Samsung ecogreen f2 1tb work well in raid 5 array?

brandinb

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
156
I am building a media server for myself and am choosing the drives. Newegg has the ecogreen 1tb for 79.99 here

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822152173

Does anybody here have any experience with these drives using Intel Matrix raid. Do these drives work well in a fake raid controller like the ich10r or do they drop out frequently or have any issues like that? Any need to adjust tler options? I checked the samsung utility and didnt notice any options like that.

Thanks
 
I'm sure the drives are fine, but personally I don't really think raid5 on ICH is a good idea. How many disks do you want? how much space do you need? Maybe a 2x1.5TB mirror would be better suited?
 
I am going for 5 or 6 drives in raid 5. Basically maximum gb/dollar with a minimum redundancy. The system is going to be a media server but array performance is still importaint for other reasons. Let me know if you have other ideas but I don't like the idea of windows home server and loosing 1tb of data if a disk fails or having to use 50% capacity to duplicate everything. loosing 20% with raid5 5 disk or 16%with 6 disk is fine however.

I mean I would love to use a nice raid controller but in my mind I could spend that money on more drives so I basically cannot justify it.
 
Well, it will work, and if it's just for media then you wont need too much IO anyways so it should be alright. Might want to look into something like one of these -- maybe one a bit bigger or two smaller ones to house all the drives. Might also want to consider having a spare disk available so if you do have a failure you are ready to swap.
 
I'd be worried about TLER (or the non-WD equivalents). As far as I know, only Western Digital hard drives have consumer hard drives that can have TLER enabled - or at least they're the only ones that have software available that turns on the feature.
 
It looks like 10 more dollars per drive to get wd greenpower drives with tler adjustment so 60 more dollars for the feature alone. The f2 ecogreen looks to have better str then the wd greenpower and does not have the issue I have read about of the wd greenpower parking the heads after 8 seconds of inactivity causing excessive head park counts on smart leading to possible issues. Anyone else have a recomendation on a ~80 dollar terrabyte drive that is effective in a raid array? I am looking at the cheap hitachi and samsung f1 but its my understanding it would be more of the same as the f2. My experience is using enterprise series drivces but this project wont allow for the cost.

Thanks guys
 
It really depends on your controller also. If you are trying to raid, it's best to stay away from the green products and get the raid or enterprise editions... if you cant do that, at least get the normal editions.

You may be able to get away with it, but if you are really worried about your data, perhaps its best to look at a backup solution... something that you should do regardless.
 
Back
Top