Report: NSA Intercepts Computer Deliveries

The police state has been firmly entrenched for decades and regular folks either don't care or game the system for their own benefit. Not much motivation to change a system that delights in vindictively wrecking innocent lives and breaking every one of its own laws whenever it feels justified, especially when a league of sycophants will stand up and defend the broken system as infallible. Fuck off.
 
Might not actually help. The article mentioned Western Digital, so it is possible that they are installing backdoors at the component level.

All this stuff is scary. What makes us think they arn't actually adding spy tech right into the processors? Even if we are running Linux and only open source how do we know we are not still at risk?

Is it time to start literally building our own computers... from scratch?
Yeah, it's truly scary.

We don't know if any or all of the components we use day-to-day in our computers has already been compromised. From what I've read so far, whatever the NSA injected into the BIOS and firmware of these computer components are undetectable by normal means. Even if wiping the firmware or BIOS, and over-writing it, the NSA "malware"/"spyware" is still there. That is pretty damn good. :eek:

Formatting a hard drive wouldn't even remove whatever got onto the platters. As someone commented on Reddit, that having worked at large corporations in the field of network security for them, he has never once noticed anything suspicious coming out of the networks or going in. The problem though, to him, is that he wouldn't know what to look for in the first place because every packet and data going in and out looks normal. If the NSA truly did inject something within the firmwares of routers, switches or the NICs or whatnot and is sending and receiving data to-and-from the NSA, it is doing a damn good job masking itself.

All of us will probably have to start learning how to make our own BIOS and firmware if this is the case. At least we'll know what's going into it.
 
Yeah, it's truly scary.

All of us will probably have to start learning how to make our own BIOS and firmware if this is the case. At least we'll know what's going into it.

Lets go Galactica on their ass and start using oldschool components, 8086 processors and shit, no room in these ICs for NSA bits :p
 
Lets go Galactica on their ass and start using oldschool components, 8086 processors and shit, no room in these ICs for NSA bits :p
I'm ahead of you there, I have an 8088-based PC XT computer out in the garage. Just needs a new fuse and it's ready to go. :D
 
I wonder how far back you have to go... in theory just unplugging from the internet and implementing tempest-proofing measures should have you set for the most part
 
This doesn't make sense to me. It just sound silly. I think they're close to compromising all electronics on the consumer market at the hardware level. We need the more juicy stuff. I want confirmation about Windows and PC CPUs.

I have ZERO trust in these smartphone ARM SoCs where they cram a bunch of modules you know nothing about.
 
Hijacking is a felony. Computer hacking is also a felony. So much for all the Republican shitheads on the Tee Vee droning on with the NSA talking points about how they have NEVER done anything illegal. :mad::confused:

Note to NSA geniuses, the ENEMY has hackers too, who will notice your hack, piggyback onto it and exploit your exploit. Smart move nimrods. :eek::rolleyes:

First they compromise the random number generators to undermine encryption worldwide. Then they hack US citizen's computers before they even get to the Dell (etc) warehouses. Then they compromise the routers that are supposed to be our first line of defense. :(:confused:

If your computer seems to be running slower than it should, it is probably doing the dirty work for the NSA and 5 or 6 other hacker operations in the background. Sorry. :cool:

You are a bit paranoid here. First off, intercepting systems for targeted individuals suspected of terrorists and fitting those systems with listening and collection devices is not actually illegal. It is an expanded power granted by Obama who last I checked, was a Democrat. In fact, Obama expanded a lot of powers to bolster our war in Cyberspace. Much of this is due to the threat of China, who is putting compromised components in upwards of 75% of the parts that get shipped out. So the US is not alone in this kind of thing. Also, it was clearly noted it was targeted individuals, not every computer component.

... oh, and as for roll our own ... HOW DO WE KNOW that the bios's on the motherboards haven't been compromised.

It is time for LINUX to step up, provide the TOTAL 100% COMPLETE source code for everything, libraries, etc EVERY LINE OF CODE so that it can be assessed, and a whole new industry of certified UNCOMPROMISED operating systems/bios can be produced.

Ditto ANDROID.... Google, either release it all including all library contents, every line, or it's we know you are in on it.

That was a good laugh. First off, Android is based off of the Linux kernel. So stating it separately is kind of funny. Second, open source means even more chances for things to get hacked and spied on. Also, Linux is one of the main OS's used by NSA. So it isn't going to solve any problems for you at all.

As one commenter on Reddit said

Here was your first mistake, listening to a commenter on Reddit like it was gospel, heh.

, if this is true, imagine the damage done to American tech companies in the next few years when their enterprise & corporate customer's contracts end. They'll probably not go back to US companies anymore if they know the computer hardware they purchased for their own business has been compromised by the NSA. Foreign companies are most likely too paranoid to trust any US tech company anymore.

Maybe it's about time we start listening to those nutcases that cry the "Sky is falling!" or "The end is near!" more often.

It probably will hurt some businesses for a little bit of time, but many businesses are multinational now, and not really controlled or influenced as much by a single government. Also note that many other countries are doing similar things, they just haven't been targeted as much from the inside as the US has by all these nutcases like Snowden. They think they are doing the right thing, but the only thing they are doing is hurting their own country. I find it humorous that he then tries to get extradicted to countries with far more severe spying and police state programs.

This stuff is going on everywhere, and honestly the world has known for quite some time about most of these programs. People have a right to be upset, but to think this isn't going on all over the world is just a feeble whim of the naive. This is the post information age, where all your information is everywhere for whoever wants it.
 
Just another quick note here, it is because of people like Snowden, that the NSA keeps increasing its spying on people within. There are almost more threats inside the country now then without. And after all, the NSA's charter is both abroad and domestic. It always has been. They have always collected information on citizens.
 
I'd like to see some evidence for this. Are the Snowden documents available online ?????
 
Lets go Galactica on their ass and start using oldschool components, 8086 processors and shit, no room in these ICs for NSA bits :p

The reason why they went with the "old school tech" mythology was actually to keep production costs down on props, monitors and effects, CG, etc.

soap operas cost alot of money
 
NSA backdoors in consumer hardware..and well basically everywhere.

http://www.spiegel.de/international...fers-spy-gadgets-for-every-need-a-941006.html

I think you are misreading the article there. The NSA has made products that can backdoor consumer products, not that they are backdooring them everywhere. Unlike China which is mass producing products with malware already installed before it even ships. Also note where it distinctly says in the article that US manufacturers are not working with the NSA to install any of the devices, which is why shipments would have to be hijacked in the first place.
 
Yeah, ummm, I see where you are coming from, but, no. For one, a lot of previous 'police states' have been very hard to leave and I'm pretty sure I was just in Mexico twice in the last week without even showing a passport.

We're barely half way there right now. Give it time. ;)

Well, if you haven't been hampered in your travels it must not be happening to anyone......

Watch "Holding Border Patrol Accountable: Terry Bressi on Recording his 300+ Checkpoint Interactions" on YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfemjqXbJsA
 
Wow, so DerSpeigel runs this piece and now all of you assume it's American Customers machines that are being intercepted and pre-hacked. Why is that what you guys get out of it and not some money dude in Mozambique or a mulah's new MacBook Pro being delivered to his mosque in Karachi? Maybe a French Muslim who sends regular cash to a specific Individual in Cairo or whatever. But you guys want to think it's your new Alienware Laptop.

But yea, I do agree here, "Obama is a shithead".
 
Wow, so DerSpeigel runs this piece and now all of you assume it's American Customers machines that are being intercepted and pre-hacked. Why is that what you guys get out of it...

Really? Let me think. Oh yeah...

...because we've already found out that they spy on American citizens.

Either your memory sucks, or you really are deluded into thinking that conscious American citizens are going to keep giving this clusterfuck of a government the benefit of the doubt.
 
Stiltto you can think either if you wish. But no matter how badly I think of the Obama Administration and the crappy impact they have had on much of the Federal Government, I still believe that the the DoD is somewhat insulated and the NSA even more so.

You are going to have to have much more on them then generalities to convince me otherwise. I know what their jobs are and it's not spying on Americans unless of course the FBI has a reason to think that American is doing bad things himself and is in contact with bad people, have opened an investigation and requested NSA assistance, which of course then requires a warrant from a Federal Judge.
 
You are going to have to have much more on them then generalities to convince me otherwise.

"The NSA spies on American citizens" is not a generality. It's a cold, frightening fact. Your constant dismissal and refusal to consider the weight of that truth is ceaselessly headshaking.
 
Stiltto you can think either if you wish. But no matter how badly I think of the Obama Administration and the crappy impact they have had on much of the Federal Government, I still believe that the the DoD is somewhat insulated and the NSA even more so.

You are going to have to have much more on them then generalities to convince me otherwise. I know what their jobs are and it's not spying on Americans unless of course the FBI has a reason to think that American is doing bad things himself and is in contact with bad people, have opened an investigation and requested NSA assistance, which of course then requires a warrant from a Federal Judge.

Actually, the NSA is both foreign and domestic. They do not need a request from the FBI. Also much of the NSA charter and mission is through Executive Orders and so they do not necessarily need a warrant from a Federal Judge. There are, however, limits to their power, and snooping and spying on the general public because they want to is not in their power. Nor does the NSA actually snoop on the public as much as people want to believe.

They have broad data collecting programs because it is hard to isolate and pick just one target to collect data from. Consider if a terrorist only uses throw away cell phones, or only uses pay phones, or uses phones from businesses. Consider that perhaps they only communicate through public lan centers or public computers and never use their own. There are many variables and many threats. Thus many reasons why they use such broad and overarching means to collect information.

Also consider that with all that data they have to sift through it to find the information that they need. Its a massive amount of data. Why would they even want to waste their time with small potatoes stuff like someone committing some petty crime or every single person that neighsays the government? They just don't care about that. They are specifically looking for threats on a bigger scale to the nation. They spy on other countries to find chatter of terrorist activity going through those channels. Thus again, the huge broad spectrum of spying.

Now on the specific targeting front which is what the TAO does, that is far more limited. They aren't putting malware, spyware, hacks and listening devices in every consumer product. The scale of that operation alone would be untenable. The systems they would target would be systems going out to terrorists, terrorist supporters, and/or spies. Honestly, they probably also do it for foreign diplomats, just like almost every other country in the world. But they are not doing it for the average citizen.
 
"The NSA spies on American citizens" is not a generality. It's a cold, frightening fact. Your constant dismissal and refusal to consider the weight of that truth is ceaselessly headshaking.

How about the fact that China snoops on the American citizen? How about the fact that Google, Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, etc snoop on the Amercian citizen? How about the fact that Britain, France, Germany, Russia spy on American citizens? Is that not as much of a cold, frightening fact?
 
"The NSA spies on American citizens" is not a generality. It's a cold, frightening fact.

OK, we will keep it simple.

If the NSA spied on one American then "American Citizens" in plural would be an incorrect statement yes?

So given that the NSA has spied on at least two American's then your statement is accurate as long as there has been at least two Americans who have been targeted and spied on.

Now let's address the word spy. The NSA is a SPY agency, it's their purpose. In fact, the Spying was being done before the Agency existed as it's predecessors were doing the spying before it. The NSA was legally intercepting ALL phone calls for the last 60 years where either end-point of the call was outside the US. Ma Bell was the company that bent over for that one and it has been maintained through all the years of change. Of course those old days it was analog not digital. Things have changed, the laws have changed, but the NSA's job has not changed.

Now without using general terms like spying let's narrow it down some.

Bulk Collection of Telephone Meta-Data? Is this spying on all American's? I am asking your definition Stiletto.
 
How about the fact that China snoops on the American citizen?

I'm not a citizen of China, so what difference does that make?

How about the fact that Google, Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, etc snoop on the Amercian citizen?

None of those entities can take money from me under threat of imprisonment or deadly force, so what difference does that make?

How about the fact that Britain, France, Germany, Russia spy on American citizens?

I'm not a citizen of any of those countries, so what difference does that make?

Is that not as much of a cold, frightening fact?

Why do people like you attempt to distract from analysis of the US government by telling us to look everywhere else? That's pretty shameful and transparent.
 
If the NSA spied on one American then "American Citizens" in plural would be an incorrect statement yes?

Holy shit. Really? You'd give the benefit of the doubt that the NSA only ever spied on one American citizen?

Then you are lost.
 
NoOther you are wrong.

Actually, the NSA is both foreign and domestic.
They are explicitly a Foreign Intelligence Service. Today a great amount of foreign traffic, (traffic generated by Non-US Persons), rides on domestic communications networks. This makes the communications foreign.

They do not need a request from the FBI.
No they don't, not if their target is foreign as in Non US Person. That's because foreign stuff is the NSA'a mission. But the NSA only target's a US Person in cooperation with an FBI request and it must be warranted by a Federal Judge. If it's being reported otherwise you are being misled.
 
NSA is explicitly foreign service... unless you are two degrees from Kevin Bacon.
 
Hey, the next-door neighbor broke in stole an ashtray.

I bet he didn't take anything else. You're gonna have to prove he took anything. Let's send him a letter requesting information on any other items he stole. Anything more is really going overboard.
 
Holy shit. Really? You'd give the benefit of the doubt that the NSA only ever spied on one American citizen?

Then you are lost.

No Stiletto, your lost, we were talking about generalities, you insisted that your statement wasn't general and I am showing you how it was.
 
No Stiletto, your lost, we were talking about generalities, you insisted that your statement wasn't general and I am showing you how it was.

You're arguing a moot point. Multiple citizens were spied on. It's not a generality, and your attempt to claim it as such is dishonest. And before you continue to trot out one of your favorite chestnuts: "US persons" includes US citizens.
 
NoOther you are wrong.


They are explicitly a Foreign Intelligence Service. Today a great amount of foreign traffic, (traffic generated by Non-US Persons), rides on domestic communications networks. This makes the communications foreign.

No they don't, not if their target is foreign as in Non US Person. That's because foreign stuff is the NSA'a mission. But the NSA only target's a US Person in cooperation with an FBI request and it must be warranted by a Federal Judge. If it's being reported otherwise you are being misled.

In fact, I am not wrong. You are confusing the charter of the NSA with that of the CIA. The CIA is limited to foreign operations only, the NSA is not and never has been. They do not perform human surveillance operations. The whole purpose of the NSA was to bridge the gap created by the separate of powers between the CIA and the FBI, specifically with the intent to oversee communications intelligence. The NSA's entire purpose is COMINT and is not limited to only operating overseas. They can operate whereever the need for intelligence exists. The NSA has used the FBI to collect information, but is not required too. They are supposed to get warrants for some information gathering especially when it concerns an American citizen, but that is true of any agency operating domestically.

Too many people confuse the duties of the CIA with that of the NSA. They are not at all the same and the barriers between the CIA's operational area and the FBI, do not at all impact the NSA. The NSA is tasked with safeguarding and securing American communications and intelligence. That is both domestic and foreign communications and intelligence. So while it can be considered a foreign intelligence agency, that is not really its primary goal, nor its only operation.
 
Multiple citizens were spied on.

So far in the news we have one single instance of one single individual who's privacy was violated according to the law.

There is a Bulk Meta-Data collection program that seems to be running, I have no more direct knowledge of it then you I think. But one Federal Judge in CA says it's "likely unconstitutional" and he put his own ruling on hold while another Federal Judge in NY ruled specifically that the same program was in fact legal, (does not mean it is actually constitutional or not, but that it does fall within the boundaries of what is currently allowed by law.)

Now this program would fall into the "American Citizens" part of your statement.
 
There is a Bulk Meta-Data collection program that seems to be running...

"Seems". I think if Clapper took a shit on your doorstep, you'd stand in the doorway with your head up and say that any presence of fecal matter in the vicinity was a "possibility".
 
I'm not a citizen of China, so what difference does that make?

I'm not a citizen of any of those countries, so what difference does that make?

They are spying on you, that seems to be your issue. Or perhaps it isn't?

None of those entities can take money from me under threat of imprisonment or deadly force, so what difference does that make?

Nor can the NSA. That isn't their mission. They can provide information to another agency, which then could carry that out, much like any of those corporations could, or a foreign government.

Why do people like you attempt to distract from analysis of the US government by telling us to look everywhere else? That's pretty shameful and transparent.

Probably because you insist on making issues out of things that are going on all over the place, but want to place the blame firmly on one agency. You are ignoring what is going on everywhere else by trying to make one agency a scapegoat. I am not distracting from anything, I am pointing out the reality of the world we live in. If you are going to be outraged, be outraged at the course of the government as a whole, not only here, but abroad. That is the issue, especially when articles are brought in about how this affects our relationship with other countries. Well, other countries are doing the same thing. So where is the solution? The biggest problem though is trying to compare the operations of the TAO to the general collection of data. They are completely two separate issues. And this thread was about the things the TAO was doing (which is isolated and targeted), not the broad collection of data (which is passive and broad).
 
I'm not confusing anything NoOther, read this then talk.

Executive Order 12333 applies to ALL US Intelligence Agencies, all of them. It expressly limits and sets the requirements necessary in order to collect on a US Person.

From this wiki page;
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Agency
The NSA is tasked with the global monitoring, collection, decoding, translation and analysis of information and data for foreign intelligence and counterintelligence purposes, including surveillance of targeted individuals on U.S. soil.

Because of Executive Order 12333 the NSA can't target a US Person unless they go through the courts. There are four explicit reasons the NSA would conduct targeted surveillance on a US person.

1. Espionage, a US Person who is spying on our own country. Allthough the NSA could be involved in an espionage case, it is the FBI's function and they would have to provide a warrant.
2. Treason, Involves specifically aiding an Enemy during time of war, knowingly and with intent, all the previous rules apply.
3. Counter-Intelligence, against foreign intelligence agents, sorry, their foreign by definition.
4. Anti-Terrorism, actually just a subset of the rest but hey, we needed new pigeon holes to keep things straight, still the FBI's job.
 
They are spying on you, that seems to be your issue. Or perhaps it isn't?

My issue has only ever been with American intelligence agencies spying on the citizens they're supposed to serve and protect.

Nor can the NSA. That isn't their mission. They can provide information to another agency, which then could carry that out, much like any of those corporations could, or a foreign government.

The NSA is part of the US government, which seizes money under threat of imprisonment from US citizens. I didn't think this necessitated explanation. Your semantical arguments are getting a bit bewildering.

Probably because you insist on making issues out of things that are going on all over the place, but want to place the blame firmly on one agency.

Not one agency. One government. You should really stop imagining arguments and responding to them.
 
Back
Top