Recommend me a video card please

Lyquist

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 21, 2004
Messages
3,368
I was wondering if someone could recommend a video card for me. I have the machine in my signature. I currently have a x1950Pro video card. I am wanting to play Mass Effect and want to be able to turn up all the details on that game. I am not a big gamer. The most important thing to me is that I run dual monitors and 2D image quality is the most important. I have always heard that ATI was the best for that and still be able to play games. I would like to order from Newegg. Both of my monitors run at 1280x1024. One is 19" and the other is 17" LCD. I am not planning on upgrading my monitors anytime soon. So playing with maximum details at 1280 x 1024 is OK with me. Thanks.
 
Well if you wanna stick with ATI, I think your best bet you would a 4870. But I think a GTX 260 will run Mass Effect a tad bit better.
 
Nvidia cards are getting these weird pink screen of death issues with their drivers. I'd go with ATI
just for better drivers.
 
I was wondering if someone could recommend a video card for me. I have the machine in my signature. I currently have a x1950Pro video card. I am wanting to play Mass Effect and want to be able to turn up all the details on that game. I am not a big gamer. The most important thing to me is that I run dual monitors and 2D image quality is the most important. I have always heard that ATI was the best for that and still be able to play games. I would like to order from Newegg. Both of my monitors run at 1280x1024. One is 19" and the other is 17" LCD. I am not planning on upgrading my monitors anytime soon. So playing with maximum details at 1280 x 1024 is OK with me. Thanks.

HD 4870 1GB if you have the money. HD 4870 512MB is fast enough but with only 512MB of RAM, it won't be at its full potential.

If you are on the budget, get a HD 4850, the 512MB version will be fine because the card won't be much faster with more RAM unlike the HD4870. If the price difference between the 1GB version and 512MB version is not big, I think that there is no reason not to get more RAM. However, the 512MB HD4870 would still be faster than the 1GB HD 4850.
 
wtf are u talking about?

Talking about these weird pink screen of death issues that are occuring with gtx260s/280s
that users are reporting. Careful, might be some kind of defective batch perhaps. Stick
with ATI for now until this gets resolved. Remember all those laptop gpus nvidia
recalled...who knows, maybe it's just with evga cards.

image019ti3.jpg


http://www.evga.com/forums/tm.asp?m=707344

http://www.evga.com/forums/tm.asp?m=699343&mpage=1&key=��
 
wtf are u talking about?

Ye dude ATI's drivers are $hit trust me, i bought the 4850x2 and had a nightmare with driver problems so i rma'd it. If your only gaming at that low a res then nothing higher then a 260 or 4870 is needed, although the 280's just dropped below the $300 mark so the balls really in the consumers park so to speak.
 
Keep in mind that my monitor only goes to 1280x1024. I think a 4850 or 4870 would be overkill. Any more recommendation? I am mainly just wanting a good, solid DirectX 10 card that will max out Mass Effect at 1280x1024. Thanks.
 
I think a ATi HD4850 is EXACTLY what you need. It will give you 60fps gaming at that res for under $150.00.
 
Any answer to the 512MB vs 1GB question on the 4850? I also want a single slot card. Which card is best for that? I have always had good luck with Sapphire. Thanks.
 
Ye dude ATI's drivers are $hit trust me, i bought the 4850x2 and had a nightmare with driver problems so i rma'd it. If your only gaming at that low a res then nothing higher then a 260 or 4870 is needed, although the 280's just dropped below the $300 mark so the balls really in the consumers park so to speak.

Not a problem here with Catalyst 8.12, Catalyst 9.1 will be out soon.
 
Keep in mind that my monitor only goes to 1280x1024. I think a 4850 or 4870 would be overkill. Any more recommendation? I am mainly just wanting a good, solid DirectX 10 card that will max out Mass Effect at 1280x1024. Thanks.


The 4870 IS overkill for a 19" monitor. And, a 4850 runs amost the same as a 3870 on a 19" monitor @1280x1024. The 4800 series cards pull ahead of the 3870 at higher resolutions ( ei bigger monitors ). I had been using a 3870 for a while when the 4850 came out and was the newest, greatest.... so I bought one. At 1280x1024 it was pretty much the same as the 3870. Eventually, I upped my home rig to a 22" monitor. At 1680x1050 the 4850 pulled ahead of the 3870.

A few days ago I got a killer deal on a Saphire 4870 ( 512 meg) . I put it in my LAN rig on the 19" monitor and I wasn't really wasn't impressed. Yes, it's faster than the 3870 but not by as much as I thought it would be. Once again, on a 22" or bigger monitor the difference is greater.

Since you are not planning on upgrading monitors and the recommended videocard for Mass Effect is an X1800XL or better, I think you'd be safe with a 3850 or 3870. But if you plan a monitor upgrade, then go with 4800 series card.

There are people on this forum that would recommend an i7 and a 4870X2 to someone playing Pogo games on a 15" CRT
 
At that resolution, you would be better off getting a used 8800GTS 512MB, you would still be able to turn most stuff up, and it will outperform the 3850 and will only cost you around $100. I am currently selling my old one on craigslist in my area for $80.
 
given your low resolution i suggest these options for price performance.

be advised i played mass effect at 1920 x 1200 with effects turned up on a 9600gt

4850 $129 AR
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814131125

4830 $89 AR
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814102803

9600GT $79 AR
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814500019

4670 $70 AR
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814121274


you could spend more but i see little reason unless u plan to upgrade your monitors
 
I think I have decided on a 4830 or a 4850. The only thing I need to know is if there are any games that take advantage of a full 1GB of RAM on the card? Thanks.
 
I don't think there are there are many (if any) games which use more than 512MB of memory when running at 1280x1024. You should be fine with the 512MB version.
 
Back
Top