Recommend me a GPU

SEALTeamSix

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 15, 2003
Messages
2,434
Hey all,

I'm currently saddled with an old x1800xt 256mb, s939 x2 4000+ @ 2.7GHz, 2GB DDR(1), 480w PSU, etc... I play mainly FPS's, with CoD4 being my go-to for now. I'm play on a 22" CRT, capable of up to 1880x1440 (though 16x12 is a good place to be as well).

I'm looking to bump up my graphics performance, but realize I will be CPU limited. I'm looking to buy the most GPU for my money that won't be bottlenecked. Budget-wise, I don't want to spend more than $300-ish.

I'm thinking an 8800gt or 8800gtx would be a good match for this system, but I haven't really kept up with all the new GPUs, and was hoping for some recommendations. So, what card should I get?
 
In terms of current tech, the 8800GT is definitely battle-tested. It's king of the midrange right now--unless you find someone throwing out an 8800GTX---but with the Radeon 4850 waiting in the wings, it might not be a bad idea to wait another few days to verify whether or not the 8800GT still has its crown on...
 
My PSU is an Antec TruePower 2 - it's not a PC P&C, but it's not a bad unit either. Here's a review. I got it for $20 on a sale last year.

It's good to know that I'm not going to be that CPU-limited. Maybe I should pick up another gig of RAM to balance things out.

I could probably also post my system up on Craigslist and get a decent start on a more modern machine... (Q6600, 4gb DDR2, etc) on the other hand, I don't upgrade very often, and I'm not really a power user, so maybe I should wait for DDR3 to become standard before ponying up on a new system... hmmm....

I'm also not opposed to buying used, particularly from companies like EVGA, BFG, or XFX with good warranty service. Also, I need a single-card solution (no SLI or Crossfire on my mobo - it's a K8N Neo4 Platinum).
 
My PSU is an Antec TruePower 2 - it's not a PC P&C, but it's not a bad unit either. Here's a review. I got it for $20 on a sale last year.

That's a poorly made review. No use of a Automated Test Equipment, no ripple measurements, etc. Not a good PSU review. A good example of a proper PSU reviews are the ones done by www.jonnyguru.com and HardOCP.

Anyway, do note that the Trupower I and 2.0 as well as the Smartpower line of PSUs had a an above average death rate due to a poor design decision as well as use of a questionable parts. Poor design decision was having the fan kick in at higher temperatures in order to make the PSU more silent and the use of fuhjyyu capacitors that died under repeated exposure to high temperatures. As a result, those PSUs do die a lot. So just an FYI.

But assuming that your PSU is kept really cool, it should be able to handle up to a 8800GTX or 9800GTX. I recommend waiting another week or two to see how well the new ATI cards perform.
 
That's a poorly made review. No use of a Automated Test Equipment, no ripple measurements, etc. Not a good PSU review. A good example of a proper PSU reviews are the ones done by www.jonnyguru.com and HardOCP.

True... but they have not reviewed my PSU. :p For $20, and a the fact that it's on the "Best Bang for the Buck" list in the [H] PSU sticky (well, old sticky anyway), I went for it. Here's a better review with testing equipment used. I'm not opposed to using a higher-quality PSU and paying more for it, but if cheap stuff works pretty well then I go for that.

It looks like 18A on each of the 12v rails will be sufficient for an 8800/9800 series card... so I'm good to go.

I should also mention that I don't intend to play Crysis on Ridiculous Quality settings - I don't have $2000 to spend on that. I've had a shrink-wrapped copy sitting on my desk for a while now, but want to update my graphics card to not have to put everything on Low.

Thanks for the advice Danny - I'll wait a few weeks and see if AMD/ATi can pull it out this round.
 
Back
Top