when it hits me in the face!

Full quote:

Sikozu: Don't you see? No. No! This isn't happening because it is not possible.
Rygel: Your brain isn't functioning. Do you think this is all just a hallucination? Do you like that explanation better, hmm?
Sikozu: No, but I simply cannot comprehend-
Rygel: Neither can I. Who cares? We're here, they did it, and that's that. You consider yourself intelligent?
Sikozu: Yes, I do.
Rygel: Then stop behaving like a child.
Sikozu: I am not a child!
Rygel: No, you're an infant! You've studied but you haven't experienced. You know nothing of life!
Sikozu: And you do?
Rygel: I've been around long enough to know how ignorant I am. I don't assume the universe obeys my preconceptions. Huh! But I know a frelling fact when it hits me in the face!
 
It does seem awfully convenient to say that 10 dimensions makes it work, but since we can only perceive 4, the other 6 are just there and imperceptible and that's that. But then, I lost interest in math.
 
All of this is very fascinating. I really wish that I could completely understand all of the advanced math.
 
I'm currently about half way though this book The Elegant Universe which is about string theory. Very interesting read.

While many are quick to dismiss it, its certainly our only shot at solving the issues in modern physics that scientist do admit that could never be solved by the Standard Model.
 
I have a very short understanding on String theory (no pun intended), but all in all, it is one of the most fascinating things human's have come across.

Wish we had our thousand years back from the dark ages. Think of where we would be today. :D
 
I currently watching "Creation" about the story of Charles Darwin, and I highly recommend it just because it's a good movie. Doesn't really go into the extreme details about his theories but that's not the point: they're trying to tell the story of who he was, what he went through, family life, inspirations, triumphs, and of course some failures along the way with a shitload of emotional baggage too.

Earlier today I watched a great video on YouTube by Lawrence Kraus (theoretical physicist) who loves to diss String Theory at most every chance he gets, it's actually pretty funny in some respects to see this guys make wisecracks about each other's respective fields of study. That video is located here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ImvlS8PLIo

If you're interested in Brian Greene, author of "The Elegant Universe," it was a PBS 3 part series in the past and of course the book is excellent as well (got the paperback sitting here in the apartment actually). It's a great laymen's treatise on the concepts of String Theory without totally bogging most of us down in the mathematics that is almost incomprehensible for the majority.

He's also got a nice video up on TED at:

http://www.ted.com/talks/brian_greene_on_string_theory.html

There's so much info out there it's not even funny, and it's all better stuff than just watching pr0n all the time... ;)
 
I currently watching "Creation" about the story of Charles Darwin, and I highly recommend it just because it's a good movie. Doesn't really go into the extreme details about his theories but that's not the point: they're trying to tell the story of who he was, what he went through, family life, inspirations, triumphs, and of course some failures along the way with a shitload of emotional baggage too.

Earlier today I watched a great video on YouTube by Lawrence Kraus (theoretical physicist) who loves to diss String Theory at most every chance he gets, it's actually pretty funny in some respects to see this guys make wisecracks about each other's respective fields of study. That video is located here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ImvlS8PLIo

If you're interested in Brian Greene, author of "The Elegant Universe," it was a PBS 3 part series in the past and of course the book is excellent as well (got the paperback sitting here in the apartment actually). It's a great laymen's treatise on the concepts of String Theory without totally bogging most of us down in the mathematics that is almost incomprehensible for the majority.

He's also got a nice video up on TED at:

http://www.ted.com/talks/brian_greene_on_string_theory.html

There's so much info out there it's not even funny, and it's all better stuff than just watching pr0n all the time... ;)

Got anything that is not youtube? Damn Air Force network is still blocking Youtube in the desert. :(
 
Uhmmm... I can download the video and dump it someplace for you if that'll work, YouTube stuff is easy to acquire these days. I already have the video downloaded anyway, just pick a place to stash it and I'll let 'er rip - the offer stands for anyone that might want it.

I know some employers, etc restrict access to many sites these days, especially YouTube even in spite of this particular video and others like it being actually educational. ;)
 
You obviously missed that whole thing where string theory has correctly predicted experimental results. Honestly, if you don't know squat about the subject, you're in no position to question its veracity.
Are you referring to this panel presentation from last year?
http://www.symmetrymagazine.org/bre...tring-theory-predicts-an-experimental-result/

String math has been used to make predictions about experiments that have nothing to do with string theory. Futhermore, "correctly" has yet to be determined, as far as I can tell.
 
Actually, I'm talking about measurements of the scattering cross-section of the W boson which compare as well as can be hoped with theory. Also, what you're referring to as "string math" is string theory.

Again, go spend a few years taking physics classes and reading research papers, THEN come back and try to state an informed opinion.
 
Actually, I'm talking about measurements of the scattering cross-section of the W boson which compare as well as can be hoped with theory. Also, what you're referring to as "string math" is string theory.

Again, go spend a few years taking physics classes and reading research papers, THEN come back and try to state an informed opinion.

Oh, snap!
 
This whole subset of science is unprovable. You can call it theoretical to try to cover up that it's all guesses that aren't really based on anything solid, but don't try to give an air of confidence about something pulled out of thin air. If you assume something, and then your assumption doesn't work out a normal person says 'Yeah, I obviously messed up.' but these guys want to say 'Well, there must be more dimensions, yeah that'll make my other assumptions still correct so I'll go with that.'

Take chemistry - now there is an actual field of science that you can take a theory, implement, and actually see if an outcome is what you expected. There's no way to disprove or prove extra dimensions - if somebody disproves 10 dimensions being able to account for everything then somebody else will just come along and say "Well, maybe there's 11 dimensions then! Quick, fund me for a few years, and I'll test that."
This makes you sound like an idiot, fyi. Wasn't going to say anything until you tried to put chemistry on a pedestal. You realize chemistry was really just a shit load of guesses until physicist developed methods to experimentally prove the chemists' guesses using their "guess" theories. Spend some time STUDYING physics, then come around and say the same thing. Uninformed to say the least.

The whole point of a practice like this is to create a theoretical, mathematical existence (because we assume things to be mathematical) where what we *observe* is possible. Right now, there are a few solid environments in which we can make accurate predictions, but they don't coexist. The idea behind unified theory, (and using higher dimensions) is to "unify" the various environments and their respective phenomena. Essentially, to say "okay, here is a mathematical model of the world that explains every known physical phenomena." The world doesn't *actually* work that way, no. There's no one with a calculator punching numbers to determine what happens next, so to say it's silly to create higher dimensions is, itself, silly, because along the same logic it's silly to try to model physical phenomena at all.
 
Back
Top