Recommended 2.5" & 3.5" External Drive Dock?

wings2004

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 17, 2012
Messages
213
I'm looking for an external drive dock for 2.5" & 3.5" SATA drives. I would prefer it to be externally powered (aka seperate power block or adapter that plugs into my strip).

I have USB 2.0, USB 3.0, and eSATA as available input interfaces. I don't anticipate using any drive larger than 2TB.

I'm trying to find the most reliable dock that has the fastest speeds in a reasonable price ($30-45). My main uses for this dock is for external troubleshooting (normally external AV scans), data transfer (just build a new desktop), and possibly everyday use of old drives as I move everything to my new system I will still need the old.

I honestly don't know what the big speed difference is between USB 3.0 and eSATA (I know theoretically its 5GB/s vs 3GB/s), would the HDD's be the bottleneck here?

Do USB 2.0 & eSATA combo docks suffer from the USB conversion when you are just using eSATA?

Is there anything else I'm missing?

Brands don't mean much to me but proven reliability would be appreciated.

Thanks!
 
Last edited:
I have a thermaltake BlackX and it works great. Never had any issues with it using the eSATA connection.
 
I have a thermaltake BlackX and it works great. Never had any issues with it using the eSATA connection.

I have a couple, one eSATA/USB version and one USB only. Both work great. eSATA works full speed, so no apparent speed loss for the "conversion". I don't think it converts eSATA, only when using the USB connection.
 
I always recommend the Antec MX-1.

They work great, have USB, eSATA, and active cooling.

eSATA is just as fast as an internal SATA drive and will blow USB out of the water.

Do USB 2.0 & eSATA combo docks suffer from the USB conversion when you are just using eSATA?
I've never heard of it and I've never read anything about it being an issue. :confused:
 
OR did I screw-up AGAIN and you really meant a real HD dock like this?

Looking back I see I missed the mark AGAIN! LOL!

Damn.....I'm on a roll! LOL!
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I always recommend the Antec MX-1.

They work great, have USB, eSATA, and active cooling.

eSATA is just as fast as an internal SATA drive and will blow USB out of the water.


I've never heard of it and I've never read anything about it being an issue. :confused:

enclosures are great for one drive, but if youre working with multiple then a dock is many times more useful. it sounds like thats what the OP wants. OP, i have a blacX too and although mine is only usb 2.0. i love it, very easy to use, and so far quite reliable. definitely get the eSATA one though. one thing ive noticed on mine is that if its on then most (maybe all?) of the time i try to shut down my comp, it will hang up at the "windows is shutting down" screen for like 10 minutes until it finally restarts and then blue screens. i have to just unplug it or press the power button on the back of the dock and then the comp shuts down fine. not sure if this is a problem just with my mobo and this dock, or if i got a defective model or what, but something to look out for if you do encounter that problem. :)
 
it sounds like thats what the OP wants.
Yep. I screwed-up AGAIN! LOL!

You'll have that. :)


it will hang up at the "windows is shutting down" screen for like 10 minutes until it finally restarts and then blue screens.
Sounds like your computer doesn't want to "let go" the USB device until it checks the data.
I use Safely Remove Hardware for USB devices.
Just safely remove your external drive before shutting down.
 
Yep. I screwed-up AGAIN! LOL!

You'll have that. :)



Sounds like your computer doesn't want to "let go" the USB device until it checks the data.
I use Safely Remove Hardware for USB devices.
Just safely remove your external drive before shutting down.

yeah that would probably work too. i just always forget about it until after i try to shut down since i dont always have it on and a drive in. :)
 
Yep. I screwed-up AGAIN! LOL!

No worries, but yes, I'm looking for a HDD "dock" not an enclosure, I have an old usb to SATA/PATA/IDE converter but I'm really looking for something that is more stable/not just for testing drives. So the consensus sounds like the Thermaltake BlacX? Has anyone had a problem with them yet. I saw several of the USB 3.0 models drop out a lot but I hope this one doesn't. I'm a wait until next week after pay day but unless someone suggests otherwise I'll probably go with the BlacX.
 
Edited - ok, dooh... this doesn't fit the OP's state need but I'll leave it for anyone who may be interested.

For 2.5, I have an Addonics Ruby ExDrive. This thing is as fexible as a Romanian gymnast. This is more of an enclosure than a dock, but it can be used for an internal dock if you get the cradle.

http://www.addonics.com/products/ruby_exdrive.php

I'm using this at my current full-time client site, as I have to use the desktop they provide which would make it tough to look at code at home. So I got an Intel 120gb SSD, put it in this enclosure and code within a virtual machine on the ssd. I get better performance with VS2010 inside the VM than on the host which runs a single platter 500gb HD.

For interface, you can go Sata, eSata, or eSatap, or you can use there eSatap to USB 3.0 converter.

Power-wise, you can power it via a USB plug, very small power brick, eSatap (eSata-USB combo port) or regular internal Sata power connector.

You can also get a cradle for it to put into a desktop bay. The enclsoure itself is not expensive, but the accessories add up.

I have experimented will all the combinations and have used the standard sata connectors most of the time, and the USB power plug with an eSata cable a fair amount.

I have used this drive to compare Sata/eSata and USB 3.0 performance. It seems using this enclosure with the Sata to USB 3.0 converter to a laptop 3.0 USB port, the data transfer rate has a lower ceiling than sata, but not so much you'd notice the difference on most tasks with a traditional hard drive. With an SSD, that ceiling would have a bit more of an impact, but again, for most uses it is probably not an issue.
 
For 2.5, I have an Addonics Ruby ExDrive. This thing is as fexible as a Romanian gymnast. This is more of an enclosure than a dock, but it can be used for an internal dock if you get the cradle.

http://www.addonics.com/products/ruby_exdrive.php

First external case I've seen that includes EUHP (eSATA USB Hybrid Port).

But it doesn't have a fan so I wouldn't run use any hot running drives for extended periods of time.

Looks pretty nice! :)

My dock is a Logitec brand and they weren't widely sold in the US but it had an eSATA port six months before any other brand.....and I couldn't wait. :)
 
Back
Top